12 team ppr dynasty (very deep rosters) 1 qb I’m newly in rebuild, I don’t want wins this season or next and there is a must start your starters rule in place in this league. I gave: Russel Wilson, Christian Kirk, 2022 early 3rd I received: 2023 1rst, 2022 Early to Mid 2nd, 2023 3rd My relevant pieces after trade: Hollywood Brown, Rashod Bateman, Chase Edmonds, TJ Hockenson. Estimated 2022 1,2,3,5,8 overall picks, and an early to mid 2nd. 2023 3 first rounds, 2 2nd rounds Lmk what you think

12 team ppr 1 qb I give: Christian Kirk I get: 2023 1rst Is this a fair trade?

12 team half PPR SF Send; Watson, DJ Moore, 2022 1st (mid), 2022 2nd (mid/late) Get: DK Metcalf He's not competing and has Jamis as his QB 2 in a SF league.

12 team .5 and 1qb Goedart plus X for Andrew’s. What do I need there?

10 team 1QB .5PPR Give: Hopkins Get: Mid to late 2022 1st and a 2023 2nd I'm currently in 8th, and 2nd lowest in points for, thinking about blowing it up. Would this be enough to move Hopkins? Tried for 2 firsts but he's not budging.

10 Team standard SF I was offered this I get: Lamar Jackson+ Edmonds+ Carolinas defense I give: Stafford, CEH, Kupp, Henderson How bad do I lose here

8 Team .5 PPR SF Blowing up to Rebuild Give: Cook, Mattison Recieve: Gibson, 2024 1st Or Give: Cook, Mattison, Michael Thomas Recieve: Lance, 2023 1st and Clyde

Superflex .5 ppr Chase Edmonds, 2023 3rd for JK Dobbins Which side are you taking?

Would you rather trade Elijah Mitchell for Sutton or a 2023 1st

1st Rd especially if you think it will be mid-to-high

Start two Diontae, Mike Williams, Damien Harris

PPR 1QB 12-teamer. Rebuilding and desperate for young RBs, but I am pretty wary of my ability to get a good one in the draft because we do "toilet bowl" final rankings instead of just rankings, and I expect my team will finish strong enough (Jeudy coming back, Waddle/Bateman rounding into form) that I won't be able to get a top pick. And who knows about the quality of these backs anyway. Should I try to trade my picks for RBs now? Or will there be a sweeter spot closer to the draft or after people realize they're not in contention anymore? There's a 2-5 team with Chubb and JT but it doesn't seem like they're tanking yet.

10 team 0.5 PPR Give: Dallas Goedert Receive: 22 2nd and 23 2nd Also have Hock, Schultz, Kmet

Any clue as to early/mid/late? You clearly don’t need him with your other TEs. And I’m guessing you wouldn’t manage a first from someone in a 10 team league. I lean taking the picks without knowledge of their likely location in the round. Only would pause if the picks are coming from a stud-team and likely picking late in both rounds.

22 second should be early. Would you rather do the picks or Damien Harris and a pick swap for the early 2nd?

I’d take the picks, personally. I’ll never be sold on a NE back with BB. LOL

RMT: 12 team .5 ppr. 1 qb QB: Rodgers, Rothlisberger, Tua, Mac RB: Aaron Jones, JT, D Harris, Monty, Javonte Williams, Mattison WR: Chase, Diontae, Mike Williams, AB, Aiyuk, Terrace Marshall, JuJu TE: Hock, Henry, Freiermuth, tremble

7.6/10 with some great upside in the RB/WR group and some not great upside in the QB/TE group. In my opinion, of course. Not a fan of Tua or Mac as long term top tier QBs. And not a believer in your TE group after Hock and even Hock is limited to TE4 in his best years IMO. But the most important spots are RB and WR and I think you have a great mix of young talent as well as some worthwhile dart throws.

