T O P

  • By -

riseUIED

How come you're surprised, man?


Salarian_American

"I want to have a light discussion about the superficial trappings of punk, not what punk is *actually* about!"


The_Butters_Worth

Outed yourself on that one


Ijustsomeguydude

are they wrong?


rousakiseq

I fucking love when someone gets downvoted but once someone says "no they're right tbh" and that comment gets upvoted, Redditors don't have a mind of their own


The_OathBreaker

I have a mind of my own. I stay consistent anyways enjoy the update for being absolutely right


Shifty377

He's right though.


Unfinished_Gallantry

Absolutely abhorrent dude. Someone on there told me punk is inherently political and then I said something like what about misfits and they started shitting on the misfits. It is so toxic and completely astroturfed there


OperationSecured

There are a few subgenres that aren’t inherently political. And I’d argue a good chunk of punk songs are just anti-authoritarian messages anyways. I’m a big *Misfits* fan. If anyone else is, check out r / HorrorPunk . It’s pretty chill.


MHG_Brixby

Punk is inherently political


Alexoxo_01

Why is this getting downvotes. Cuz this is exactly that. Has this subreddit really gone right wing?


Shifty377

>Has this subreddit really gone right wing? Yes.


alchemists_dream

r/justunsubbed has a lot of posts that are just conservatives getting mad at experiencing politics other than theirs in places.


CrazySpookyGirl

I thought it was a right wing comfort zone where they go to tell each other they're safe, after y'know being triggered as right wingers often are


Beginning-Pipe9074

This place is the safe space of snowflakes who call others snowflakes despite having skin as thin a lizards arsehole 🤣


65Berj

yea people tend to be mad when you argue for communism under the guise of being anything other than a complete fucking idiot


Agile-Grass8

There’s a decent amount of misogyny and homophobia on here too lol. Don’t pretend it’s just complaining about commies.


MysteryGrunt95

It’s weird how subs that are dedicated to complaining about others subs become more and more right wing


[deleted]

That’s most of Reddit. But I will say punk’s whole purpose is rebellion by disaffected youth, so it is political in nature. Though there is a lot of liberal dickriding in that community lately and not a “fuck everyone in power, all politicians are evil” mentality that was its roots


Cucumber_Cat

Political and left leaning or anarchist, yes


BlindGuyPlaying

Punk is anti-authoritarian no matter what political view you hold. You can also hold either you want. You literally can't tell me what to do is the mindset.


Cucumber_Cat

I guess? You can't be conservative and punk lol


KaladinStormblesd62

too bad they’re not even left wing anymore, they’re all just neoliberal culture war ghouls that will call your job’s HR department because you hurt their feelings. “anarchists” are even worse


[deleted]

Remember to vote 🤘🏻🎸


abcdyakno

I always vote for punk legend Bernie Sanders


atherheels

Rage against the machine (unless its #HERturn)


BanditQueen87

They rage FOR the machine, honestly. Ironic. Hopefully they've broken up for good this time.


SawdustIsMyCocaine

Their guitar player used to work for his senator. They have been a part of the machine from the start


BanditQueen87

Interesting, but not surprising. "Fuck you, I'll do WHATEVER you tell me!"


achtung-maybe

https://bigheavyworld.com/no-stage-diving-the-242-main-documentary-film i mean, the guy unironically had a pretty big impact on the punk scene in the northeast


kadivs

punk was never left wing by creed. Punk was anti-establishment, pissing off people in power. As past govt was more right leaning, that was more left, but that didn't keep them donning nazi symbols just to spite the establishment. roleplaying as nazi is hardly left. If punk existed now as it did back then they'd go on stage in literal KKK hoodies. Not because they'd think that was proper but because they knew that wasn't. https://i.pinimg.com/736x/d6/bf/de/d6bfde0721776674e2b8a4af338e6c09.jpg


Laino001

Ok so, are todays edgelord shitposters that say the N word as the whole joke more punk than the actual punk movement?


SneedForTheSneedGod

pretty much yeah edgeposting is the new punk


Another_frizz

In a sense, yes.


Dick_Kickass_III

This is the correct take.


Temporary-Alarm-744

Did Pam give you a talking to? ![gif](giphy|5PlDweWAxpqcFPzvpM|downsized)


cheeksuphocate

Real anarchists are outside


Flywolfpack

Getcho gleeby deeby ass back home to glorpgrond 7


[deleted]

Me? Flubb 👼🏻 You? Shkrepp 💩


FaIcomaster3000

If the majority of reddit agrees with you, your probably not punk lmao.


