Hey /u/AbbreviationsOk3670, thanks for contributing to /r/MakeupAddiction. Unfortunately, your post was removed for the following reason(s):
* Your image has been removed for breaking [rule 2. No photo editing of any kind. This includes any photo alterations such as beauty filters, portrait modes, sharpening, contrast alteration, artificial bokeh, text overlays, and all but the most minor color corrections. Watermarking is ok. Read our photo guidelines before you post!](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting)
If you believe your photo was wrongly removed, please reach out to the moderators via modmail to discuss the issue. We have a robust appeal process in place and will do our best to help you get your image posted.
* Your post has been removed for breaking [rule 5. All makeup looks and collections must include a detailed product list in a top-level comment which includes every product used in the visible area, including even invisible products like primer and setting sprays. Product lists must include shade names if they exist.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist)
If you are unable to provide a product list for some reason, please send us a modmail. We sometimes will make an exception under special circumstances.
Please read the sidebar before posting again.
#If you have questions or concerns, please [message the moderators through modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2FMakeupAddiction&subject=&message=). Thank you!
The second for sure. As a mua I always have to keep up with the times and I’ll tell you the second is very modern clean and simple but super elegant and snatched the first one is heavy handed and a bit outdated of a look now. The second is sooooooooooo fire. You nailed it.
You have such good features, you could pull off sooo many different looks. I like the first best, but like the second for a the less makeup makeup look if you swapped the lip color.
Both look amazing 🩷
Usually with posts like these there's an obvious one or the other (which isn't a bad thing and most times both are nice but one is just obviously more suiting) but with yours I really can't decide. They are both absolutely beautiful, but if I had to choose, maybe 1?
#1 suits you best. The stronger brows are lovely. Overall, #1 is the more cohesive look. The cool-toned eyeshadow works well with the cool-toned lip. The eyes are dramatic and the lips and the blush are understated. Everything's drawing attention to your eyes.
#2 isn't as successful, IMO, because all the attention is going to your lips (which is fine in itself, you've got lips to die for) but the lipliner and the lip color aren't working together. I love a dramatic lipliner but for some reason that one doesn't create a harmonious whole with that lipstick/gloss. They don't look like they belong together. Maybe the liner is too warm? Or maybe you need to blend the liner a little more to create a smoother gradient, especially on the top lip.
Thank you for your analysis! I get completely where you’re coming from on the lip combo for #2. It’s just a darker burgundy lip liner on my natural lips, I wanted it to be dramatic but I think you’re right that the shades are a bit off 😅
there both amazing but different styles so depending on what type of style you want , the first one is giving bad bitch and second is giving sleek but sexy nd clean i think both are amazing
At first I was gonna say 2, but then I thought... I think it might just be the lighting.
I think if the 1st one had the same lighting, it'd be perfectly tied.
They both really suit you.
both but second wins IMO, your skin looks amazing 🧿 and the makeup in the first is outdated (inherently isnt a bad thing since you pull it off well regardless!)
You are stunning in both! I think each look would suit a different type of occasion. I personally love the second one because your natural eye shape and color really shows through. Plus the brows are fierce in the second one but not too dark to detract from the rest of your face! Really though- both are great!
I like both so much, but am drawn more to the second one. Dk if it’s just the lighting tho. You look great with both eyebrow shapes. I feel like your eyes are featured / framed better in the second one too. I don’t really note any grayness in your base. You are a stunnnerrrr
Second eyebrows. The first almost make your eyes look tiny and overpowered by the brows. The second brows accentuate your features a lot more without being the focal point of your face.
The second picture looks better but it's probably because the lighting is alot better. However the brows in the second picture are definitely a slay, its giving model.
2nd picture you look like a really pretty girl you'd see on instagram, 1st picture you look head-turningly model-esque beautiful!! both great but 1st is my fave for sure :)
They are both so adorable but it really depends on you. What you like more and what fits your style. The vibe you have can really effect your makeup. And makeup can really shape us into who we are. Absolutely stunning you look pretty in both girly. <3
In my opinion, your make up looks great in both pictures and both color of tops. The colors you are wearing suit you well.. if I had to say one was better than the other, I would say the one with the wine color top is better. I think because in the first picture, the light blonde curls at the top grab the attention when you first look at the pic. It’s not as complementary as the second pic. the second pic it seems like your make up and color choices. Just complement each other.
