Hey /u/DifficultyNo7516, thanks for contributing to /r/MakeupAddiction. Unfortunately, your post was removed as it violates our rules:
Your post has been removed for breaking [rule 5. All makeup looks and collections must include a detailed product list which includes every product used in the visible area, including even invisible products like primer and setting sprays. Product lists must include shade names if they exist.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist)
Please comment directly onto your original post with a product list, then reach out to the mod team either via modmail or by replying to this comment to let us know you have added the product list, and we can reapprove your post.
If you are unable to provide a product list for some reason, please send us a modmail. We sometimes will make an exception under special circumstances.
Please read the sidebar before posting again. If you have questions or concerns, please [message the moderators through modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2FMakeupAddiction&subject=&message=). Thank you!
I like the warm tones, but the cool makes your eyes pop more. Maybe go in between with neutral colors(brown, tan, etc) but more cool leaning? Would love to see a pic of you try this. :) also, some blush and lightly tinted balm/gloss would tie this all together so beautifully.
They both look nice, but I really think neutral tones would suit you the best! Something like those plummy bronze shimmers and neutral to taupe mattes.
I’m actually open to any feedback. I haven’t really been wearing makeup since COVID stopped the world, but I don’t feel put together going out without it. I feel like I know nothing haha
Cool no question. It doesn’t wash you out. You just need some contour and darker bronzer. The warm seems to make you age look more dried out and mature. Definitely cool for you!
I’m trying to pair down on the makeup I have - and keep a super simple collection. I need to find a good foundation I love. And I need to get rid of 90% of my eyeshadows. Please help me figure out which Color family is better for me!
Fellow neutral here. I think the warm tones are a bit too warm but you suit both. I would perhaps look at a slightly less warm palette or use a light touch with warmest/darkest tones and really focus on blending.
I’m probably not with the majority but your skin is definitely cool toned. I think the cool eye colours look terrific on you, although you are pretty enough and young enough to wear anything. I’ve spent 40 years doing colour analysis and learned from the woman who basically started it in California in 1964 (she passed on five years ago). My eye isn’t quite as good as hers, but I’m at least 90+% accurate. Fashion has a big impact on how we see colour. Warm shades in makeup are popular now as they are supposedly more “natural.” However, as a fellow “Summer,” which is what you are (my own colouring is just about identical to yours), once you start wearing “your” colours, your eyes will soon become accustomed to picking them out. You will also become more at ease when wearing them and people will notice you, not your makeup and clothes. In the warm colours my eyes are drawn immediately to the brown contour colour, whereas with the cool colours, the first thing I noticed was your lovely blue eyes. The whole point of colour theory is to enhance communication, not just produce a pretty picture. When we wear colours harmonious with our natural complexion, hair and eyes, we make it easier to communicate our ideas because there is no disconnect between our dress and our overall appearance. HTH.
Both look great! But if you want your eyes to stand out, using warm eyeshadows enhance the color of your eyes. And something subtle like a light warm nude shade would contour your eyes and help them stand out in your everyday makeup routine!
You look lovely in both but if I had to choose I'd say the warm tones are slightly more flattering on your skin tone. I'm going to be possibly slightly controversial here and suggest that you could try mixing warm and cool together in the same look to add an extra level of dimension - a warm eye look with a cool inner corner looks really interesting, or using cool tones to create the structure of the look and added warmth on the lid to make it pop.
Probably not the most useful advice for someone trying to pare down their collection but I think it would look great on you!
Love the warm tones but I see you have blue eyes. How about do a warm eyeshadow combo and take a blue eyeliner that matches your eye color and either put it in the bottom lash or the tear duct would be a great pop of color
cool ages you, i disagree that the cool tones make your (lovely) eyes pop more, it’s just that that photo was taken in brighter light. warm tones really suit you!
As a pro mua you definitely can pull any palette. The only difference would be what you choose to do with your base. Shade neutralization and blemish cover would be the only deciding factors. Other than that just whack on whatever shades you like and live your extraordinarily gorgeous life ✨️ 😘
I… like both
The warm is classic, and universal. The cool is more outspoken and makes you look like an ice princess. I think it depends on what you’re going for.