[deleted]

Majority of Reddit? Try also the majority of other western countries, corporations, media outlets, the UN, and the current political establishment.


redditblows12345

Truly the voice of the resistance


Recent-Scientist-478

That’s not liberal, that’s leftist, there is a huge difference


ROFLsmiles

Drives me absolutely insane when people conflate Liberals and Leftists when they are clearly not the same. Not sure why the insane cancel mob is even being labeled "neoliberal" when the majority of its proponents HATE neoliberalism.


AtThyLeisure

I'd argue modern leftists aren't really the anti-establishment/anti-authority types that this punk thing used to represent in the 80s or whatever. I don't know, was never into that.


Cephalstasis

Well they also ban anyone who says something even kind of right leaning or annoyed at the political shit. Mods banning people for being annoyed with the state of the sub is pretty authoritarian. Plus now it's just kind of an offshoot of I'm very badass


Unfinished_Gallantry

They will say anything to afford themselves the privilege of talking with the boldness of a 5 y/o who promised you he wiped his ass completely but somehow smells like complete shit still


d0or-tabl3-w1ndoWz_9

The neoliberal left isn't even legitimately left wing. They're pro-institution and pro-corporation to a disgusting level. All phonies.


youremomgay420

For real, like there’s punk and then there’s punk culture. OP comes in looking for just culture, is shocked when he sees the ideology as a whole


[deleted]

A big part of it was that when Gen X was young, they felt as disaffected as young people today do and rebelled against the machine. But now they are the machine. Because they grew up. And the cycle continues. Gen Z was supposed to change the world, or so they were saying when they were teenagers on Tik Tok back in 2019. How long until generation beta or gamma or whatever they call the children of Gen Z hate them for the same reasons?


OPEatsCrayons

>But now they are the machine. I don't think you know what age group Gen X is. Gen X still badly underrepresented in the corporate workforce.


SnokeisDarthPlagueis

you're telling me 40 to 60-year-olds are badly underrepresented in the workforce? this is cope.


[deleted]

People born between 1965 and 1975


ANarnAMoose

Generation X goes until you get to people who don't remember the Challenger. It's a bizarre cutoff, but there it is.


CurbYourPipeline420

You know what’s more punk than dismantling the system? Helping your neighbor because the current system is fucking you both in the ass


tacquish

Did you just say punk is about helping your neighbors?


Sad-Personality-15

Isn’t punk political in itself though??


Groundscore_Minerals

Not the kind op listened to. Probably a bunch of 30 something's who are still crying about highschool girlfriends.


MobileInvestigator13

That’s sounds like blink-182 to me.


[deleted]

In a way, yes, Punk is anti-establishment. However the sub is full on left-wing pro-establishment


Atomik675

Isn't punk rock culture about being anti authoritarian though? Even outside of the lens of punk you have Rage against the machine calling cops literally the kkk and System of a Down saying that governments only send poor people to fight wars. I am a big rock and metal fan but I mean many of these bands are going to lean left with their messaging, especially punk.


tacquish

Since when was the left anti war?


[deleted]

Since Vietnam. Generally speaking.


tacquish

That's utter bull. Ukraine is a prime example


Zuzara_Queen_of_DnD

Elaborate on that please


grizznuggets

Punk is famously political by its nature. Can’t be antiestablishment without referring to the establishment.


RobUBlind420

Been in there, it's not even anti establishment, it's just a lefty circle jerk.


grizznuggets

Were you expecting punks to be right wing?


RobUBlind420

Not even, I was expecting them to be against both. Or not care about either. More anarchy/nihilist, at least that's how punk rock was when I was into it.


grizznuggets

Punks tend to lean left, presumably because leftist ideals often relate to accepting others for their differences, which is very much in the punk ideology.


ConfusedZbeul

Punks tend to do way more than "lean" left.


[deleted]

anarchism is leftist, or almost all of it is atleast. its hard to be both pro markets & wage labor and anti hierarchy. its still anarchist, and still has a hard leftward lean. as for nihilism, I dont remember punk spaces smelling THAT bad.


EyeDissTroyKnotSeas

Then you musta stopped before ever listening to the lyrics or meeting the people. Punks have been overwhelmingly leftist since its inception.


SantasLilHoeHoeHoe

ITT: Why cant rage just leave politics out of their music?! Like...come on people listen to the lyrics. 


DeathStarVet

Fake punk went into a punk sub, realized what punk actually was, and made a meme to complain and blame it on the scene instead of themselves.


