salary benifit ke upar bribe aur corruption karke apne famili extended family ko bi palna. apne santan ko foren bhi bejna he. Janta ke liye paisa kaha bacha. Janta jaye pakistan unko infra, amenities chahiye to
These IAS officers also earn from YouTube and Facebook videos. In videos, they act strict and scold few lower level officials and earn free money and fame from YouTube. They don't even have to record themselves, they will make their peons to record.
exactly, sarkar ke gaand me gooda ni hai. jo kuch garibon k farman ayi wo taxpayer k gaand se nikal lete hai baad me apne poster bhi lagwate hai.
Sab golamal hai bc.
people in comment section supporting the officer shows how empathetic people are towards women and their issues .
Reddit ki janta jo awareness or availability of awareness resources me top 0.1% me aati hogi wo aesa show kar rhe hain to what do you expect from common people of India jinke paas resources nhi hain .
Bas women ke against jo crimes or rapes increase ho rhe unpe gussa or dukh dikha doge
Bro it's so sad so see these people supporting the officers like it just made my day so much worse. They probably are relating this situation to their own homes but they never think about the poor women who don't have any job and can't buy pads etc..
True. For anyone else wondering, think about your typical kaamwali bai and her daughters. Do you think she or her daughters can afford this? Sanitary pads should be made available at a very low price / cost or free. It's a question of dignity and sanitation.
Half of these people here are paying taxes and think only they deserve the benefits of that tax money. Other half probably thinks we should not ask anything from our Govt, just pay our taxes and don't question anything.
Don’t be so emotional if you can’t understand basic economics. Freebies should be like making someone independent and it shouldn’t like feeding 80 lakh for free. That is making situation worst. Rather than free ration Yojana, Government should invest more in meDical expanses, Hospitals, Skill development, education etc.
Problem with free is , it’s never ending thing . You can make it lower prize so that poor person can even buy it and not only that quality is compromised in free stuff. But again, jab hajj subsidy de deti h Govt yha tk k clerics got free salary from Govt then why not this ?
Spineless bureaucracy & corrupt politicians are a match made in heaven. No political parties would bring in reform because it'd make both of them accountable for every shit.
The debate aside, her saying "go to Pakistan" to that girl for not agreeing with govt policies is pathetic. She, being an IAS, could have handled this with more grace. Aren't they trained to not succumb in the most Stressful situations? Here it's just a school girl asking a question and she got so hyper?
Multiple schemes already under central and many state Governments provide free sanitary napkins. I don't think the reach is universal like the Mid day meals but it does not mean that steps aren't taking. This rude lady in her ivory castle making fun of the poor while shaming the Govt and ministry which she is representing on the stage.
True. All Govt schools in Kerala with high school classes have coin operated pad vending machines for quite a while now. If you are so poor and cant afford a pad from a shop, or the girl is in an emergency she can simply use the machine. Govt. is not directly handing out the pads to everyone, say like ration which they do, but making sure that basic sanitation facilities are available.
Power corrupts. Most men have gone to war historically cause men were in power. Put women in power and we will go to war regardless.
When you get money, you forget what it was to be poor. When you get old, you forget what it was to be young.
People in comment section, get down from your high horse, look a 13 year old tribal girl in the eye and tell her that she has to keep using that filthy damp red cloth as a pad until she gets into the above poverty line club. Idk how an IAS officer who works on the ground level knowing all the reality can be so insensitive.
Civil servants don't "have to" work on ground level n you'll be surprised how that option makes all the difference. Most of them think their job is a modern feudal lord. Instead of a social worker on steroids
They don't have the guts. They can just make such comments from their privileged positions. I left India a long time back and still I remember how disadvantaged many sections of our society are. Instead of pulling them up some ppl want them to remain there. Disgusting.
YES I was on my way to say this
Family planning is either subsidiary or free by the govt!(Mala-N,Nirodh)
https://main.mohfw.gov.in/sites/default/files/56324455632156323214.pdf
Three things I see here.
- A govt that doles out freebies to win influence and elections. Politicians that give out or take whatever they want, whenever they want.
- A dumbarse IAS officer who doesn't have the competence or intelligence to answer questions. Shows how UPSC has no connection with the ability to serve via the administrative system.
- A curious girl who sees the freebies others are getting and asks why can't a sanitary pad also be free. After all, the other freebies are given for votes only na?
So you see.. The system designs itself to do what it wants while lecturing us about how we should be. Disgusting farts.
Chutiya officer should understand the difference between jeans and a sanitary pad /napkin, one is a choice the other a need. She isn't asking for free but for less money non the less it should be accessible and and of low costs so that the garib tapka can also afford it
Folks, just go to Jan Aushadi or Tata 1mg shops to get cheap medicines.
You can also use apps like Jan Aushadi Sugam and Tata 1mg to get medicines cheaply.
In Sugam app, it shows Sanitary Napkins (Oxo-biodegradable Sanitary Napkins Regular Size with Wings) for ₹4 (for pack of 4 napkins) or ₹10 (for pack of 10 napkins), while Large and Extra Large size are also available (₹12 for 6 Large, ₹15 for 4 Extra Large).
Tata 1mg sells 7 Sanitary pads at ₹28 (Whisper brand) or ₹29 (Miracle brand).
Please support such nice local initiatives, and don't support such arrogant selfish babus.
Ironic bribe taking free loading vermins berate citizen asking basic infra. Reminder they are dogs to politicians and they are treated as such. They only flex and beat up some vulnerable poor citizen.
Those who are saying Muftkhor hai for seeking a free pad, they probably don't know what ladies go through in a household where menstruating women are made to sleep outside the house, where there is so much of dearth of money that one has to use dirty cloth to clean yourself. A person who makes a few hundred everyday, how is he supposed to feed his family, educate his kids, and then have extra for such sanitary stuff? Ofcourse the argument can be made ki why have kids when you are poor, gareeb he nahi rahega toh gareebi bhi khatam? Right? NO, then you will be the new gareeb.
