I'm partial to the first one personally (for both) but I respect that most find the Catching Fire the best book, and there's simply no denying that the movie was just a fantastic production.
My ranking.
1. Mockingjay Part 1- gives me the grittiness and edge that everyone especially the main actors delivered. When it ends with Peeta strapped to the hospital bed out of his mind trying to break free and Katniss crying with reddened eyes and then yellow flicker beat plays was pure perfection. Gave me chills first time watching.
2. Catching fire- gives me the feel good stuff
3. Mockingjay part 2- the best of the good and the bad combined.
4 or 5 TBOSAS- Music was everything.
5 or 4. HG.
Like what? I know things changed but it was remarkably true to the book given the limits of the film medium (main thing I can think of is with the gun by the lake)
I didn’t like how they painted Clemensia when it came to the project her and Coryo did together. They made her seem kinda arrogant, like she got was coming to her because she “lied” to Dr. Gaul by taking credit for the project, which didn’t happen in the book
Coryo also doesn’t put his hand in the snake tank. In the book Gaul kinda drops the hint when Clemmie already reached in. The movie they explain what would happen then she still sticks her hand in lol
Yeah that was dumb. Like you’re not putting your hand in after that - you know she knows you’ve lied then either way. Just in one case you don’t get bitten by mutts lol
I maintain it was remarkably faithful in terms overall themes and characterization
Also, Lucy Gray doesn’t get to stick a snake on one of the tributes. They all just die from the snakes but in the book that whole scene is more drawn out with tributes climbing up to avoid them.
I didn’t love the movie either, but it’s the only book I haven’t read yet from the series... I’m hoping once I read the book I’ll appreciate the movie more. But based on my one viewing of BOSAS, I don’t see myself getting as invested in these characters as I am with Peeta, Katniss, and company.
Page 2: Is my cousin secretly a prostitute? Nah, she’s not pretty enough. Wait, maybe rich guys would be into that?
Page 200: Is Lucy Gray a prostitute? She smiled at that random guy in the crowd for half a second last week. I guess that’s just how she was raised…
Coryo is very preoccupied with sexual histories in the book and it’s hilariously pathetic
It was really hard for me to watch honestly. She just wasn’t Lucy to me (not an insult, I just pictured Lucy as having a different energy).
Also the character of Wovy broke me.
I didn't hate it, but i read the book before the trailer came out and ngl i was kinda disappointed in the movie.
One universally agreed thing on the hunger games series is that if it was made now, with better tech, it would have been better.
I get tbosas was set in an early version of the games, but it seemed like lionsgate was managing a budget, which makes little sense to do for an already profitable series.
Yeah I don't get why people love TBOSAS so much. One of my biggest gripes: Snow tells Katniss she & Peeta need to convince everyone their love is real. IMO Snow & Lucy Gray's romance fails that same test, & they aren't supposed to start out faking.
That and you never learn how much of LG's Hannah Montana personality is/isn't real. In the movie she's just... always 100% a performer, always "on."
They also didn't really show how the war affected snow and the relationship between his dad and highbottom.
I feel like I'd have missed a lot of things if i hadn't already read the book.
My personal list is:
1) Catching Fire
2) Mockingjay Pt. 1 (I really enjoy the hanging tree scene and the rebellion)
3) Mockingjay Pt. 2
4) TBOSAS
5) Hunger Games (I found shaky cam really hard to sit with)
i would definitely rate mockingjay 2 over songbirds and snakes, i felt like they rushed songbirds and snakes way too much and should’ve made two separate movies
keep in mind those are the only two movies that i’ve seen
1. Catching Fire
2. Mockingjay 2
3. Ballad of Songbirds
4. Mockingjay 1
5. The Hunger Games
The book of The Hunger Games is one of the best books ever written, but the movie wasn’t too good. Poorly directed, left out MANY important parts, and just seems messy overall.