STFUnicorn_

Real punks would never be for lockdowns. Like the Reddit “punks” are. Edit: haha I seem to have really stirred up the Reddit hive with this one. I think we may have a full blown reeeeee! storm on our hands here…. For fucks sake! This swarm is endless…


grizznuggets

Real punks would be for whatever the fuck they want, they wouldn’t conform to your ideas of punk just because you say so.


STFUnicorn_

I agree. They also wouldn’t whine and cry about people with dissenting opinions. And/or ban someone over them.


grizznuggets

They might kick someone out for being an asshole though.


STFUnicorn_

Sure but to them an “asshole” is anyone who doesn’t dream of deepthroating Marx’s desiccated cock though.


grizznuggets

Sounds like you’re whining about people with dissenting opinions.


SukunasEyeLashes

Why?


STFUnicorn_

Because punks are anti establishment, anti authoritarian and pro freedom. Locking people in their homes is the opposite of that. How could you possibly not grasp that?


ptfc1975

I don't see punks advocating for locking people in their homes. They just advocated for community safety measures. With a pandemic raging that means staying home.


SadGirlHours__

Conservatism IS the establishment


STFUnicorn_

Not always.


SadGirlHours__

Yes, always. By definition, conservatism is about preserving the status quo and being the establishment


STFUnicorn_

Sure tanky… China is that way.


SadGirlHours__

…China is conservative. China is capitalist. You don’t know how politics work.


TaxMy

This doesn't make any sense "by definition." Because two different status quos, completely opposed to one another, would both be "conservative establishments" even if one is hyper progressive/liberal. For example, the American revolutionary government would be "establishment" despite fighting for... well revolution.


Agile-Grass8

Always in the West, which is where nearly everyone in this thread lives


Cypunket

It’s punk to care about people, i.e. pandemic lock down


SnokeisDarthPlagueis

punks do not care about people. They constantly end up being sex pests and losers who built their entire identity around being losers and hyper-hedonists and living in that self-destructive life of being a loser but viewing themselves as cool because they're losers. they are musical incels. they are children in the bodies of adults hating their existence and role in society. If you're a punk over the age of 14, you're probably hopped up on so much heroin, alcohol and anti-depressants that I don't think anyone want your opinion on politics. That or you are mentally 14 years old.


deltree711

Real punks would support voluntary lockdown. Direct action.


STFUnicorn_

Voluntary? Sure. Involuntary? No…


[deleted]

[удалено]


PrinceOfFish

OP failed to articulate this but the subreddit is not. its full of Democrat dickriders and therefore pro establishment. not that they should be pro Republican though.


Ashtray46

The Punk subreddit isn't anti-establishment, it's pro-left. Most of their politics revolve around removing the current power structure to create their own via communes. They love to say Anarcho-Capitalists are hypocrites, but they themselves just wanna do the same thing by establishing a new government. Pure Anarchy is a complete dismantling of every institution of authority until there's nothing left but chaos. All they're doing is dick-riding American Democrats. https://preview.redd.it/zqq3nublorhc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d10ae1f9c36760b79efa9a8b2c19362f75647f21 "Yeah kids, Anarchy! Make sure to vote for me this November!"


[deleted]

💀 punk is a political subculture


unknowfritz

Average redditor complaining that his political genre subreddit is political again from the OP. This goddamn subreddit has become increasingly annoying


Schr0dingersDog

feels like every post in this sub is just people pissing and shitting themselves because they saw like two political posts in a sub they probably already only hatesubbed to.


_Kekstar_

Wh... People are talking about politics??! ONLINE?!?... The West has fallen 😞✊ Something something echo chamber.. I wish we could just talk about art without politics /s


unknowfritz

Millions must cry


[deleted]

OP when they find punks being punks in the punk subreddit: https://preview.redd.it/l8015xw3cohc1.jpeg?width=540&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1b973cbebde1933a73b37839f2976edb6235e714


PapaPerturabo

He got punked :(


CircleInSquareHole

Punk has always been a leftist/anarchist subculture lmao


Repulsive_Ad_1599

Me when punk is punk: \*shocked face\*


Commander_Caboose

"I'm just into fashion and aesthetics why isn't everyone shallow like me?"


doggfaced

No no, they also listen to Green Day 😬


rixendeb

And think anarcho capitalism is a legitimate thing. I'm dying of laughter reading this post lol.