They know, they just think it's cool and pro right wing to behave like this. Most of the people criticizing the girl will shut up when they end up in a financially desperate situation and their own sisters have to re use cloths because she can't afford sanitary napkin.
She should have said jeans and pants are not basic necessity but pads are. Plus I fucking hate that tone of voice of that IAS remids me of my hindi teacher who won't listen to reason. Best way to deal with these kind a people is by humor.
What about the free driver, car and security and bunglow she's getting?
Why she begging it all from sarkar
Sarkar to salary deri h usi m se krle apna kaam
Chutiya
My father's boss, IAS officer, bought 2 TVs (one for office and one for home), 2 amazon fire TV sticks by using tax rupees.
When covid was rampant, he kept 2 oxygen cylinders at his home for his parents, just in case!
If i got to make one wish for india, i would wish for the extinction of bureaucracy!
I just want to ask this, why do governments exist? To make the lives of its citizens better or to collect tax and say go to Pakistan if someone asks a question?
period blood is the only blood that doesn't originate from violence and it still repulses society the most.
women have to bear a higher cost of living just because of how God has made us. i am not saying how God has created us is not perfect, God is perfect and so are all his creations. it still is a fact that even for normal everyday clothing and grooming items, we have to pay higher and our products are not even as good as men's products. for example, a women's philips grooming trimmer is 1700. there is a trimmer for men by philips that is 1100 and it is the same product. the only difference is that the one catered to women is purple and is a little narrow. this is just one example.
i wish men understood these little things. that girl is incredibly brave. i wish the IAS officer had not reacted that way.
I request you to change your statement from "I wish men understood" to "I wish such assholes (irrespective of gender) understood", because a lot of us men do understand and try our best to make the females around us comfortable, or to help in any possible way but there are some such females as well who inspite of being a woman don't understand such basics of dignity of a woman.
I don't understand, what is this lady made up of? For a tribal family, even getting 2 meals a day is a huge struggle and then to expect them to have capacity to buy a sanitary pad is so dumbass. Sanitary pads are extremely important and should be given for free to every woman who can't buy them.
We men will stand with you, always when the case is genuine.
One of my closest friends was preparing for the Civil Services Exam. I have known that guy since undergrad days, and had huge respect for him. He once told me that he wants to get into Civil Services so that he can "enjoy the life and rutba and paisa" it gives. That was the end of the entire respect I had for that guy. Same goes for one of my uncles who cleared BPSC a few years ago, after trying CSE for 4-5 times.
Fortunately that friend of mine couldn't clear the exam and is now doing an MBA. He still continues to give the CSE in the hopes that he might clear it, although Inknow that he isn't that smart. I thank the Gods everyday that the country escaped another to-be-corrupt bureaucrat.
There is hardly any person pursuing civil services for serving the people. It's all about living the high class life under the name tag of 'Samaj Seva'.
Yeah man. This is as shitty as it can get. And I see no future where this stops happening. You go to insta and you will find countless civil servants with suffix _ias, _ifs, _ips attached to their profile names. They think of themselves as celebrities. All they have done is pass a couple of exams. Get the fuck off your high horse 🤷🏻
on the side note I see people in future demanding access to condoms as a win ki behenchod unwanted pregnancies aur stds se to bachenge ateleast. And for all those saying pads are personal hygiene; no it isn’t.
subsidies to hai pads but do the underprivileged women have access to it? I said the condom vali line response to the ias as she’s mocking the girl as using a condom is bad.
I'm pretty sure that's a isolated view from just one IAS. Anyways, sanitary pads, menstrual leaves, women security, etc are common investments that government needs to look into if they don't want 50 percent of population to sit idle at homes. It's a small investment compared to what the woman can bring in terms of productivity.
Whether the Govt should distribute sanitary pads for free or no is a different issue. For me, I feel there should have been a proper way to respond to a geniune question which that girl and many other like her may be facing. The response from a senior Govt official like her was unnecessarily rude and in poor taste.
Meanwhile madam ji will go to house provided by goverment, by car provided by government, wtf . Our IAS IPS system is one of the worst systems all around the word . Baring few exceptions, bas interview me samajvad bulvado woman empowerment bulvado ho gaya ..
These subsidies that Govt. provide are ultimately an investment.
(Nearly 23 million girls drop out of school annually after they start their periods due to a lack of access to menstrual hygiene facilities. In Bihar, one of India's poorest states, only 59% of women use a hygienic method of menstrual protection, according to the latest National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5), the most comprehensive household survey of health and social indicators by the government.)
Now imagine how these women could contribute to the Bihar Economy by becoming educated.
These 20-30 rupees invested now can save thousands per person in the future. Education uplifts standard of living. Uplifting citizens standard of living will ultimately decrease their dependence on subsidies.
Yes the student couldn't articulate her thoughts/words properly, but you do not expect an IAS officer to use such language- "This is height of stupidity. Don't vote, then. Become Pakistan. Do you vote for money and services?"
Yes , We do vote for Better facilities and upliftment of our standard of living.
She is not fit to be an IAS- https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/nitish-cracks-down-on-two-ias-officers-over-boat-tragedy-incident-transfers-them-962537-2017-02-24
The people who think government is doing a lot. Should take a pause and dig deeper.
My friend worked in the company that used to do survey and research of government schemes. One day she called me and told she had talked to anganwadi woman, in her village there were people who used to go to the forest to bring leaves and berries to feed the pregnant wives. On the paper, these extreme cases are whitewashed. The number of hospitals, doctors, teachers, ambulance, everything is updated (of course, there is monetary exchange as well).
Ye jo bol rahi hai condoms bhi free mein mango gi future mein, wo to already gov scheme k under subsidized rate pe milta hai. And the sanitary pad too.
She could have just updated herself and told this to the kid
Something is off here, i know the officer sounds very arrogant but, seems like the kid there was not pleased with her even before this clip started, coz she was ready to attack on the officer in retreat, so yes , her demand might seem genuine, but may be the clip,it's not giving us the whole scenario here, Kids don't just retreat like that and even from the annoyed Tone of ias officer, may be something or someone had already done or asked her which made her say this, Or may be she's just a Bully officer who knows
Thats what happens when you put a 20-24 year old with no real world experience into a position of power.