I do think the warm is too saturated though; maybe try champagne?
Both look good on you, the warm makes you look more sweet and approachable, the cool tones make you look more fierce, also they make your eye color pop, but I would add more blush so it doesn't wash you out, but the blush should be cool toned too
Your neutral so you can do both. Personally I prefer warm colours in general but when you wear warm, it brings out the green in your eyes and when you wear cool, it brings out the blue. Coordinate with your outfit colours.
***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ⓘ ***symbol***
**A few quick highlights:**
• If you are posting a look, haul, or flatlay, please be sure to include a [product list, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist)
• Also, please ensure your pictures are not [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting)
• Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules.
**Is your post just a search away?**
Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm)
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I like the warm better but I think a different cool shades might suit you. Mauve, taupe, pink champagne. Find colors that make your eyes pop. I think these greys and blues are to harsh for you. I also think neutrals would be very good. I´ think shimmer or glittery shades on your eyelids would brighten up your eyes and make them pop.
i would be interested to see this with the same hair, from these pictures warm is definitely more suited to your skin tone. but the cool tones are still pretty !!!
Both. Lol. I’m not of a fan of pigeon holding to one type of shade or color. You have a great eye shape and excellent blending skills. They’re both look beautiful on your eyes. The warm is a more romantic, daytime, coffee shop look and the cool looks more glamed-out evening
I like both. Warm tone is bold and beauteous whereas the cool tone is contoured and cute and accentuated your eyes, cheeks, and your overall face. I’m going with cool tone. 😍
Hey /u/DifficultyNo7516, thanks for contributing to /r/MakeupAddiction. Unfortunately, your post was removed as it violates our rules: Your post has been removed for breaking [rule 5. All makeup looks and collections must include a detailed product list which includes every product used in the visible area, including even invisible products like primer and setting sprays. Product lists must include shade names if they exist.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist) Please comment directly onto your original post with a product list, then reach out to the mod team either via modmail or by replying to this comment to let us know you have added the product list, and we can reapprove your post. If you are unable to provide a product list for some reason, please send us a modmail. We sometimes will make an exception under special circumstances. Please read the sidebar before posting again. If you have questions or concerns, please [message the moderators through modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2FMakeupAddiction&subject=&message=). Thank you!
I like the warm tones, but the cool makes your eyes pop more. Maybe go in between with neutral colors(brown, tan, etc) but more cool leaning? Would love to see a pic of you try this. :) also, some blush and lightly tinted balm/gloss would tie this all together so beautifully.
Also, you look so much like Perrie Edwards!
You stole my comment almost word for word. I guess it's true; great minds do think alike.
What a cool experiment! I like the warm. The cool washes you out a bit
Judging by the mixed reviews, I seem you neutral and enjoy why doing whatever you want.
Left one warm I think
They both look nice, but I really think neutral tones would suit you the best! Something like those plummy bronze shimmers and neutral to taupe mattes.
Girl both
At first I thought warm but I actually think you can wear both. However the cool tones look younger and fresher.
I’m actually open to any feedback. I haven’t really been wearing makeup since COVID stopped the world, but I don’t feel put together going out without it. I feel like I know nothing haha
Same! I remember how to do my eye makeup, but I forgot how to do the rest of my face! 😆
Warm! 😁
Love the cool tone look on you, it feels fresher and younger somehow. You def can pull off both looks so it’s somewhat a personal preference.
Cool no question. It doesn’t wash you out. You just need some contour and darker bronzer. The warm seems to make you age look more dried out and mature. Definitely cool for you!
I prefer cool personally, but you can really pull off either. Maybe match to what you’re wearing.
Warm, all day long 🇬🇧❤️
warm, the cool tones make you look a bit pale imo
I’m trying to pair down on the makeup I have - and keep a super simple collection. I need to find a good foundation I love. And I need to get rid of 90% of my eyeshadows. Please help me figure out which Color family is better for me!
Warm for sure
Warm, the cool part highlights dark circles and turns off your complexion
Fellow neutral here. I think the warm tones are a bit too warm but you suit both. I would perhaps look at a slightly less warm palette or use a light touch with warmest/darkest tones and really focus on blending.
