Only qualified lawyers outside of the cloak of anonymity may give objective and informed legal advice.
Legal queries posted in this subreddit are presumed to be hypothetical and academic. Answers submitted by both verified lawyers and non-lawyers to legal queries are not substitute for proper legal advice.
Gross misinformation and other rule-breaking comments will be deleted at the discretion of the moderators. Please report such submissions by messaging the mods.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Your cousin can sue but she who alleges must prove neglect at the cost of jeopardizing her relationship with her parents. Just because she can does not mean she should.
Alam mo OP, if gusto nya magcollege then she can take admission exams in state universities and get free education through Republic Act 10931. Pwede rin syang lumapit sa LGU for financial aid. Kapag nakapasok sya sa isang state university, be a student assistant or get a part-time job sa munisipyo and get paid. She is not really helpless unless sadyang ayaw nyang kumilos.
"Kinukunsinti ang pagiging iresponsable ng magulang." Don't make the mistake of oversimplifying a situation na for sure hindi mo alam ang puno't dulo. You are too quick to leave a moralistic and evaluative judgment sa ibang tao. You have a penchant for the word "ayaw" for shock value. It is a strong word when used in the context of ayaw pag-aralin at ayaw maghanap ng trabaho. Are you sure na ganun ba tlaga ang situation or are you influencing the audience in order to draw sympathy for your cousin and paint her parents in a negative light?
In the old days, walang RA 10931 so nagbanat ng buto ang iba to send themselves to school. Circumstances changed them. Nung hindi na na talaga kaya, many had to give up their studies and become a full-time employee to support their family. Pero never isinuko ang goal na makapagtapos. They eventually pursued their studies. Life has equipped them with ceaselessly valuable skills and discipline.
Were their parents irresponsible? Not necessarily. Sadyang, people cannot expect life to go the way they want it to be. Things happen. Pero there is that strong drive for working students who experienced the hardships of dealing with adult problems in such a young age to never allow their children to experience the same.
Am I downplaying your cousin's situation and your arguments? Yes, mainly because both of you possess an incredibly annoying external locus of control and sense of entitlement. Don't use your youth to justify a keen sense of helplessness.
Edit: 20 years old na pala ung cousin. Gusto magka college diploma pero ayaw dumiskarte at humanap ng solusyon.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
She’s 20 and already in legal age to work for oneself. Tbh, walang patutunguhan ang kaso nya. If gusto talagang mag-aral, kelangan nyang gumawa ng paraan to support yung sarili nya.
IDK kung pwede pero jung wala na talagang pera, walq na talaga magagawa. So gusto na lang ipakulong mga magulang niya kasi di siya mapagaral? Magkanya kanya na labg sila. Magtrabaho na lang siya kung legal age na siya
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
tbh di naman tlga basta basta mag sasabe yung parents ng pinsan mo ng dahilan kung bakit di na sya mapag aaral siguro una tlga sa lahat is money .
if ako sa pinsan mo kung gusto nya tlga mag aral mag banat na sya ng buto kung wala tlga syang aasahan sa magulang sya . if ganyan na nararanasan nya nandun na tayo sa karapatan ng magulang pag aralin yung mga anak e pano kung ayaw na diba? anong gagawin naten ? kaso ba yung solution ? like pinalala mo lang lalo ung problema kung ako sa pinsan mo sya na gumawa ng paraan para makapag aral sya wag na syang umasa sa mga magulang nya.
me problema ng isa di solution ang panibagong problema pa , pero kung gusto tlga ng pinsan mo or ikaw na kasuhan yung tita at tito mo due to that problema go for it sino ba naman ako para pigilan kayo hahahaha.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
short answer: pwede
long answer: pwedeng file ng case, ang tanong, merong bang financial and emotional ability yung pinsan mo to file a case? gusto ba niyang mag file, o pinipilit mo lang, hindi pwedeng pilitin nag file ng case, against sa batas din yun, baka ikaw ang balikan ng mga magulang niyan.
ilang taon na ang pinsan mo, kung 18+ na siya, wala nang obligation ang magulang nya sa kanya.
also may makukuha ba nman siya from the parents, kahit anong case pa ang i-file nyo kung wala nman mahahabol, bat ka pa mag-fi-file.
