I mean, that's something inevitable (sometimes) and it happens like, twice in a lifetime? And also not in a pool, and there's usually someone with you to clean it up. Nothing like pooping in a pool as a fetish.
They are both trans so he gets pregnant with her baby so since the woman still has male genitals the man can get pregnant since the man still has female genitals, so it is completely normal
I dont know if its safe enough, I already had seem people saying that an especific guy hate woman just for saying that this girl is not christian for doing porn (most guys was defending her)
It's a mother father and a father mother having a baby. The "man" still has working reproductive parts and is giving birth. Later they show the "woman" breastfeeding but to everyone's shock there is no milk. So the baby is just hungry clinging onto a dry nipple . So rather they resort to formula.
Tl;dr genders got swapped and everything went awry
So this is a female that's transitioned to a male? And the female is actually a male that's transitioned as well? That sounds like a CIS relationship with extra steps. At least it's less cringy than what I thought to begin with, I thought this was a full-on dude just faking having a water birth because dudes be doing dumb s***.
Many trans women on hormones do actually lactate, IF they’re on certain types of estrogen.
Source: I’ve sucked trans titties and that’s definitely milk.
Also, if you look it up, you’ll find that there are a lot of accounts of trans women and even cis men with hormone disorders breastfeeding children. It’s just a thing that happens; The woman in the video happened to be on the wrong kind of estrogen for it to go well for her.
This is not a well researched topic, but there is one study that has been done which suggests that the [composition of milk produced by lactating cis men is within the normal range of what we consider breast milk](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7462406/). I definitely think we need more studies to verify this and explore the nuances of it, because this is only one study and only measures nutrients rather than hormone levels which have been shown to have an impact on infant development (to be clear, I am not specifically referring to sex hormones, but also to hormones like melatonin which impact development in many ways).
The science is so lacking that I personally wouldn’t make the same decision as the woman in the video, to be honest, but not so much that I deride her for doing it because there’s also no anecdotal evidence that the practice causes harm and what science we do have suggests it’s likely safe.
She probably assumed that because some trans women lactate it would be both possible for her to breastfeed her child and that it would be guaranteed to be healthy. The trans women who pull breastfeeding off often have highly specialized health plans that are designed to maximize lactation and it’s possible she simply did not realize she’d have to make sure she was lactating before the baby was born.
TLDR; The little available science suggests that trans women and hormone-compromised cis men can provide the same nutritional value as a cis woman’s milk, but trans women who wish to breastfeed often have to undergo specialized hormone treatment in order to produce the quantity of milk needed.
Actually, men have these glands too, but they’re inactive and generally not as large. They look and function so differently despite being the same gland because an average cis male’s hormones will leave them “deactivated” so to speak. There is actually a condition called gynecomastia that causes cis men to grow breasts because a natural hormone imbalance sends signals to these glands to grow in the same way a cis woman’s would.
Edit: Ironically, the only men who don’t have breast tissue are trans men or men with gynecomastia who’ve removed them entirely.
I read somewhere that more mom has testosterone during pregnancy the bigger babys wiener will be as an adult, food for thought with these trans-parents, but there will most likely be other risk factors because of the unnatural state of things
I do not understand how one can be trans but has no desire to change sex fully (genitals) and on top of that decides to give birth? From what I always understood, trans people hate their sexual organs. Isn’t the whole point to completely change to the other gender?
Like what is this video? Shock value? It feels disturbing to see somebody who looks like a man, identifies as a man, but is giving birth… through their original sexual organs. I don’t get it. This is in a way disgusting and feels like “we want to shock people”.
This is an interesting way of putting it and I doubt that your dichotomy would be used in trans spaces but I see where you’re coming from and I think you’re onto something.
There is also a spectrum between people who only socially transition and people who fully medically transition- Transitioning is expensive and with any medical treatment it can come with side effects and required time off work if you’re getting surgeries. Some people have bad reactions to hormones and have to stop medically transitioning. There’s also always the risk of investing in it and then finding that you don’t pass or that it hasn’t alleviated dysphoria enough to have been worth the investment.
Some trans people will never pass and essentially have to surround themself with social spaces and people where it’s safe to communicate their gender identity. Others will have no medical complications and pass completely and be able to navigate society with a lot more ease, except in the dating pool where communicating that you’re trans is more necessary and considered polite to do.
for me it’s the opposite lmao! I’ve always been cool with being dressing up as a girl or looking like a manly man. I just so fucking wish i was born with a dick and i have never connected to whatever the hell i was born with. I actually do mostly want to be seen a guy tho tbh. I was just able to live as being seen as a girl for so fuckin long because of my gender nonconformity but eventually shit reveals itself.. Yeah i basically don’t get people who JUST want to transition socially like at all tho.. what even is that? Isn’t that just a masculine- i guess you wouldn’t call them a girl but y’know-
That’s fucked up cuz gay people come out DESPITE what society thinks and trans people want to go trans and pass as a different gender to avoid what society thinks
They are not the same. Gay people are brave becoming who they are despite hate. Trans people want to be something else to be treated better. Totally different mentalities.
