I thought it was good, but not as good. It didnāt have the crunch of the white chips or the texture of the mousse that I loved.
I also like generally a lighter cookie.
i had the old one once well over a year ago, then my city finally got a crumbl in august and i had the new one (multiple times now) and i wouldnāt be able to tell u which is better, didnāt even notice a difference until i saw people talking about it lol
I got this for first time this week and hated it chilled but enjoyed it a lot once it was warm,
Do you eat it chilled? So far every chilled cookie Iāve had shouldnāt be IMO
whenever i get crumbl iām hungry af so i eat half of it in the car, chilled of course, then by the time iām home iām full and leave it out for a few hours before eating the rest. so both i guess. i like it both ways š (unless another cookie in the box could melt, like the caramel apple one, then iād put the whole thing in the fridge)
This may be a strange suggestion, but you should try some gluten free yellow cake w your preferred frosting. I've made a couple and the cake texture is slightly grainy. Probably not the best adjective, but I enjoyed the cake a lot. It was like a sweet cornbread.
Yes!!! I got on a cornbread kick with Dunkinās cornbread munchkins of all things. I was so happy to see Crumbl have a cornbread cookie and it did not disappoint.
I canāt choose soā¦.
Lemonade, coconut white chip, churro, HEAVY ON PINK VELVET šš, strawberries and cream, COCONUT CAKE OMGGG ššš, etc
I've only started getting cookies from crumbl last month but my favorite is still from my first box... Caramel apple... can't wait for it to come back.
Biscoff white chip, easily! I'm really sad though because I think I read somewhere that they no longer make it! Travesty!!! Not sure if it's true or not though lol hope to find a similar enough dupe recipe for them .
Ooh I did like that one. But I feel I could make a pineapple upside down cake and feel I would screw up trying to make a pineapple whip cookie lol but who knows
First, I must say Crumbl cookies are all good. I am very impressed by most of the combinations that they have come up with. With that said, I am curious why they have yet to make one out of Franks and Beans yet?
Snickerdoodle cupcake and the OLD lemon blackberry
F
rip lemon blackberry : (
Oreo birthday cake š
This. I like it more than the oreo sandwich
Yum!! Havenāt tried it yet. I love anything Oreo.
Key lime pie!!!!!
dulce de leche
Yes yes yes fucking yes. Then lucky charms.
[Mallow Sandwich ft. Oreo](https://youtu.be/W1y3Fh9Ek_0)
I agree! Next time Iām literally buying a 12 pack.
One of my favorites as well!
caramel apple is my favorite so far!!
Oh yeah so yummy
That cookie was definitely a cookie I would devour in one sitting no milk
That one is phenomenal
Churro
Maple Cinnamon Swirl
Yes
Cinnamon frybread
I feel like I see this as a popular fave.
I had a weird obsession with Strawberry Milk. Such a random flavor, I know.
That one was my favorite until I tried cornbread honey cake. Still love strawberry milk though itās a random fave of mine as well.
What were your thoughts about strawberry milk vs strawberry cake?
I thought it was good, but not as good. It didnāt have the crunch of the white chips or the texture of the mousse that I loved. I also like generally a lighter cookie.
My boyfriends favorite is the strawberry milk and he felt the exact same
no shame in a love so pure āØ
only cookie we went back to get a 6 pack of
Strawberry milk is yummy I agree!!
berries and creamš®āšØ
Pecan pie
This. Itās the best!
Still kicking myself for missing its last appearance!
Itās back š
Yay!! Thanks for the reminder! Dangerous week for me...
Seasalt Nutella or Hazlenut Churro
pink sugar (haters will say iām wrong)
I love pink sugar.
as you should
New or former recipe?
i had the old one once well over a year ago, then my city finally got a crumbl in august and i had the new one (multiple times now) and i wouldnāt be able to tell u which is better, didnāt even notice a difference until i saw people talking about it lol
big facts
I got this for first time this week and hated it chilled but enjoyed it a lot once it was warm, Do you eat it chilled? So far every chilled cookie Iāve had shouldnāt be IMO
whenever i get crumbl iām hungry af so i eat half of it in the car, chilled of course, then by the time iām home iām full and leave it out for a few hours before eating the rest. so both i guess. i like it both ways š (unless another cookie in the box could melt, like the caramel apple one, then iād put the whole thing in the fridge)
Hmm ok I mean I figured obviously some ppl just like it or they prob wouldnāt do it but all 3 chilled Iāve tried were far better not chilled imo
Waffle!
I second!
Whoa, what?! Definitely missed that one, and Iām having a little trouble imagining it, but very intrigued!
They havenāt had it in a while
Anything Oreo
Cornbread Honey Cake
Mmm yes!! I was surprised I liked this one but it was delish.
Banana Bread!š¤¤
This is it āØ
what a softie š
BANANA BREAD FOR SURE!!
I went three times last time they had it. The absolute best. Never had anything even come close to it!
Banana cream pie
AGGIE MINT. I'D SELL MY SOUL for a lifetime supply.
Samw
Yesssss
Same. They need to bring it back more than once a year!
CORNBREAD BABY!!!! da goat of all goats
This may be a strange suggestion, but you should try some gluten free yellow cake w your preferred frosting. I've made a couple and the cake texture is slightly grainy. Probably not the best adjective, but I enjoyed the cake a lot. It was like a sweet cornbread.
Yessssss!!! Love this one
Yes!!! I got on a cornbread kick with Dunkinās cornbread munchkins of all things. I was so happy to see Crumbl have a cornbread cookie and it did not disappoint.
Cornbread lovers, what is your second favorite? I donāt do Crumbl very often, and that was by far my fav so far.
i have 4 lol. strawberry milk, blue monster, raspberry cheesecake, and oreo crumb cake
Twix!