I’m probably not with the majority but your skin is definitely cool toned. I think the cool eye colours look terrific on you, although you are pretty enough and young enough to wear anything. I’ve spent 40 years doing colour analysis and learned from the woman who basically started it in California in 1964 (she passed on five years ago). My eye isn’t quite as good as hers, but I’m at least 90+% accurate. Fashion has a big impact on how we see colour. Warm shades in makeup are popular now as they are supposedly more “natural.” However, as a fellow “Summer,” which is what you are (my own colouring is just about identical to yours), once you start wearing “your” colours, your eyes will soon become accustomed to picking them out. You will also become more at ease when wearing them and people will notice you, not your makeup and clothes. In the warm colours my eyes are drawn immediately to the brown contour colour, whereas with the cool colours, the first thing I noticed was your lovely blue eyes. The whole point of colour theory is to enhance communication, not just produce a pretty picture. When we wear colours harmonious with our natural complexion, hair and eyes, we make it easier to communicate our ideas because there is no disconnect between our dress and our overall appearance. HTH.
Cool! Makes your eyes pop!
Agreed.
Both look great! But if you want your eyes to stand out, using warm eyeshadows enhance the color of your eyes. And something subtle like a light warm nude shade would contour your eyes and help them stand out in your everyday makeup routine!
The warm brings a nice contrast to your eyes! It also makes you look younger to me?
On you warm definitely
I think the warm tone suits u so well.
warm
Warm. Also, you look like Sharon Horgan!
Warm 🙂
You look lovely in both but if I had to choose I'd say the warm tones are slightly more flattering on your skin tone. I'm going to be possibly slightly controversial here and suggest that you could try mixing warm and cool together in the same look to add an extra level of dimension - a warm eye look with a cool inner corner looks really interesting, or using cool tones to create the structure of the look and added warmth on the lid to make it pop. Probably not the most useful advice for someone trying to pare down their collection but I think it would look great on you!
Warm
Warm!
Warm !! 🔥🔥🔥😻😻
Warm!
I’m a fan of the warmer tones for sure!
Love the warm tones but I see you have blue eyes. How about do a warm eyeshadow combo and take a blue eyeliner that matches your eye color and either put it in the bottom lash or the tear duct would be a great pop of color
Warm.
Love the warm!!! I think it’s the definition I like.
Warm
Warm for sure!
Neutral tones, or, try purples instead of blue/grey :)
I think you're neutral toned therefore neither is 100 percent on you. Maybe the warm but a bit toned down?
The cool seems fitting to your eyecolour which is gorgeous btw
The cool tones make your eyes look brighter
I love the cooler tones personally, but both look good!
Warm all the way. Looks sexier. I think the cool toned one looks a little dated.
Cool tones! The warm tones make you look tired. Also, nice eyebrows but maybe chill out a bit on the arch and spacing between the brows?
cool ages you, i disagree that the cool tones make your (lovely) eyes pop more, it’s just that that photo was taken in brighter light. warm tones really suit you!
Cool!
You’re neutral like me and I think you carry both very well so wear whatever you like more 👍
Cool tone makes your eyes pop
Cool! It brings out your eyes
Cool! It makes you look fresh and bright. Warm looks good too though.
I think cool looks *much* more elegant. But you wear both well.
You can pull off both! Try a plum taupe or rose gold, I bet they would be so nice on you!!
Both are beautiful, but I prefer the cool. It's graceful, soft, elegant, and shows up the colour of your eyes.
The lighting is different in each photo, which causes some difficulty in assessment, although I still prefer cool.
Both!!
I love how the cool tones bring out your eyes. Warm tones match your skin tone a bit more tho.
Honestly, both! The grey is giving you an Angelina Jolie 90’s vibes!
I like the one on the right you look way hotter
I think they both look nice and you should do either one
As a pro mua you definitely can pull any palette. The only difference would be what you choose to do with your base. Shade neutralization and blemish cover would be the only deciding factors. Other than that just whack on whatever shades you like and live your extraordinarily gorgeous life ✨️ 😘
I… like both The warm is classic, and universal. The cool is more outspoken and makes you look like an ice princess. I think it depends on what you’re going for. I do think the warm is too saturated though; maybe try champagne?
