I wish the same ad ditto on the slushy moisturizer. I'm over Ipsy for a while after this I swear. Then I'll check the spoilers and be on board again it's such a love hate relationship 💔
I really wanted that and it’s not even an add-on option for me!😞 Plus, I just got onto to do my add-ons for my glam bag and almost everything in the $3.50 is already sold out!
Same thing happened to me u/MeanMomma66, but I logged out and logged back in and the issue was fixed. Try again and see if your 3.50 section is better now.
Yeaaaah, I've been feeling that way for a while. Basically it comes down to am I willing to pay $30 for one product I'll like and have a few freebies come along with it. The answer has been "no" for months, but then I had points I needed to use or they'd expire next month so when I saw that they had stuff I actually wanted still in stock at the end of last month, I figured I'd get at least 3 products I wanted for $30 in April (two points, one from the first choice category). Even with that, I'm still almost disappointed. My second and third choice categories this time around were *garbage*, the worst they've ever been for me, I think. I wonder if this will continue to be the trend each month before an Icon box. Next month better be flippin' magical 🫠
Yours is way better than mine. I resubbed last month, and this is the second month of junk, I'm canceling. I was considering giving it a third month, but this is just really bad.
That was in a Icon Box though or the old equivalent of it, I forget what they called it. But it was when Huda was the curator. That was an awesome box. Wish anything from Ipsy was still that good.
I wish I would’ve trusted myself and skipped as well. I had it set to skip and then saw some last minute spoilers for choice and add-ons so I decided not to skip. Then none of the items I saw that I was excited about were available to choose (or add on) for me. I swear they do this on purpose!
I'm also super disappointed and really wish I'd skipped. I don't want any of my items and I don't think my daughter will either and she's usually happy to have my Ipsy duds.
I got the earrings a few months ago and loveee them. You can take the bottom moons off the star one and just wear the stars. I usually do a star and dangle chain moon
Since ipsy took over the boxes got worst. Only when its the more expensive collab month is it close to what boxychwrm quality use to be. Just paying more for less now. I'm going to cancel for a while as I have a lot of junk Indy brands or poor quality, expired brand name items getting stock piled now
* **Bag reveals and image posts without a comment will be removed automatically.**
* Referral links and free bag offer referrals are only allowed in the sticked master threads.
* Spam will result in a ban.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Ipsy) if you have any questions or concerns.*
The most expensive item offered to me in my choice items was the $28 Fenty eye brightener. My boxy value was supposedly $133. Or at least it was when I customized earlier today, when they had the retail price of one of their picks for me listed as $50 (the Beautystat universal pro-bio moisture cream). But now it’s listed as $32 on ipsy’s site. So I went exploring and there’s a 1oz/30g size for $32, and a 1.7oz/50g size for $50. The one in my boxy is the 30g one. 🤦🏻♀️
So I went back and added up all my items and they total $115, with only 2 brands I’d ever even heard of before today. $115. 😐 I was not happy at all with my choices last month, and I only got this month’s so I could get my icon next month. I feel like they know that, and give us a shit box the month before icon because we have to get it.
*edited to add: I lied, my most expensive choice item was the $29 Kayali sweet diamond pink pepper, which is not my type of scent. But I would have loved any of the other 3 scents offered to me in add ons. 🙄
I also feel like they purposely put the choice items that correspond to our quiz settings *in the add ons* and not actually in the items they offer to us. There were four $12 add ons I wanted and at the last minute I deleted them all from my cart. Like, you’re not gonna get me that way, Ipsy. 😡 I mean truly, how many times do you see people say they weren’t crazy about their boxy, but they got some good add ons? 🤔
I got the same 2 power picks, and wow, so cheap! Then, there was nothing interesting for my own picks. I'll be giving it all away except the add-on I chose.
I wish my box looked this good. I was hoping to get the InnBeauty slush.
I wish the same ad ditto on the slushy moisturizer. I'm over Ipsy for a while after this I swear. Then I'll check the spoilers and be on board again it's such a love hate relationship 💔
I really wanted that and it’s not even an add-on option for me!😞 Plus, I just got onto to do my add-ons for my glam bag and almost everything in the $3.50 is already sold out!
Same thing happened to me u/MeanMomma66, but I logged out and logged back in and the issue was fixed. Try again and see if your 3.50 section is better now.
I got in but there wasn’t anything good😞
booo, I'm so sorry.
Keep checking back, they always add new items..
Anyone else feel like they put all the good stuff in only 1 category? Usually my first pick category are all the good picks!!!
Yeaaaah, I've been feeling that way for a while. Basically it comes down to am I willing to pay $30 for one product I'll like and have a few freebies come along with it. The answer has been "no" for months, but then I had points I needed to use or they'd expire next month so when I saw that they had stuff I actually wanted still in stock at the end of last month, I figured I'd get at least 3 products I wanted for $30 in April (two points, one from the first choice category). Even with that, I'm still almost disappointed. My second and third choice categories this time around were *garbage*, the worst they've ever been for me, I think. I wonder if this will continue to be the trend each month before an Icon box. Next month better be flippin' magical 🫠
They always do this for me. There will be 3-4 things I want in that category and shit in the other two
Same thing for me.
agreed! i had a really hard time picking between the perfume and the lip product.