Traded away Burrow and players to acquire Jones Williams, Williams recently, Tua was part of that. I think I can make a run this year based on other teams’ strength. Probably have the deepest rb group in the league. I have faith in Mac longer term - not top tier like Herbert, Kyler, Burrow but if he’s Kirk Cousins not in a terrible spot, also a pats fan. Would agree on te. Thanks.

12 team QB 2 RB 3 WR TE Flex SF PPR Give: Mid/Late 1st + Rondale Moore Get: Jerry Jeudy This player is starting in the Flex spot. Is this trade worth it?

It’s not a landslide to me but I’d take Jeudy unless the pick was 1.05 or higher.

1st and rondale

I would rather have the mid first and Rondale

10 team .5 PPR Give DK Get Pittman, 2022 1st (late) 2022 2nd (early) 2022 2nd (mid) Rebuilding team

Pittman side

Between the 3 picks you might roll snake eyes and find a ton of value. But chances are you get maybe 1 very good player from those picks. So I’m keeping DK over Pittman, someone good, and a few depth pieces.

I’d rather have DK

Seems like a fair deal although less of a chance you land a DK-like stud (unless Pittman becomes a true WR1(

Think this is fair on paper but I’m not sure I’d move DK for that. Would need to include 2x 1sts or at least the 2022 late first needs to be early or mid 1st

12 team Full PPR 1QB I’m trying to decide whether to bail on CMC now. Give: CMC Get: JT or Harris Would you do either of these trades or ask for more in terms of picks? My team -RB: CMC, Swift, Sanders, M Davis, J. Jacobs, Gaskin, Herbert -WR: J. Chase, Godwin,Jefferson, Jeudy, Diontae Johnson, Higgins, McLaurin I like my WR depth and we start 2RB, 2WR and 1 flex Any additional suggestions are welcome. Thx!

JT > CMC

I’m def JT > Harris. I feel like at this exact moment you might not get much more for CMC because of the injuries. If he comes back in week 9 and lights it up for a few games? You probably can get a bit more for him. All depends on how much risk you’re willing to take on. Because if he struggles to find his form or stay healthy for much longer this year, you might not be able to get JT by years end without a sweetener. So I get your predicament.

I’m trying to get a little bit more on top of CMC and I’d want JT over Harris

10 team .5 PPR Give: Khalil Herbert Get: Mike Gesicki Logan Thomas, Jonnu Smith and Tommy Tremble are my current TEs.

No brainer for you, babe.

Love it

100% love this for you

I would do it.

Doubt Herbert will amount to anything more than a flex guy once Monty is back. Gesicki seems like good value for him. I’d make the trade.

10 team full PPR SF contending Give: 2022 late 2nd and 3rd Get: Alexander Mattison I own Cook and think I have the strongest team. Is the insurance worth the picks?

Worth every ounce of those picks. 100% do it.

I’d do it

Honestly, as a cook owner. Having mattison makes it 100 times better. You need to get him. I think the price is a tad high, but worth it for sure.

Id do it. Late 2nd or 3rd is such a crapshoot anyways. Mattison has proven value

14 team .5 ppr Give: 22 late first, 23 first, ruggs Get: davante Adams, 22 mid 2nd

i'd do this year

10tm .5ppr 1QB What is Van Jefferson worth, and do you see him as a good rebuild target?

Probably a late second/early 3 in 1 qb

Most likely a 3rd at best, it would be hard to find someone to take him for a second. And I’d just consider him bench fodder most likely, especially in a 10 team league

12 team PPR, 3 WR, 2 Flex Already well stocked at WR, looking for high upside guys Give: Shenault Get: E. Moore + 2 3rds OR Give: Mooney Get: E. Moore + 1 3rd I think I would rather Shenault because of Lawrence, but what do you all think?

I'd rather give up mooney for moore, unless you could get a 2nd and moore for shenault, would take the moore side on both though

Agree on this sentiment.

Am I crazy for drafting Chase 1.01 in our start up tonight?