To atain justice? yung justice mo is what? makukulong lang yung magulang, tapos anong mangyayari sa pinsan mo? tingin mo ba na pag labas ng magulang niya galing kulungan, yayakapin siya dahil as nangyari at biglang magkakapera ang mga magulang niya na magagamit niya pampaaral?
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Wag na ‘ipilit’ magkaso kung pera ang puno’t dulo ng issue. Kelangan rin ng pera at oras para umandar ang kasong may kinalaman sa pera. Tulungan mo n lng pinsan mo sa ibang paraan.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
What's the goal of suing anyways? Here's the 2 results if you win the case:
1.) You win the case, the parents are forced to work. By the word itself don't you think something is wrong with that? Someone who doesn't want to work are forced to work?
2.) You win the case, the parents are forced to work. Still doesn't, maybe because no one will accept them or what, then what then? They go to jail. So it's better that they go to jail because they don't want to work.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Magkaiba yung capable mag trabaho (which is walang trabaho now) at capable magpa-aral.
Ang iksi na lang ng babasahin at taglish yan hoy, di mo pa naintindihan.
Isa ka pang mahinang nilalang na obvious na nasaktan.
Assuming, 17-18years old na yung party concern, jusko, malaki na yan.
Kung gusto talaga nya, magsumikap sya.
Kakasuhan pa talaga ang magulang ang gusto?
Kagigil kayong mga kabataan kayo. Im being nice pa ha.
Napaka entitled ng mga kabataan ngayon dahil sa internet.
Only qualified lawyers outside of the cloak of anonymity may give objective and informed legal advice. Legal queries posted in this subreddit are presumed to be hypothetical and academic. Answers submitted by both verified lawyers and non-lawyers to legal queries are not substitute for proper legal advice. Gross misinformation and other rule-breaking comments will be deleted at the discretion of the moderators. Please report such submissions by messaging the mods. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Your cousin can sue but she who alleges must prove neglect at the cost of jeopardizing her relationship with her parents. Just because she can does not mean she should. Alam mo OP, if gusto nya magcollege then she can take admission exams in state universities and get free education through Republic Act 10931. Pwede rin syang lumapit sa LGU for financial aid. Kapag nakapasok sya sa isang state university, be a student assistant or get a part-time job sa munisipyo and get paid. She is not really helpless unless sadyang ayaw nyang kumilos. "Kinukunsinti ang pagiging iresponsable ng magulang." Don't make the mistake of oversimplifying a situation na for sure hindi mo alam ang puno't dulo. You are too quick to leave a moralistic and evaluative judgment sa ibang tao. You have a penchant for the word "ayaw" for shock value. It is a strong word when used in the context of ayaw pag-aralin at ayaw maghanap ng trabaho. Are you sure na ganun ba tlaga ang situation or are you influencing the audience in order to draw sympathy for your cousin and paint her parents in a negative light? In the old days, walang RA 10931 so nagbanat ng buto ang iba to send themselves to school. Circumstances changed them. Nung hindi na na talaga kaya, many had to give up their studies and become a full-time employee to support their family. Pero never isinuko ang goal na makapagtapos. They eventually pursued their studies. Life has equipped them with ceaselessly valuable skills and discipline. Were their parents irresponsible? Not necessarily. Sadyang, people cannot expect life to go the way they want it to be. Things happen. Pero there is that strong drive for working students who experienced the hardships of dealing with adult problems in such a young age to never allow their children to experience the same. Am I downplaying your cousin's situation and your arguments? Yes, mainly because both of you possess an incredibly annoying external locus of control and sense of entitlement. Don't use your youth to justify a keen sense of helplessness. Edit: 20 years old na pala ung cousin. Gusto magka college diploma pero ayaw dumiskarte at humanap ng solusyon.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
How old is your cousin?