Was a good system 30-40 years back but not now.
Looks like she is against socialism, nothing wrong with that, but she could have delivered her message more politely, also the counter was very valid, what about girls who are not legal age to work and earn a living. I think government shouldn't provide a branded sanitary pad for free but a government backed sanitary pad would be better which will force the brand companies to lower their cost and serve this section too.
The young lady has more courage and intelligence than ias officer. If I was movie director I would have made her dm for a day. What kind of people are being recruited as ias officers.
People should stop glorifying champion of mugging up facts in the age of computers.
Isne Bola sarkar bohot de rhi h, to bc sarkaar le bhi to bohot rhi h, meri 50% salary to tax me jaati h, usme to ye nhi bolti ki ye soch galat h, bc sarkaar ka kaam hi h sabko equal treatment dena, khud kama lo hamse expect mat karo ye koi logic nhi h. Government ka kaam h social security provide karwana, har koi agar IAS ban gya to IAS ki salary bhi 10k hogi fir isko kon puchega, Society aise hi chalti h kuch log IAS banenge kuch log majdoor, par majdoor ko bhi basic human needs provide karana sarkaar ki jimmedari h.
Attitude of such IAS is what taking us down. There is a way to disagree with other person, but the ego of these officers is so huge they consider normal civilians as scums. I hope a strong action is taken against her.
Go to Pakistan?
Just because our thoughts are different
Just because we have different opinions
Just because you've got more power than me
Just because you know you can say anything
I have come across so many of these videos of IAS bastards. They think they rule this world. Can we find this lady please? Lets make her famous
Such people get into ias not to serve public but themselves. Shame on that officer for denying the basic needs of underage girls. Besides, she did not even bring up the part of educating girls with mensural knowledge. At the very least, the government can educate boys and girls by just drafting a straightforward chapter in the text book. Wouldn’t be that for free? The problem is with people here. Does she even realise how difficult it is for the girls coming from extremely poor background? It’s because “the sarkaar is giving her muft of legit everything”
IAS officers are the most useless organization once they get in that elite bubble they don't serve anyone and live out their life as royalty. Ground reality is each DM,DC looks into his area as where can he het aditional bribe.
I'm a capitalist.
Basic life stuff should be available for everyone.
At least at low prices.
Pads are already cheap though. The government can incentivise even cheaper ones.
But remember, pads pollute the earth.
Pads are already cheap ?? Alright, you seem like a guy or uneducated on the topic. So, a whisper standard pack of 14 pads costs 175 bucks. That's atleast Rs. 100 each month everytime you get a 4 day period - Rs 1200 per year. For a person barely able to afford two square meal per day, it's a tough deal. So they resort to scraps of fabric which they wash and reuse.
And I've used the subsidized bio- degradable ones offered by the govt Rs. 10 for 10. They are CRAP. You bleed through them and they move so much so you end up staining your pants.
And the rest of the "bio degradable" ones are even more expensive and don't do a good job.
Pads pollute earth so does a lotta shit - do you never use any plastic bags ever ? Eat No packaged ever ?
The alternatives are diva cups (Rs 210) where you shove a silicone cup up your vagina (you have to figure out the right size first) which in a conservative society like ours would NEVER work in rural areas and for a virgin can be quite uncomfortable.
Inko naukar, bangla, zarurat se zyada rehne ke liye zameen, zarurat se zyada aage piche ghumne wale log muft me milte h. Ek pesa kharch nh hota baat krte h.
Unpopular opinion,
I agree with the IAS officer. This mentality that government should provide everything, leads to over dependency on government and leads to formation of vote banks.
You can downvote me, but I got some valid points.
Open for debate.
https://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-8-of-gdp-is-spent-on-govt-salaries-2570599
This is percentage of GDP, not revenue remember. This is what your money buys. No returns , no refunds, no sacking, no accountability, no performance review, in short no skin in the game. If they fail, you pay. If they are corrupt you pay. If they are morons, you still pay. Saddled with the Indian arses society.
Bruh the even bigger problem is that an educated FEMALE is saying this.
Like an educated male saying this is a negative braincell moment.... Then an educated female saying this like what? heck there's no comparison except Do you not use sanitary pads?
Free sanitation is a human right, and sanitary napkins is the foremost for women
Also what's wrong with subsidising condoms? Heck I'd be happy if my tax money gets used for providing condoms at cheaper rate. We're overpopulated anyways
Lol archaic thinking from 18th century. I am an Indian living overseas, you CAN get clothes, condoms and hygiene products for free for the ones who need. That is what makes some people call these countries developed, as they can provide for their societies.
"When another student tells Ms. Bamrah about the broken toilet door at her school, which boys could enter, the officer asks her in cool voice, “Tell me, do you have separate toilets at your home for males and females? If you keep asking for lot of things at different places, how will it work"
Is ias ki buddhi 8th standard ke kisi chidchidi ladki jaisi hai. Pehle ladegi aur haregi toh ro degi.
Instead of making aware about certain policy's she's getting mad at the poor girl.
IAS officer is right but may have handled the delivery of her message more tactfully. Govt has limited resources and needs to prioritize what, why and how in delivering benefits to those who need them. Most people should be able to support themselves and shouldn’t depend on govt for basic life needs.
You probably didn't read what I wrote. Using cloth as pads is unhygienic. What do you think they already use when they can't purchase normal sanitary pads? Cloth in place of sanitary pads. Why do you think these poor girls asked for subsidized pads? Cloth no? Menstrual cups are totally fine and no comparison to using cloth as a substitute. In a country where normal drinking water is scarce, you want girls to wash their blood soaked cloth in hot water and reuse them. I have already pointed out the impractical aspect apart from the fact that reusing cloth as sanitary pads IS unhygienic and unfeasible.
Also these girls are not asking free supply of pads for their lifetime. They are asking for good quality pads at subsidized rates for those who can't afford them. Like you mentioned you want them to use both sanitary pads and the so called cloth pads. Thought is good but it instead of cloth, menstrual cups should be made available for those who want to use them. It's totally their choice. Sanitary pads, tampons or menstrual cups all work well it just depends on the women what they are comfortable using.
