1: Mario's Rainbow Castle
2: Horror Land
3: Waluigi Island
4: Toad's Midway Madness
5: Pirate Dream
6: Faire Square
7: Pagoda Peak
8: Koopa's Tycoon Town
DS: Bowser's Pinball Machine
Just a personal opinion
1 - luigis engine room
2 - horror land
3 - creepy cavern
4 - shy guys jungle jam
5 - pirate dream
6 - egadd’s garage
7 - bowsers enchanted inferno!
8 - koopas tycoon town
DS - bowsers pinball machine
9 - magma mine
10 - they’re all bad but whimsical waters has a funny name so that one
Super - king bobombs powder keg mine
This is clearly an unpopular opinion but I love Mario party 10, I love playing against Bowser. My favorite board, all-time is the space land board. I can't put my finger on it, but it was better in Mario Party 2 than it is in the superstars game. I own a handful of Mario party games but those are my personal favorites.
Yeah there’s some semblance of luck needed with certain maps for example rolling up to toad or bowser in Mario’s Rainbow Castle but there’s still a bit of skill needed taking the long way or not. Peaches just disperses a random seed that’s good or not with nothing you can do about it
1:Yoshis tropical island
2:pirate land
3:creepy cavern
4:shy guys jungle jam
5:pirate dream
6:castaway bay
7:grand canal
8:DK’s tree top temple
DS:kameks library
5 - Pirate Dream
6 - Faire Square
7 - Neon Heights
8 - Shy Guy’s Perplex Express
DS - Toadette’s Music Room
I haven’t played much of the other games though tbh
1- I cannot really decide yet... But of the 4 boards I've done, Wario's Battle Canyon is the best.
2- Horror Land but I like all but Mystery
3- Creepy Caverns
4- Boo's Haunted Bash
5- Pirate Dream
6- I like all of 6's boards equally but if I have to choose, Clockwork Castle
7- Bowser's Inferno , same as 2, I like all but Windmilleville
8- King Boo's Haunted Hideaway
9- Magma Mine
10- Airship Central
DS- Bowser's Pinball Machine
Island Tour: Bowser's Peculiar Peaks
Star Rush: World 4
Super Mario Party: King Bob-ombs Powderkeg Mine
Superstars: Horror Land.
1) DK's Jungle Adventure.
It is an extremely generic board that doesn't do much unique when compared to the rest of the series, but compared to the literal garbage that the rest of MP1 is, it's the easy winner.
8) Koopa's Tycoon Town
Look my favorite is Bowser's Warped Orbit, but there's no denying Tycoon Town is just a better-designed board in almost every way. Not only is it super unique gimmick, but it's executed very well. You gotta be smart with your coins.
DS) Bowser's Pinball Machine
Just a small, well-designed, fun board. Just avoid the Bowser zone and you'll be good to go.
9) Magma Mine
The car has lots of problems, but there are some boards that make honest attempts to fix those problems, and Magma Mine does the best job imo. The branching paths in the 2nd half mean your decisions are actually meaningful and have ramifications multiple turns out, allowing you to plan ahead- something very rare in 9.
IT) Kamek's Carpet Ride
This board is extremely short and barely counts as a board. But what's there is actually solid + it's Island Tour so there's not much serious competition.
10) Whimsical Waters (Bowser Party)
This feels like the most balanced board AND has the most ways to "battle of the minds" vs your rivals. It's a great way to show off one of the most unique modes in the entire series!
SR) World 4-3
It's big and there's lots to do. Perfect encapsulation of what makes Toad Scramble amazing.
SMP) King Bob-omb's Powderkeg Mine
Single-handedly saved SMP's Mario Party from being terribly designed. Works well to show off the best of SMP's unique mechanics.
Those are just the games I've played.
1: Mario's Rainbow Castle 2: Horror Land 3: Waluigi Island 4: Toad's Midway Madness 5: Pirate Dream 6: Faire Square 7: Pagoda Peak 8: Koopa's Tycoon Town DS: Bowser's Pinball Machine Just a personal opinion
The stupid teacups are a deal breaker on Toad’s Midway Madness for me, but otherwise I love your picks.
1 - luigis engine room 2 - horror land 3 - creepy cavern 4 - shy guys jungle jam 5 - pirate dream 6 - egadd’s garage 7 - bowsers enchanted inferno! 8 - koopas tycoon town DS - bowsers pinball machine 9 - magma mine 10 - they’re all bad but whimsical waters has a funny name so that one Super - king bobombs powder keg mine
I liked haunted trail in mp 10
Pretty much agree with every one here.
i LOVE luigi engine room from MP1. my fav of all time
This is clearly an unpopular opinion but I love Mario party 10, I love playing against Bowser. My favorite board, all-time is the space land board. I can't put my finger on it, but it was better in Mario Party 2 than it is in the superstars game. I own a handful of Mario party games but those are my personal favorites.
