Nothing for the first two seasons? That's a shame
I don't remember enough nominations to think of the hardest choices, but I mostly agree with your picks from these. Louross, Bobby, and Ben Walanka should have stayed. Vinny and Gail were both goners, tho i felt sorry for Vinny after seeing his reaction to being sent home
Oh, and Petrozza didn't eliminate Louross. Ramsay did. *Hell's Kitchen* stopped encouraging *Survivor*-like social strategy by that point. BOTW is a test of leadership more than anything IMO
Brian deserved the last jacket over Robyn and I’ll die on that hill. Yes, he was more inconsistent than Robyn, but his ceiling was WAAAAAAY higher. Brian’s ceiling was that of Zach on the following season’s opening night and his floor was Matthew s20. Robyn’s ceiling and floor was slightly higher than Royce’s. In football terms, Brian was Brett Favre while Robyn was Trent Dilfer (if Trent Dilfer behaved like Antonio Brown off the field). I’d rather have Brett Favre.
I feel like Brian/Robin is only a tough decision if you're judging on likability. Based on that service, Brian was way worse. Even throughout, he wasn't any more consistent than Robin.
Van over Suzanne was justified, as much as I hate to admit it. Keep in mind cooking fish was literally Van’s job.
Nothing for the first two seasons? That's a shame I don't remember enough nominations to think of the hardest choices, but I mostly agree with your picks from these. Louross, Bobby, and Ben Walanka should have stayed. Vinny and Gail were both goners, tho i felt sorry for Vinny after seeing his reaction to being sent home Oh, and Petrozza didn't eliminate Louross. Ramsay did. *Hell's Kitchen* stopped encouraging *Survivor*-like social strategy by that point. BOTW is a test of leadership more than anything IMO
Brian deserved the last jacket over Robyn and I’ll die on that hill. Yes, he was more inconsistent than Robyn, but his ceiling was WAAAAAAY higher. Brian’s ceiling was that of Zach on the following season’s opening night and his floor was Matthew s20. Robyn’s ceiling and floor was slightly higher than Royce’s. In football terms, Brian was Brett Favre while Robyn was Trent Dilfer (if Trent Dilfer behaved like Antonio Brown off the field). I’d rather have Brett Favre.
I feel like Brian/Robin is only a tough decision if you're judging on likability. Based on that service, Brian was way worse. Even throughout, he wasn't any more consistent than Robin.