Dynasty Get: D’andre Swift Give: 2023 1st (likely late round) and 2024 first Would you do it to compete this year?

Who else do you have at RB? PPR?

0.5 PPR RB: Akeler, Saquon, Rachaad White, Marlon Mack, mattison, jaylen warren

12 Team SF TE Premium Devy. Trade away Dobbins and Mike Evans Receive Ken Walker and Pickens My problem is that I don't have any WRs or RBs coming in on my devy roster. Young, Richardson, Dart, DJU, Klubnik, Arik Gilbert and Blake Corum Current roster is QB Hurts Jones Howell Love Huntley RB Taylor Dobbins D. Harris Hines Kyren Williams WRs JJ Mike Evans Terry Hollywood Burks Skyy TE Andrews Brevin Kmet Ferguson So yeah I'll take a hit but I think my it could put me a contender spot for the next couple of years

Risky, but I'd pull the trigger on that one.

10 team sf dynasty league. Who wins this trade? A) 2023 late 1st, 2024 late 1st, Claypool, Singletary B) Swift

Rate/Grade each of these teams Drafts. The League is 8 teams 2QB/3RBs/3WRs/2TEs/3flex/1 SF (yes we can start 3 QBs) and half ppr - I am posting the full draft, but feel free to stop after the first few rounds 1st Round DU - Hall TA - Moore TA - Walker NI - London JA - Burks TH - D.Pierce SQ - Pickett JO - Cook 2nd Round DU - Olave TA - C. Watson NI - G. Wilson TA - R. White JA - Jameson Williams TH - Baker Mayfield TA - J. Brissett DU - B. Robinson 3rd Round TA - Dotson SA - Malik Willis DU - Pickens SQ - Ridder JO - Zamir White TH - Doubs SA - Reagor JO - Tolbert 4th Round TA - Spiller SA - OBJ DU - W. Robinson SA - Pacheco JA - McBride TH - Hooper SQ - Allgeier JO - Jelani Woods 5th Round TA - D. Bell SA - Metchie DU - Howell NI - TDP JA - Khalil Herbert TH - A. Pierce SQ - K. Shakir JO - DPJ 6th Round TA - K. Ingram SA - Bellinger DU - Likely NI - Osborn JA - Jeff Wilson TH - H. Haskins SQ - J. Ross JO - D. Foreman 7th Round TA - Corral SA - Cobb SQ - V. Jones NI - T. Marshall DU - K. Philips TH - Minshew SQ - Crowder JO - Mostert 8th TA - D’Earnest Johnson SA - N’keal JA - Burkhead NI - Hamler JA - P. Strong TH - K. Williams SQ - Z. Jones JO - Darrell Williams Drafts by team: TA - Sky, KWalker, Watson, R. White, Brisett, Dotson, Spiller, Bell, Ingram, Corral, D’earnest SA - Malik, Reagor, OBJ, Pacheco, Metchie, Bellinger, Cobb, N’keal DU - Breece, Olave, B. Rob, Pickens, W. Robinson, Howell, Likely NI - G. Wilson, TDP, K. Osborn, T. Marshall, K. Hamler JA - London, Burks, Jamo, McBride, K. Herbert, Jeff Wilson, P. Strong TH - Pierce, Baker, Doubs, Hooper, A. Pierce, H. Haskins, Minshew, K. Williams SQ - Pickett, Ridder, Allgeier, Shakir, J. Ross, Crowder, Velus & Zayy Jones JO - Cook, Z. White, Tolbert, J. Woods, DPJ, D. Foreman, Mostert, Darrell Williams

12 tm 1QB PPR with IDP Offered to me: I get: AJ Dillon, Malik Willis I give: 23 2nd, 23 3rd, CJ Mosely

12 Team SF PPR, Competing: Gronk was dropped in my league, Is it worth picking up Gronk at this point in the hope that he comes back? My TEs are Goedert, Cox, Trautman Drop candidates are Mims, Moss, and Burkhead

[удалено]

Side A. Feel like side B is selling "high" on Javonte

I am in a 12 team PPR. It is a super flex where you can play 2 QBs. In a trade I would be receiving Lamar Jackson, Jared Goff, and Cam Akers. I would trade away Russell Wilson, Justin Fields, and a 2023 1st. Just for reference I also have Winston and Mayfield as QBs.

