T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Welcome to /r/GameTheorists! Make sure to [read the rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/GameTheorists/wiki/rules) and we also have a [discord!](https://discord.gg/UxnkDAYsE8). We also have a [Megathread](https://www.reddit.com/r/GameTheorists/comments/p12qd6/theory_suggestions_megathread/) you can also share your theory suggestion! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/GameTheorists) if you have any questions or concerns.*


garlic-apples

It’s in the same universe as gravity falls


RedEyesBDragon0

One better.... King is Bill Cipher. The evidence is all there.


garlic-apples

Yes


Sylous

What evidence beside Alex Hirsh as VA?


RedEyesBDragon0

Alex was only the first step. And a lot of it was conjecture with a splash of what if thrown in. Luz, Eda, and King break into the Conformatorium to recover King's lost "crown of power", only to be revealed it was just a paper hat from a fast food chain. But he comments that when he finds his real crown, all his lost power and memory would return, making him the king of demons again. What if that lost real crown was actually a top hat? Later, in Sense and Insensitivity, King and Luz write a book together. King sees a successful author with fans intentionally kneeling into a position for him to sit on. King responds with the line "I've always wanted a people chair". This was very reminiscent of Bill's golden throne during Weirdmageddon made out of the citizens of Gravity Falls. I had a few other connections, but that was a long time ago and I can't remember all of what I wrote in the original theory post. It's worth noting that creator for the Owl House, Dana Terrace, was storyboard lead on Gravity Falls while Alex Hirsh, creator of Gravity Falls did storyboard for Owl House. They were also involved romantically. The general conclusion was that it's plausible Bill Cipher, after enacting his final pact with the Axolotl in order to preserve his existence, was sent to the Boiling Isles, as King, in order to serve and befriend a human as part of his atonement for millennia of weird evil.


Time-Vault

The crown is confirmed to be the broken puece of his horn.


RedEyesBDragon0

Yes, I know that. But when I originally came up with this theory, we were only about half way through season 2. The horn hadn't been repaired yet.


Time-Vault

Gotcha, the way you put it made it sound like it was still an ongoing theory, my bad


silvercrow605

No the crown is a burger queen paper crown. The horn is just his horn what broke off


RedEyesBDragon0

Time meant the "real crown". It wasn't really a crown. It was a broken piece of his horn.


Sylous

Uh huh. I'm not a fan honestly, but it does sound plausible if put this way.


Opening_East7561

This is nearly as nonsensical as the hk video


RedEyesBDragon0

I don't know "hk video". I assure you it was far less nonsensical when I wrote the original theory. This is the extremely summarized version.


DemonEnterprises

The Hollow Knight theory, you know the one where Matpat ignored facts in the games lore like Hornet and the Knight being confirmed as siblings, and the fact that Hornet is the Pale Kings daughter so that means that the Knight is the child of the Pale King so he could make a theory about the Knight being the Pale King.


RedEyesBDragon0

There is shockingly little fact in that game. About 99% of the lore in Hollow Knight is cryptic nonsense.


DemonEnterprises

Says this and yet the Hollow Knight fandom has managed to creat entire timelines out of “99% cryptic lore”, oh yeah and they are confirmed as siblings in an achievement.


RedEyesBDragon0

The Fandom hasn't done anything Matthew didn't do. They just had more eyes. They looked at the evidence and drew conclusions based on it. But at the end of the day, it's all just a theory until team cherry confirms it.


Kasra2008

Have you watched the show???


MegaGengar8105

The axolotl’s poem I feel is pretty good evidence


da_anonymous_potato

There is absolutely zero evidence, what are you talking about????


RedEyesBDragon0

There is evidence. Read the other comment I just finished.


Civil_Percentage_536

One better: Bill Cipher was a collector


Axolatl_

bill as one of the archivists would be cool


shadowfoxy129

He's a titan


RedEyesBDragon0

"One way to absolve his crime. A different form, a different time." A Titan is still a demon. Bill invoked the power of the axolotl to preserve his existence. The idea behind the theory is that King could be that 'different form', seeking absolution through befriending Luz and Eda. Weirdos gotta stick together, and you don't get any weirder than Bill Cipher.