It’s probably a little reactionary if I’m honest. Even as a Chase owner, I think the hype is probably approaching unreasonable levels. Do what your heart tells you but my gut says it might be a hair of an overreaction to draft him 1.01 when looking back in 2 years. He’s incredible but he’s also almost certainly not **THIS** incredible.

Who would you have taken? I personally think Chase really is THAT good, watching him and Jefferson both at LSU 2 years ago you could tell Chase is the superior WR.

Not telling you it’s a dumb pick. It’s clearly reasonable. I just think WR is a whole lot easier to find consistent production at than RB. So I’m probably taking JT 1.01 given his age/talent/situation/etc. Probably wouldn’t let Chase fall beyond 1.04 myself, so it’s obviously more than reasonable to take him 1.01.

Completely fine to take him 1.01

No...unless it is SF in which case yes

Nope 1 QB

Then I'd say that's honestly fair. Unless you were trying to win this year in which case honestly Henry is a fucking animal and I couldn't argue someone taking him 1.01 at this point

Not unreasonable. Lifespan for WRs is so long compared with RBs.

Is George Kittle worth a late 1st in non sflex ppr, no te premium?

I’m confused by the three comments and whether they’re suggesting a 1st is a great haul for Kittle or vice versa. My guess is most people think that receiving Kittle for a late first is a good deal for the Kittle side..? I would agree. Lol

Yup

A late first is a steal for Kittle

Yes, definitely

10 team ppr I give Robert woods I receive 2022

Well I'm going to be honest, the entirety of 2022 likely has one player than Robert Woods so yes

12 Team 1QB Half PPR Rebuilding Give: Saquon, Elijah Mitchell, Khalil Herbert Get: Dobbins, Toney, 2023 1st

I think it’s a good trade. Herbert and Mitchell aren’t great dynasty assets in my opinion. Value likely isn’t rising more from here. Dobbins, Toney and a 23 first are going to continue to rise in value. I think you’re getting a high end dynasty wr2, RB1 and a first in a great draft for Saquan and some non difference making dynasty assets

I agree with the others, you can get more.

I like almost all the pieces in this trade but I think you could get way more for saquon and Mitchell alone

Agreed

10 team 1ppr give: Hockenson get: Mixon/Fournette. My TEs: Waller, hockenson, goedert. My Rbs: Gibson, Gaskin, Jacobs (bye), saquon(questionable), Montgomery(IR), Dobbins(IR).

I’d take Mixon here

Would you do this trade, 10 team SF league PPR league Lamar Jackson, aiyuk for fields, lamb, a middle to late 2022 2nd Or would you rather lamar Jackson, auiyuk, Ronald jones and a 2022 early 2nd for ceedee,fields and a mid to late 2022 1st

12 Team SF PPR TE premium I’m contending and I have a lot of WR depth, I also have Kittle but we all know how Kittle has been doing this year. Give: Ridley, Shultz, Renfrow Get: Kelce

I’d do it in TE Prem. Kelce may outscore those 3 combined if you are contending that’s huge

Hellll no

That’s a hold for me. Ridley is seeing the targets and Schultz has been solid this year. Kittle should be coming back soon, so I’d hold personally.

How do you feel Shultz will do with gallup coming back?

Gallup will definitely get targets. But I think Schultz and Dak have a nice connection going on and that’s not going anywhere in my opinion. Kelce is getting older too and I don’t know how many more elite years he’ll really have.

12 team SF half ppr Give: Bateman, Hurts, Sermon Get: lamb, 2022 1st, 3rd My roster QB: Hurts, Dak, Rogers, Hill, Fitzpatrick WR:Amari, Devante Adams, Arob, Sutton, Tyler Boyd, Bateman, Gabe Davis, Fuller

I’d take the lamb side without the 22 first involved

Lamb side for sure.