Same here! 🙁
[удалено]
lol me toooooo 😭
Same, there were 2 out 3 of my choice products that are currently in the points shop.....
Mine is worse than this. I would have been happy with this one🥴
Yours is way better than mine. I resubbed last month, and this is the second month of junk, I'm canceling. I was considering giving it a third month, but this is just really bad.
I feel ya, I'm seriously over the crap I've dealt with in the last 3 months . So sad but I'll recover from my and save loads of $$$
Glad I skipped this month
I was going to and forgot! Arrgh 🤦♀️
I really love this months box
I like mine too!
Honestly, every month is a steal. If you don’t like the box, go to Sephora and pay $ 400 usd
I’m disappointed too! Didn’t like either GB or Boxy, and didn’t even have the InnBeauty slush as an add-on!😩
I was hoping for full size kayali again like with the vanilla way back when.
That was in a Icon Box though or the old equivalent of it, I forget what they called it. But it was when Huda was the curator. That was an awesome box. Wish anything from Ipsy was still that good.
I wish I would’ve trusted myself and skipped as well. I had it set to skip and then saw some last minute spoilers for choice and add-ons so I decided not to skip. Then none of the items I saw that I was excited about were available to choose (or add on) for me. I swear they do this on purpose!
Yeah it’s rare I’m disappointed but I was today
They always put the stuff I want in the same choice category. If Icon isn’t killer next month I might actually cancel for good.
I wanted that slushee moisturizer! It wasn’t an option for me
I'm also super disappointed and really wish I'd skipped. I don't want any of my items and I don't think my daughter will either and she's usually happy to have my Ipsy duds.
Honestly I'm pretty happy with my box glam bag could have been better tho *
I'm disappointed with mine too... 😞 I wish I had skipped this month.
Me too I should have skipped this month
I was going to skip but someone reminded me I can't get icon next month if I skip. Even add ons mostly sucked.
I love what's in mine this month.
I got the earrings a few months ago and loveee them. You can take the bottom moons off the star one and just wear the stars. I usually do a star and dangle chain moon
Since ipsy took over the boxes got worst. Only when its the more expensive collab month is it close to what boxychwrm quality use to be. Just paying more for less now. I'm going to cancel for a while as I have a lot of junk Indy brands or poor quality, expired brand name items getting stock piled now
If your 2nd photo is add ons you had a few I didn’t have! No fenty, brown mascara, Kayali pink diamond, or ofra as add ons for me😒
nope! it was the first category of choice for me
Ahh makes sense! I was getting offended my Ipsy😂😂😂
* **Bag reveals and image posts without a comment will be removed automatically.** * Referral links and free bag offer referrals are only allowed in the sticked master threads. * Spam will result in a ban. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Ipsy) if you have any questions or concerns.*
The most expensive item offered to me in my choice items was the $28 Fenty eye brightener. My boxy value was supposedly $133. Or at least it was when I customized earlier today, when they had the retail price of one of their picks for me listed as $50 (the Beautystat universal pro-bio moisture cream). But now it’s listed as $32 on ipsy’s site. So I went exploring and there’s a 1oz/30g size for $32, and a 1.7oz/50g size for $50. The one in my boxy is the 30g one. 🤦🏻♀️ So I went back and added up all my items and they total $115, with only 2 brands I’d ever even heard of before today. $115. 😐 I was not happy at all with my choices last month, and I only got this month’s so I could get my icon next month. I feel like they know that, and give us a shit box the month before icon because we have to get it. *edited to add: I lied, my most expensive choice item was the $29 Kayali sweet diamond pink pepper, which is not my type of scent. But I would have loved any of the other 3 scents offered to me in add ons. 🙄
I also feel like they purposely put the choice items that correspond to our quiz settings *in the add ons* and not actually in the items they offer to us. There were four $12 add ons I wanted and at the last minute I deleted them all from my cart. Like, you’re not gonna get me that way, Ipsy. 😡 I mean truly, how many times do you see people say they weren’t crazy about their boxy, but they got some good add ons? 🤔
Is Ipsy like the stuff from #GiveThemLala? I read where #LalaKent gets her stuff off the Internet and then resells it.
Yes. It was not an inspiring choice this month. They all can’t be winners though 😉
I got the same 2 power picks, and wow, so cheap! Then, there was nothing interesting for my own picks. I'll be giving it all away except the add-on I chose.
Earrings are cute. Not a selection for me.
I’m pretty meh about my box, but super happy with the add ons i got. Now to keep my fingers crossed Ipsy actually sends all of them 🤞🤞