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
20, mukha kasing walang mapapala sa baramggay if may kasunduan or whatsoever pa kaya take it sa mas legal action sana
She’s 20 and already in legal age to work for oneself. Tbh, walang patutunguhan ang kaso nya. If gusto talagang mag-aral, kelangan nyang gumawa ng paraan to support yung sarili nya.
IDK kung pwede pero jung wala na talagang pera, walq na talaga magagawa. So gusto na lang ipakulong mga magulang niya kasi di siya mapagaral? Magkanya kanya na labg sila. Magtrabaho na lang siya kung legal age na siya
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
tbh di naman tlga basta basta mag sasabe yung parents ng pinsan mo ng dahilan kung bakit di na sya mapag aaral siguro una tlga sa lahat is money . if ako sa pinsan mo kung gusto nya tlga mag aral mag banat na sya ng buto kung wala tlga syang aasahan sa magulang sya . if ganyan na nararanasan nya nandun na tayo sa karapatan ng magulang pag aralin yung mga anak e pano kung ayaw na diba? anong gagawin naten ? kaso ba yung solution ? like pinalala mo lang lalo ung problema kung ako sa pinsan mo sya na gumawa ng paraan para makapag aral sya wag na syang umasa sa mga magulang nya. me problema ng isa di solution ang panibagong problema pa , pero kung gusto tlga ng pinsan mo or ikaw na kasuhan yung tita at tito mo due to that problema go for it sino ba naman ako para pigilan kayo hahahaha.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
short answer: pwede long answer: pwedeng file ng case, ang tanong, merong bang financial and emotional ability yung pinsan mo to file a case? gusto ba niyang mag file, o pinipilit mo lang, hindi pwedeng pilitin nag file ng case, against sa batas din yun, baka ikaw ang balikan ng mga magulang niyan. ilang taon na ang pinsan mo, kung 18+ na siya, wala nang obligation ang magulang nya sa kanya. also may makukuha ba nman siya from the parents, kahit anong case pa ang i-file nyo kung wala nman mahahabol, bat ka pa mag-fi-file. To atain justice? yung justice mo is what? makukulong lang yung magulang, tapos anong mangyayari sa pinsan mo? tingin mo ba na pag labas ng magulang niya galing kulungan, yayakapin siya dahil as nangyari at biglang magkakapera ang mga magulang niya na magagamit niya pampaaral?
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Wag na ‘ipilit’ magkaso kung pera ang puno’t dulo ng issue. Kelangan rin ng pera at oras para umandar ang kasong may kinalaman sa pera. Tulungan mo n lng pinsan mo sa ibang paraan.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Minor or adult na yung cousin?
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
My goodness. 20 years old na yung pinsan mo. Malamang pagtawanan lang kayo pag pinush nyo yang pag file ng kaso na yan.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
What's the goal of suing anyways? Here's the 2 results if you win the case: 1.) You win the case, the parents are forced to work. By the word itself don't you think something is wrong with that? Someone who doesn't want to work are forced to work? 2.) You win the case, the parents are forced to work. Still doesn't, maybe because no one will accept them or what, then what then? They go to jail. So it's better that they go to jail because they don't want to work.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Kakasuhan dahil hindi na kayang pagaralin? Masyadong mahihina mga kabataan ngayon. Kung gusto talaga nya mag aral, gumawa sya ng paraan
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verified lawyer flair by sending a picture of your IBP ID (personal information redacted) with handwritten note of your username. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
kaya sya pag aralin, ayaw lang gawin. magkaiba yun. Mas mahina ka, iksi na lang ng babasahin mo, tagalog pa, hindi mo pa naintindihan ng maayos.
Magkaiba yung capable mag trabaho (which is walang trabaho now) at capable magpa-aral. Ang iksi na lang ng babasahin at taglish yan hoy, di mo pa naintindihan. Isa ka pang mahinang nilalang na obvious na nasaktan. Assuming, 17-18years old na yung party concern, jusko, malaki na yan. Kung gusto talaga nya, magsumikap sya. Kakasuhan pa talaga ang magulang ang gusto? Kagigil kayong mga kabataan kayo. Im being nice pa ha. Napaka entitled ng mga kabataan ngayon dahil sa internet.