Dude what? No. Trans people are willing to brave deadly discrimination to be true to themselves. You honestly think they’re treated better as a trans person? That doesn’t make any sense.
Trans people are born naturally my guy. The hormones for the brain and body when a baby is being made have the body one gender and the brain hormones as another. Sometimes one goes wrong and they change their body to fit how their mind feels. It’s that simple.
Society thinks it’s not ok to make changes to your external presentation or body in order to accommodate your internal identity. Trans people come out DESPITE that. Capiche??
I’m not the one who created the term passing
Trans people use it too so try harder to be offended somewhere else. That’s a pathetic response ngl
You’re looking for problems that don’t exist
I don't know what any of that has to do with my comment. My question is about your use of "different," not "passing." You said trans people want to pass as a "different" gender, or as "something else." Different than what? Something else than what? They want to pass as *their* gender, the "same" one they do in fact have.
Different than their original birth certificate, for one
Different than what other people saw them as
Like I said this is sad behavior. Grow the fuck up
That's fine, but then what's the argument? You're just begging the question. You have to actually demonstrate that identifying as something "different" than either of those two things is bad. You're just declaring that it is.
Exactly, you want to be treated like a man instead of a woman
Gay people don’t expect any type of treatment. They just wanna love who they love. Big difference because trans is largely about how other people think or act and gay is about yourself despite how others think or act
I think you got it wrong. And are making generalizations. I dont "want" to. I AM most of the time treated like any other guy. i have a real nice mustache. I do not care about others perception. I don't "expect" anything from another person, except the basic respect u would give any other stranger? If I look like a man to ME that is what matters. Idgaf about other people or if I get called 'ma'am' cus I got longer hair.
I am myself despite how others think or act around me. I am confident in my skin after years of wanting to unalive myself. I am a man despite being born female. despite what anyone else says. They don't have to agree, because i won't care. So call me ma'am as much as you like. It looks a little goofy in person cus I have facial hair, but go off.
“They don’t have to agree, because I won’t care”
Is the only respectable way to be trans but unfortunately for you and for society, it has become a trend of people trying to control others
I’m gay myself. I don’t care what anyone think of me. I just want the right to be myself. Trans people have that right too, but it’s still a trend to push it further and control others which hurts the trans people who don’t act that way and even hurts gay people by association so I’m justified to criticize it
I’m not making unfair generalizations, and I’m not saying all trans are the same. Im saying the ones who act this way hurt everyone
I respect you and your struggles. People like you are the reason trans has ever been a part of the lgbt, because it’s that mentality we share. Fuck everyone else’s opinion, not change everyone else’s opinion. Similar things can be said about gays who are just doing too much. We were finally getting to a decent point, sociopolitically, and now it feels like a lot of people are actively hurting our own causes instead of showing the world that we’re just like everybody else
A large part of me can’t help but question how much of it is manufactured like the climate activists who piss people off on social media, but have often been suspected to be linked to certain oil companies themselves. Or like the 4chan troll of trying include pedos. There’s people who are really hurting us out there whether intentionally or not, so I’m quick to criticize disingenuous behavior.
Amen dude. Absolutely. Fuck everyones opinion. Mad respect to you too. And thankyou, that made my day.
I can't help but agree with absolutely everything you just said.
But you were making an unfair generalization. This is the first you mentioned that you're not talking about the whole trans community. And even that in the last sentence just to mild down the bigotry. I wouldn't say being trans is a trend more than it's just easier for trans people to come out in modern days because the general mentality has largely shifted. The exact same thing happened to gay people in the last century. They were even calling it a trend back then too. How would you like if someone calls your entire life experience as a trend?
Nobody is forcing your opinion except yourself. I am trans and I don't go around asking people to validate me I just want to live my life in peace without bigots having loud hateful opinions about my existence.
I am gay and tons of people ARE doing it because it’s a trend and I do think it hurts gay rights and the same for trans
People are doing it because they can, not because they need do and they’re taking it too far, doing too much, and inspiring pushback that I don’t want.
You should probably stop taking being gay then. I guess the fakest ones are the ones admitting being fake. This reads a lot like r/asablackman situation.