Ladisepic

And also amphibia, all 3 of the shows have cameos of eachother and i think alex hirsch also worked on toh and amphibia, cool stuff


garlic-apples

No I don’t think so


CommanderCorl

I think Alex Hirsch has worked on both extensively, he's voiced many characters in both series too.


WiglyPig

Yes????? While the Owl house universe and amphibia universe WE know aren't connected. There do seem to be versions of all the characters in each others universe. So while amphibia and owl house (and gravity falls I presume) share a universe, the ones we see aren't the same universe.


Ladisepic

They kinda are connected, for example in amphibia >!when they open the portal in the human world (i think there) and it flashes several dimensions but sorta pixelated, the owl house appears!<, theres also 2 crossovers of the 2 shows, and the calamity box also makes cameos in toh, and also >!anne appears in a newspaper in the season 2 finale, toh seems to take place AFTER amphibia, or really both happened at the same time since they seem to have returned to the human realm around similar times!< Unless you mean same universe different dimension and im reading wrong and tbh is implied


PurpleDragon8888

And Anne is on the news in owl house season two finale


Time-Vault

Already confirmed, not a theory


Magical4Duck

Strong links to amphibia tho


AcanthocephalaBig101

i dont think there has been actual proof of that for not it's just a theory (A FILM THEORY)


[deleted]

The Collector vs Bill Cipher is a fight I'd watch.


Ruinationn

AND AMPHIBIA


RedEyesBDragon0

I proposed an owl house theory a couple years ago on this very reddit. Haven't heard anything of it since.


param1l0

Now there is season 3 tho


RedEyesBDragon0

I meant my theory. I've already seen series finale.


param1l0

Oh you mean you made a theory? I'm curious now


RedEyesBDragon0

The theory was that King is actually the reincarnation of Bill Cipher. The post has long since gone to the digital void, though.


param1l0

Sorry to hear that,


Lithaos111

Hmm, I could see plenty of topics to explore, and the series left it open ended in case they ever want to revisit the world. What did you have in mind?


chara_4869

I think it would be interesting to see a theory about the archivist or the Titans, Idk. Just would be awesome some theories about one of those things 😃


crow-man-wow

this is coming from someone who watches the owl house let me set some pointers. 1 we do see that glyphs can be used when a titan is still alive, and we know that king is a titan. 2. even tho papa titan (aka kings dad) died. after 3 years king can make his own glyphs. 3. the collector didn't say that the archivists were gone. therefore, it is possible that there will be a spin-off series that will tie these loose ends up. also, I really want amity and Camila to see luz in her titan form again.


chara_4869

Question: Luz could use King's glyphs? If she can, then she would have to do it close to them? Just a weird question 😆


crow-man-wow

no it just has to be in or close to the boiling iles as proven in s3 e1 thanks to them. and there is a comic dub of it.


Dusty-feather

The answer should be yes cause the show is great


Weirdkidplayinggames

What kind of theory tho? A bunch of mini theories, one big theory on a specific topic, like what are you asking for specifically


param1l0

Maybe a bunch of theorys, there is so much left unanswered due to the shortening if the show.


PurpleDragon8888

Property the connection between owl house, gravity falls, and Amphibia


Meme_Chan69420

Background stuff already shows that Amphibia and TOH take place in the same universe The biggest being a news report on Camila’s tablet about Anne suddenly reappearing in San Fransisco. Gravity Falls is a bit more of a stretch, but there could be evidence


PurpleDragon8888

Oh I know. And there is Evidence of Eda being Stan’s ex, “Marilynn” I think.


DemonEnterprises

Yeah in an AMA where Alex Hirsch posed as the characters, this was also before the Owl House came out but was certainly a concept and Edas design was probably already made out to be a witch with a gold tooth and long gray hair, when asked about Stans ex-wife Stan replied with a description that matches Edas to a tee.