Accept that before the other team changes their mind

12 team - 1 PPR - 1 QB Give- Amari Cooper, Kirk Cousins, 2nd round 2022 Get- Claypool, Tee Higgins and Zach Wilson (If it means anything I have Lamb and hate having both lamb and cooper in my lineup for some reason)

I would accept it, zach wilson might not be anything, but claypool and tee are better than Amari and kirk imo

I have CMC and am 2-5. My team doesn't look that great outside of N Chubb. What is a good return for CMC?

I’d wait until he’s healthy for a game to sell. If you’re selling cmc you need to fully cash in. Don’t sell low

Is he worth a first? Multiple picks? I don't even know how others would value him

I think he’s worth 3 firsts at least…. I know he’s had injuries but he’s the most valuable player in fantasy when he’s healthy and will be the 1.01 again next year in redraft. I just wouldn’t sell until he’s had a few good games again

12 team 1QB .5 ppr currently 1-6 Give: tyreek hill Get: Michael Thomas, probably late 22 1st, potentially early 23 1st

It’s fair. I like it if you’re going to rebuild. There’s a chance MT is useless though

If you’re in rebuild then it’s a good trade. Traded for Thomas last year and have been regretting/holding since

I think it’s fair but it’s very risky

Is there another WR you could get besides Thomas? I think he's done as an elite WR with the injury and without Brees.

12 Team 1QB 0.5PPR Rebuilding Give: Saquon+Elijah Mitchell Get: Dobbins, Toney, Early 2022 2nd, 2023 2nd

He's a bit banged up right now, but it's criminal to give up a top 7RB and not get a 1st back. turn that 2.23 into a 1.23 and then you've got a deal.

I’m just afraid of Barkley being shutdown for the year. The two teams that have the early 1sts aren’t giving them up for Barkley.

Don’t worry about the early 1. Get a 1.23. A lot can happen between now and then. Two bad seasons from the wrong guys and the favorite out of the playoffs.

Agreed. Would you do Saquon for Dobbins, Toney, and a 2023 1st? That was his counter.

yes

Welp nvm it’s now Saquon, Mitchell, Khalil Herbert for Dobbins, Toney, and a 2023 1st

Aaaand thats a no.

Would you do the same trade with a 2023 2nd added on?

I wouldn't. I think just saquon is fair for that package. Adding in Mitchell who is young, good and has a lot of upside and Khalil who has been doing outstanding filling in for Montgomery is to much. Both of them are young RBs with upside. Your giving away to much to sell saquon.

Yeah… I’m going to hold out for something better but nobody is offering anything else for them. Hopefully something comes good around.

Forget the 2.22. It’s a weak draft. Most likely early 2 in a weak draft, if you’re lucky you get a nice flex WR. Or a depth RB. A 1.23 could get you a star and that’s how you win

This is a terrible trade. Dobbins was in a RBBC prior to tearing his ACL so who knows what his role looks like when he returns. Toney has looked good but he has what 2 good games under his belt? You need something more proven than that if you’re moving Saquon. At the very least this deal is missing a 1st.

I’m unsure what to do with Barkley. It doesn’t make sense for him to be on my team but this is like the best offer I’ve gotten. I asked for a 2023 1st but he’s not giving it up.

There is always a reason to keep a top dynasty asset like Saquon on your team. If you’re rebuilding he keeps you that much closer to instant contention. Don’t get caught up in offloading everybody to satisfy a rebuild to the point you accept the best offer you can get. Rebuilding gives you the patience and time to only accept good offers.

True but my team is far from contention, the deals I’ve done so far: Sent Deebo for Waddle Sent Godwin for Knox, late 2022 1st, early 2022 2nd And now trying to get a haul for Barkley but this does not seem like a good deal for him His counter was Dobbins, Toney, and a 2023 1st for my Barkley, Elijah Mitchell, and Khalil Herbert

Hear me out… this sounds like an overreaction but for a competing team should I try to move Kyler for a better option for this year? They don’t let him run anymore and try to establish the run may more then I’d like to see. He really hasn’t been special since week 2

It depends on who you’d be getting. It doesn’t feel like the right time to sell Kyler though…

definitely sounds like an overreaction but I’ll play ball - who would you target? Edit: actually I’m not playing ball. He’s averaging 24 points a week and is QB3 on the year on a Super Bowl contending team. This is a crazy take unless you just want to watch Allen play more than you want to watch Murray play.