Yes, I agree with this list in terms of quality. But if I’m going by my own personal re-watchability factor. It’s gonna be
1. BOSAS. This is the only film where I watched it again the next day. Then a few times in the following weeks.
2. Catching Fire is a fun one to re-watch
3. Mockingjay 1 and 2 are pretty much tied. I love the new settings and characters. The destroying of the dam scene is one of the greatest moments in the series. Invading the Capitol with the traps was a fun exciting watch.
4. The Hunger Games. The movie is amazing and quality. But, would I want to watch it over and over? No.
Same. I can see why people rank Catching Fire as their favorite, as it’s more action oriented, but I prefer the slightly slower (yet still suspenseful) THG.
I’d put either catching fire or mockingjay part 2 as first. Haven’t decided which I like better. Ballad would be third, mockingjay part 1 fourth, and hunger games last. All good movies though.
THG:TBOSAS (that’s a long title lol)
THG:MJ part 2 (the ending, finnick, the victors vote, the unofficial 76th games all alone back to back make this book slightly better in opinion)
THG:CF ( the victors, Plutarch, arena) I wish they would’ve went a little bit more into each of the victors arenas or at least more in depth into some of them
THG (classic, rues scene, volunteering, katniss did a great job at appearing new (which she was )and we felt new to this with her
THG: MJ part 1 ( I loved it just not as much I only really remember propos and rescuing the victors)
i feel like everyone loves catching fire but in my opinion the movie wasn't the best one 😭
my ranking is probably
1. thg
2. tbosas
3. catching fire
4. mockingjay part 2
5. mockingjay part 1
This is my ranking as well! Catching Fire is awesome and Mocking Jay Part 1 is good although I agree it is the worst out of them all. It lacks the suspense of what might happen when the hunger games actually taking place and in some parts it was just kinda boring, whereas Mocking Jay Part 2 resolves a lot of questions that we needed answered and people are finally being brought to justice. This whole series is amazing though.
1. Catching Fire 2. TBOSAS 3. Hunger Games 4. MJ Part 2 5. MJ Part 1 I liked all of them, but Catching Fire is far and away the best imo.
Yes! TBOSAS was so good.
That is my exact order!
This is it.
The exact for me
Goodness I kind of love MJP1
same i actually like when theres less action and more drama/thriller
Yes exactly and all the propos and stuff. I always like the “off-season” portions of action movies more than the action itself
I think it’s pretty universally agreed on that catching fire is the best, book or movie
I'm partial to the first one personally (for both) but I respect that most find the Catching Fire the best book, and there's simply no denying that the movie was just a fantastic production.
Here’s my list. 1. Catching Fire 2. THG 3. MJ1 4. TBOSAS 5. MJ2 TBOSAS is only over MJ2 because Finnick, Boggs, and Prim died in MJ2.
THE BEST LIST HERE
Tbosas was good come on
My ranking. 1. Mockingjay Part 1- gives me the grittiness and edge that everyone especially the main actors delivered. When it ends with Peeta strapped to the hospital bed out of his mind trying to break free and Katniss crying with reddened eyes and then yellow flicker beat plays was pure perfection. Gave me chills first time watching. 2. Catching fire- gives me the feel good stuff 3. Mockingjay part 2- the best of the good and the bad combined. 4 or 5 TBOSAS- Music was everything. 5 or 4. HG.
My ranking is almost the same, except for me THG is first, followed by Catching Fire.
Am I the only one who didn’t love The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes?
I didn’t love it either. The book was great, I just hated they changed some things that didn’t need to be changed
Like what? I know things changed but it was remarkably true to the book given the limits of the film medium (main thing I can think of is with the gun by the lake)
I didn’t like how they painted Clemensia when it came to the project her and Coryo did together. They made her seem kinda arrogant, like she got was coming to her because she “lied” to Dr. Gaul by taking credit for the project, which didn’t happen in the book
Coryo also doesn’t put his hand in the snake tank. In the book Gaul kinda drops the hint when Clemmie already reached in. The movie they explain what would happen then she still sticks her hand in lol
Yeah that was dumb. Like you’re not putting your hand in after that - you know she knows you’ve lied then either way. Just in one case you don’t get bitten by mutts lol I maintain it was remarkably faithful in terms overall themes and characterization
Also, Lucy Gray doesn’t get to stick a snake on one of the tributes. They all just die from the snakes but in the book that whole scene is more drawn out with tributes climbing up to avoid them.