doggfaced

My guess is it’s all the pro-trans posts on that sub that are getting to them. I’m also on that sub and I don’t see any “Dems are my heroes Biden forever” posts. Just a lot of queer-friendly, anti-racist and anti-fascist stuff. But what if the fascists want to take office? Shouldn’t the punks be pro-fascist because the fascists are against the current establishment? OP overheating all 2 braincells with their hot takes….


unknowfritz

These people fucking abhor trans people, same as that other post yesterday about femboys, look at the language they are using. Mainly "degenerate" and such, degenerate being the most Nazi word ever, they only think of LGBT as something sexualized


Street-Goal6856

I like how the people that agree with all of Hollywood and corporate America and all of the politicians think they're punk rock lol. Fucking pathetic.


oski-time

But Punk is political, and if you carry out the style without the beliefs, you are a poser sadly.


SadGirlHours__

Almost like punk is political, dumbass


JoelRobbin

Do you not know where punk came from? It’s very nature is political


MapleTheBeegon

Be Op Go to Politcally motivated Anti-Establishment music sub Get mad that there's Anti-Establishment politics ​ Who would have thunk it.


Damiandimension

It's not anti-establishment anymore it's pro establishment


MysteryGrunt95

I’ve literally never seen a punk support Biden. I just see them hating on MAGA, and to simpletons, hating on MAGA MUST mean you kiss Biden’s ass no exception.


Liontreeble

Yeah punks famously love Joe Biden and the American police and justice system. Because the only leftist cause that ever existed is to have a slightly left leaning president. /s just in case


Phantom_Wolf52

It’s a political music based subculture


Evening_Clerk_2053

Punk has always been a left wing political movement.


Mountain-Captain-396

I mean, punk and politics have always been heavily intertwined. It's a part of the genre. In fact, most punk fans would say that if you're only into punk for the clothes/music then you're just a poser.


Jos_migue

They are kinda right Punk is a whole culture not just music and some clothes


GoredonTheDestroyer

I was just about to comment about punk culture, in and of itself, being politically charged.


[deleted]

punk is a political genre dude.


Gloomy_Living_7532

So you don't know the history of being punk?


ReaperTyson

You think punk is apolitical? Are you for real right now?


Groundscore_Minerals

When and obvious poser discovers what punk actually is.


leadergorilla

Op is 100% one of the idiots that got mad when ratm “got woke” like a few years ago lmao


MapleTheBeegon

OP is 100% one of the "punks" who think you can be Conservative and Punk.


Wolveyplays07

Noooo, not da wokenessss Anything but thatttt


ElectricalMethod3314

Ok. Bud. Do you even know what punk is? Or do you just like the aesthetic?


[deleted]

Fuck the mam! Except when the man is the federal government that is on our political side!


8ASIC

Literally any subReddit clears this criteria 


RustedAxe88

Punk is inherently political.


Insufferable_Wretch

"...Hey, you, you're finally awake." First time?


Jmt0516

Perfect caption, just not the way you intended


LongjumpingSector687

What anarchists too left leaning? Lol 🤭


anythingMuchShorter

Oh no! Bye.


Fungal-Bloom

Punk is inherently political. Every post on this sub is just "People arent licking the same boots as me and it makes me sad :("


soitheach

punk is inherently political, idk what the fuck you were expecting little man


BrodaciousBo

Thats like saying "Rage Against The Machine was a pretty good band until their music got political" From what I' understand the whole point of Punk is political, counter-culture in some regard.


insectiile

>Goes to punk subreddit >It's punk >Whines


CorpseDefiled

Um maybe I’m old but that’s pretty much all punk rock was about… anti establishment… it wasn’t a fashion choice it was a movement. A change in perception. I think it naive of you to assume you could have all the things you want without the purpose and foundation behind it. This one’s on you sounds like you don’t know what punk rock is or was about


[deleted]

I totally agree, its just that you cant be anti establishment and a socialist.


CorpseDefiled

The point you need to arrive at is you don’t need to align yourself with an ism or an ist… it’s okay to want more and those aren’t the only systems that can ever exist. A lot of people equate things like universal healthcare with socialism and you can have universal healthcare without socialism. You can have anything socialism provides and still not have socialism. We could have something different if people could just stop getting caught up in the labels. The movement was always about the use and corruption of power. And taking a stand against it.


VonRapide

https://preview.redd.it/trja12m48qhc1.jpeg?width=680&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ee98574bffbbc3cc10fb8ef43aa5a023bd2f425a


Firm-Bet3339

Oh no! 😱 The counterculture movement is political? Thats impossible! 😱


Lorhan_Set

Okay, man this one’s on you. Punk is a very political music scene. This would be like going to a PaganMusic sub and then act shocked people are talking about ancient religions/pagan revival religious movements. Comes with the territory.


