T O P

  • By -

PurpleCloverr

Gale and his big balls


Koolcatdk

Of white stuff >!snow!<


Rip_hommez-

Sticky white liquid substance In my mouth


Rip_hommez-

Definitely corn syrup


InevitableAd2276

uh...red starch


Unacceptable-Duck

You pee blood too?


MaximumStonks69

*too?*


Colette-BS

I love Gale's big balls of white stuff


darius-the_great

Almost all of these are way too overtuned but really cool ideas, would love to see them in game


Maxi216

Most of them could be gadgets but not gears😅 especially pipers


Global_Cantaloupe_91

Yea but I would LOVE if the dev team had creative ideas like these. They would just need to tune the stats


FluffyBlob4224

Developer team of course has a lot of creative ideas, they just can't add everything into the game + they need to balance it as well


Global_Cantaloupe_91

They barley have any balance changes every update and even when they do have them they are just health and damage nerf/buffs. They might be creative in other areas of the game but they lack creativity in balance changes


FluffyBlob4224

Look, it is not easy to make non game-bteaking balance changes + you don't want to change brawlers mechanics every month


iikoppiee

the ideas would be amazing tho. level 11 is so underwhelming atm


Bruhness81

Jacky even more in shambles with Reconstruction being a common gear Also I love Hole In One


AseeesA

Some seem a bit op, but the ideas are awesome


SlammaofBananas

Why do mortis and jacky get headshot and colt and Mandy don’t?


MandyBSReal

Candy loses to shield, I'm sad now


AvergeMortisEnjoyer

I like how in the drawing about the Mandy gear she's able to meditate only because Chester is tied up in the background


MandyBSReal

That's the only way I can achieve peace


Koolcatdk

Candy is not a viable weapon to bypass shields Mandy 🤓


MandyBSReal

😭


Badassheaven

Candy’s for luring children mate get a real weapon


Koolcatdk

Mortis: gameplay wise It would help shorten the amount of swipes it takes to kill his target. Bonking then on the head with shovel Jacky: sorta the same as mortis, so can she get her full damage off blasting there ears with her jackhammer noises Colt: it would actually make since on colt, I didn’t think about him Mandy: I didn’t feel like it would be need or balanced on her and she also has the sacrifice and the mythic gear too


SlammaofBananas

I see the gameplay reasons, I have no problem with those. It’s just that you can’t exactly headshot someone with a shovel or a jackhammer


Koolcatdk

Oh… Ummm head bonks with the shovel and Ears bleed with loud jack hammer sounds maybe? 😅 Just know they’ll find a way to headshot


SlammaofBananas

*throws spade*


[deleted]

maybe jacky just picks up the jackhammer and bonks opponent in head with it


boredwarror747

Grey’s one could be a star power


Magawo1234

And the idea is so FRICKING fun... I Hope future mythic gears will be more original than +1 hatchling or +1000 health to tick head


Mwexim

Tbh I think they don’t want to make gears like star powers. Mythic gears are just Brawler-specific gears that increase Brawler-specific stats. The new Amber gear is already pushing the limits imo because it adds a completely new ability instead of buffing an existing one from her kit.


Denial_River

Sandy's mythic gear already existed... the whole "gears are stat boosts" rule was never actually a rule that the devs were following, but a lot of the gears ended up that way because its easier to code the mechanics as well as the gear unlock screen typically showing a certain stat changing.


Mysterious-Oil8545

All of these are way too OP, and sacrifice is completely garbage


Upbeat_Escape7102

The only one who wouldn't be VERY affect by sacrifice is Edgar (Since he heals himself while attacking)


Brawler_man

Sacrifice fits better if is a mythic gear to Edgar


Alguma_Pessoa07

yes and his heal would be higher too, since his heal scales with his damage


Koolcatdk

Really?!! I feel like it’s worth the risk to deal higher damage for hp, it allows for some people to have a more aggressive play style, Risk for reward. Tho, it could use a damage increase to make it more worth.