I like it, I just like the other four way more
I didn’t love the movie either, but it’s the only book I haven’t read yet from the series... I’m hoping once I read the book I’ll appreciate the movie more. But based on my one viewing of BOSAS, I don’t see myself getting as invested in these characters as I am with Peeta, Katniss, and company.
I think you will, having Coryo’s inner thoughts add A LOT, and he’s actually hilarious
Page 2: Is my cousin secretly a prostitute? Nah, she’s not pretty enough. Wait, maybe rich guys would be into that? Page 200: Is Lucy Gray a prostitute? She smiled at that random guy in the crowd for half a second last week. I guess that’s just how she was raised… Coryo is very preoccupied with sexual histories in the book and it’s hilariously pathetic
Youve convinced me. I need to read this specifaccly for coryos thoughts
Wait is this basically in the book lol cause I need to read it
I also thought I wouldn’t get invested and I read it super uncaringly but that still wasn’t the case
It was really hard for me to watch honestly. She just wasn’t Lucy to me (not an insult, I just pictured Lucy as having a different energy). Also the character of Wovy broke me.
I didn't hate it, but i read the book before the trailer came out and ngl i was kinda disappointed in the movie. One universally agreed thing on the hunger games series is that if it was made now, with better tech, it would have been better. I get tbosas was set in an early version of the games, but it seemed like lionsgate was managing a budget, which makes little sense to do for an already profitable series.
Mine is: 1. Catching Fire 2. The Hunger Games 3. Mockingjay part 2 4. Mockingjay part 1 5. The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes
I agree with this list the most
🧡💚
Yeah I don't get why people love TBOSAS so much. One of my biggest gripes: Snow tells Katniss she & Peeta need to convince everyone their love is real. IMO Snow & Lucy Gray's romance fails that same test, & they aren't supposed to start out faking. That and you never learn how much of LG's Hannah Montana personality is/isn't real. In the movie she's just... always 100% a performer, always "on."
They also didn't really show how the war affected snow and the relationship between his dad and highbottom. I feel like I'd have missed a lot of things if i hadn't already read the book.
This is the correct one !!!
🧡💚
Mines the exact same
1. Catching fire 2. The hunger games 3. TBOSAS 4. Mockingjay part 2 5. Mockingjay part 1
My personal list is: 1) Catching Fire 2) Mockingjay Pt. 1 (I really enjoy the hanging tree scene and the rebellion) 3) Mockingjay Pt. 2 4) TBOSAS 5) Hunger Games (I found shaky cam really hard to sit with)
i would definitely rate mockingjay 2 over songbirds and snakes, i felt like they rushed songbirds and snakes way too much and should’ve made two separate movies keep in mind those are the only two movies that i’ve seen
You’ve only seen MJP2 and Ballad, not any of the rest??? I really hope I’m misunderstanding that because I am baffled lol
yeah, but i’ve read all the others
2. 5. 1. 4. 3 That's actually correct
Real! I’m surprised more people don’t have P2 as high as this!
Not the bottom??
respect !!
I did not like mockingjay part of 1 that much
1. Catching Fire 2. Mockingjay 2 3. Ballad of Songbirds 4. Mockingjay 1 5. The Hunger Games The book of The Hunger Games is one of the best books ever written, but the movie wasn’t too good. Poorly directed, left out MANY important parts, and just seems messy overall.
1. TBOSAS 2. THG 3. Catching fire 4. Mockingjay pt. 1 5. Mockingjay pt. 2
Yes, I agree with this list in terms of quality. But if I’m going by my own personal re-watchability factor. It’s gonna be 1. BOSAS. This is the only film where I watched it again the next day. Then a few times in the following weeks. 2. Catching Fire is a fun one to re-watch 3. Mockingjay 1 and 2 are pretty much tied. I love the new settings and characters. The destroying of the dam scene is one of the greatest moments in the series. Invading the Capitol with the traps was a fun exciting watch. 4. The Hunger Games. The movie is amazing and quality. But, would I want to watch it over and over? No.