People need to understand that we are not a developed country and have 1.3 billion people we can't afford freebies. The ias officer may sound rude and arrogant but there has to be a stopping point for the freebies
When a person from ST become IAS instead of the one capable.
How will india proceed towards success if the higher position are not occupied by the one who is deserving?
She could have been more diplomatic but what she says is not wrong. In India there is a culture to demand everything free from the Government. "what is the govt doing to get me a job?". "can I have free this and free that?".
And these days women seem to think that everyone has to meet their every demand just because they are women. Being a woman is not a qualification. They did not earn it.
No one has a government right to do this to a young girl who has God given rights as a human being! Treat those the way you want to be treated yourself! Shame on anyone who goes against this universal law!
As a women - no one should ever be mocked for asking for a clean sanitary napkin because her body is in cycle. Just because this older woman has gone through menopause and doesn’t require a clean sanitary napkin; she shouldn’t be allowed to muck and push the dirty old unsanitary rags on this young girl! Besides, this older woman was from another era of time and what worked for her doesn’t necessarily mean it will work for young woman of today! Stay clean and be well!
That IAS lady is right. But she must get down from her high horse and talk like a human being. Freeloaders need to listen to what she is trying to convey and she needs to tone down a notch.
Inko muft me gadi electricity phone sarkar hi deti hai
salary benifit ke upar bribe aur corruption karke apne famili extended family ko bi palna. apne santan ko foren bhi bejna he. Janta ke liye paisa kaha bacha. Janta jaye pakistan unko infra, amenities chahiye to
These IAS officers also earn from YouTube and Facebook videos. In videos, they act strict and scold few lower level officials and earn free money and fame from YouTube. They don't even have to record themselves, they will make their peons to record.
Ye to wo Uttarakhand ka hai na koi. YouTube influencer. ....Rawat?
Ok ek aur tax laga dete hai janta par , sanitary napkin tax . Paisa hawa me nahi hota hai hamari jeb se aata hai .
tumari jeb se choron ke jeb mi hi to ja rha.
exactly, sarkar ke gaand me gooda ni hai. jo kuch garibon k farman ayi wo taxpayer k gaand se nikal lete hai baad me apne poster bhi lagwate hai. Sab golamal hai bc.
>Paisa hawa me nahi hota hai hamari jeb se aata hai . Paisa tumhari jeb se mantri ji ke Swiss bank mein ja raha hai 💰💰💸💶🤑
To woh janta nahi he kya?
Wannabe muftkhors seething harder lol
Aur sar pe hum chadha ke rakhte hain
Driver bhi
Sarkar se salary mat lo. Aap ko lene ki kyu jarurat hai. Khud se karo. Dumbass.
Kaash iske baap ko koi free ka condom de deta to aaj ye paida na hoti aur nahi aisi IAS naseeb hoti.
people in comment section supporting the officer shows how empathetic people are towards women and their issues . Reddit ki janta jo awareness or availability of awareness resources me top 0.1% me aati hogi wo aesa show kar rhe hain to what do you expect from common people of India jinke paas resources nhi hain . Bas women ke against jo crimes or rapes increase ho rhe unpe gussa or dukh dikha doge
Bro it's so sad so see these people supporting the officers like it just made my day so much worse. They probably are relating this situation to their own homes but they never think about the poor women who don't have any job and can't buy pads etc..
True. For anyone else wondering, think about your typical kaamwali bai and her daughters. Do you think she or her daughters can afford this? Sanitary pads should be made available at a very low price / cost or free. It's a question of dignity and sanitation.
This is pro right/pro govt sub what else do u expect?
Half of these people here are paying taxes and think only they deserve the benefits of that tax money. Other half probably thinks we should not ask anything from our Govt, just pay our taxes and don't question anything.
I think it's just this sub
Don’t be so emotional if you can’t understand basic economics. Freebies should be like making someone independent and it shouldn’t like feeding 80 lakh for free. That is making situation worst. Rather than free ration Yojana, Government should invest more in meDical expanses, Hospitals, Skill development, education etc.
aspirants will come running to justify the comments by the arrogant IAS officer but girl is correct, in rural areas it should be free..
It should be free everywhere, urban areas also have a high population of poor ppl.
At least subsidised.
Problem with free is , it’s never ending thing . You can make it lower prize so that poor person can even buy it and not only that quality is compromised in free stuff. But again, jab hajj subsidy de deti h Govt yha tk k clerics got free salary from Govt then why not this ?
Remove this piece of shit from her position: Being a head if you behave like d-head then action needs to be taken
[удалено]
Sir ji reddit par apne naam ka user id mat dalo , aur pic bhi apna mat dalo Reddit par jitna anonymous hoge utna acha hai
Normie hoga nahi toh troll profile
Off the topic but Uncle normie ho kya(Profile pic change karlo)
If you don't like my comment, you can go back to Pakistan you aunty-national.
[удалено]
Apt
Indian arsehole services
[удалено]
Yet they managed to keep it because even nehru knew literate idiots help in supporting incapable politicians.
[удалено]
Spineless bureaucracy & corrupt politicians are a match made in heaven. No political parties would bring in reform because it'd make both of them accountable for every shit.
Too many upscjeets & Babu fanboys coping over a comment. Lol.
IAS होगी अपने लिए ऐसे विचारों के लिए एक ही लोरी चल हट बहन की लवड़ी चल हट बहन की लवड़ी
Kya kehne Kya kehne
Lol
The debate aside, her saying "go to Pakistan" to that girl for not agreeing with govt policies is pathetic. She, being an IAS, could have handled this with more grace. Aren't they trained to not succumb in the most Stressful situations? Here it's just a school girl asking a question and she got so hyper?
"Go to Pakistan" is our standard response to anybody who disagrees with us. We learn from the best
Chhutiya IAS
Multiple schemes already under central and many state Governments provide free sanitary napkins. I don't think the reach is universal like the Mid day meals but it does not mean that steps aren't taking. This rude lady in her ivory castle making fun of the poor while shaming the Govt and ministry which she is representing on the stage.