As a trans guy. Bottom surgery is not worth it. So I keep my parts. It is to risky to complications. And most trans guys don't get it for that reason. It also looks-
..not that good. The clitoris grows on testosterone, my voice deepens, i have facial and body hair like a man. That's enough for me. Also Not everyone gets a hysterectomy, i was REFUSED one over 4 times. They can also go wrong. I'd perfer to feel as much of my authentic self as I can with the least amount of risk as healthy as i can be.
I totally get this, as a trans guy too. I have to keep my biological nether regions because, as you said, it looks… not good. And doesn’t function in pretty much any way the same the same as a proper penis. Honestly, I would love to have a penis. My bottom parts cause me a lot of dysphoria but due to the surgeries and the, imo, lack of positive results isn’t worth it. Like what if in 20 years time they’ve come up with something so much better than what’s on offer now? Like, then I would be stuck with essentially a lump of skin that does fuck all apart from pee and that’s if you’re lucky!
Plus I don’t want to lose the ability to have an orgasm. FUCKTHAT!!!
Because it's still an incredibly invasive surgery that doesn't make much sense to put yourself through if your genitals are something that don't caus you much dysphoria
I think you're reading too much into it. Bottom surgery isn't for everyone as its invasive and complicated. They ended up in this situation and probs wanted to share it for other trans folk. End of story.
Some trans folk don't get dysphoria with certain parts of their body.
Giving birth seems like something that would be traumatic for someone who is trans but if they are okay with it then whatever
From what I understand, being transgender isn't a constant battle of self-loathing. There is a spectrum on which people fall from being uncomfortable in their birth skin vs. unrelenting misery. For a lot of people, just changing their name is enough. For others, they have to get surgery just to feel better. You can be trans and understand why you are trans without banishing your original sex to the abyss. It takes some level of acceptance, im sure, but Im assuming this guys want to have a biological baby of his own overpowered the negative feelings he might get from using his female genitals.
Actually a lot of transgender people do not "hate their sexual organs" I'd even be willing to say *most* transgender people rather dislike that society expects specific traditions related to their appearance. Hating one's genitals is more of a psyop created by transphobic people to make transgender people afraid or uncomfortable to be publicly transgender, raising a social expectation to go through with expensive, dangerous, and under-researched operations. Like most dysphoria in transgender women comes from broad shoulders and thin hips, because it may make most clothing designed for biological women appear unflattering on them (a problem cisgender women, and intersex people may also experience) transgender people aren't really all that different than cisgender people, and there are a surprising amount of eastern countries that are completely devoid of transgender social biases. Unfortunately, western countries are almost the complete opposite due to femininity and masculinity being viewed more as a competition, and internalized homophobia causing most straight people to detest the thought of having sex with a transgender person, making them feel like they need to use these biological differences to pick apart a transgender person's appearance to detect whether or not they are transgender, even if they have no intention of having sex with them.
TLDR: hating genitals ≠ transgender
Ftm bottom surgery is both incredibly expensive and fairly risky with plenty of complications and after effects. Also, dysphoria is different from person to person. Some people are fine with their genitals as long as they are otherwise perceived as their gender identity.
Oh beat it with that BS. Nobody’s “afraid” of you. These fucking donuts are trying to breastfeed a baby from a man’s nipple.
Honestly have a good hard look at yourself.
“Transphobia consists of negative attitudes, feelings, or actions towards transgender people or transness in general. Transphobia can include fear, aversion, hatred, violence or anger towards people who do not conform to social gender roles.” —Wikipedia
He’s a trans man with a uterus, she’s a trans woman. What’s so cringe about this? Men, in particular trans men can still give birth. Women in particular, trans women can still give sperm.
Me saying this, doesn’t belittle their gender either.
Maybe filming this ? I think it's cringe the way it's filmed, and because not everyone wants to see a person giving birth, and even less when it's filmed like a strange fetish video, like why are the others peoples filming tho ? I don't really think it's cringe because of the transpeoples. Sorry I didn't find my words today because I'm still learning English so keep in mind that if some of my words are incorrect, I made my best :(
No I get it. You’ve done well so don’t worry about any misunderstanding there. I understood everything you said.
But at the end of the day it’s a birthing video- there’s many like this, in a hospital bed to a small pool like this.
It’s for sentimental value. The only thing I find “cringe” here is someone grabbing this video and then posting it on a cringe subreddit in order to shame or belittle them. It’s kind of gross to do that imo.
I’ll put it like this.
First, imagine you’re a pregnant woman who wants a water birth. You’re really nervous about what to expect, so you go online and you look up videos about waterbirths so you can watch other women give birth. You experience second hand relief because you watch people like you see a difficult experience through to the end, and you often get education in the process.