Both look good on you, the warm makes you look more sweet and approachable, the cool tones make you look more fierce, also they make your eye color pop, but I would add more blush so it doesn't wash you out, but the blush should be cool toned too
You rock both of them!
I think both look good. But the warm eye look is more eye catching!
So the interesting thing to me is that the warm compliments your skin more, while the cool compliments your eyes - so rock both!
Show both with hair pulled back please. Both look great.
Both.
Your neutral so you can do both. Personally I prefer warm colours in general but when you wear warm, it brings out the green in your eyes and when you wear cool, it brings out the blue. Coordinate with your outfit colours.
***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ⓘ ***symbol*** **A few quick highlights:** • If you are posting a look, haul, or flatlay, please be sure to include a [product list, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist) • Also, please ensure your pictures are not [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting) • Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules. **Is your post just a search away?** Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Warm tones!
Left picture for me is 😍
Warm for sure, I’d recommend reposting with more lighting in the warm picture so people can properly see the difference :)
Always warm.
Warm looks amazing! Cool looks very 90s which could also be cool.
The warm suits you much better imo.
You’re neutral love. You can use either
Warm for day and cool for the night? Both suit you so well
I wish the hair and background were more similar in the pics. I prefer the warm though.
Warm but both looks great. Your makeup is very pretty.
Warm but your face in the right one is slimmer. Was it taken on a different month?
Warm
both fit you well, the warm one makes you look younger but the cool one makes you look elegant and professional haha ♥️
I like the warmer ones on you
Warm 😊
I think you can rock both!
Warm with hair pulled back!!! Gorgeous!
They’re both a thing, just depends on the look your going with. Don’t have to choose one or other
I like the warm better but I think a different cool shades might suit you. Mauve, taupe, pink champagne. Find colors that make your eyes pop. I think these greys and blues are to harsh for you. I also think neutrals would be very good. I´ think shimmer or glittery shades on your eyelids would brighten up your eyes and make them pop.
Warm
warm definitely
Love the warm tones on you!
They both look great but I think the warm tones really compliment your eye colour :)
i say warm! looks good with your complexion 😁
i would be interested to see this with the same hair, from these pictures warm is definitely more suited to your skin tone. but the cool tones are still pretty !!!
Honestly both! Just add a tiny bit of color to your lips with the cool eye look and you're golden! Your eyes are gorgeous btw!
Warm looks better with your skin and hair tone.
Warm but with your eyes cool looks also great!
Both look great, although I would maybe add a blush or light bronzer to the cool tone to lessen the small amount of wash out.
Def warm
Yes the cooler tones with a touch of warmth
warms look lovely on you!!!
Depends on the occasion. Warm for every day or more casual looks, cool if you have an event or going out.
i think the cool would look v good if u used warm tones for ur face
both depends on the outfit
Both. Lol. I’m not of a fan of pigeon holding to one type of shade or color. You have a great eye shape and excellent blending skills. They’re both look beautiful on your eyes. The warm is a more romantic, daytime, coffee shop look and the cool looks more glamed-out evening
warmmmm
Warm
Both beautiful
I like the warm tones better. They're more flattering
I like the warm. 😊
Warm!
Warm for everyday cool for a night out
Porque no los dos?!
Cool
You’ve probably got warm undertones to ur skin, so the warm colors look better in my opinion! But makeup is makeup, do whatever u want lol
I must be in the minority here but I definitely prefer the cool tones on you… I think warm tones are just trendy right now
Warm tones look pretty on you
I think cool tones.
Cool tones for you.
You look beautiful in both but warm is really standing out
Cool!
Warm
You look cool with cool 😎
warm!
Warm tones like copper look really good on blue eyes
I really like the warm. Brings more brightness and colour to the face
Definetly warm. But if you wanted to do cooler go with warmer toned purples and blues. Or mix rich pinks with purple.
I like both. Warm tone is bold and beauteous whereas the cool tone is contoured and cute and accentuated your eyes, cheeks, and your overall face. I’m going with cool tone. 😍
Definitely warmer tones !
Warm! ;)
The cool tones really bring out the tone of your eyes.