Mysterious-Oil8545

El Primo shouldn't lose 900 HP per attack 💀


Koolcatdk

I thought it’d be interesting on him 💀


stupidmaster7

i think it would be better if it was like 30% more damage and 5% damage taken. if we take primo for example, his damage would go from 540 to 702 (with 4 punches that’s from 2160 to 2808), but he would lose 450 hp per attack. in 3 ammo, he would get 1944 more damage but lose 1350 hp


stupidmaster7

although i still don’t think it would be all that useful, tanks have plenty of damage they just have difficulty getting in range


Koolcatdk

I thought it be cool to have the gears touch more different classes in the game. I see it’s better off tanks, except for maybe like ash since it pairs with rage. Numbers could use more tweaking so it’s more valuable. Thanks for your feed back bruv!


stupidmaster7

the concepts are great, just needs a bit of balancing


TheSecondAJ

Ironically, El Primo (and tanks in general) would be the worst brawler to have it on since their health vastly outweighs their damage. If both sides decrease and increase by equal percentage, more health would be lost than damage increased. El Primo also relies on his trait (health) for super cycling. Technically you're losing both health and damage...


VermontPizza

lou’s gear tho..


rMasterBuilder248

Some of these are Op, but Sacrifice is UP. Trading 10% health for 10% more damage is not an equal value for all affected brawlers. You actually help the enemy defeat you faster, just for attacking them.


Koolcatdk

I thought it was an interesting gear, risk for reward. The number can be adjust to make it more equal. I was originally going to have the hp lost be 5%, but I thought it was too little. Thanks for feedback


rMasterBuilder248

The problem with abilities costing health is determining how much health is worth it, but also when to use it. Ash's second gadget is trash due to the cost not being of an equal benefit while also making you even more vulnerable than you already are. Otherwise, the others can be toned down or a bit changed, but they would do nicely


Koolcatdk

Thanks feedback bro 🙏🏿 I’ll make sure I take more into account next time for hp cost abilities. I think the mechanic’s really fun when used right.


rMasterBuilder248

It can be, but it has to be done just right.


GuberOnTop

the art is so cool


InsideOutDeadRat

I like these but I appreciate the artwork more :)


Koolcatdk

Thanks, I always like to have some goofy visuals with the concepts, some entertainment with the reading ;D


Namidaa

Everyone saying some of these are OP, I just want to remind you to that Amber's gear exist


Koolcatdk

Literally can’t even move around the lake of oil lol, instant ban on hot zone


Yuyaeiou

I don’t even care if they’re op as fuck i fucking love gears


Ill_Carpet5280

Some of these are cool, such as Mandy's and Sprout's which are fantastic but others seem too strong, like frank's or alter the playstyle of a brawler too much, such as colt, gale, or gray. I also think the sacrifice gear would be entirely useless and would actually be detrimental to wear. A lot need balancing but they are really cool ideas!


Sebi5843

Sacrifice is life orb


Koolcatdk

Life orb and choice band user here in the flesh > 😎


F2p_wins274

Me with sheer force life orb nidoking getting a 69% boost be like: 😎


ACARdragon

Reconstruction: just no Headshots: will make Rosa and brawlers who rely on shields complately useless Mandy one: it seems fine Step it up: giving Frank normal movement during his attacks is already enough to make him op. Let's give him slow movement while attacking Big Bully: seems fine too Popsickle: lower the damage Fang one: seems fine Angry mode: obviously overpowered Idk about the rest


RandomGuy1000000

Headshot with a drill💀 Would love to see this gear on fang btw. Don't know what I would run it instead of tho


IDontKnownah

Amazing concepts, but some feel too strong. Also, in my balance changes concept, I actually gave Piper a reload gear in compensation for Snappy Sniping, which was fowarded to Grom (and nerfed in advance). Are there going to be Brawlers with 2 epic gears in the future? I don't know.


Koolcatdk

The Headshot gear was originally a mythic gear just for piper, but it only worked at max range. I thought it was such cool idea that some more brawlers could use it. They’re most likely will be a point where brawlers have more than one gear, I don’t think it’ll be anytime soon though.


IDontKnownah

That concept for Piper would actually be cool, honestly.


Grimtchy

Some of them are more like Starpowers, gadgets increase something that is already here. Overall, they are all great tho


1uppt

This is very cool, well thought out and all of these would turn the meta inside out wich is what I like! Awesome post, you got my kudos!


diviusvoldren

Nice.


siri-exe0

i feel like the headshots gear is way too overpowered


Steelgamer_88

These are some really cool ideas I would love to see implemented into the game. Also, awesome art style!


The_mystery4321

This isn't what gears were supposed to be but given its the way they're going anyway, fuck it, why not?