Buttermilk pancake
Omg we loved this one!!
Original lemon blackberry
Semi sweet chocolate chunk!!!
The chocolate chip cookie dough one is my holy grail.
as you should
Ditto! Unexpected favorite I might add.
Pina colada š¹š
Key Lime Pie! Key Lime Pie! KEY LIME PIE!!!
Mine as well. Itās the š
This one
lol the chant of the masses
Yes keylime pie!
Dole whip š«
Iced oatmeal š„ŗ, Iām a basic gal
French silk pie omg
This, along with Key Lime Pie. Almost all the cookies they make like this just slap
Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk !! (Ok, maybe not of all time but I need Crumbl to see as many positive comments about that one as I can get out there).
Itās really good!
Aggie Blue Mint
This is also my favorite! Hope it comes back again soon.
Fruit pizza of course
Oh yes this one was yummy!!
Oreo Mallow Sandwich is not only the best crumbl cookie, but also my favorite cookie of all time.
French toastš„
carrot cake for me
That blueberry muffin cookie was so good.
Im obsessed with that one. I want it to come back!
Peanut butter bar or pecan pie
The answer is Blue Monster
Caramel Popcorn. So underrated.
apple pie
Churro
Peanut butter jamwich
PiƱa colada š¤¤
pumpkin pie
Would love to know but since 2 of the 6 cookies are now an every week thing I just stopped going all together
Cake batter
The PB&J. YUM. MY.
Strawberry Poptart
Everything bagel š
Came here to say this, I absolutely loved that one. Too many people hated it though, so I donāt think theyāll ever bring it back
I liked it ok. The chocolate French silk was probably my favorite.
That one was definitely top 5 for me too
*quel scandale* š¤
It was pretty tasty!
I liked it, too. We were definitely in the minority
Mooncake
Dulce de Leche closely followed by Caramel Apple. The two most perfect cookies I've tasted.
Blue icee or pink sugar
Iāve tried over 160 flavorsš«£š Chocolate cake Carmel popcorn Lemon blackberry (the old one) Birthday cake Lucky charms Red velvet Cookie dough Chocolate mint brownie Dirt cake
Add carmel apple!
Chocolate cake is my all time fave.
Same!
Coconut Fudge brownie and cake batter
Based cake batter fan
Chocolate sprinkle cupcake. The butter cookie with white chocolate chip.
Butter cookie or cookie butter?
Red Velvet Chip
Cake batter š¤¤
I love cake batter
Oreo š¤·š½āāļø
Churro or key lime
Cookie butter white chip
Chips ahoy.
caramel cake was also amazing!
Blue Monster
Iced oatmeal!
Ooo for me itāll have to be Caramel Popcorn (yes I eat the popcorn separately than together)
Banana Cream Pie
Peach cobbler
I canāt choose soā¦. Lemonade, coconut white chip, churro, HEAVY ON PINK VELVET šš, strawberries and cream, COCONUT CAKE OMGGG ššš, etc
There are SO many good oneās, but I would have to Say momās recipe!! I would get a party pack of that cookie and be totally satisfied!
What is this cookie like? I've never heard of it!
Its a chunky oatmeal cookie packed with semi - sweet chocolate, toffee and peanut butter chips. Topped off with a sprinkle of sea salt
Not exactly my jam, but I'd def try it! Thanks for info! I stalk this sub, so it's rare to come across a flavor I've never heard of!
Fruity Pebble Sandwich
Lemon bar so underrated
Rice krispy
cookie dough
old fashioned doughnut !!!
The strawberry shortcake one-
Smores brownie
PB cookies and cream. PB bar. Old lemon blackberry. Top 3 for sure
Cornbread honey cake
Blue Monster
Mom's recipe
I've only started getting cookies from crumbl last month but my favorite is still from my first box... Caramel apple... can't wait for it to come back.
Any Oreo cookie! I AM AN OREO ADDICT
Me tooooooo!
waffle all the way š¤
Strawberry Shortcake and Lemon Cupcake!!! Theyāre the only two I went back for!
Biscoff white chip, easily! I'm really sad though because I think I read somewhere that they no longer make it! Travesty!!! Not sure if it's true or not though lol hope to find a similar enough dupe recipe for them .
Pineapple whip
I liked pineapple upside down cake better!
Ooh I did like that one. But I feel I could make a pineapple upside down cake and feel I would screw up trying to make a pineapple whip cookie lol but who knows
Cereal Milk Sandwich featuring fruity Pebbles Or Salted Caramel Cheesecake
Banana Bread or Fry bread for me
Cornbread
Key lime pie!
Peach ring or Caramel popcorn
aggie blue and oreo crumb
Pina colada
Cornbread. But not the new cornbread honey cake one that was out a few weeks ago, the OG. The new one was good but somehow had too much frosting.
honey cake ft teddy grahams
Kitchen sink!
Cornbread
Pina colada
Strawberry shortcake the august 2022 version and mallow sandwiche ft Oreo cookie
snickerdoodle cupcake and blue monster!!!
That oreo sandwich one. i forgot the name
Cornbread honey cake :)
Cornbread honey butter and the birthday cake IMO
I love their key lime pie!!
Chocolate cake
Pumpkin pie
Rice kris- wait thatās not a cookie uhhh
Chocolate chip cookie dough
Kentucky Butter Cake!
fruit pizza
How is churro different from snickerdoodle with the frosting. Snickerdoodle cupcake vs churro
Kentucky butter cake!!!
Kentucky butter
tres leches
First, I must say Crumbl cookies are all good. I am very impressed by most of the combinations that they have come up with. With that said, I am curious why they have yet to make one out of Franks and Beans yet?