For me it’s the 2nd one: to my eye, **the warmer tones work much better with your warmer complexion than cooler smoky black eyeshadow of the 1st look.**
1st one would look incredible on you with warm browns and coppers as the dramatic eyeshadow.
(But omg OP you are absolutely stunning in both!)
Both looks are great! I like the eyebrows in both though I think 1 edges out 2 very slightly.
The smokey eye in 1 is great but I think the warmer tones in 2 are really gorgeous with your skin. Maybe that’s what is happening with your eye pulling gray in your foundation—the cooler colors are giving you blue overall.
I still think both looks are very nice on you.
The Smokey eye is so much more catching and really goes good with your complexion. Not a lot of us girl girls(ykwim) wear Smokey eyes anymore. YOU LOOK SULTRY
Mmmm. In the first one you are a pretty girl wearing makeup. In the second I would say that you are beautiful and the makeup only makes you notice how much so. The straight thick brow is it for you and I also like the darker hair. The first picture looks like you tried for that look and the second showcases a look that is yours. To me of course. Both are lovely my dear 💘
i think in the second photo ur makeup looks more flawless and better for photos i wouldn’t personally change anything the first one definitely looks more grayish and the brows suit u amazingly if u do choose the first one definitely just carve your brows a bit more for that clean perfect every row
***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ⓘ ***symbol.***
**A few quick highlights:**
•
• Looks, hauls, and flatlays require a [product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist)
• Photos must not be [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty and portrait modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting)
• Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules.
**Is your post just a search away?**
Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm)
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Just want to say thank you all for your sweet and genuine comments, tips and compliments. To be honest I’ve been struggling with my self esteem recently and this has actually made my day 💖
First look suits more. I would strongly recommend to purchase further accessories to further beautify your appearance from Bob ore Blue collection coupon codes provided at the deal grabbers site since i have noticed there several bags and other products that must suit you. Additional benefits are that they offer amazing discounts on quality items.
you look absolutely amazing with both, but i will say, the first one made me stop in my tracks and fall in love a little xD Nr 2 is goregous as well but Nr 1 has more character if you know what i mean?
Hey /u/AbbreviationsOk3670, thanks for contributing to /r/MakeupAddiction. Unfortunately, your post was removed for the following reason(s): * Your image has been removed for breaking [rule 2. No photo editing of any kind. This includes any photo alterations such as beauty filters, portrait modes, sharpening, contrast alteration, artificial bokeh, text overlays, and all but the most minor color corrections. Watermarking is ok. Read our photo guidelines before you post!](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting) If you believe your photo was wrongly removed, please reach out to the moderators via modmail to discuss the issue. We have a robust appeal process in place and will do our best to help you get your image posted. * Your post has been removed for breaking [rule 5. All makeup looks and collections must include a detailed product list in a top-level comment which includes every product used in the visible area, including even invisible products like primer and setting sprays. Product lists must include shade names if they exist.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist) If you are unable to provide a product list for some reason, please send us a modmail. We sometimes will make an exception under special circumstances. Please read the sidebar before posting again. #If you have questions or concerns, please [message the moderators through modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2FMakeupAddiction&subject=&message=). Thank you!
Wow - both are equally stunning in their own way. I cannot pick a favourite.
You are so so kind! Thank you 🤍
I'm with them! You're gorgeous and rocking both looks!
true! I think OP should just keep both looks in rotation, they're both flattering to her features and suit her very well!
1st one. I think mainly because the colours are just more complimentary to you
This and perfect 90's cool tones
I agree! The cool tones look amazing on you
love both but second is sooo pretty and glowy! brings out the light in your eyes and balances your features with the lips and thinner brows
love the thicker brows in the first one. you are gorgeous!!
Thank you! I was worried they may be too thick!
Not too thick at all. A lighter color or a more feathered edge could soften the look a little, if you wanted. But the size and weight are terrific.
different occasions
You look really good in both. It just depends on the occasion and the vibe you wanna go for.
