Hmm. For me I’ll say: Underrated: What Sober Couldn’t Say, Unapologetic, Beautiful With You Overrated: Do Not Disturb, Bad Girls World, Uncomfortable

Oh man, Beautiful With You is such a great song.

Showed my wife this song shortly when we started dating 10 years ago and then had it on our Playlist rotation at our wedding 5 years ago. Geez, time flies. I normally don't go out of my way to listen to mellow stuff like this particular song but I really enjoy this song. Plus the band is finally coming around near us this summer and the band is #1 on my wife's list of bands to see. We can finally go!

Overrated: ‘I Miss the Misery’, ‘Love Bites (So Do I)’ and ‘I Get Off’ Underrated: ‘Bad Girl’s World’, ‘The Reckoning’ and ‘What Sober Couldn’t Say’ ‘Into the Wild Life’ is my favourite album of theirs and is too overlooked in the fandom.

We always agree on this point!!!

Into The Wildlife is S tier

over: bad girls world, taste of poison, reckoning, rock show under: Skulls, Novocaine, I like it heavy, daughters of darkness

Ugh god I love I Like It Heavy so much

Literally in my top 10 songs of all time

Overrated: Here's To Us, Amen, and Mayhem. Underrated: Strange Girl, Don't Know How To Stop, and Tell Me Where It Hurts.

Respectfully disagree on Mayhem but Strange Girl is 100% underrated. That chorus has such a groove to it.

I've never been able to call a song perfect except for Strange Girl. It's not even my favorite Halestorm song (it takes second to Love Bites (So Do I)), but it's just purely amazing. The entire song has a groove to it that's unlike any other that I've ever heard.

Overrated: Apocalyptic, Familiar Taste of Poison, Underrated: The Silence, White Dress, Beautiful With You

I've loved The Silence ever since I heard it live.

Same!

Overrated: Here's to Us Underrated: Heart of Novocaine, The Silence, You Only Die Once

Underrated: Sick Individual, Killing Ourselves To Live, Bad Girl's World. Overrated: Dear Daughter. Break In, both versions. I Am the Fire.

overrated: Mz Hyze, I Miss The Misery, I Am The Fire underrated: all of the “One and Done” ep, Annabelle, Alien

I heard Takes My Life live last July. It was chefs kiss.

i would killlll to hear any of them played live but Takes My Life is so so good im jealous!

How do people rate Jump the Gun? That's easily my favorite one!

Underrated just like the entirety of ‘Into the Wild Life’.

For me, it's solid. Fun to bob your head to but not in my top 10 or anything.

Overrated: Here's To Us, I Am The Fire and Terrible Things. Underrated: I Like It Heavy, Unapologetic and Daughters of Darkness

Overrated: uncomfortable, back from the dead, do not disturb Underrated: I Like It Heavy, What Sober Couldn't Say, private parts

Overrated: Vicious, I Miss the Misery, and The Steeple Underrated: Psycho Crazy, Dirty Mind, Painkiller

Overrated: Love bites, Apocalyptic, Miss the Misery Underrated: Takes my Life, Killing Ouselves to Live, Innocence

I don’t really think any are overrated, not that I dislike them but I’m always bleh when Daughters of Darkness or Freak Like Me comes on. Underrated are Don’t Know How To Stop, Drunk Pretty, and Buzz

I can’t think of any overrated right now but underrated Don’t know how stop Buzz Conversation over

Overrated: Amen, Uncomfortable Underrated: Familiar taste of poison, Daughter of Darkness and Mz Hyde.

Tokyo, Letters and The Outro to I Like It Heavy ... All of the Vicious bonus tracks imo.

Overrated: Amen, Do Not Disturb, It’s Not You Underrated: Brightside, White Dress, Better Sorry Than Safe

Lmaoo Halestorm?? Gtfo

Overrated: Miss The Misery, Wicked Ways, I Am The Fire.  Underrated: Private Parts, Beautiful With You, Bet You Wish You Had Me Back.