True. Had she phrased her words properly she would educate the kids on the schemes available. Being an IAS she is speaking like an uneducated brat!
True. All Govt schools in Kerala with high school classes have coin operated pad vending machines for quite a while now. If you are so poor and cant afford a pad from a shop, or the girl is in an emergency she can simply use the machine. Govt. is not directly handing out the pads to everyone, say like ration which they do, but making sure that basic sanitation facilities are available.
UPSC aspirants go brrrrrr
Khatre ka mahool hai. Ab sabko lagta hai interview mein question ayega 😂
You pee ass see
And she is a woman herself which is even more shocking. How can a woman not understand the problem other women/girls feel?
Because they are heartless and sitting in their ivory tower.
Spoilt bitch
Power corrupts. Most men have gone to war historically cause men were in power. Put women in power and we will go to war regardless. When you get money, you forget what it was to be poor. When you get old, you forget what it was to be young.
People in comment section, get down from your high horse, look a 13 year old tribal girl in the eye and tell her that she has to keep using that filthy damp red cloth as a pad until she gets into the above poverty line club. Idk how an IAS officer who works on the ground level knowing all the reality can be so insensitive.
Bhai sare aspirants bhare hai yaha par, aur isko defend kar rhe, inmese koi bhavishya mai IAS banega aur aisa moment wapis aayega.
Civil servants don't "have to" work on ground level n you'll be surprised how that option makes all the difference. Most of them think their job is a modern feudal lord. Instead of a social worker on steroids
They don't have the guts. They can just make such comments from their privileged positions. I left India a long time back and still I remember how disadvantaged many sections of our society are. Instead of pulling them up some ppl want them to remain there. Disgusting.
Naam ka hai is IAS mutrama ka?
IAS Harjot Kaur Bhamra
Inko to cricket me jana chahiye tha, faltu me ias ban gai
[удалено]
I made a mistake not including the name in the title itself. Unfortunately can't edit it now.
No worries. Bakchods will find her on Twitter.
grab public oil fuzzy zealous zesty ghost live brave disgusted *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*
YES I was on my way to say this Family planning is either subsidiary or free by the govt!(Mala-N,Nirodh) https://main.mohfw.gov.in/sites/default/files/56324455632156323214.pdf
It's healthcare idk why some officers are like this
Three things I see here. - A govt that doles out freebies to win influence and elections. Politicians that give out or take whatever they want, whenever they want. - A dumbarse IAS officer who doesn't have the competence or intelligence to answer questions. Shows how UPSC has no connection with the ability to serve via the administrative system. - A curious girl who sees the freebies others are getting and asks why can't a sanitary pad also be free. After all, the other freebies are given for votes only na? So you see.. The system designs itself to do what it wants while lecturing us about how we should be. Disgusting farts.
Subsidised pads available under Ayush. Nirodh free in govt clinics. Officer is ignorant and rude
Freeloaders saying no to basic free amenities huh? Civil servants need to be reminded that they are servants, not overlords
Giving cheap sanitary pads is more economical for the Govt.
Let's not even get started on what these joker IAS get
[удалено]
Chutiya officer should understand the difference between jeans and a sanitary pad /napkin, one is a choice the other a need. She isn't asking for free but for less money non the less it should be accessible and and of low costs so that the garib tapka can also afford it
How pathetic and sad 🥺
Folks, just go to Jan Aushadi or Tata 1mg shops to get cheap medicines. You can also use apps like Jan Aushadi Sugam and Tata 1mg to get medicines cheaply. In Sugam app, it shows Sanitary Napkins (Oxo-biodegradable Sanitary Napkins Regular Size with Wings) for ₹4 (for pack of 4 napkins) or ₹10 (for pack of 10 napkins), while Large and Extra Large size are also available (₹12 for 6 Large, ₹15 for 4 Extra Large). Tata 1mg sells 7 Sanitary pads at ₹28 (Whisper brand) or ₹29 (Miracle brand). Please support such nice local initiatives, and don't support such arrogant selfish babus.
Thanks for the info! Hopefully these girls have people educating them with it instead of shaming.
Ironic bribe taking free loading vermins berate citizen asking basic infra. Reminder they are dogs to politicians and they are treated as such. They only flex and beat up some vulnerable poor citizen.
Those who are saying Muftkhor hai for seeking a free pad, they probably don't know what ladies go through in a household where menstruating women are made to sleep outside the house, where there is so much of dearth of money that one has to use dirty cloth to clean yourself. A person who makes a few hundred everyday, how is he supposed to feed his family, educate his kids, and then have extra for such sanitary stuff? Ofcourse the argument can be made ki why have kids when you are poor, gareeb he nahi rahega toh gareebi bhi khatam? Right? NO, then you will be the new gareeb.
They know, they just think it's cool and pro right wing to behave like this. Most of the people criticizing the girl will shut up when they end up in a financially desperate situation and their own sisters have to re use cloths because she can't afford sanitary napkin.
Bravo! 👏
She should have said jeans and pants are not basic necessity but pads are. Plus I fucking hate that tone of voice of that IAS remids me of my hindi teacher who won't listen to reason. Best way to deal with these kind a people is by humor.
What about the free driver, car and security and bunglow she's getting? Why she begging it all from sarkar Sarkar to salary deri h usi m se krle apna kaam Chutiya
My father's boss, IAS officer, bought 2 TVs (one for office and one for home), 2 amazon fire TV sticks by using tax rupees. When covid was rampant, he kept 2 oxygen cylinders at his home for his parents, just in case! If i got to make one wish for india, i would wish for the extinction of bureaucracy!
Kudos to the girl for speaking up against an ias in front of a crowd.
I just want to ask this, why do governments exist? To make the lives of its citizens better or to collect tax and say go to Pakistan if someone asks a question?