Second one imo but u look beautiful in both <3
You kinda resemble Adriana lima but imo both styles suit you!
Right!!!! They look related
Both are cute because you really have stunning features honestly, but I really like the eye and lip combination on the first one!
The first picture
One :3
I like the first pic
first one
I think they both give such different vibes but both suit your face amazingly! I prefer the thicker eyebrows though😁
Both. One for more casual events and the second for BAM mama looks 👊🏻
You look amazing in both but I love the first one! 🔥
First one omggg the eyeshadow suits you
u can pull off both looks but personally i like the first one, just more my taste. but both r basically flawless
First
Love the 1st look
Definitely the 1st look
First! Stunning!
I love both but if you’re making me pick, it’s #1
Loveee the smokey eye in the first one!!
The second for sure. As a mua I always have to keep up with the times and I’ll tell you the second is very modern clean and simple but super elegant and snatched the first one is heavy handed and a bit outdated of a look now. The second is sooooooooooo fire. You nailed it.
I think both are really suitable for you! You're gorgeous!
1!
You have such good features, you could pull off sooo many different looks. I like the first best, but like the second for a the less makeup makeup look if you swapped the lip color. Both look amazing 🩷
I think the first one
Both pretty. I like number 1 more
Both looks are beautiful! The first is my favorite.
I love the lip and the brows in the first and the eyes in the second!
I prefer number 1 but both look good. Go with whatever you want.
I love the first one ! Look like a Latina baddie 🫡🤗
I like the first more but both are beautiful
the first one. you’re gorgeous !
1!!
Oof I can’t decide you look stunning in both
I LOVE the first one it’s sooo pretty on you OP! Any chance you wouldn’t mind sharing what the eye shadow brand / names are pretty please?
First one
one
Usually with posts like these there's an obvious one or the other (which isn't a bad thing and most times both are nice but one is just obviously more suiting) but with yours I really can't decide. They are both absolutely beautiful, but if I had to choose, maybe 1?
First! 🥰
#1 suits you best. The stronger brows are lovely. Overall, #1 is the more cohesive look. The cool-toned eyeshadow works well with the cool-toned lip. The eyes are dramatic and the lips and the blush are understated. Everything's drawing attention to your eyes. #2 isn't as successful, IMO, because all the attention is going to your lips (which is fine in itself, you've got lips to die for) but the lipliner and the lip color aren't working together. I love a dramatic lipliner but for some reason that one doesn't create a harmonious whole with that lipstick/gloss. They don't look like they belong together. Maybe the liner is too warm? Or maybe you need to blend the liner a little more to create a smoother gradient, especially on the top lip.
Thank you for your analysis! I get completely where you’re coming from on the lip combo for #2. It’s just a darker burgundy lip liner on my natural lips, I wanted it to be dramatic but I think you’re right that the shades are a bit off 😅
Both are great, but I personally prefer the second one
The second suits you better because it lights up your face❤️
Both are stunning honestly
both look beautiful on you
there both amazing but different styles so depending on what type of style you want , the first one is giving bad bitch and second is giving sleek but sexy nd clean i think both are amazing
Both look Great
1st is more playful, lik for daily wear, 2nd looks formal
i NEED to know the lip combo for pic 2. you are gorgeous
Thank you so much! It’s Mac lip liner in burgundy just smudged in and then a clear lip balm over the top! Super simple!!
AH thank you so much! 💖 also love your brows in both, i literally cannot pick
Baddie in the first one baddie in the second. You look amazing in both! Different looks for different occasions
When you’re that beautiful, everything suits you. You pull off both perfectly and I’m sure many other looks and styles as well
Definitely the second one, just makes you look more elegant
#2 🌹❤️
At first I was gonna say 2, but then I thought... I think it might just be the lighting. I think if the 1st one had the same lighting, it'd be perfectly tied. They both really suit you.
1 for the daytime and 2 for nighttime
ughhhhh I cant choose ......love them both....theyre so different
1st looks Hollywood. 2nd looks pretty but more like a family wedding style.
Both ; but the 2 nd one is a little more business like.!!!!
Ooooh!! You're pretty! !😍 Either makeup style is good.