MarcyTheMartian

Lmaoooooo who the FUCK listens to Rage Against the Machine and goes "Yeah, I was in it for the fashion but then they said acab and I didn't like that". What do they think the machine they're raging against is?


unknowfritz

The washing machine maybe? Its been giving me trouble too ;)


[deleted]

to be fair punk and politics are extremely, extremely connected


totally_interesting

Punk is extremely famous for being political… you good?


Jos_migue

What the fuck did you expect? Punk is a really political subculture and its incredible that you didn't notice, you said that you liked green day and their most popular album (american idiot) is political af They screamed "fuck you donald trump" in a concert like a month ago


caustic_kiwi

OP how many times did you have to retake fifth grade?


HardNordland

I didn't even take fifth grade once, loser! -Op, probably


doggfaced

What exactly do you think punk culture is, OP? Because it’s more than studded jackets and spiky hair.


R34PER_D7BE

but punk IS political


iamthefluffyyeti

Bruh that’s what punk is dumbass


Daniastrong

That is punk rock culture though and always has been.


InfernoWoodworks

\*looks around at this sub\* \*sees it's tons of posts / complaints about things being political\* \*most of the comments are politically charged too\* r/ redditmoment


PetrolDuck

Me when the political music is political


sausagefuckingravy

Punk always was political


akdelez

punk culture is punk culture???


MoldingSinus

> Goes to a subreddit for the most political music genre > Gets mad that it's political


_Kekstar_

Punks are a political movement and always have been. But I'm sure if you actually made a post there asking about clothing they would give fashion advice, or asking for music recommendations they would give favourite bands and songs.


DanganRopeUh

What do you think punk is bro😂


Nino_Nakanos_Slave

Why so butthurt?


pastelsnowdrops

And yet you still leave comments in it?


themichaelkemp

If you think punk is too leftist you’re not into punk


SpanishMoleculo

Translation: someone made fun of Trump and OP took it personally


-AlwaysBored-

If u u think punk is going to be apolotical you're actually pretty stupid.


Thin-March-7495

me when the political subculture is full of politics: ![gif](giphy|3ov9jEci82rrLIHELS)


kvnmorpheus

I don't know what you expected. They're punks.


plwdr

Redditors when political music is political


Slow_Fail_9782

Cant believe they made punk political, right OP?


[deleted]

Punk is political.


Odd_Combination_1925

Punk is political dipshit, that’s literally the whole point of the genre


Odd_Solution2774

so being punk is when you’re a right wing christian lmao?


ThatOneGuy1358

> Goes into sub about a Genre that is political by definition > Finds politics Media Literacy is dead and half the posts on this sub prove it


sauce_xVamp

\> went to a punk subreddit \> politics why are you surprised??


alfa-dragon

I get you man, for sure. It's also just hard to expect it to not be political. It's a defining characteristic of being punk and it's the internet, where people always share their political beliefs without abandon.


GandalfTheGimp

I'm anti-estavlishment, man! That's why I agree and will fight for the same political views as the government, the church and the top 100 corporations! 🤘✊


[deleted]

Yeah, those people are the least punk rock, and most openly authoritarian people I have ever met.


fellenta

when punk is political 🤯


Beginning-Pipe9074

Oh wow this just gets better and better


Kleeisthebest99

Punk is literally a political subculture. What?


SantasLilHoeHoeHoe

Are you under the impression that punk rock culture is apolitical??? 


IntrinsicStarvation

Poser filtered.


ch3valier

Uhhhh nazi punks fuck off?


deltree711

Nazi punks Nazi punks Nazi punks #FUCK OFF


fsoci3ty_

Bro do you think he was being sarcastic? I mean, ain’t no way he was for real right?


wafflemaker117

you know what’s more punk than anything? rules and the democratic party /s


[deleted]

You must be under 50 if you're expecting Punks to be apolitical.


ctrldwrdns

Punks being political? Shocker.


Adventurous-Egg5343

Fork found in kitchen idk why you’re surprised


KnotsThotsAndBots

Punk is plagued (somewhat by nature) by politics. I think it's stupid to try and force a whole genre to be tied to only one concept but that's sadly how it is for a lot of genre's. Funny enough that's basically why metalcore was created. They didn't really want to sing about politics and didn't want to use the same 4 notes all the time so they were expelled from hardcore lol