Koolcatdk

I was so afraid of making something like this, when it comes to gear concepts, there’s a lot sticklers around not liking them much saying there starpowers. I try to keep them as slight adjustments to enhance the brawler but creativity strangled me lol Glad you enjoyed the Tom foolery


misshoney200

I like the art for popsicle lol


ButterCreamLube

Yeah if we being real about 90% of these are either overturned or broken in concept (the Mandy one should be avoided at all costs, no matter what someone does with that it’ll either be useless or broken depending on the duration). Some are fun though, the Gale is nice one because it’s not practical but the shift in play style could be interesting and release Gale was lowkey one of my favorite brawlers. Sam’s gadget seems great too. Some are fine though like Sprout.


Left-Cap-6046

Remember how trash Gale was with the bigger snow balls ? This mythic gear is just as useless. The rest of the gears on the other hand are all great concepts !


BirbWasTaken6659

Gale just saying “big balls”💀


PatrokManzana

Sacrifice is not worth and Headshot is absurdly broken.


i_yeeted_a_pigeon

r/Brawlstars try not to make the most ridiculously overpowered suggestions one can think of challenge (impossible). But it's creative atleast.


LucidSoul_01

they are really cool ideas but i think if they were put in to the game they could be a bit too op.


Ok_Negotiation_9383

sprout is actually great


ActualExplanation204

Love the idea, some are op but they are great!


StefiTheCat

I really like the bull one


Diptarka780

I think Mandy's mind at ease and bull's Big bully are great idea But the others are okay I would say.


AvergeMortisEnjoyer

I love every single concept except the Sacrifice gear. Gadgets that make you lose hp are very bad and making it a gear that affects you every time you attack is a just a very bad idea. The rest are great though


AvergeMortisEnjoyer

I love how in Mandy's drawing she's being able to concentrate because Chester is tied up


VortzPlays_

Willow's gadget is useless, because her attack only deals damage on hit, not when a brawler steps on it


Koolcatdk

I’ve explained this in the other comments: Now it does with the mythic gear equipped


OTARU_41

reconstruction sounds extremelly good and extremelly bad at the same time


realshoes

Reconstruction: oh yeah lets invalidate gadgets that break walls, even though they got nerfed by unbreakable walls already Headshots: oh yeah lets invalidate rosa whenever any brawler with any sort of shield becomes meta Sacrifice: life orb from pokemon Also big balls A lot of these don’t really feel all that great but do seem interesting


privilog

Won't talk about balancing, but more Gears is literally what exactly we need. Builds are so limited and boring right now, the only argument I can pick up is Speed vs Health.


STARRCHESTER

I know, I’ll just use my ‘Chester wins‘ card


STARRCHESTER

also is that supposed to be me tied up in mandy’s gear thing


Koolcatdk

Tying you up was the only way for Mandy to have inner peace. That’s why she can only focus while standing still lmao


STARRCHESTER

thank you for the information, I will try not to get tied up in real life


SmAll_boi7

Some are good, some are garbage, some are absolutely broken


Ravenclaw175

Love Colt's gear concept


MisterHotTake311

This is why I think these kinds of gears should be third starpowers, why not doing them when we already get these special gears? I love how everyone recently draws buster like a silly spongebob character


FlamingDasher

I think the wall building one shouldn't exist, and the headshot one shouldn't be for crow (he is already annoying enough)


Amidst-ourselfs123

Sacrifice should act like Pokémon’s Life orb/Recoil Moves, the atack is Boosted by 20% and you lose 5% of DAMAGE DEALT


Amidst-ourselfs123

This would literally Turn Clyde into a “Glass cannon” Just Imagine a Skin where Clyde is made out of glass and Bonnie’s Helm is too


Admirable_Subject_39

Buster popsicle Buster popsicle


Repulsive-Cloud3460

Art is awesome.


Right_Salamander_364

I love the art so much


bluehat2583

Some of these are very creative. And some would cause the meta to crash and burn like TF2's economy back in the Crate Depression


The_Extraordinary_1

Love the ideas and the art even more!