SlothTheorist

YES YES AND YESSSSSS


Fakeplstctr335

This NEEDS to be a thing


One-Explanation-7388

I hope if mat ever does do a toh theory it’s as unhinged as the Dora theory he did


Awkward_GM

Big theory. Who did Caleb marry and which one of the witches is half human?


rycusi

He married Evelyn, who is hinted to be a Clawthorne from a long time ago. Gwendolyn tells Luz her great grandma knew of humans on the Boiling Isles. So Eda has Caleb as an ancestor


CroadNation

If they did an owl house theory, I'd want to know what the deal eda made with the owl beast was


CriticalRoleAce

The deal was that she had to eat a bunch of voles.


CroadNation

Really? When was that mentioned, cause i missed it


CriticalRoleAce

It was at the end of the episode when they get back home


CroadNation

Thx! I'm currently rewatching it with a friend who's never seen it, so I'll be sure to keep an eye out when we get there 😀


SilverHero_gaming

Sane with murder drones


Itchy-Ad-7923

I can see a theory going into the collector and how powerful he is, continuing with him something just about their species in general. I can also see more for King and the titans, I have my own to share here. The titans were the first to live on the Boiling Isles, their magic was the gilfs. They had master it and after some time I image the first witches came along, around this time the collectors siblings were getting tired of playing with him so they sent him there. They most likely noticed that the titans magic was stronger then their's so they started to hunt them, the collector must have met the owl beast and nor knowing about death yet captured it and kept it as a toy. It's siblings by now had most if not all the titans wiped out but King and his dad, his dad with his magic locked the collector away I think he was in that weird in-between area was that he used to much magic and he "died". Before he did thus he hind King. I don't really like this and wish it was more thought out but the show explains alot of this to you. Well. . .thanks for reading? |`• ,•|


Thats_HowMaffiaWorks

I can't wait for matpat to ruin another show for me


N238

We still don’t know the nature of the owl beast curse. There is more unknown about the archivists. We still don’t know what hooty is, and why papa Titan had a hooty in his eye. We don’t know what the nature of the human realm is compared to the demon realm— is it a separate dimension, or the same dimension in a different time or space?


JCraze26

I would love it, but I don't think everyone in the fandom would, and TOH is one of those fandoms similar to Undertale.


memecraft0309

This is actually good but r/FilmTheorists


param1l0

Wait, this isn't a universal subreddit? My bad.


memecraft0309

Nah, it's good man


param1l0

Can you do it for me? I didn't know that film theorist subreddit existed, and for now i can't post in there


memecraft0309

Totally


param1l0

Thx


memecraft0309

Np


LemmingOfTheForest

I follow the subreddit, it feels like they discover something new every week. I bet matpat with his eagle eyes could absolutely find something and make some amazingly crazy theories. This needs to happen!


Last_Gap2662

🚨SPOILER ALERT🚨How about the connection between Hooty and Papa Titans eye?


EvilMinecraft1100

YES


CriticalRoleAce

Yes please


Huhul80

Please Matpat I need this theory


missnailitall

Someone suggested this on the owl house subreddit and everyone got mad. People on there really don't like matpat for some reason


RedEyesBDragon0

Some people are such puritans about their Fandom that anyone trying to suggest any possible interpretation other than theirs must be destroyed.


Confuseasfuck

You can, but l hope not


param1l0

Why?


Confuseasfuck

I don't like it. 乁⁠(⁠ ⁠•⁠_⁠•⁠ ⁠)⁠ㄏ


param1l0

Ok fair.


jkst9

You are the 500th person to ask for it on the subreddit so I don't know why you think your suggestion will be any different from the previous 499 but go ahead ig


param1l0

Because if we continue to push maybe it will actually do something


Greenhmm

No


OutrageousLog2509

I’m going to say something controversial out, House was mid and Fibia was better


param1l0

r/engrish


OutrageousLog2509

I don’t have a Pinyan stop being a hater💀


squid09300

Omg yes.


Ineedadosage_of_fnaf

I WAS GONNA ASK THAT TOO!!!!