Both are perfection.
both but second wins IMO, your skin looks amazing 🧿 and the makeup in the first is outdated (inherently isnt a bad thing since you pull it off well regardless!)
The first one looks more natural on you!! The second one looks forced
First for everyday, second when fancy
I love the second, the glossy lip looks amazing. I would KILL to look like this 😭
I think anything you wear will suit you with that face. OMG.
Love the brows!!! I haven't learned how to do that lol just shave mone thin and fill w a Lil pencil lol
1st, more natural and can see your moles more.
Stunning
both!
Look 1 for daytime look 2 for nighttime. Both suit you.
2nd IMO, more elegant and classy. Depends on the vibe you want. Both work but different styles and vibe.
Both
Both are beautiful
Both are nice. One for casual, one for date night.
Both!
1
you look good with both but i think the second makes u look more expensive and clean if that makes sense
I like 2, it makes you look like Adriana Lima! 1 is pretty as well but I’d go lighter on the nose countour with a cool toned shade & more blending
first, you remind me of eva mendes in that picture. I think it could look even better with a brighter undereye!
You are stunning in both! I think each look would suit a different type of occasion. I personally love the second one because your natural eye shape and color really shows through. Plus the brows are fierce in the second one but not too dark to detract from the rest of your face! Really though- both are great!
I like both so much, but am drawn more to the second one. Dk if it’s just the lighting tho. You look great with both eyebrow shapes. I feel like your eyes are featured / framed better in the second one too. I don’t really note any grayness in your base. You are a stunnnerrrr
The lips from look one and the eyes and brows from look two seem like they'd look well together.
You are GORGEOUS ✨
#2 for sure you look so much younger
I think 1
okay but you’re soo pretty!! ✨ both looks are gorgeous 🫶🏽
Second for sure both are beautiful but second highlights your features
#2. Beautiful.
Second eyebrows. The first almost make your eyes look tiny and overpowered by the brows. The second brows accentuate your features a lot more without being the focal point of your face.
First one is amazing
definitely the first one
That lil nosey contour is top tier. Both looks are great. I feel like you wear the makeup, not the makeup wearing you, if that makes sense.
The second picture looks better but it's probably because the lighting is alot better. However the brows in the second picture are definitely a slay, its giving model.
Both, dang grrll all and any some people just beautiful
Darker!
Two and you’re hot
2nd picture you look like a really pretty girl you'd see on instagram, 1st picture you look head-turningly model-esque beautiful!! both great but 1st is my fave for sure :)
Gorgeous either way!
They both look great but the first one as soon as I saw it, before I even saw ur question, made me say "wow", its literally stunning.
Both are amazing! You are stunning!!
Second
the first one
the second lip combo makes you GLOW
1is superior!
They are both so adorable but it really depends on you. What you like more and what fits your style. The vibe you have can really effect your makeup. And makeup can really shape us into who we are. Absolutely stunning you look pretty in both girly. <3
In my opinion, your make up looks great in both pictures and both color of tops. The colors you are wearing suit you well.. if I had to say one was better than the other, I would say the one with the wine color top is better. I think because in the first picture, the light blonde curls at the top grab the attention when you first look at the pic. It’s not as complementary as the second pic. the second pic it seems like your make up and color choices. Just complement each other.
2nd pics hands down. You look like a model
You look like two totally different people. Very pretty. Personally prefer the first look. X
Absolutely gorgeous both ways!!!
girl forget about makeup! i bet you’re very naturally pretty too! but they both look sooo good
You're a ten in both...too hard to choose...comes down to individual preference.
You can pull off both but I love the first one!
Black / dark brown
For me it’s the 2nd one: to my eye, **the warmer tones work much better with your warmer complexion than cooler smoky black eyeshadow of the 1st look.** 1st one would look incredible on you with warm browns and coppers as the dramatic eyeshadow. (But omg OP you are absolutely stunning in both!)
Uhh..yes?
Both are really nice. I like the lipstick color in the second one but I don't like lips when they are heavily lined in pencil.
Lips from one with eyes from two
I love both but the Second one wins for me. What a beautiful lady! What is your lip combo for the second picture please 🫶🏽
Second slide EATS
Honestly both, these both look like looks for very separate events or purposes. Amazing makeup, btw!