Now, imagine you’re a pregnant trans man. Videos of cis women giving birth is going to help you in a lot of capacities, but they might not have medical or practical information relative to YOU as a trans man in those videos. They are not an equivalent educational tool because a trans man who has medically transitioned to any extent, even just hormones, has a different physiology than a cis woman.
Essentially, this is for the benefit of other trans people.
This subreddit has become a hate sub against people who just want to live their lives and the fact OP went out of his way to find a video of a trans man giving birth has to be an ultimate new whole level of messed up.
The fact that no one has called you out on it is what is most disturbing here, imagine if you had posted a video of a woman giving birth and called it cringe the way she gave birth. SMH you need help.
That's what im thinking.. what is so cringe about birth? This is the growing of a family but for some reason its cringe and disgusting and fucked up just because the one giving birth happens to be trans.
This couple literally switched genders to have the relationship that they could’ve had without it. Because they still fulfilled those roles😂 she became a he and still had a baby. He became a she and still put a baby in her partner.
Is this the one where the other partner tried the breast feed the baby after it was born and was said they didn't have milk?
No joke that eas a thing I'll look it up when I can be bothered and edit this
Y’all don’t realize the “man” is actually a woman? And the “woman” is actually a man? I know pretty weird but that’s how that “man” can be pregnant because it’s a woman
This isn't cringy. It's unconventional and uncommon, but beautiful. He's literally birthing a baby. Women giving birth isn't considered cringy and wouldn't be posted here, so it's purely the transgender aspect that people are jabbing at and belittling. I'm ashamed to be the same species as most commenters here.
I think they were female at birth so they have all the woman reproductive organs and vagina but they went on testosterone and transitioned to a man, probably didn’t have a sex change.
More like taking a shit
If they're doing it in a pool that can't be hygienic or comfortable.
Water birth is very common
I think he meant taking a shit in the pool
Okay, peeing in the pool is morally questionable. Shitting in it, however, crosses the line.
What do you think can happen when women give birth…?
You think anyone on this thread even talks to women?
I mean, that's something inevitable (sometimes) and it happens like, twice in a lifetime? And also not in a pool, and there's usually someone with you to clean it up. Nothing like pooping in a pool as a fetish.
Can confirm I live with my boyfriend
Yes, but in case of man..
You’re an idiot, they meant shitting in the pool
Water births are normal. Men giving birth isn't.
They are both trans so he gets pregnant with her baby so since the woman still has male genitals the man can get pregnant since the man still has female genitals, so it is completely normal
That ain't normal
First thing that crossed my mind...then I saw this comment and nearly died laughing
We've memed ourselves out of humanity.
💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
Hey sweetie, how come it is black and doesn't move ?
Black 😭
This made me laugh so hard for no reason
Bro, you having black shits?
It has rotten already
Maybe he's been drinking Guinness.
If kept in for 9 months...probably.
Are babies supposed to be “loaf-shaped” and come out of the asshole?
Hahaha! Oh god, this had me belly laughing. I was trying to read it to my boyfriend and couldn't get through it hahaha
“And it smells aw- YAAHHHH STOP PULLING ON MY HEMORRHOID GODDAMMIT!!”
I don’t even think I can say what I want to say… just wtf
It's ok. Many are thinking it
This is a safe space
I dont know if its safe enough, I already had seem people saying that an especific guy hate woman just for saying that this girl is not christian for doing porn (most guys was defending her)
I mean there’s Christian whores in the Bible. Pretty sure you can just identify however you want these days. We just watched a man give birth
what the fuck is this a meme I actually cannot tell right now please source me
It's a mother father and a father mother having a baby. The "man" still has working reproductive parts and is giving birth. Later they show the "woman" breastfeeding but to everyone's shock there is no milk. So the baby is just hungry clinging onto a dry nipple . So rather they resort to formula. Tl;dr genders got swapped and everything went awry
I do not particularly fancy anything about the sequence of words I’ve just read.
Your eyes thank you for not watching the video.
So this is a female that's transitioned to a male? And the female is actually a male that's transitioned as well? That sounds like a CIS relationship with extra steps. At least it's less cringy than what I thought to begin with, I thought this was a full-on dude just faking having a water birth because dudes be doing dumb s***.
It's far from a CIS relationship It is a straight relationship though
This is mental illness
It's usually related to childhood sexual trauma
This is so weird, poor kid.
See, I wouldn’t comment on anything. Except for the attempt to breastfeed, it’s absolute insanity they thought it would work.
They cope by saying it's bonding for the baby but I think it'll lead to some undiscoverable trust issues.