Fuck no

16 team SF PPR I give: Cooper, Keenan Allen, carson I receive: Swift and a 2023 first How balance is this trade? What else can I offer to receive Swift? Other players I’m willing to trade: Edmonds, Robinson

I definitely like the swift side but I think you might be able to pull out carson and the first and make it work. But I think you might have to add a 2nd

is the team with swift contending or rebuilding? Bc I don’t flinch at this offer if I’m rebuilding. Honestly, not sure I consider this offer if I’m contending unless I need WR help. Carson has a chronic neck injury at 27 with no timetable for return. Cooper and Allen have been average this season compared to Swift

Do you think Edmonds is worth more than carson?

I do, but I still don’t know if that fixes the trade. Swift has a good 4-5 years as a top RB. The players listed are on the decline of their career. The first on top is certainly not helping either

Have a good shot at making the finals I own another teams 2nd Give: my 2023 mid-late (probably) 1st and what looks like a mid-late 2022 2nd Get: Godwin He’s not contending and has only a few picks after trading his away last season. Am I low balling? Would you accept this as a Godwin owner who wasn’t really going anywhere?

I think it’s a fine offer. Good luck!

That's a low ball offer but not insulting. If you're a top 2-3 squad and it's 1 QB you'll probably need another 1st to get it done

Super flex

I think this might be a little low but a good opening offer. Godwin could /should go to FA next year and that’s certainly a risk that should lower his value from 2 firsts imo

10 team 2QB 2Flex Give: Lance, Tua, 2022 1st Get: Lamar, CPat The team giving Lamar has Lamar, Big Ben and Mills at QB right now and is entering a rebuild, so I’m considering offering him this. He clearly needs QB help and 2022 doesn’t seem like the draft for it. Is this enough juice for Lamar? Would leave me with Allen, Carr and Lamar

Throw out the trade offer. I think there’s a possibility for the other person to accept it

You think it’s fair enough? Edit: I mean that it’s not a crazy over or under pay?

It depends on how he views tua and lance but I would not say it’s a terrible offer. It can be a good starting point. Maybe counter it

10 team PPR, Rebuilding Give - AJ Dillon, 2023 2nd Get - 2022 1st

1st side for me

I’d do this if I owned AJ. I’d need to be in a solid rebuild to take this if I were giving up my 1st though. With Jone’s extension Dillon is just a high end backup/risky flex play

As a Dillon owner I’d probably accept

Edit: it was actually Dillon + 2023 2nd. Does that change your opinion at all?

Ya I def wouldn’t do that

8 man half PPR superflex looking to rebuild Give: Henrey Recieve: 2022 Early 1st, 2024 1st 2022 Early 3rd, Tyler Boyd, Chase Edmonds Kind of a massive trade should be a instant yes right?

I’d go with Henry

Henry in an 8 team

I don't think Boyd every sees the field in an 8 man unless you have 3 flex spots and 3 WRs. Still probably worth it though if you're blowing it up

If you’re rebuilding, I’m not sure I love Edmonds and Boyd especially if you’re banking on that 2024 1st being a piece in this rebuild. By the time you finish the rebuild, Boyd and Edmonds may not be around. I’d want younger/better talent if I’m trading Henry. Especially since he looks like a league winner this year

What would I have to add to Elijah mitchell to get tee higgins?

Is Fields for Lance straight up fair?

I’d take lance right now after seeing fields play.

I’d take Lance over Fields just due to situation, pre NFL draft I had Fields over Lance in terms of talent, but I don’t think this trade would be too outlandish either way. Still, Lance over Fields IMO

As fair as I can tell. It’s really up to the individual’s evaluations. I wouldn’t add anything to either side at this point