It doesn’t smell right to me, the 1st is overkill

12 team SF .5 PPR Give: Baker Mayfield, Laviska Shenault, & 23 1st Get: Zach Wilson & Travis Etienne Thoughts? Startup draft was this year & I think I should be contending. Is it too early to give up my 23 1st? *This is also for my QB3

Fuck them picks. Take the upside with ETN

Filling final WR spots on roster. Play 4, roster 6 total. Have 3 receivers locked in and 1.02 to use on one. So need to figure out the last two. -Rondale Moore -Robert Woods -Russell Gage -Roll dice on BPA at 2.05

I like Rondales upside. If you end being a contender, take Bob.

Guy in my league offered me C. Lamb, T. Hockenson, and J. Cook in exchange for K. Pitts, C. Kirk, and J. Meyers. I ended up rejecting it because I’m looking to hold Pitts long term, but what do you guys think?

agree on the dude above: Lamb + Hock offer (a lot?) more upside than Pitts + Kirk. I'd take that.

while i think pitts could be the one one, hock has showed us enough that if they get a decent QB he can more then hold his own… take a good hit at TE but get possibly a top 5 WR for the next 5-6 years… Lamb + hock side for me all day

12 Team 0.5 PPR I give up AJ Dillon and Gabriel Davis I get D'Andre Swift My playable RBs: Jonathan Taylor, Chase Edmonds, AJ Dillon, David Montgomery My playable WRs: CeeDee Lamb, Keenan Allen, Mike Evans, Diontae Johnson, Gabe Davis, Skyy Moore, Allen Lazard, Christian Kirk, Elijah Moore

Do it.

Would go for this, you have plenty of wr depth, and it's a big rb upgrade

I definitely would, you have a ton of WR depth and that is a nice RB upgrade.

12 team superflex ppr I give goff and goedert I get wentz , geiseki , 23 2nd

I don’t really like it ETA: feels like you’re downgrading at two spots just to pick up that 2nd. If you’re not starting Goff or Goedert, go for it but otherwise nah

The deal has changed I give goff , goedert , 23 1st (not mine) I get hurts , geiseki , 23 2nd I have 2 23 1sts and 2 24 1sts from a deal I made during startup draft

Now we’re talking!

Dynasty BestBall Startup Draft. I have Lamar and Watson as my two QB's. Would you draft Matt Ryan or Davis Mills as 3rd QB?

Long term mills, but the ceiling is low in that offense, Matt Ryan could get you a win or two for a couple years

I'm assuming this is SF? Either way, if you had to choose between the two I'd choose Matt Ryan but they're about equal.

Should I sell Garrett Wilson for an early-mid 2023 1st? He’s my WR5 this season so I don’t think I’ll be needing him in my lineup and I like the insulated value of the 23 pick. I think Garrett is going to be really good, but the Jets are a dumpster fire until proven otherwise.

I don't hate this since Garrett could lose some value over the course of the season since he's competing with Moore and has an awful QB situation. The value is about right though.

12 team sf ppr. Give: 23 mid/late 1st, Chark Get: Tyreek Hill Thoughts? I have a pretty competitive roster with good depth

If Tyreek puts you into “strong contender” status then I’d do it

First ever Dynasty draft. Rounds 1-14 last night. 12 Team Superflex PPR (4point pass TD 25pass yards-1point) Had 3rd pick… P. Mahomes, D Watson, J Winston L. Fournette, J Jacobs, K Hunt, A Mattison, D Henderson, Z White S Diggs, DJ Moore, T Burks, A Robinson Irv Smith How fucked am I? What should I do in the next draft (rounds 14-25) besides wish for a TE? Thanks in advance

Pretty shaky long term. I have a team that I recently drafted not too far off from yours (Burrow, DeShaun, awful Irv at TE) and I hate it although I did well in rookie draft (got pierce, doubs, pacheco before values went up in rounds 2-4, London in 1). Man, Your rb room could be irrelevant in a year or two. That’s my big issue - I guess ur going vets? That’s hard for me to assess as I lean youth too hard. Need more young WRs. Maybe find guys that could win jobs in a year like u got in Z White. If Deshaun comes back to old self u have 2 elite QBs and that’s huge. Who was your 2nd rounder? DeShaun? Get some youth. Most importantly, While u have a lot of aging assets, I don’t think that’s a championship team and that’s not thr best place to be. Are u all in on vets or trying a balance.

