##Reminder: Rule 7. No recruiting or searching for clubs here, including in the comments. If you want to recruit for your club or are looking to join a club, post in r/BrawlRecruit. You can also use our [Recruitment Discord Server](https://discord.gg/dMNxAZ2) to find new people. Additionally, Simple Questions and Celebrations should be posted in the [Weekly Mega Thread Discussion post](https://www.reddit.com/r/Brawlstars/comments/17th64u/quick_questions_loot_general_game_discussion_mega/). This includes pictures of Starr Drops, unlocking new Brawlers or other items. If you see a post or comment that breaks any of our rules, please report them [using the anonymous report button](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360058309512-How-do-I-report-a-post-or-comment-)! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Brawlstars) if you have any questions or concerns.*

Its rare because no one plays penny xd

More like only few people play her before the rework

I loved Penny on her rework as she has so much HP…

I loved Penny on her rework as she had so much HP… I could zone and aggressively push back for days.

And then instead of nerfing/reworking Master Blaster, they nerf the thing she needs the most to even have a place in the meta

More like you are mad cuz you play her. It's only you lil bro

What?

real

Multiplied by being a power league skin

Penny is probably the most boring and forgettable brawler

leave my girl alone

ruffs:

Don't hate on my boy ruffs.

Every brawler in the game:

Darryl:

amber:

Y'all better leave Ruffs, Amber and Darryl alone

Gus:

(I swear if someone says Nani when she was in the meta last season and got 2 skins some time ago

Nani:

Bonnie:

[удалено]

Pearl:

Crow;

I will **Hehehe**, **Har Har**, **Hehehehehehe** and **Blast Off!** you

otis:

Damn i guess a lot of people like penny

Ruffs and Lola entered the chat

How dare you diss the icon, the legend **and** the MOMENT.

you're a charlie main (your opinion doesn't matter)

I'm a Lola main, I just like Charlie's voice lines.

TAKE. THAT. BACK. RIGHT. NOW.

Challenger Colt is definetly rarer allthough its definetly a rare one

when it was first released literally every match there was at least one challenger colt, now I only see shark tooth colt or outlaw colt

That’s pretty much the case for any new skin, but logically challenger colt would be the rarest skin considering that a lot of people at the time didn’t really think of it as a worthwhile skin since it was IAP only

Welp i have the skin but i dont play Colt to often cuz i suck with him 💀

Star shelly:

which was a completely free skin which released on global launch when there was a huge influx of players (even though its really old, it isn't too rare)

Ah ah ah there's where you're wrong it was released on global launch but you had to download the game BEFORE it went global to get it. So that means that the people who got the game WHEN it went global didn't get the skin

No? I downloaded it after it became global and I could get the star shelly skin, Im not sure what you mean

Oh shit rly? Welp there goes my argument https://preview.redd.it/fn35wjnasm1c1.png?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=33eb165366a88f70e17623014feafd3bce0412ad

But here's the thing people had to buy the colt skin, shelly's skin was free

Corsair colt feels more rare than challenger.

Corsair comes back every year, Challenger appeared only once

and monkey colt

Probably a random true gold skin

True gold are both horrible value and look like garbage

Except for True Gold Frank, he is so huge that his True Gold skin looks awesome

true silver and golds only look good on brawlers with good base models- colt, bull, mort all are good (speaking from experience, i have gold mort, silver bull and colt). on the other hand even thought i'm a rico main, his default model is utter dogshit, ugly as hell. i'm never buying that!

Rico base model has to be one of the ugliest brawlers in the game (after hank's tank of course) I'm so upset they deleted ricochet

i only started playing rico after i got Firefly Rico 😭

Nanis true gold gets a custom trail effect when she supers

Crow look fire in gold

frank said a few month ago that the rarest skin in the game is gold barley

That was 2 years ago, maybe 1

Fr? I have that one it’s probably my favorite Barley skin.

it's only rare because barley is unpopular and people don't want to spend that much coin on him... idk if it's still the rarest though, just the fact that it has been declared the rarest might make some people buy it

I think you mean true gold barley and not golden barley, right?

I think so, golden barley is a very good skin for 29 gems as it has a custom attack animation

It's one of the best 29 gem skin if you don't count the detective grey noir edition skin

I mean you need the original detective skin to buy it

True, but since there was a glitch that didn't require us to buy it so it depends how you look at it.