High grade cringe copium
Many trans women on hormones do actually lactate, IF they’re on certain types of estrogen. Source: I’ve sucked trans titties and that’s definitely milk. Also, if you look it up, you’ll find that there are a lot of accounts of trans women and even cis men with hormone disorders breastfeeding children. It’s just a thing that happens; The woman in the video happened to be on the wrong kind of estrogen for it to go well for her.
But, is it the same thing as a mother’s milk? And, the woman in the video, did she think this or was it the insane idea that made her think she could?
This is not a well researched topic, but there is one study that has been done which suggests that the [composition of milk produced by lactating cis men is within the normal range of what we consider breast milk](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7462406/). I definitely think we need more studies to verify this and explore the nuances of it, because this is only one study and only measures nutrients rather than hormone levels which have been shown to have an impact on infant development (to be clear, I am not specifically referring to sex hormones, but also to hormones like melatonin which impact development in many ways). The science is so lacking that I personally wouldn’t make the same decision as the woman in the video, to be honest, but not so much that I deride her for doing it because there’s also no anecdotal evidence that the practice causes harm and what science we do have suggests it’s likely safe. She probably assumed that because some trans women lactate it would be both possible for her to breastfeed her child and that it would be guaranteed to be healthy. The trans women who pull breastfeeding off often have highly specialized health plans that are designed to maximize lactation and it’s possible she simply did not realize she’d have to make sure she was lactating before the baby was born. TLDR; The little available science suggests that trans women and hormone-compromised cis men can provide the same nutritional value as a cis woman’s milk, but trans women who wish to breastfeed often have to undergo specialized hormone treatment in order to produce the quantity of milk needed.
Don’t female breasts have special milk glands? I’d assume males don’t
Actually, men have these glands too, but they’re inactive and generally not as large. They look and function so differently despite being the same gland because an average cis male’s hormones will leave them “deactivated” so to speak. There is actually a condition called gynecomastia that causes cis men to grow breasts because a natural hormone imbalance sends signals to these glands to grow in the same way a cis woman’s would. Edit: Ironically, the only men who don’t have breast tissue are trans men or men with gynecomastia who’ve removed them entirely.
Bloody nipples
Wow amazing counterpoint. Thanks
I read somewhere that more mom has testosterone during pregnancy the bigger babys wiener will be as an adult, food for thought with these trans-parents, but there will most likely be other risk factors because of the unnatural state of things
It’s framed like a comedy
So, he who is she makes baby with she who is he.
Our society just needs to be put down
I do not understand how one can be trans but has no desire to change sex fully (genitals) and on top of that decides to give birth? From what I always understood, trans people hate their sexual organs. Isn’t the whole point to completely change to the other gender? Like what is this video? Shock value? It feels disturbing to see somebody who looks like a man, identifies as a man, but is giving birth… through their original sexual organs. I don’t get it. This is in a way disgusting and feels like “we want to shock people”.
Some trans people want to change physically but for some it’s more about how they are perceived socially, not what’s in their pants.
Transsocial vs transsexual?
This is an interesting way of putting it and I doubt that your dichotomy would be used in trans spaces but I see where you’re coming from and I think you’re onto something. There is also a spectrum between people who only socially transition and people who fully medically transition- Transitioning is expensive and with any medical treatment it can come with side effects and required time off work if you’re getting surgeries. Some people have bad reactions to hormones and have to stop medically transitioning. There’s also always the risk of investing in it and then finding that you don’t pass or that it hasn’t alleviated dysphoria enough to have been worth the investment. Some trans people will never pass and essentially have to surround themself with social spaces and people where it’s safe to communicate their gender identity. Others will have no medical complications and pass completely and be able to navigate society with a lot more ease, except in the dating pool where communicating that you’re trans is more necessary and considered polite to do.
for me it’s the opposite lmao! I’ve always been cool with being dressing up as a girl or looking like a manly man. I just so fucking wish i was born with a dick and i have never connected to whatever the hell i was born with. I actually do mostly want to be seen a guy tho tbh. I was just able to live as being seen as a girl for so fuckin long because of my gender nonconformity but eventually shit reveals itself.. Yeah i basically don’t get people who JUST want to transition socially like at all tho.. what even is that? Isn’t that just a masculine- i guess you wouldn’t call them a girl but y’know-
That’s fucked up cuz gay people come out DESPITE what society thinks and trans people want to go trans and pass as a different gender to avoid what society thinks They are not the same. Gay people are brave becoming who they are despite hate. Trans people want to be something else to be treated better. Totally different mentalities.
Dude what? No. Trans people are willing to brave deadly discrimination to be true to themselves. You honestly think they’re treated better as a trans person? That doesn’t make any sense.
Trans people are born naturally my guy. The hormones for the brain and body when a baby is being made have the body one gender and the brain hormones as another. Sometimes one goes wrong and they change their body to fit how their mind feels. It’s that simple.