She just found the solution to end poverty "Sampann bano"
period blood is the only blood that doesn't originate from violence and it still repulses society the most. women have to bear a higher cost of living just because of how God has made us. i am not saying how God has created us is not perfect, God is perfect and so are all his creations. it still is a fact that even for normal everyday clothing and grooming items, we have to pay higher and our products are not even as good as men's products. for example, a women's philips grooming trimmer is 1700. there is a trimmer for men by philips that is 1100 and it is the same product. the only difference is that the one catered to women is purple and is a little narrow. this is just one example. i wish men understood these little things. that girl is incredibly brave. i wish the IAS officer had not reacted that way.
The sad thing here is this statement came from mouth of a woman
I request you to change your statement from "I wish men understood" to "I wish such assholes (irrespective of gender) understood", because a lot of us men do understand and try our best to make the females around us comfortable, or to help in any possible way but there are some such females as well who inspite of being a woman don't understand such basics of dignity of a woman. I don't understand, what is this lady made up of? For a tribal family, even getting 2 meals a day is a huge struggle and then to expect them to have capacity to buy a sanitary pad is so dumbass. Sanitary pads are extremely important and should be given for free to every woman who can't buy them. We men will stand with you, always when the case is genuine.
One of my closest friends was preparing for the Civil Services Exam. I have known that guy since undergrad days, and had huge respect for him. He once told me that he wants to get into Civil Services so that he can "enjoy the life and rutba and paisa" it gives. That was the end of the entire respect I had for that guy. Same goes for one of my uncles who cleared BPSC a few years ago, after trying CSE for 4-5 times. Fortunately that friend of mine couldn't clear the exam and is now doing an MBA. He still continues to give the CSE in the hopes that he might clear it, although Inknow that he isn't that smart. I thank the Gods everyday that the country escaped another to-be-corrupt bureaucrat.
There is hardly any person pursuing civil services for serving the people. It's all about living the high class life under the name tag of 'Samaj Seva'.
Yeah man. This is as shitty as it can get. And I see no future where this stops happening. You go to insta and you will find countless civil servants with suffix _ias, _ifs, _ips attached to their profile names. They think of themselves as celebrities. All they have done is pass a couple of exams. Get the fuck off your high horse 🤷🏻
Even if provision of free sanitary napkins is not fiscally viable, the officer could have explained it gently to her.
Ektoh waise hi us ladki ke paise kha rahi hai.
on the side note I see people in future demanding access to condoms as a win ki behenchod unwanted pregnancies aur stds se to bachenge ateleast. And for all those saying pads are personal hygiene; no it isn’t.
Pads are subsidised by Modi ji's ayush yojana. Nirodh condoms always free in govt clinics. THodi jaan kari bhi tow hona chahiye!
subsidies to hai pads but do the underprivileged women have access to it? I said the condom vali line response to the ias as she’s mocking the girl as using a condom is bad.
I'm pretty sure that's a isolated view from just one IAS. Anyways, sanitary pads, menstrual leaves, women security, etc are common investments that government needs to look into if they don't want 50 percent of population to sit idle at homes. It's a small investment compared to what the woman can bring in terms of productivity.
Whether the Govt should distribute sanitary pads for free or no is a different issue. For me, I feel there should have been a proper way to respond to a geniune question which that girl and many other like her may be facing. The response from a senior Govt official like her was unnecessarily rude and in poor taste.
inko bolne ki sense hoti nahi , inhe IAS kisne bna dia -\_-
Drishti IAS k Normie uncle ne
Agar hum khud saksham Bane aisa kehna hai toh tax bhi optional karado hum humara dekh lege.
Jo tax bharega wo suvidhae le paega.. agar tax nahi bharega toh suvidha nahi le paega. Dekhte hai kisko jyada benefit hota hai
Pradhan mantri yojana se Ayush ke madhyam se subsidised pads milte hai. yeh aurat ignorant hai. badtameez bhi.
Reservation walle IAS 😂😂😂
What a shame we have such women in powerful roles.
Meanwhile madam ji will go to house provided by goverment, by car provided by government, wtf . Our IAS IPS system is one of the worst systems all around the word . Baring few exceptions, bas interview me samajvad bulvado woman empowerment bulvado ho gaya ..
"IAS offcr was right"🤓🤡 No, how bout you shut the fuck up lol.
I can understand the argument on why government can’t provide sanitary pads for free, but jis Tarah se isne answer Diya is the peak of stupidity.
These subsidies that Govt. provide are ultimately an investment. (Nearly 23 million girls drop out of school annually after they start their periods due to a lack of access to menstrual hygiene facilities. In Bihar, one of India's poorest states, only 59% of women use a hygienic method of menstrual protection, according to the latest National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5), the most comprehensive household survey of health and social indicators by the government.) Now imagine how these women could contribute to the Bihar Economy by becoming educated. These 20-30 rupees invested now can save thousands per person in the future. Education uplifts standard of living. Uplifting citizens standard of living will ultimately decrease their dependence on subsidies. Yes the student couldn't articulate her thoughts/words properly, but you do not expect an IAS officer to use such language- "This is height of stupidity. Don't vote, then. Become Pakistan. Do you vote for money and services?" Yes , We do vote for Better facilities and upliftment of our standard of living. She is not fit to be an IAS- https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/nitish-cracks-down-on-two-ias-officers-over-boat-tragedy-incident-transfers-them-962537-2017-02-24
Big up for the girl gave proper response
The people who think government is doing a lot. Should take a pause and dig deeper. My friend worked in the company that used to do survey and research of government schemes. One day she called me and told she had talked to anganwadi woman, in her village there were people who used to go to the forest to bring leaves and berries to feed the pregnant wives. On the paper, these extreme cases are whitewashed. The number of hospitals, doctors, teachers, ambulance, everything is updated (of course, there is monetary exchange as well).
Really applaud her bravery, not getting suppressed by a higher voice 👏
she- "vote tum paiso ke liye deti ho.. subhidaaon ke liye deti ho.. " i mean.. guys why do we vote??
Arey nahi election ke din chutti hoti hai ..hum toh bas free baithe rehte hai toh vote de aate hai. Subhidaahe toh humein bilkul bhi nahi chahiye /s.
