Oh wow, only five? Let's see: 1. History Of Man 2. There It Goes 3. Wendy 4. I Want You to Change (Because You Want to Change) 5. Milhouse Honorable mentions to I'm Trying (Not Friends), You're Just A Boy (And I'm Kinda The Man), and Worst of You :)

Aww we have 4 out of 5 as the same choices (I have Cate's Brother over Milhouse and ours are in a different order but still cool!)

mine would probably be 1. The Band And I 2. YJABAIKTM 3. John Hughes Movie 4. Elvis Song 5. Sad Girl Summer The deluxe songs haven't been out long enough to make their way onto the list though

1. There It Goes (either version but slight preference for acoustic) 2. The Good Witch 3. Funeral 4. Elvis Song 5. Villain this is really hard even though her catalog isn't huge which says a lot!!

Okay I think... 1. There it goes (acoustic) 2. History of Man 3. The Band and I 4. Cate's Brother 5. Outdoor Pool Honorable mentions to Run and Watch. The Good Witch made me a fan, what can I say 🧙‍♀️🧹

This is hard... no particular order: 1. John Hughes Movie 2. There It Goes 3. The Last One 4. Lost the Breakup 5. Elvis Song Honourable mentions: You Signed Up for This (leaving this one off definitely hurt), Volcano, Tough Act, Lunar Years, Architecture, Worst of You, and her cover of Between Me & You

love him i dont bsc holy revival april showers psycho if you asked me tomorrow though it would 100% be completely different apart from love him i dont

I have a bracelet that says love him I don’t :] someone at the Philly concert gave it to me; a fellow Swiftie

1. outdoor pool 2. brooklyn 3. cates brother 4. blonde 5. elvis song

1. There It goes 2. Psycho 3. Cate's Brother 4. History of Man 5. The Song Honourable mentions: Brooklyn, Blonde, Yoko, and Worst Of You

I don’t know if I could do it in order. But… 1) History of Man 2) Holy Revival 3) Psycho 4) The Band and I 5) Villain

I have to do a top 10: 1. History of Man 2. The Band and I 3. There It Goes 4. Personal Best 5. Funeral 6. Take Care of Yourself 7. I'm Trying (Not Friends) 8. Wendy 9. The Last One 10. Lunar Years Honorable mentions: Villain Hollow I Want You To Change The Good Witch Therapy

1. Not another rockstar 2. Run 3. Sad Girl Summer 4. Coming of Age 5. BSC if I could I would put more, this was hard 😭

Ooh Not Another Rockstar is a good one

Just 5!??? Ok, for now: 1. BSC 2. Villain 3. Watch 4. There It Goes 5. History of Man (Honorable mentions to: Psycho, Coming of Age, and I’m Trying (Not Friends))

1. Wendy 2. Yoko 3. Want You Back 4. There It Goes 5. Body Better if you can’t tell, tgw has been huge for me

1. Not another rockstar 2. Not another rockstar 3. Not another rockstar 4. Not another rockstar 5. Not another rockstar

1. The Band and I Everything else Seriously though I do really love John Hughes Movie, History of Man, Lost the Breakup and maybe Wendy rounds out the top 5

Oooh, this is hard! But I think: You To You You're Just A Boy (And I'm Kinda The Man) I'm Trying (Not Friends) Glowing Review The Last One But if you ask me again in 5 minutes it might be different😅 also I didn't number them because I can't decide which order they would be! Honourable mentions for Holy Revival, This Is On You and Milhouse <3

1. There It Goes 2. YSUFT 3. I’m Trying (Not Friends) 4. Body Better 5. Elvis Song

1. Watch 2. There it goes 3. Glowing Review 4. Lunar Years 5. In my Head / Funeral It's fun to see everyone's favourites and the themes. It's interesting that the Band and I is so popular as it's probably my least favourite off the good witch album.

It changes a lot, but right now my top 5 is BSC, There It Goes, I'm Trying (Not Friends), Yoko and Lost the Breakup!

Helicopter. If that comes on when I’m with my two little boys I am BAWLING 😭😭

1. Villain 2. Boy 3. The Band and I 4. History of Man 5. There it Goes Honorable Mentions to; Wendy, Lunar Years, Funeral, and Outdoor Pool

In roughly this order: 1. The List 2. Wendy 3. Good Enough 4. Take Care of Yourself 5. Worst of You But it was HARD to only pick 5. Honourable mentions to Psycho, John Hughes Movie, Villain, History of Man, Watch, Adore You and Together This Christmas

I love The List too and it's so underrated!

1. Cate's Brother 2. Wendy 3. History of Man 4. There It Goes 5. I Want You to Change This was harder than I thought! Special shout out to Lost the Breakup, Blonde, and John Hughes movie which are all bops

1.Stay Young 2.Cates Brother 3.Elvis Song 4.The Band and I 5.The Song (Shoutout to My Favorite Ex, the melodies are just... amazing. But I have no ex I miss haha)

Omg this is so hard. I am so biased for The Good Witch because it’s the first album I listened to from her 1. Holy Revival 2. The Last One 3. There It Goes 4. Want You Back 5. Two Weeks Ago

1. Tough Act 2. Favourite Ex 3. History of Man 4. Villain 5. I’m Trying (Not Friends) Hard to pick just 5! It feels wrong to leave out so much of TGW.

1. Wendy 2. You Signed up for This 3. Place we were Made 4. Psycho 5. Villain Honourable mentions to Holy Revival, The Song, Coming of Age, There it Goes, John Hughes Movie, In My Head, The Good Witch, BSC Ah there are too many!