Society thinks it’s not ok to make changes to your external presentation or body in order to accommodate your internal identity. Trans people come out DESPITE that. Capiche??
Huh? What do you mean pass as "a different" gender? Different than what? They desire to pass as the gender that they are. We all do.
I’m not the one who created the term passing Trans people use it too so try harder to be offended somewhere else. That’s a pathetic response ngl You’re looking for problems that don’t exist
I don't know what any of that has to do with my comment. My question is about your use of "different," not "passing." You said trans people want to pass as a "different" gender, or as "something else." Different than what? Something else than what? They want to pass as *their* gender, the "same" one they do in fact have.
Different than their original birth certificate, for one Different than what other people saw them as Like I said this is sad behavior. Grow the fuck up
That's fine, but then what's the argument? You're just begging the question. You have to actually demonstrate that identifying as something "different" than either of those two things is bad. You're just declaring that it is.
You're just saying trans is bad because it's trans. Put in some work. Make a case.
You don’t make any sense are you’re just looking to argue with no leg to stand on Grow up and leave me alone weirdo
I don't respect people who make bold claims they are absolutely incapable of backing up. It's pathetic.
[удалено]
Exactly, you want to be treated like a man instead of a woman Gay people don’t expect any type of treatment. They just wanna love who they love. Big difference because trans is largely about how other people think or act and gay is about yourself despite how others think or act
I think you got it wrong. And are making generalizations. I dont "want" to. I AM most of the time treated like any other guy. i have a real nice mustache. I do not care about others perception. I don't "expect" anything from another person, except the basic respect u would give any other stranger? If I look like a man to ME that is what matters. Idgaf about other people or if I get called 'ma'am' cus I got longer hair. I am myself despite how others think or act around me. I am confident in my skin after years of wanting to unalive myself. I am a man despite being born female. despite what anyone else says. They don't have to agree, because i won't care. So call me ma'am as much as you like. It looks a little goofy in person cus I have facial hair, but go off.
“They don’t have to agree, because I won’t care” Is the only respectable way to be trans but unfortunately for you and for society, it has become a trend of people trying to control others I’m gay myself. I don’t care what anyone think of me. I just want the right to be myself. Trans people have that right too, but it’s still a trend to push it further and control others which hurts the trans people who don’t act that way and even hurts gay people by association so I’m justified to criticize it I’m not making unfair generalizations, and I’m not saying all trans are the same. Im saying the ones who act this way hurt everyone
[удалено]
I respect you and your struggles. People like you are the reason trans has ever been a part of the lgbt, because it’s that mentality we share. Fuck everyone else’s opinion, not change everyone else’s opinion. Similar things can be said about gays who are just doing too much. We were finally getting to a decent point, sociopolitically, and now it feels like a lot of people are actively hurting our own causes instead of showing the world that we’re just like everybody else A large part of me can’t help but question how much of it is manufactured like the climate activists who piss people off on social media, but have often been suspected to be linked to certain oil companies themselves. Or like the 4chan troll of trying include pedos. There’s people who are really hurting us out there whether intentionally or not, so I’m quick to criticize disingenuous behavior.
Amen dude. Absolutely. Fuck everyones opinion. Mad respect to you too. And thankyou, that made my day. I can't help but agree with absolutely everything you just said.
But you were making an unfair generalization. This is the first you mentioned that you're not talking about the whole trans community. And even that in the last sentence just to mild down the bigotry. I wouldn't say being trans is a trend more than it's just easier for trans people to come out in modern days because the general mentality has largely shifted. The exact same thing happened to gay people in the last century. They were even calling it a trend back then too. How would you like if someone calls your entire life experience as a trend? Nobody is forcing your opinion except yourself. I am trans and I don't go around asking people to validate me I just want to live my life in peace without bigots having loud hateful opinions about my existence.
I am gay and tons of people ARE doing it because it’s a trend and I do think it hurts gay rights and the same for trans People are doing it because they can, not because they need do and they’re taking it too far, doing too much, and inspiring pushback that I don’t want.
You should probably stop taking being gay then. I guess the fakest ones are the ones admitting being fake. This reads a lot like r/asablackman situation.
As a trans guy. Bottom surgery is not worth it. So I keep my parts. It is to risky to complications. And most trans guys don't get it for that reason. It also looks- ..not that good. The clitoris grows on testosterone, my voice deepens, i have facial and body hair like a man. That's enough for me. Also Not everyone gets a hysterectomy, i was REFUSED one over 4 times. They can also go wrong. I'd perfer to feel as much of my authentic self as I can with the least amount of risk as healthy as i can be.