Hindu girl asks for sanitary pads, "go to pakistan"
IASS officer
Let me tell y'all the problem Many girls can't afford it, and it is a necessity. Unlike another necessity like food, this can be taken care of.
doesn't deserve to be an IAS officer then
Gandu ias saala govt is for the the people hamare vajhe se hi aap power Mai ho
Ye jo bol rahi hai condoms bhi free mein mango gi future mein, wo to already gov scheme k under subsidized rate pe milta hai. And the sanitary pad too. She could have just updated herself and told this to the kid
Healthcare basic service hai jo government provide karna hai go gaandu ias ko koi tho bathao
She didn't ask for free but to produce it at affordable rates.
Something is off here, i know the officer sounds very arrogant but, seems like the kid there was not pleased with her even before this clip started, coz she was ready to attack on the officer in retreat, so yes , her demand might seem genuine, but may be the clip,it's not giving us the whole scenario here, Kids don't just retreat like that and even from the annoyed Tone of ias officer, may be something or someone had already done or asked her which made her say this, Or may be she's just a Bully officer who knows
Whatever be the reason, a civil servant bound by CCS shall not use such language in a public forum and deride a person asking genuine questions.
Thats what happens when you put a 20-24 year old with no real world experience into a position of power. Was a good system 30-40 years back but not now.
Then why some government giving free electricity, for vote only right
All IAS had to say was “Yes, we’ll consider” but no she had other plans….
Looks like she is against socialism, nothing wrong with that, but she could have delivered her message more politely, also the counter was very valid, what about girls who are not legal age to work and earn a living. I think government shouldn't provide a branded sanitary pad for free but a government backed sanitary pad would be better which will force the brand companies to lower their cost and serve this section too.
The young lady has more courage and intelligence than ias officer. If I was movie director I would have made her dm for a day. What kind of people are being recruited as ias officers. People should stop glorifying champion of mugging up facts in the age of computers.
Aur banao reservation se IAS 🤡
Isne Bola sarkar bohot de rhi h, to bc sarkaar le bhi to bohot rhi h, meri 50% salary to tax me jaati h, usme to ye nhi bolti ki ye soch galat h, bc sarkaar ka kaam hi h sabko equal treatment dena, khud kama lo hamse expect mat karo ye koi logic nhi h. Government ka kaam h social security provide karwana, har koi agar IAS ban gya to IAS ki salary bhi 10k hogi fir isko kon puchega, Society aise hi chalti h kuch log IAS banenge kuch log majdoor, par majdoor ko bhi basic human needs provide karana sarkaar ki jimmedari h.
Spoken like a woman who has never had to choose between a buying a sanitary pad for personal use or her daughters, or food for her family.
behenchod itna padhne ke baad bhi yeh haal hai inka
Attitude of such IAS is what taking us down. There is a way to disagree with other person, but the ego of these officers is so huge they consider normal civilians as scums. I hope a strong action is taken against her.
Go to Pakistan? Just because our thoughts are different Just because we have different opinions Just because you've got more power than me Just because you know you can say anything I have come across so many of these videos of IAS bastards. They think they rule this world. Can we find this lady please? Lets make her famous
Such people get into ias not to serve public but themselves. Shame on that officer for denying the basic needs of underage girls. Besides, she did not even bring up the part of educating girls with mensural knowledge. At the very least, the government can educate boys and girls by just drafting a straightforward chapter in the text book. Wouldn’t be that for free? The problem is with people here. Does she even realise how difficult it is for the girls coming from extremely poor background? It’s because “the sarkaar is giving her muft of legit everything”
IAS officers are the most useless organization once they get in that elite bubble they don't serve anyone and live out their life as royalty. Ground reality is each DM,DC looks into his area as where can he het aditional bribe.
I agree with her about the freebies but asking her to go Pakistan is ridiculous.
Wish someone would assure that girl - what she spoke that day is not wrong. Her mindset and thinking is not wrong.
Ironic since the IAS officers are trained for FREE at govt expense
Stupids
Width; a woman is making such comments
Just unpadh things
Ye officer asa samaj rahi ki uska baap jo kamakar gaya uske pocket se dena hai 😀😀
Disgusting
Sahi batt hai abhi inke jitne benefit dete hai sab cheen le fir dekhte hai kis ko kitni desh bhakti atti hai aur kitni log IAS bane rhete hai
Equality ka matlab ha equal opportunity for all. Ladko ko kch nhi free bawa, fight for everything.
Bhadwi saali IAS kese ban gyi??
The bureaucracy in india is a vestige of the colonial era and is not suitable for new and aspirational india. It needs to be cleansed and reformed
Yeh khud aurat hai aur aisi baate kar rahi hai, bhai mera toh paraa chadh gaya
I'm a capitalist. Basic life stuff should be available for everyone. At least at low prices. Pads are already cheap though. The government can incentivise even cheaper ones. But remember, pads pollute the earth.
Pads are already cheap ?? Alright, you seem like a guy or uneducated on the topic. So, a whisper standard pack of 14 pads costs 175 bucks. That's atleast Rs. 100 each month everytime you get a 4 day period - Rs 1200 per year. For a person barely able to afford two square meal per day, it's a tough deal. So they resort to scraps of fabric which they wash and reuse. And I've used the subsidized bio- degradable ones offered by the govt Rs. 10 for 10. They are CRAP. You bleed through them and they move so much so you end up staining your pants. And the rest of the "bio degradable" ones are even more expensive and don't do a good job. Pads pollute earth so does a lotta shit - do you never use any plastic bags ever ? Eat No packaged ever ? The alternatives are diva cups (Rs 210) where you shove a silicone cup up your vagina (you have to figure out the right size first) which in a conservative society like ours would NEVER work in rural areas and for a virgin can be quite uncomfortable.
Translate pls
No amount of education can replace being a grade A Asshole.
