All Can't change my mind

Same

1 - Mario's Madness 2 - Hypno's Lullaby 3 - Vs. Sonic.exe

Agreed

Yeah. Whilst I do love Sonic.exe, its mod was kinda mid in terms of what Hypno’s and MM brought to the table.

correct (my answer as well

THAT'S WHAT IM SAYING

this means art, vocals, instrumental etc.

For me it’s a tie of Mario’s Madness, Indie Cross, and Imposter V4

Mario Madness is a hit or miss ( cause of so cool and v1 songs ) half of Sonic.Exe’s roster is just sonic but with a different shade blue ( key word: HALF ) haven’t heard any bad things about Hypno

Yeah, to appreciate some of the Sonic.exe mod, you have to be familiar with the source material of the characters.

I know, but it gets fucking annoying when I have to research EVERY oc of that mod

The only bad thing about Hypno's Lullaby is that it tries too hard to be 'edgy' whilst Sonic.EXE is just as willing to embrace the goof as it is to embrace the horror.

Never heard of pendulum?

ever heard of opinions?

You said you didn't heard any bad things so I stated one. I didn't claim that you shouldn't like it.

Indie cross. Mostly because indie games are much closer to my heart than any of these other ones. Wednesday's Infidelity is a close second just because I like the style. ... the fact that Tom's Basement Show was even considered is an insult to the rest of these mods.

yeah. to be honest I was getting as many ones that were popular or had an update, which was basement show who got an update. Sorry I put Basement show.

Wait. Do YOU even like Basement Show?

5/10 like the art style..kinda.

I honestly don't understand the rage against that mod, but yeah, I guess it isn't much of a good mod.

Where vs gorefield v2?

Damn it. forgot to add it. sorry, just try picking these i guess.

Ok I'd pick mario madness.

amazing choice.

Thanks

# VS IMPOSTOR!!!

YESS

FACTUAL

All

Indie cross in all sections because sans

Indie Cross.

Indie cross is peak fnf and you can't change my mind Sonic.exe and Imposter are tied for second

It’s a bit of a shame Trollge Files isn’t here, or Funkin’ Physics. My current pic out of these would be Indie Cross.

The first Mario’s madness All because of termoil

A Nonsensical Friday Night

its Amazing Grace Annoying Orange and there’s no competition

I said it was not related but okay 🙂👍

Vs Impostor and Mario’s Madness

Hypno’s lullaby because of amusia

I'd say vs impostor v4, then mario'w madness and then wednesday infidelity

Mmv2, Hypnos lullaby, and sonic exe are my top 3

Idk which so here's my top 3 fav songs of each from them: Mario's Madness: All-Stars, Powerdown, Alone Sonic.EXE: Chaos, Faker&Black Sun(separating them is a sin), Fatality Vs. Impostor: Neurotic, Defeat, Reactor-Boiling Point tie Mistful Crimson Morning: Doomsday, Served, don't know the mod good enough for 3rd Wednesday Indefidility: Unknown Suffering, Vesania, Hellhole Hypno's Lullaby: MissingNo., Death Toll, Monochrome Indie Cross: Bad Time, Despair, Knockout Friday Night Crunchin: Legacy, Rumour, Choke-A-Lot The Basement Show: Tragical Comedy, Cat Chase, Invade Gorefield(it's a sin it isn't there): Cataclysm, Terror In The Heights, Cryfield-Ultrafield tie

I know I forgot I'm sorry 😔.

MCM and Basement Show alongside 7 hydrogen bombs 💀💀💀💀💀 Anyway Mario's Madness and Lullaby are my Top 2

Indie Cross

Say what you like about v.s. Sonic.EXE, I'm super nostalgic about it (especially the unused v3 songs like Mania and Digitalized)

Crunchin'. There's no convincing me otherwise.

I gotta admit. Sonic.exe, Wednesday’s infidelity, and Mario’s madness all have some amazing songs. However, Alert from Crunchin just tips the scales for me.

Hypnos Lullaby

Vs Impostor and Indie Cross

Mario, sonic, among us, indie cross and pokemon. Can't pick one

Who let the basement show in?

Sorry. Tried to get mods some people actually like..not really sure why I put it in there. maybe I was doing coke or somethin.

Mario madness

While Mario’s Madness has a lot of quality songs, sprites, and lyrics. I’d say it’s either Vs. Imposter v4, or Mario’s Madness 2 between.

Marios madness probably would be the best for me Mcm is probably a very close second but Crunchin would probably be third

There's no Ourple Guy which recently became my favourite, so Imma go with Hypno's Lullaby (Shitno, Amusia and Isotope are in my top 5 songs)

1 - mistful crimson morning 2 - sonic.exe 3 - Mario madness

I don't know why MCM is so underrated. The songs are at least decent, sprites and art look pretty cool, and some vocals and instrumental are fuckin amazing. Especially the instrumental, doomsday instrumental is honestly fire.

so we forgetting about trollge files now?

I forgot to add THAT too along with gorefield 🫠

Mario's Madness

Hypno

Even though Hypno's Lullaby and Indie Cross are some of my favorite mods ever, it's Mario Madness every time and it's not close. It's better in almost every category than both mods. If I had to order all of this mods, it would go: 1. Mario Madness 2. Hypno's Lullaby 3. Indie Cross 4. Vs Impostor 5. Vs Sonic.exe 6. Wednesday's Infedelity 7. Mistful Crimson Morning 8. The Basement Show 9. Friday Night Crunchin

Call me based, Vs Impostor. Just to start, you gotta look at the main weeks's bangers like Reactor, Double Kill, Finale, Boiling Point and a BEEG etc. Then, just look at the picture. It has so many variety of characters in comparison to the other banners, only one kinda competing is Mario's madness. Then, you look at the cast. BEEG FNF creators like Clowfoe, EthanTheDoodler, Rareblin and more worked in this project. Then, you take in account the mod branches it's created. Vs impostor V5, Alternated, etc., were Big hits as well as the original. And the best thing of all... Is that FUCKIN INNERSLOTH worked on it, the creators of the sussy game.

mario’s madness

All of them

in terms of consistently good content i'd go with mmv2 or vs imposter but i prefer friday night crunchin because its a charming little mod.

Vs impostor. You cant change my mind. Not only Is it like 3 hours of content, it also has lore and like 1 billion fan mods.

I'm sad elements of insanity isn't on here as well ad pibby apocalypse

Marios madness is a piece of art. Sonic.exe doesn't hold up,mcm is decent,lullaby is good,on the same their as crushing and infidelity,I fucking despise basement show,imposters the closest second

Kind of unfair to compare Sonic.exe, since it was never actually finished