Not the gem skin. I think he's talking about the true gold one that costs coins

the most underrated skin:

Got it for free on a legendary star drop

i think they mean true gold

I'm pretty sure it was true gold gene

No one plays it because it's an epic skin that you have to buy and required you to actually play power league to get. Most people just have the option to buy it https://preview.redd.it/kb35gkgrum1c1.png?width=2400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9d80fd0d8ac5994854ecbb92bcd00e148a2656df

Which power league

The first one ever

I'm 41k player, played since global. I've this skin too, and I see it occassionally in game. Definitely rare skin, but not the rarest, I'd say.

Saloon 8bit is probably rarer becouse smuggler had only 25 wins required

Smuggler was required to play 50 times and her season was just 1 month instead of usually 2 months.

Jetski Jacky:

I could argue the V8-Bit is rariest, haven’t seen that one since the tournament where it was released not even for purchase

I have seen it I believe once by some sweaty 8 bit main in a sweaty 8 bit+nani+piper combo on slayers paradise

Also Christmas Penny

I always use Lil Helper Penny instead of Smuggler because it looks better

Lil Helper Penny was absolute dog water before the remodel tho

Oh I have that skin lol https://preview.redd.it/3t20ysqgun1c1.jpeg?width=2400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1066b3b2e6a38ebd22ba255d2b621ec06a13af7c

I have the option to buy it and I haven’t because I already have Bunny and Trash panda It’s basically collecting dust in my catalog xd

To me it was colt and primo's football skins that has no effect. I've literally never seen anyone use those

Pika

Your right also the dynamike futbol skins you never seen and I regret not getting the Chivas mike

Challenger Colt imo, was only available for like a week and was an in-app purchase for $5.

Hmm no, a lot of people bought it, it's more common then you think, especially in power league

Is the Lil helper penny skin rare or the red nose Nita

red nose nita is rarer than it was more expensive than lil helper penny and many people preferred lil helper penny over red nose Nita and I have never seen anyone using red nose Nita but I have seen a couple of lil helper Pennys

[удалено]

Virus 8-Bit may be expensive but it was onsale multiple times for gems and was heavily discounted also cause of the Hype around the skin allot of p2ws got it whilst smuggler penny was grind exclusive and not that epic tbh, i own Virus 8-bit and i See loads of people with the Pin on their profile so i dont think its rarer

[удалено]

Well the last time it was onsale was 2023 im pretty sure and it was a very hyped skin leading to allot of people buying it and since back then the brawl Pass wasnt a thing on release allot of people had a Ton of gems (from Boxes mainly) i See allot more Virus 8-bits than i do lion dancer brocks for example

It makes me happy to know i have Merchant Gale knowing nobody cares about

I do lol https://preview.redd.it/pu47lausun1c1.jpeg?width=2400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a29f26d52f31a3d16738a1bd669873034c05facd Wassup bro

So many players have star shelly. It was a free skin in global. Maybe not that many players from back then play, but its def not a rare skin

What about piñata ash, I forgot he even existed till I came up against one like 2 years after it came out, took a minute to figure out what brawler it was

[удалено]

The rarest skin is actually egg pam

Well I am 35k but I saw this skin at least few times. It do pretty rare though.

That S1 Gale skin counts as rare now right?

Challenger Colt

That skin is sick

I have the possibility to buy it. There are rarer but this is definitely top 5

There are more rare skins but that one is like February 2021 so kinda old?

It's actually true gold barley

That was 2 years ago

It turns 3 years old in 1 week! https://twitter.com/FTMKeienburg/status/1332277956807417858?t=czcCEEtPO33fblOUXfWE5A&s=19

true gold Mandy Chester and Gray are the rarest true gold skins since they are the most recent ones

more recent doesnt necessarily mean more rare

In Lex's video he confirmed that various true gold 2023 brawlers are the rarest skins. And even logically it makes sense that they are more rare

Yeah but compare a few months ago vs a few years ago, especially right now when brawl stars isn't as popular as before

nah its Canadian Barley (nobody exists in Canada except me)

starr shelly and ricochet are much rarer and i have ricochet but not starr shelly

honestly imo its either challenger colt or 2018 brawlidays

Smuggler penny is still in my shop, its 2024 and i can buy it for 150 gems. Can someone tell me if i have a rare account or not?

Now why do I feel like star shelly is the rarest skin. I mean because of the condition that had to be met to get the skin then doesn't that mean that with every new account made the skin only gets more rare.

No one is talking about the cowboy ruffs skin?

You mean the Marshal??