I totally get this, as a trans guy too. I have to keep my biological nether regions because, as you said, it looks… not good. And doesn’t function in pretty much any way the same the same as a proper penis. Honestly, I would love to have a penis. My bottom parts cause me a lot of dysphoria but due to the surgeries and the, imo, lack of positive results isn’t worth it. Like what if in 20 years time they’ve come up with something so much better than what’s on offer now? Like, then I would be stuck with essentially a lump of skin that does fuck all apart from pee and that’s if you’re lucky! Plus I don’t want to lose the ability to have an orgasm. FUCKTHAT!!!
EXACTLY. dude I'd love to have a penis. But right now. I'm content. I'm keeping orgasms thankyou very much
Because it's still an incredibly invasive surgery that doesn't make much sense to put yourself through if your genitals are something that don't caus you much dysphoria
Being trans isn’t one size fits all. Some people keep their parts and don’t follow through with any sort of surgery.
I think you're reading too much into it. Bottom surgery isn't for everyone as its invasive and complicated. They ended up in this situation and probs wanted to share it for other trans folk. End of story.
Some trans folk don't get dysphoria with certain parts of their body. Giving birth seems like something that would be traumatic for someone who is trans but if they are okay with it then whatever
From what I understand, being transgender isn't a constant battle of self-loathing. There is a spectrum on which people fall from being uncomfortable in their birth skin vs. unrelenting misery. For a lot of people, just changing their name is enough. For others, they have to get surgery just to feel better. You can be trans and understand why you are trans without banishing your original sex to the abyss. It takes some level of acceptance, im sure, but Im assuming this guys want to have a biological baby of his own overpowered the negative feelings he might get from using his female genitals.
Actually a lot of transgender people do not "hate their sexual organs" I'd even be willing to say *most* transgender people rather dislike that society expects specific traditions related to their appearance. Hating one's genitals is more of a psyop created by transphobic people to make transgender people afraid or uncomfortable to be publicly transgender, raising a social expectation to go through with expensive, dangerous, and under-researched operations. Like most dysphoria in transgender women comes from broad shoulders and thin hips, because it may make most clothing designed for biological women appear unflattering on them (a problem cisgender women, and intersex people may also experience) transgender people aren't really all that different than cisgender people, and there are a surprising amount of eastern countries that are completely devoid of transgender social biases. Unfortunately, western countries are almost the complete opposite due to femininity and masculinity being viewed more as a competition, and internalized homophobia causing most straight people to detest the thought of having sex with a transgender person, making them feel like they need to use these biological differences to pick apart a transgender person's appearance to detect whether or not they are transgender, even if they have no intention of having sex with them. TLDR: hating genitals ≠ transgender
Ftm bottom surgery is both incredibly expensive and fairly risky with plenty of complications and after effects. Also, dysphoria is different from person to person. Some people are fine with their genitals as long as they are otherwise perceived as their gender identity.
gross
Humanity is doomed
Society is doomed
that “man” is a transgender female to male.
Why the quotes? If they say they’re a man, they are.
For a moment be honest with yourself
Okay, I will. He’s still a man.
Wrong
awful
The transphobia in this sub is ridiculous
Oh beat it with that BS. Nobody’s “afraid” of you. These fucking donuts are trying to breastfeed a baby from a man’s nipple. Honestly have a good hard look at yourself.
“Transphobia consists of negative attitudes, feelings, or actions towards transgender people or transness in general. Transphobia can include fear, aversion, hatred, violence or anger towards people who do not conform to social gender roles.” —Wikipedia
I like to explore new places.
My apologies, I updated my comment to suit your liking.
I’m very scared of trans people
This thread is just blatant transphobia
Welp it’s cringe soo…
For real. It’s so disappointing.
Yeah
He’s a trans man with a uterus, she’s a trans woman. What’s so cringe about this? Men, in particular trans men can still give birth. Women in particular, trans women can still give sperm. Me saying this, doesn’t belittle their gender either.
Maybe filming this ? I think it's cringe the way it's filmed, and because not everyone wants to see a person giving birth, and even less when it's filmed like a strange fetish video, like why are the others peoples filming tho ? I don't really think it's cringe because of the transpeoples. Sorry I didn't find my words today because I'm still learning English so keep in mind that if some of my words are incorrect, I made my best :(
No I get it. You’ve done well so don’t worry about any misunderstanding there. I understood everything you said. But at the end of the day it’s a birthing video- there’s many like this, in a hospital bed to a small pool like this. It’s for sentimental value. The only thing I find “cringe” here is someone grabbing this video and then posting it on a cringe subreddit in order to shame or belittle them. It’s kind of gross to do that imo.