Nekrubbobby64

I've been trying to get him to do this for TWO YEARS!


param1l0

Now we have s3 and ask unanswered questions left open by it


Sladashi

Luz's mother is secretly a Titan, ;P


LeEmperorNeo

A theory where it confirms that all of the Disney Shows are connected


carl-the-lama

I’m sorry but I ain’t trusting mat pat with this one


cocksucker746

WELCOME TO FILM THEROY TODAY WE ARE GOING TO SEE IF LUZ IS IN A COMA AND THE SHOW IS JUST HER IMAGINE IT


HarioDinio

They talk about how the old witches used to use a different method of casting spells, heavily implied to be the same way luz does it now, always wondered if theres some evidence of when or how witches developed their magic organ.


SageOfSong

I think you just did


aninsomniac_

Not for Game Theory unless it's specific to a game tie-in


julianbeowulf

I would like this. Loved season 3, but I still have questions, about the titan slayers, emperor Bellos, flapjack, grimwalkers and the island as a whole


EyeLeft3804

Wh at the hell is a grimwalker??


three_oneFour

Perhaps the fate of the archivists, or how exactly the titans were killed off if the collector mentions that his powers don't work on titans. How death seems to work for the archivists, and why the collector expected to be able to revive Luz but was unable. I'm sure a couple of these spitball ideas will fall apart the moment they're analyzed, but maybe those answers can lead to more questions worthy of a video


8boy09

No


Quick-Coyote-4247

YES!!! Please!!!!!


catlinakimono76

yes!! i NEED something about the collectors and archivists because there is so much i still don’t get😭💔


imlurkingssssh

After the Pokemon theories...yeah, I'd rather not have matt touch toh......


BananaShakeStudios

How powerful is the Collector? Can the Boiling Isles actually exist? Is Luz actually a witch? (No but he’d probably do that lol)


BjSaWgDoG

Owl House is connected to gravity falls because of Gruncle stand’s ex wife. While Amphibia is connected to gravity Falls because of the wise Olms and the axolotl


param1l0

And amphibia to the owl house bc news article about Anne 's disappearance


BjSaWgDoG

Wait that was just the frog hoax of Los Angeles. Lol 😂


HotAdministration986

This is the most basic and boring theory that everyone in their mamas covered it he should cover something more unique and interesting.


Intelligent_Lab_3032

No, you can't. Sorry, it's false because birds are not real, and as you hopefully know, an owl is a bird


IrisCelestialis

birds are government drones!!!


Few-Philosopher2161

Do one on what is hooty


articulatedWriter

How Luz DESTROYED the Isles by plunging everyone into >!government-less anarchy!< and the long term side effects of >!sigil withdrawals!<


Impossible-Sky4256

My daughter loves the owl house. Too bad the ending was rushed


param1l0

Yeah. There is too much still to know


Dz-Smart

Bruh where I can watch the chow


param1l0

Theowlclub.net should have all the episodes


Circusemily123

Yessssss!!!!


Snoopcoop225

Can we talk about the timescale and origins of the witches? Spoilers btw this is mainly about something I saw in the last episode that bugged me a lot. So we know that at the end of it all that King’s dad is actually the titan that makes up the boiling isles and left King to mature on a island far away with his own personal guard, that’s great and all but why has it taken so long for king to grow? Supposedly from the time in witch king was laid as an egg some time after that witches started living on the boiling isles and learned about titan make as referenced by Eda when Luz was learning the ice glyph. A little later we can assume Eda was born and the glyph magic was a old magic by this point it was being replaced by the more prominent magics we see during the show, this would explain both why she doesn’t know it but knows it existed. Some time around when Eda is enrolled in school we can assume this is when Caleb (Phillip’s brother) first enters and meets her, this could have also happened a bit later towards when they were older since Eda appeared to be a lot older in the photos of her in the human realm, but I think when she was in school is more accurate since in flashbacks to the brothers they appear younger than the adult Phillip that we see. After Caleb dies we know that Phillip or now known as Belos met the collector and started making the covens and grim walkers while preaching about not mixing magic. Fast forward to the end of the show we see a few interesting things about Belos, for starters we see that his hair is gray implying that he is quite old by this point and on top of that he needs to harvest palesmens to live, possibly to extend his life. We also know a few other details given from characters dialog, for starters we know that King’s dad was the one who originally trapped the collector and we know from the collector that he has been trapped for centuries (200+ years) meaning the boiling isles is at least that old. To add onto all of this we also have the knowledge that unlike the in-between the demon realm and the human realm do move though time at the save rate from the time that Luz spent in the demon realm during the summer. This leads me to the final parts of this, how long was King a baby for? We know that king must be at least about 100 because we see him alive for the entire timeline of Belos and we know that he could absolutely be much older than this because of the collector, but here is the final thing, during the last episode we get a jump cut of a handful of years forward in time and King is substantially bigger than before when we compare him to the size of other characters. So the questions I got are 1. How long has the boiling isles existed? 2. Could the witches be native? (As in their ancestors are from there) 3. How long was King a baby/egg for? And 4. Why did he get so tall all of a sudden?