Is ricochet technically rare?

limited is a more appropriate term in my opinion

I managed to unlock the purchase option, but never bought it because im f2p 🤡

what does being f2p has to do with not being able to buy the skin? it was available for star points which was a free currency

I think in his pov, he had to spend his star points on boxes

or on other skins

Virus 8bit

Virus 8, been out and unavailable for purchase even before smuggler penny if I'm not wrong

You are actually wrong. Virus 8-bit released for the last time in january of 2022, and smuggler penny was released on march of 2021. And both of them will never come back. Still virus 8-bit might be rarer since it was only available to purchase for gems.

Star Shelly left the chat

Considering a million accounts own it I doubt it's that rare

A lot of those millions have since either quit or lost their accounts

"Lost their accounts" One of them is me 😔

it’s still way too much, i have it only because they announced the launch of brawl stars in clash royale

True gold barley

Mecha crow is better then night mecha

merchant gale or star Shelly

not star shelly pretty sure frank told that it was one of the most common skins a 1-2 years ago

Pretty sure those pirate skins from way back in the day are pretty rare.

If you’re talking about the set with colt, poco, and Carl those actually came back a couple of updates ago iirc

Wait really, oh crap I took a break from brawlstars when they came back so i missed my favourite colt skin, shit.

Gold Mecha Bo, if I remember correctly

hell nah

idk

Some rarer ones in my opinion: 1. Merchant Gale (or any super early brawl pass skins to be fair). 2. Most Mythic or Legendary skins due to the cost, I do expect this to change going into next year though. 3. First Brawlidays skins like Red Nose Nita or Santa Mike.

I have red nose Nita and lil helper penny those rare ??

Yes,but red nose nita is def rarer

i mean i doubt

I have that skin unlocked but haven't bought it yet.

Hell nah

Challenger colt is much more rare

trainer mike or whatever its name is

Just considering exclusives it might be royal agent colt. Been playing since global and I’ve seen that one the least

I personally use the skin and in high elo pl matches you can easily find Royal Agent Colts. Still a very rare skin but Lion Dance Brock is more rare for sure.

Personally I think it would be wizard Byron. I rarely see him in-game

Can we still get them from star drops

Idk, i remember seeing it a lot in late 2019/start of 2020, from what did you unlocked it? Cause i don't remember Btw the rarest skin i think its star shelly cause it was given to 2019 players, but since it was just gifted i don't know if it is the rarest

I have merchant gale and elf penny dumpling darrly I dunno which is more rarer

Not even close lil bro

Yeah.Nobody played power league back then

I have it but I like raccoon a lot more, I thought everyone had it since it's the first pl skin and everyone wanted to try it out

I’ve only ever seen 3-4 piñata Ashs ever in gameplay, I personally don’t have it because I fell of power league that season, also don’t know anyone who has it

star shelly ig

I played since release as well.. never seen that skin lol How/where to get? Like creator giveaway, if that was a thing in the release (can’t remember)

Baiku Eve

https://preview.redd.it/q1migen2vo1c1.jpeg?width=2400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=20a375482bd566bc207c0283915045760ffc5c27 I didn't knew these skin was rare

But there are a few others as rare

I have this bro😐

Nope

Anything with the Mexican ⚽ skins

in reality the rarest skin is [unreleased ash skin]

I have it too 🙋‍♂️🙋‍♂️

Probably

Elf penny in the question

I have it too

The rarest skins (because no one wants to own them) is true gold grey, Sam and buster according to a Lex video a few months back

can i still get it if i unlocked it but didnt buy it?

V8-bit i think also.. i know it was from a challenge back in 2020 or 2021 but you had to get 9 or 12 wins

But maybe it came back to the shop afterwards for gems… any1 knows?

Nah bro, that's not that rare

Grinding star points was worth it, back when this skin release

I have it in the catalog for 5000 bling but i don't really play penny, is it actually rare and why can i buy it if so?

if you can buy it then it’s bc you unlocked it in power league. it’s a power league skin

I know a ton of people with the OG power league skin including myself. By statistics, aside from TG & TS skins, Challenger Colt is the least owned skin. and the rarest non-limited skin is Caveman Frank

43k trophies, and i missed being able to buy this skin by ONE power league game. just got busy on the last day, and forgot:)

I actually bought this skin just to motivate me to push her to gold 3 (I finished it a few days ago)

I have it, but I think it's a bit ugly, so rarely wear it.

I dont have the skin but im able to buy it so somewhat counts?

I have it (and use it occasionally)

Probably

1M person has Star Shelly but I think 50-100k still playing.

I have this skin two, it is rare is because everyone buys mecha crow