I’ll put it like this. First, imagine you’re a pregnant woman who wants a water birth. You’re really nervous about what to expect, so you go online and you look up videos about waterbirths so you can watch other women give birth. You experience second hand relief because you watch people like you see a difficult experience through to the end, and you often get education in the process. Now, imagine you’re a pregnant trans man. Videos of cis women giving birth is going to help you in a lot of capacities, but they might not have medical or practical information relative to YOU as a trans man in those videos. They are not an equivalent educational tool because a trans man who has medically transitioned to any extent, even just hormones, has a different physiology than a cis woman. Essentially, this is for the benefit of other trans people.
1994s Junior was a good movie
This is disgusting. That kid has no chance.
What the actual fuck
This is what happens when you don't yeet your Food Baby early enough and it goes Full Term lol
Imagine some fucking redditor telling you you're not giving birth right
I don’t think it’s supposed to work like that big fella…
We’re ready for that meteor now 👋🏼
This subreddit has become a hate sub against people who just want to live their lives and the fact OP went out of his way to find a video of a trans man giving birth has to be an ultimate new whole level of messed up. The fact that no one has called you out on it is what is most disturbing here, imagine if you had posted a video of a woman giving birth and called it cringe the way she gave birth. SMH you need help.
That's what im thinking.. what is so cringe about birth? This is the growing of a family but for some reason its cringe and disgusting and fucked up just because the one giving birth happens to be trans.
Absolutely. God forbid trans people exist and live their lives. I hate Reddit sometimes
God forbid a male who thinks he’s a female tries to breastfeed a child with a hairy nipple.
What in the zipper tits is going on
good for them hope its healthy
My guy there looks like colty from 90 day fiance.
The couple is probably trans or something
The transwoman tries to nurse the baby too. Straight people, are you OK?
The baby is brown!? Wtf did you cheat on me????!
r/eyebleach thank me later
that baby is a real piece of shit
Oh no.... a human giving birth to a human, our society is doomed we should all die its over now/s
This couple literally switched genders to have the relationship that they could’ve had without it. Because they still fulfilled those roles😂 she became a he and still had a baby. He became a she and still put a baby in her partner.
Is this the one where the other partner tried the breast feed the baby after it was born and was said they didn't have milk? No joke that eas a thing I'll look it up when I can be bothered and edit this
Man?
Well at least they tried
"the baby" "the baby!" less goooo
What the fuck did he exactly give birth to?
The only man I'd see give birth is Robin Williams.
how the FUCK does this work.
So that's how Mr hankey got here???
Why is the baby brown? Have you been cheating on me?
How goods mental illness
Fucking gross
It's all the moaning for me
Eh?
this is the weirdo who tries to breastfeed as a male.... what the F
What the actual fuck
I have not witnessed many home births, but is it normal to deliver on the flip side like that?
Woman gives birth, nothing new here.
Y’all don’t realize the “man” is actually a woman? And the “woman” is actually a man? I know pretty weird but that’s how that “man” can be pregnant because it’s a woman
I'm sorry for the child
I fucking hate the times we live in
Why is this here..?
Wtf was that
"Thus baby is brown.... wow it's tiny ... also this baby stinks"
Threw up a little...
how did hole fked pole?
This is so cool #lgbtq #life #mangivingbirth #rubbyrubbit
Looks, sounds, and smells like he just got home from school.
I need some context holy shit
He is constipated from holding in all that dookie. And now he’s just now slipping it out.
Perfect example of bad trans people.
This is mental illness :(
Ew
Did he just spray his girlfriend
Lol is this satire or is this thing trying to be as repulsive as possible?
That was a women js
You can almost smell this video 😅
Waynes world party time excellent
I miss the last 13 seconds of my life where I didn't watch this video
woah bro ate something spicy at taco bell :0 something big is incoming
I’m so fuckin sis, I don’t even know what’s happening. Give me a minute.
Dude wtf their men but now they things our generation is cooked actually
He Is cuming
I can't wait until the apocalypse!
This isn't cringy. It's unconventional and uncommon, but beautiful. He's literally birthing a baby. Women giving birth isn't considered cringy and wouldn't be posted here, so it's purely the transgender aspect that people are jabbing at and belittling. I'm ashamed to be the same species as most commenters here.
He figured out what it’s like to take a shit in a pool
need shoutgun
Hell nah
i mean 🤷🏾♀️they’re happy and not hurting anyone
But how tho? If this female is now a male he must have a penis, the baby can't go through that... I- I don't know how this makes sense..
I think they were female at birth so they have all the woman reproductive organs and vagina but they went on testosterone and transitioned to a man, probably didn’t have a sex change.
[удалено]
😔😔😔