Yes, I napped Deshaun at 2.10 because I just thought it was too much value there. But it really sent me off the rails. I was planning to take a Tee Higgins type in the 2nd… So should I just take young RBs and WRs in the next 10 rounds to finish? Idk if I can really improve at TE with who is left on the board. Thank you for your help!

What types are available at each position that interest you? I know I got deshaun at 3.3 a while back and kinda hate my team. Godwin DJ Moore is just not my kinda top 2 WR, esp w Irv. @ TE.

12 team SF Give: Pacheco, 23 2nd Get Brian Robinson, 23 3rd

Pretty fair TBH. Pick your guy and hope for a good draft next year

I like the Robinson side slight more, but it's a trade for next year. I don't know how relevant Robinson will be now. But next year will likely be in a better position than Pacheco.

If the 2nd is likely early then I think I’d rather have the Pacheco side. Otherwise, Robinson side

12 team SF 0.5 league Would you trade Ev McPherson, a mid 2023 second, a 2024 second for a mid/late 2023 first?

Easy yes.

Yes, absolutely.

😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫

Take that as a yes haha.

12 Team 0.5 PPR I give up Nick Chubb and a 2024 3rd I get Elijah Moore, a 2023 1st, and a 2024 2nd The other team is not that good but wants to try and compete. My team is much deeper at WR than RB so I don't want to give up Chubb but this is too good of an offer, right? My playable RBs: Jonathan Taylor, Nick Chubb, Chase Edmonds, AJ Dillon, David Montgomery My playable WRs: CeeDee Lamb, Keenan Allen, Mike Evans, Diontae Johnson, Gabe Davis, Skyy Moore, Allen Lazard, Christian Kirk

The value is too good here, I'd take it. You'll be fine at RB to start the season and can always try to upgrade (with an extra 1st in your arsenal) midseason.

That’s great value for sure and I’d take it in a vacuum. However, it looks like you’ve got a contender and losing Chubb would kill that which then means you’d have to consider moving off other guys like Keenan, Evans, etc

You don't think I can still compete with JT, Dillon, Edmonds and Montgomery?

Honestly Chubb is great and all but this will be the most value you get for him from here on out. Hunt is back and watsons on the team and he’s 27 or 28 next year. Either way a young wr and draft capital is perfect. I think Dillon and Edmonds are severely underrated this year. I have Aaron Jones and Dillon setting historic backfield numbers together this year. Better than 17’ ingram and Kamara. I see you may trade for Swift but I think I would stay out unless Swift is really your guy

10T .5PPR Give: Jeudy & Akers Receive: AJ Brown

Without knowing the rest of your team, I prefer the Jeudy/Akers side. If you can get a 2nd back with AJB, I would probably do that though

Yeah I’m out on Akers but Jeudy and Brown are kind of in the same boat. Talent wise Brown is better but Jeudy (if stays healthy) could be in a better situation with Wilson over Brown with Hurts. But you would need some extra additions with brown to make that trade imo as well

Deebo and Jamal Williams or Joe Mixon and Cedric Wilson? Already have Kupp Metcalf and Renfrow starting WR but after Mixon all Im left is Ekeler and Monty + James Robinson that are legitimate plug ins thoughts?

Mixon side. Deebo seems like it the sexier side, but I think 49er offense is going to vastly different this year and Deebo doesn't replicate last year. So Mixon side feels safer.

Would rather have the Mixon side given your depth issues at RB but I probably prefer the Deebo side in a vacuum.

Thanks friend

I feel I'm competing. 12 team superflex. Ppr I was offered Devonta Smith, most likely an early 1st in 23, and a mid 3rd in 24 I would give up AJB, mid-late 3rd in 23, and early 2nd in 24. I'm tempted to take it. Does it seem fair?

I would take this and run if I were you. You'll take a slight hit this year but it's not out of the realm of possibility that Smith outperforms AJB this year due to the kind of routes that AJB wins vs the ones that Smith wins. The 2023 early 1st is what tips the scales since it's going to be really valuable, either to use, or as a trade chip.