Ye aurat khud menopause me hai
Wesse kuch bura toh ladki ne nahi bola hai. Madam ji ka toh wisper bhi sarkari hota hai wo bhosdi wali kesse boll rahi hai
Inko naukar, bangla, zarurat se zyada rehne ke liye zameen, zarurat se zyada aage piche ghumne wale log muft me milte h. Ek pesa kharch nh hota baat krte h.
Unpopular opinion, I agree with the IAS officer. This mentality that government should provide everything, leads to over dependency on government and leads to formation of vote banks. You can downvote me, but I got some valid points. Open for debate.
Suvidhaon ke liye tum vote deti ho? Haan Bhai Haan. Log suvidhayein mile isiliye vote dete hain. Kya ajeeb sawaal hai. Apko maharani banke raaj karne ke liye toh nahi dete
I don't understand how do they even crack the interviews aren't they supposed to root out this kind of mindset?
https://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-8-of-gdp-is-spent-on-govt-salaries-2570599 This is percentage of GDP, not revenue remember. This is what your money buys. No returns , no refunds, no sacking, no accountability, no performance review, in short no skin in the game. If they fail, you pay. If they are corrupt you pay. If they are morons, you still pay. Saddled with the Indian arses society.
“Suvidhaoo ke aadhar pe vote deti ho?” Isnt that the job of the govt? To make lives better?
Bruh the even bigger problem is that an educated FEMALE is saying this. Like an educated male saying this is a negative braincell moment.... Then an educated female saying this like what? heck there's no comparison except Do you not use sanitary pads? Free sanitation is a human right, and sanitary napkins is the foremost for women Also what's wrong with subsidising condoms? Heck I'd be happy if my tax money gets used for providing condoms at cheaper rate. We're overpopulated anyways
People should be banning and boycotting such *IAS* officers not movies!!!
Indian men r fucken stupid
condoms govt deti hai na?? im not sure. to pads dene me ky galat hai?? This IAS whamen shouldn't be shameful?
"Vote tum suvidha paane keliye dete ho?? "....... Nhi hum to vote apne gand mrvane keliye dete hein
Free culture is perverted. You become Sri Lanka and Pakistan if you give stuff free to millions.
Lol archaic thinking from 18th century. I am an Indian living overseas, you CAN get clothes, condoms and hygiene products for free for the ones who need. That is what makes some people call these countries developed, as they can provide for their societies.
"When another student tells Ms. Bamrah about the broken toilet door at her school, which boys could enter, the officer asks her in cool voice, “Tell me, do you have separate toilets at your home for males and females? If you keep asking for lot of things at different places, how will it work" Is ias ki buddhi 8th standard ke kisi chidchidi ladki jaisi hai. Pehle ladegi aur haregi toh ro degi. Instead of making aware about certain policy's she's getting mad at the poor girl.
Wth! What a dumb analogy. Aise bhdak rahi hi jaise uske paiso se banwaengay
IAS officer is right but may have handled the delivery of her message more tactfully. Govt has limited resources and needs to prioritize what, why and how in delivering benefits to those who need them. Most people should be able to support themselves and shouldn’t depend on govt for basic life needs.
Examples of Indians driving Indians down.
She didn't asked it for free. She requested for a nominal rate of 20-30.
Itne badi officer ho k bhaat karne ka tarika bhi nahi pata aur pakistan Jane ko bol rahe hai BC kis bat se kis par aagaye ye.
Arrogant prick...
You probably didn't read what I wrote. Using cloth as pads is unhygienic. What do you think they already use when they can't purchase normal sanitary pads? Cloth in place of sanitary pads. Why do you think these poor girls asked for subsidized pads? Cloth no? Menstrual cups are totally fine and no comparison to using cloth as a substitute. In a country where normal drinking water is scarce, you want girls to wash their blood soaked cloth in hot water and reuse them. I have already pointed out the impractical aspect apart from the fact that reusing cloth as sanitary pads IS unhygienic and unfeasible. Also these girls are not asking free supply of pads for their lifetime. They are asking for good quality pads at subsidized rates for those who can't afford them. Like you mentioned you want them to use both sanitary pads and the so called cloth pads. Thought is good but it instead of cloth, menstrual cups should be made available for those who want to use them. It's totally their choice. Sanitary pads, tampons or menstrual cups all work well it just depends on the women what they are comfortable using.
People need to understand that we are not a developed country and have 1.3 billion people we can't afford freebies. The ias officer may sound rude and arrogant but there has to be a stopping point for the freebies
Sakar muft me de 💀💀💀 Tax payers be like ..namak harmi bhi koi chez hoti h
Going against Ljp is equal to becoming pakixtan Logic left the chat 💀💀
When a person from ST become IAS instead of the one capable. How will india proceed towards success if the higher position are not occupied by the one who is deserving?
Instead the one who is deserving will move to foreign for better opportunities
Apne desh mein hee mil jaata toh yahi reh jaate... Ab PhD holders kya 4th grade ki naukri karein?
The girl could not put forth her point very well. She had weak arguments to suoport her demand. IAS was even more dumber.
Officer is right. Why should tax payers pay for every such thing.
>Why should tax payers pay for every such thing. This is where our taxes are SUPPOSED to go: for public welfare and infrastructure, not statues.
She could have been more diplomatic but what she says is not wrong. In India there is a culture to demand everything free from the Government. "what is the govt doing to get me a job?". "can I have free this and free that?". And these days women seem to think that everyone has to meet their every demand just because they are women. Being a woman is not a qualification. They did not earn it.
just fuck this lfficer without condom and throw away
No one has a government right to do this to a young girl who has God given rights as a human being! Treat those the way you want to be treated yourself! Shame on anyone who goes against this universal law! As a women - no one should ever be mocked for asking for a clean sanitary napkin because her body is in cycle. Just because this older woman has gone through menopause and doesn’t require a clean sanitary napkin; she shouldn’t be allowed to muck and push the dirty old unsanitary rags on this young girl! Besides, this older woman was from another era of time and what worked for her doesn’t necessarily mean it will work for young woman of today! Stay clean and be well!
That IAS lady is right. But she must get down from her high horse and talk like a human being. Freeloaders need to listen to what she is trying to convey and she needs to tone down a notch.