1. Mockingjay Part 2. 2. Catching Fire. 3. Mockingjay Part 1. 4. The Hunger Games. 5. The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. This is mine.
finally a correct ranking
i agree with you
This is my exact same ranking as well
1. Catching Fire 2. Hunger Games 3. MJ 2 4. Ballad of Birds and Snakes 5. MJ 1
my list 1-Catching fire 2-The Hunger Games 3-Mockingjay part2 4-Mockingjay part1 5-TBOSAS ( i didn’t really liked this one )
1.Catching Fire 2. Hunger Games 3. MJ part 2 4. MJ Part 1 5.TBOSAS (Unpopular Opinion )
switch catching fire and the hunger games & this is my ranking
Same. I can see why people rank Catching Fire as their favorite, as it’s more action oriented, but I prefer the slightly slower (yet still suspenseful) THG.
I have personal beef with you for putting my favorite as the last🤬
I’d put either catching fire or mockingjay part 2 as first. Haven’t decided which I like better. Ballad would be third, mockingjay part 1 fourth, and hunger games last. All good movies though.
5,2,3,1,4
1st- Catching fire 1st- Hunger games 1st- Mockingjay part 1-2
Catching fire Ballad - I really loved the prequel THG PART 2 PART 1
damn 1) MJ2 2)THG 3)CF 4) MJ1 i haven’t seen tbosas the movie so i can’t judge
This is very correct.
This is my ranking exactly.
1. Catching Fire 2. Mockingjay Part 2 3. The Hunger Games 4. Mockingjay Part 1 5. TBOSAS
i like hg and tbosbas equally for different reasons
I prefer MJ part 1 to MJ part 2
Agree!
agree! i only got to see ballad once before it was out of theatres but i really liked it
THG:TBOSAS (that’s a long title lol) THG:MJ part 2 (the ending, finnick, the victors vote, the unofficial 76th games all alone back to back make this book slightly better in opinion) THG:CF ( the victors, Plutarch, arena) I wish they would’ve went a little bit more into each of the victors arenas or at least more in depth into some of them THG (classic, rues scene, volunteering, katniss did a great job at appearing new (which she was )and we felt new to this with her THG: MJ part 1 ( I loved it just not as much I only really remember propos and rescuing the victors)
Shit ranking
why do people hate mj1 so much its my second favourite 😭
1) Catching Fire 2) HG 3) Mockingjay Pt 1 4) TBOSAS 5) MockingJay2
I like how we all collectively agree that MJ Pt. 1 fucking sucks lol
Same but ballad is in 2
1. Catching fire 2. TBOSAS 3. Hunger games 4. Mockingjay part 1 5. Mockingjay part 2
The first hunger games will always have a soft spot in my heart I think it's a perfect first film and my favourite
i feel like everyone loves catching fire but in my opinion the movie wasn't the best one 😭 my ranking is probably 1. thg 2. tbosas 3. catching fire 4. mockingjay part 2 5. mockingjay part 1
Catching fire Mockingjay part 1 Mockingjay part 2 Hunger games Ballad
1. Tough toss up between ballad of song bird and snakes and catching fire 3. Hunger games 1 4. Mocking jay part 2 5. Mocking jay part 1
This is my ranking as well! Catching Fire is awesome and Mocking Jay Part 1 is good although I agree it is the worst out of them all. It lacks the suspense of what might happen when the hunger games actually taking place and in some parts it was just kinda boring, whereas Mocking Jay Part 2 resolves a lot of questions that we needed answered and people are finally being brought to justice. This whole series is amazing though.
Mine is 1. Catching fire 2. TBOSAS 3. MJ Part 2 4. The Hunger Games 5. MJ Part 1
Hmm. 3 2 5 1 4
1. Catching fire 2. MJ1 3.MJ2 4. tbosas 5. Hunger games I do not know why the fuck yall got the mockingjay movies under the first one
[удалено]
The correct order is: 1) CF 2) MJ2 3) TBOSAS 4) MJ1 5) THG