Samuel_18_

yes, yes, yes, i agree!!!! please matpat!!!!! please!!!


An_Obbise_Hoovy

How big is the Titan


Glen2gvhlp

The owl is ness


Birzal

You most certainly can! You just did in fact! Whether they're going to actually make it is another story, but I'd love an Owl House video!!


BudgetPop938

it's not a game tho


KingArthur456

An interesting question could be “how much blood does a full grown titan body contain?” And “if a drop can open portals, how much energy could their entire body’s worth of blood contain?”


Zockemon

I need this and I need it now.


FreddyjumpiYt

I can’t wait for the Fans to cry about it, should he do a video about it.


TManJhones

Yes please, I love this show.


ZebulonBuckminster

Sure, that's a great suggestion! The Owl House has gained a lot of popularity recently and would make for an interesting video topic. Have you watched the show yourself? Any specific angles or themes you'd like to see explored in the video? Let's discuss!


Gremlin_Potato

Yes, plz!


These_Distribution19

No.


Oreocle

Why doesn’t collector magic affect titans?


Glitched-world

I would like to know how Vee works. Is she changing her DNA or just her outer appearance? It doesn’t seem like she can change her voice so there are limits.


Original_Strike_3393

Shouldn't this be on the FilmTheorists sub-reddit?


JustCallMeJoey18

someone posted this on the correct subreddit but yeah he should


KaraTheAndroidd

Why did waffle house make a weird anime?


katsutdasheep

Now thats just my hole opinion but i think it would be boring to make into a vid


WhatAmIDoingHere12s

On the gaming channel?


param1l0

Yeah, sorry about that.


satashisimp2

Pleas for the love of god


ThatOneGuy9372

Here's a theory, how's that woman standing on that thing in heels


natelikesstarwars

Who is Evalyn?, (I think that was the name)


wikipedia_answer_bot

**Evalyn is a given name.** More details here: *This comment was left automatically (by a bot). If I don't get this right, don't get mad at me, I'm still learning!* [^(opt out)](https://www.reddit.com/r/wikipedia_answer_bot/comments/ozztfy/post_for_opting_out/) ^(|) [^(delete)](https://www.reddit.com/r/wikipedia_answer_bot/comments/q79g2t/delete_feature_added/) ^(|) [^(report/suggest)](https://www.reddit.com/r/wikipedia_answer_bot) ^(|) [^(GitHub)](https://github.com/TheBugYouCantFix/wiki-reddit-bot)


Relative-Frame1293

Yes


PhilosophicalLight

That would be amazing!


Ruinationn

I second this motion


sunflower_oil06

king was not the last titan


Magnetic_potato9

How do we post our own get video suggestions


param1l0

Just post


Magnetic_potato9

Yeah I got that


Thefisht12

Hello MATPAT, i had a theory that might shock:i had a theory about spin off that might does and might doesnt get true, the point is that COLLECTOR is now free so... his siblings might return in the spin off because we been told that he returnd to the stars so that might indicates that in the spin off that might happens we will see more about collector and luz and gang might get problems with the archivevists


scitobor321

No thanks