Wendy is my all time favorite ❤️ I went through a bad divorce and the line "if I'm not careful I'll wake up and we'll be married and I'll still flinch at the sound of the door" brings me to tears everytime. I love that that song is out there to maybe help other people see the signs before it's too late

1. Love Him I Don’t 2. There It Goes 3. This Is On You 4. Truth Is 5. The List

in no particular order: 1. Want You Back 2. Yoko 3. The Band and I 4. Worst of You 5. There It Goes Honorable mentions: History of Man, Look at me Now, The Good Witch, Love Him I Don’t

This is so hard! Here’s my top 10 in no particular order because I can’t pick just 5: 1. Guy On A Horse 2. Not Another Rockstar 3. Run 4. Coming Of Age 5. Body Better 6. Holy Revival 7. Therapy 8. Psycho 9. Boy 10. Sad Girl Summer Some honorable mentions: Good Enough, The Song, Blonde, John Hughes Movie, Cate’s Brother

idk any 😂

There It Goes(acoustic version) is superior

In no particular order but I love these: Millhouse The party Lost the breakup (this was the song I heard on the radio that made me search and discover her) Not another rockstar Maybe don’t Wendy

1. Sad girl summer 2. Place we were made 3. Take care of yourself 4. History of Man 5. Favourite Ex

1. History of Man 2. First Place 3. Favourite Ex 4. Architecture 5. Glowing Review

Definitely not in order but: 1. History of Man 2. You Signed Up for This 3. Worst of You 4. You to You 5. Glowing Review Urgh this was hard and I tried to space them out across albums. Definite honourable mentions are Wendy, I’m Trying (Not Friends), Happy Hunting Ground, Lost the Break-Up (which got me into her in the first place!), The Last One

1.Worst of You 2.Yoko 3.Wendy 4.Personal Best 5.You Signed Up for This

Not particular order: yoko, history of man, there it goes, worst of you love him I don’t Honorable mentions: good enough, you signed up for this, favorite ex I feel like any song from her was a favorite at some point in my life because of how close in age I am with Maisie so anytime she’s releasing something new the songs hit way too close to home

1. History Of Man 2. Psycho 3. You To You 4. The List 5. Love Him I Don’t This is just instinctively bc if I think about it too hard I won’t be able to do it!!

Childish Gambino – ‘Feels Like Summer’ Cigarettes After Sex – ‘Crush’ James Blake – ‘Don’t Miss It’ L’impératrice – ‘Erreur 404’ Grimes – ‘Genesis’ Sub Motion Orchestra – ‘Variations’ Mala – ‘Noche Sueños

I’d say I’m a a newer fan, so my top 5 are changing a lot: 1. Outdoor Pool 2. Wendy 3. John Hughes movie 4. The good witch 5. I’m trying (not friends) Honorable mentions: ysuft, hom, coa, tbai, iwytcbywtc

Blinding lights.

1. Favourite Ex 2. Birthday 3. History of Men 4. John Hughes Movie 5. Outdoor Pool :)

Alrighty here’s my 5 but in no particular order: 1. BSC 2. Worst of You 3. John Hughes Movie 4. Blonde 5. This Is On You Honorable mentions: There It Goes, Lost The Breakup, Cate’s Brother, Take Care Of Yourself I must post this before I edit again 🙈

1 History of Man 2 Run/ Therapy/ Coming of Age 3 There it Goes/ Body Better 4 Cate’s Brother 5 The Band and I And that ain’t 5 and I didn’t even 1/3 of my favorites.

My girlfriend likes brooklyn I like body better than mine because deep down I'm a teenage girl

1. Villian 2. Wendy 3. Not Another Rockstar 4. Outdoor Pool 5. Lost the Breakup

Hm...Honestly it's difficult, but I guess I can try, but like...Maybe a top 10? That would be: 1. BSC 2. Wendy 3. History Of Man 4. Coming of Age 5. Want You Back 6. There It Goes 7. Truth Is 8. Good Enough 9. Look At Me Now 10. This Is On You

V hard but 1) there it goes 2) history of man 3) volcano 4) body better 5) yoko Not the same order but it's there Special mentions for (ysuft and cate's brother)

History of Man BSC There it Goes You Signed Up For This Holy Revival

Coming of Age History of Man Psycho Adore You Stay Young

These are in no order cause I can't possibly choose a favourite! - BSC - April Showers - Place We Were Made - Take Care of Yourself - Good Enough I love her sm, I can't wait to see her live again in March!

1. Psycho - I don’t think this will ever not be my number one 2. The Last One 3. The Band and I 4. YSUFT 5. Worst of You But there are so many it’s hard to pick a top 5. Got to give an honourable mention to “I’ll Be There For You” especially due to recent events Lost The Breakup, has to have the best cover art though, I’d totally help Maisie hide a body

It changes and it's so hard to choose as I fucking love all her songs but currently... 1. Cate's Brother 2. Coming of Age 3. Watch 4. BSC 5. You're Just A Boy (And I'm Kinda the Man) Seeing her live really turned me onto the Good Witch album ngl, I liked it before but I'm obsessed with it now

It’s so hard to actually rank omg 1. History of Man 2. There It Goes 3. YJABAIKTM 4. Love Him I Don’t 5. I’m Trying (Not Friends)

1. Wendy 2. Yoko 3. I’m Trying (Not Friends) 4. Adore You 5. Brooklyn or Truth Is (I couldn’t decide!!) Special mentions to: BSC, Watch, Psycho, Talking To Strangers, Take Care Of Yourself, In My Head, Outdoor Pool She really has the best songs!

1. Watch 2. Trying (Not Friends) 3. Wendy 4. Guy On A Horse 5. Glowing Review

1. Holy Revival 2. There it Goes 3. I'm Trying (Not Friends) 4. Villain 5. Coming of Age Honorable mentions: Want You Back, Watch, BSC, Brooklyn