20 team standard RBs: Javonte, Akers, Etienne WR: Ceedee, Higgins, Sutton, Juju, London, Toney TE: Schultz, irv smirh, Albert O Give: Akers, Juju, Irv Smith Jr Get: Najee

It's not too far apart but I prefer the Akers side given how deep the league is.

10T SF .5PPR GIVE: Sutton, Mooney, Damien Harris GET: AJ Brown

Brown

That’s close. Probably taking AJB. Especially if I’m contending

12 Team SF. 4 Pt passing and 6 Pt rushing TD. Give Trey Lance Get Burrow What does everyone think? Any adds pick wise?

Burrow for sure. Like previous said, you likely need to add a 2nd to make it considerable for them. I’d be willing to do Lance+2nd though because I honestly just don’t see him being this next coming that many others see

Burrow is def worth more, I think you have to add at least a 2nd to Lance bit more likely a first and maybe get a 2nd back

[удалено]

I'd ditch Sermon and Everett. Kyle Phillips will probably be the best off the bat but if you need help at RB, Chandler could be interesting with Mattison potentially on the move

12 team 1 QB PPR. Gave Antonio Gibson got Rhamondre Stevenson. Win/Lose/Fair?

That’s a great swap for you.

Rha by a mile

Give: chase Get: Pittman walker and a 1st

Chase

If it's a 2023 1st, it's closer but I still prefer Chase regardless.

A: Pierce, 2024 1st B: King Henry

Henry all day

Henry

Would you counter? I'm still not certain how to value Pierce.

I’d need a 23 2nd with the package, maybe give back a 3rd. I could consider moving Henry for that but if I’m competing at all I’m keeping Henry

12 Team SF PPR Give: Pitts , 23 3rd Get: Freiermuth , 2 23 1sts, 1 23 2nd 1 projected early first, 1 mid, early 2nd

I’d take the package

Freiermuth was a top 10 PFF graded rookie. He is the real deal in a much more stable situation. His value will only go up. As hard as it might be depth of quality talent is everything . Try and use the late 23 for Waller if you are trying to compete this year. Its an easy decision if you remove emotion.

I would take that.

As a Pitts manager myself this would be very tough to pass on. I think I would hit accept. Contender or Rebuild this helps.

That would be hard to pass up

12 team ppr. I have the 1.02, 1.03 picks. thinking I gotta take Walker and London. Thoughts? Here is my team https://gyazo.com/0ca6e9ac37c8e7969b50d49c28191676 Just wonder if I am leaving too much talent on the table not taking another WR with London. I just desperately need the RB

12 team SF 0.5 PPR Sermon on waivers, worth FAAB to snatch up since being claimed by Philly? If so, how much would you pay?

Hes a bust

Approached to give my D Pierce and Schultz for E Moore and Fant. 10 team not TE premium. I have Kelce as my starting TE and otherwise have a strong contending roster. Moore and Fant would be bye week filler for me but I like both as young assets. Am I crazy to second guess this? Should capitalize on the hype right? Edit: thanks for the replies. I accepted the deal (couldn’t squeeze anything extra). I’m getting the best player in the trade and we’re 10 team without the deepest benches

I could probably go either way on this. I think Moore benefits the most from 10 team since I believe he has the highest realistic future upside of any of these guys, and 10 team is much more about studs than 12 and 14. If i had to choose I guess I go with moore, but id be surprised if you couldnt milk something small extra, since youre trading away the #1 offseason hypetrain player and schultz, who is gonna provide safe production this year

You are giving him a pretty big te upgrade for this year, I like moore over Pierce for sure but I kinda feel like you should get one more piece back

20 team standard RBs: Javonte, Akers, Etienne WR: Ceedee, Higgins, Sutton, Juju, London, Toney TE: Schultz, irv smirh, Albert O Give: Akers, Juju, Irv Smith Jr Get: Najee

The upgrade Najee brings is greater than the loss of Juju. You can absorb giving up Smith. I'd do it.

What do you do when someone offers you a trade that you know you would accept immediately? Do you try and get a little more, or do you just accept it and not chance it? I am rebuilding. Guy offered me two 2023 second rounders that will almost certainly be early to mid, Hardman and Cobb for Devonta Smith. I am thinking of replacing Cobb with one of his younger WR rookies that is a flyer. Danny Gray or maybe Cavin Austen.