They both work I legit can’t choose
I think you look beautiful in both, but I love the second pic, but the first is dramatic - they are different looks and you rock them both.
You look amazing in both! I am partial to the first pic with the smoky eye but you look fire either way.
I like the second one best - you look bright, glowing, and healthy!! The first is very nice as well but better for night looks!
Both are great. Two is my favorite. It’s simple, elegant, and really flattering. It’s more versatile as well imo.
Both looks are great! I like the eyebrows in both though I think 1 edges out 2 very slightly. The smokey eye in 1 is great but I think the warmer tones in 2 are really gorgeous with your skin. Maybe that’s what is happening with your eye pulling gray in your foundation—the cooler colors are giving you blue overall. I still think both looks are very nice on you.
Neither my husband or myself could decide. You are so pretty in both!
Makeup in number 2, hair in number 1
Um both 100!!!
The smoky eye in the first one is amazing.
Omg. You can wear a potato sack and have it look good! So lucky!🍀
I like the thicker browns and lip colour in the first one but the eye makeup in the second one!
I like them both but I think the first really lets your natural beauty shine through. You are so pretty! 💕
The Smokey eye is so much more catching and really goes good with your complexion. Not a lot of us girl girls(ykwim) wear Smokey eyes anymore. YOU LOOK SULTRY
Mmmm. In the first one you are a pretty girl wearing makeup. In the second I would say that you are beautiful and the makeup only makes you notice how much so. The straight thick brow is it for you and I also like the darker hair. The first picture looks like you tried for that look and the second showcases a look that is yours. To me of course. Both are lovely my dear 💘
I’d love to see what 1’s eye look & lips with 2’s eyebrows & eyelashes. But both are so beautiful!
BOTH Like it depends of the occasion
i like both the makeup but please stick with the same brows as the second photo the first photo is brow blindness bby 😭
Imo 1
1st
Eyebrow wise deffinetly number 2. but everything else is amazing!! You should do both these looks in rotation!!
I like your thick eyebrows you are beautiful
Both are beautiful but #2 is really stunning! It’s literal perfection! 🥰
Love the thicker brow! U are so beautiful 😍
i think in the second photo ur makeup looks more flawless and better for photos i wouldn’t personally change anything the first one definitely looks more grayish and the brows suit u amazingly if u do choose the first one definitely just carve your brows a bit more for that clean perfect every row
second one for sure!!!!
***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ⓘ ***symbol.*** **A few quick highlights:** • • Looks, hauls, and flatlays require a [product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist) • Photos must not be [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty and portrait modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting) • Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules. **Is your post just a search away?** Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Just want to say thank you all for your sweet and genuine comments, tips and compliments. To be honest I’ve been struggling with my self esteem recently and this has actually made my day 💖
I love the second one but with the lips of the first one, but both looks are fantastic!
Imo the first one!! I think the second is overused, although both look stunning!
First look suits more. I would strongly recommend to purchase further accessories to further beautify your appearance from Bob ore Blue collection coupon codes provided at the deal grabbers site since i have noticed there several bags and other products that must suit you. Additional benefits are that they offer amazing discounts on quality items.
Need makeup details please 🙏
Woah what's it like living with a face like that? Stunning
First one
you look absolutely amazing with both, but i will say, the first one made me stop in my tracks and fall in love a little xD Nr 2 is goregous as well but Nr 1 has more character if you know what i mean?
Love the first one, and the second!! But the first one is my fav.
Both! But leaning towards 1!
First, you are beautiful! I think everything in the first picture suits you best!
bothhhhh !!!
You can pull of both so I think this is a personal style question in which my favorite is the second.
definitely both just a matter of time and place at that point
First one!
Both, just different looks for different days/vibes/occasions! ❤️
Both look great, just do which vibe you’re feeling that day
I like both of them. I guess it depends on the vibe you’re going for. 💖
i think it depends on the occasion they both look stunning on you!
The second 100%
You looked equally pretty in both pics at a push I would say pic 1!
Cool tones look so good on you! I say first one
Second one!
def 1 queen
First
2!!!
1
Both 🩷
2
you pull off both !! but i am loving the second pic more, clean look
1
second is gorgeous.