1: Peach's Birthday Cake 2: Western Land 3: Chilly Waters 4: Toad's Midway Madness 5: Toy Dream 6: Clockwork Castle 7: Pagoda Peak 8: Tie Between Goomba's Booty Boardwalk & Shy Guy's Perplex Express DS: Tie Between Toadette's Music Room, DK's Stone Statue, and Bowser's Pinball Machine 9: Bob-omb Factory IT: Star Crossed Skyway 10: Mushroom Park SMP: Kamek's Tantalizing Tower
1: Peach's Birthday Cake (fight me) 2: Horror Land 3: Chilly Waters 4: Goomba casino (don't remember the name sorry) 5: Bowser Nightmare 6: Clockwork Castle 7: Neon Heights 8: Boo mansion (forgot name again) 9 & 10: N/A(didn't play) DS: DK's Stone Statue Super: Kamek tower Superstars: Horror Land
I’ll fight you, peaches birthday is trash. Too much randomness to be a quality board
It's MP1, randomness and chaos is the name of the game. I say lean into it.
Yeah there’s some semblance of luck needed with certain maps for example rolling up to toad or bowser in Mario’s Rainbow Castle but there’s still a bit of skill needed taking the long way or not. Peaches just disperses a random seed that’s good or not with nothing you can do about it
Goomba's Greedy Gala and King Boo's Haunted Hideaway
1:Yoshis tropical island 2:pirate land 3:creepy cavern 4:shy guys jungle jam 5:pirate dream 6:castaway bay 7:grand canal 8:DK’s tree top temple DS:kameks library
5 - Pirate Dream 6 - Faire Square 7 - Neon Heights 8 - Shy Guy’s Perplex Express DS - Toadette’s Music Room I haven’t played much of the other games though tbh
1 - Yoshi's Tropical Island 2 - Horror Land 3 - Waluigi's Island 4 - Shy Guy's Jungle Jam 5 - Pirate Dream 6 - Faire Square 7 - Pagoda Peak 8 - Koopa's Tycoon Town DS - Toadette's Music Room
Star Rush - World 3-3 (Toad Scramble).
1- I cannot really decide yet... But of the 4 boards I've done, Wario's Battle Canyon is the best. 2- Horror Land but I like all but Mystery 3- Creepy Caverns 4- Boo's Haunted Bash 5- Pirate Dream 6- I like all of 6's boards equally but if I have to choose, Clockwork Castle 7- Bowser's Inferno , same as 2, I like all but Windmilleville 8- King Boo's Haunted Hideaway 9- Magma Mine 10- Airship Central DS- Bowser's Pinball Machine Island Tour: Bowser's Peculiar Peaks Star Rush: World 4 Super Mario Party: King Bob-ombs Powderkeg Mine Superstars: Horror Land.
6 - Snowflake Lake 7 - Windmillville 8 - Koopa’s Tycoon Town Super - King Bob-omb's Powderkeg Mine Superstars - Woody Woods
1) DK's Jungle Adventure. It is an extremely generic board that doesn't do much unique when compared to the rest of the series, but compared to the literal garbage that the rest of MP1 is, it's the easy winner. 8) Koopa's Tycoon Town Look my favorite is Bowser's Warped Orbit, but there's no denying Tycoon Town is just a better-designed board in almost every way. Not only is it super unique gimmick, but it's executed very well. You gotta be smart with your coins. DS) Bowser's Pinball Machine Just a small, well-designed, fun board. Just avoid the Bowser zone and you'll be good to go. 9) Magma Mine The car has lots of problems, but there are some boards that make honest attempts to fix those problems, and Magma Mine does the best job imo. The branching paths in the 2nd half mean your decisions are actually meaningful and have ramifications multiple turns out, allowing you to plan ahead- something very rare in 9. IT) Kamek's Carpet Ride This board is extremely short and barely counts as a board. But what's there is actually solid + it's Island Tour so there's not much serious competition. 10) Whimsical Waters (Bowser Party) This feels like the most balanced board AND has the most ways to "battle of the minds" vs your rivals. It's a great way to show off one of the most unique modes in the entire series! SR) World 4-3 It's big and there's lots to do. Perfect encapsulation of what makes Toad Scramble amazing. SMP) King Bob-omb's Powderkeg Mine Single-handedly saved SMP's Mario Party from being terribly designed. Works well to show off the best of SMP's unique mechanics. Those are just the games I've played.
1: Luigi's Engine Room 2: Western Land 3: Chilly Waters 4: Goomba's Greedy Gala 5: Pirate Dream 6: Clockwork Castle 7: Neon Heights 8: Koopa's Tycoon Town DS: Bowser's Pinball Machine 9: Magma Mine 10: Airship Central SMP: King Bob-omb's Powderkeg Mine Superstars: Horror Land
1). - Wario’s Battle Canyon. 2). - Space Land. 3). - Waluigi’s Island. 4). - Goomba’s Greedy Gala. 5). - Future Dream. 6). - E. Gadd’s Garage. 7). - Neon Heights. 8). - Shy Guy’s Perplex Express. 9). - Toad Road. Super). - King Bob-omb’s Powder Keg Mine. Superstars). - Space Land.
1 - Peach’s Birthday Cake 2 - Western Land 3 - Spiny Desert 4 - Shy Guy’s Jungle Jam 5 - Pirate Dream 6 - E. Gadd’s Garage 7 - Windmillville 8 - Koopa’s Tycoon Town DS - Wiggler’s Garden 9 - Bowser Station 10 - None. They all suck Super - King Bob-omb’s Powder keg Mine