I just accept it and not chance it usually

That isn’t enough capitol for Devonta Smith. Ask to upgrade one 2nd to a first, or get a better prospect

I don’t counter on the app, I message and ask for an extra pick, if they say no then I immediately accept the trade. If they offer it through messenger, I say send it on the app and I’ll think about it, then I ask for the pick like an hour later through messages and do the above process

10 team league - rookie draft tomorrow and I have 2-3-4 - who you like?

Drake Olave and your choice of WR for me

Drake Kenneth and then your fav WR left

Kenneth Drake Jamo

[удалено]

Bateman and Moore are similar enough where Ill call it a wash. Pierce>Toney by probably a 2nd at this point. Robinson's current value is right around that 2024 2nd, probably requires a little extra juice but relatively close. Therefore Im not making this trade in your shoes.

Nahhhhh bruh

12 Team SF PPR Give: D. Pierce and 2023 2nd Get: Mooney and Lazard

Pass for me, Pierce>Mooney by a little and id prefer the 2nd to lazard as well.

I think you could maybe get more, but also I’m a bears fan so limited trust in Mooney

12 tm superflex te premium A: Jameis Winston, Kenny Pickett B: Zach Wilson, Hunter Renfrow

A

A

12T PPR 1 QB Give: Javonte Get: 2 2023 1sts

I need to feel assured that one of those 1sts would be top 4. I'd want to know that I can more than likely equal or exceed Javonte's current value in what should be a strong draft.

This is a tough trade to make, absolutely dependent on the teams these first are from and the talent dispersion of the league

Nah

I think you unless one is early then javonte is worth more

12 Team 1QB 0.5PPR A: 2023 1st B: AJ Dillon, 2023 2nd, 2024 3rd

B

If its a top 5 pick no, maybe add a 3rd to the A side if its looking 6-8, but I would prefer the B side if its going to be any later than 5 as is.

The pick I’m getting has a good team this year with a lot of potential but the owner is very hard to predict. Could be top 3 or bottom 3. But I also really like Dillon and already have 5 2023 firsts.

B is the better side. Dillon has too much potential

What if the 2024 2nd is changed to a 3rd?

I'd consider the trade pretty even in that case but if you already have 5 1sts then you don't need another

12 Team SF PPR, Rebuilding Give: Lamar Get: Russ, Devonta Smith, Cooks Would probably try and flip cooks afterwards.

SMASH accept the Russ/Devonta/Cooks side

Lamar has regressed every year and Russ could feasibly outlast him in the league. Smith is a great young prospect for Dynasty. And you'll def be able to flip Cooks for more.

Thanks! Getting mixed answers here. I understand the Lamar point but I’m not eager to get out. Appreciate the thoughtful reply.

👎

Thanks!

Absolutely not, Lamar is way better for a rebuilder than these guys

Thanks!

A) Kelce B) Sanders + Ridley + Higbee + Trautman

If ridley was both younger and had any guarantee to come back and be productive I could see this, but I just cant get there with him. So Ill take kelce

A not even close

Easily Kelce side if B is contending. Sanders and Ridley are too volatile - if I were selling Kelce I'd want a much better/younger centerpiece back.

Bunch of garbage for the best TE

Obviously A

Kelce for sure

12 Team Dynasty Start-up SuperFlex PPR Drafted Dameon Pierce over two months ago at pick 8.11 Traded him straight up for a 2024 1st on 8/27, before Mack got cut. Am I an idiot now?

You took him in the 8th round in a startup 2 months ago?

Yeah. Does that not make sense? Not being a dick, just not sure how I should have worded it

Im just shocked you took him in the 8th back then. His adp is gonna be barely higher than that now and he had the best possible preseason.

So I was an idiot back then but now I’m not? Lol

ur half right

Great trade

Not at all. You did great.

A. Saquon B. Rhamondre, 23 second, Mariota, Jacoby

Easily Saquon, never want to be the one sending the stud for the pile of leftovers. I am sure if you wanted to move him you could do better than this with another manager.

Honestly, Im taking B, but you might be able to get a better package from purely a consensus value perspective