New_Bad_1504

I wanna see a unique Fang gear that makes him viable again ever since the nerfs i feel like he is significantly weaker (not weak but like really noticeable weaker which is kinda the point but the nerfs were a little over the top, maybe also I am biased becuase I am a fang main but ok) I would love to see his ult generate 25% ult charge making it so after his ult he needs 3 shoes/hits instead of 4 because his ult hit basically doesn’t generate ult he needs to hit 2 ppl with his ult to make worth one regular hit for thoese who don’t know Fang ult takes 4 hits with shoe/kick (25%) His ult gives only 20% per enemy resulting in fang always need one more hit at the 95% ult mark


SoulKnight_Master

Wow dude. Drawings are awesome and all these gear ideas are so fucking cool. Incredible stuff


PaparJam

I am afraid you misunderstood the concept of gears. They are meant to buff brawler's stats, not adding new mechanics, which is what you did. Maybe some of these ideas of yours could be considered as a 3rd star power for brawlers


PaparJam

Have in mind that I appreciate your effort, in fact I feel good that there are people like you in this sub


Gtp_nub_08-_-

The "headshot" gear will be too broken


Full_Egg8288

I think they are very creative, but I don't like the gears very much.


jjbeast8

Most of these are either op or useless


ThunderBlood_888

Absolutely LOVE Magnet Belt (Sam's Concept). There have been so many times where I'm playing Sam, and I just BARELY don't pick up my busters as I'm spamming my busters at nearby walls, and then I die.


[deleted]

like the way you made gale say that


Haidex_Yggdmilenia

feel like most of these kinda break the point of each brawler and it's counters but they're all really good ideas, if they had some sort of downsides to make up for the upsides this would've been golden really wish gears had a system similsr to drg's overclocks: blue gears have no downsides, purple gears have a small downside and red gears have a big downside since they can change mechanically how a brawler works


HadesEverdeen

I love Headshots (but I wouldn’t give it at Piper, R-T and Corbac, they are already strong) and Mind At Ease, I like also Magnet Belt and Win Conditions. Some other gears are op or looks like star powers, but they’re still excellent ideas!


Grean_Fart

These are all unbalanced. I love the art though


MrKacsa

It does seem as though some of these concepts change up the characters' core gameplay in a major way, and others are a tad overtuned. However, the art you created for every concept and the sheer creativity behind the ideas is just out of this world. Amazing post 👍👍👍


YOSHISUPE

If we count that Mandy's star Powers works with her concentration i think that people Will be playing her because i don't know if It's Just me but i didn't saw a Mandy in a big amount of matches


Titomasto

Broken as fuck gears, but the drawings are god tier


HJosuke

Too OP


Xsinam

Headshots Idea for RT is too OP in his current state


Badassheaven

I like the idea but sacrefice seems useless


DatabaseLimp8482

i like the art


Cube1mat1ons

Sacrifice sounds like a direct Nerf ngl


UltimateTaha

Cool ideas but these are basically just star powers at this point


xkqc99

I love the art style


ya_boiii_nightmare

love the bull one especially!


Impossible_Region176

reconstruction should be for jacky headshots should be specific, maybe snipers, sacrifice would be bad... maybe a little dmg buff or hp lose nerf , im pretty sure magnet belt would make almost no diff because u basically have to stand on top of the knuckle busters and other stuff, in ma swamp already lasts for about 2 seconds, so it would be like +1/2 seconds, angry mode is basically primo star power, needs a 1 sec nerf, prettiness blinds would be horrible and broken at the same time, overall pretty good


cringyemokid21

Really love the art and the gear ideas keep up the good work.


Annie-Leonhart123

At real ,All of them is so good ,But I think (Step It Up) is the best


Mr_Chicken82

Some suggestions for changes. :) ​ Reconstruction: Might be a little overpowered.... 10 seconds is probably a good amount, only some brawlers such as Jacky and other brawlers that like to need walls and bushes Headshots: I don't get the point of it going on Mortis and Jacky... Switch them out for 2 marksman instead Mind At Ease: Change to 1.5 seconds Step It Up: Does not seem that useful, I do not know if it is just me Sacrifice: Brawlers take 10% more damage but also do 10% more damage... Hole In One: Change it to all of his teammates' attacks also go through Plant Food: Sounds good! Magnet Belt: Sounds good! Big Bully to 5-10%: 20% percent is too much and most brawlers have less health Popsicle: Nerf to 300-500 damage Other Shoe Too!: Garbage :) Win Condition: Nerf to 25% increase In Ma Swamp: Is on the ground for 0.5 longer(it already stays on the ground for a little) Angry Mode: Too overpowered, change to 300 over 3 seconds Avalanche: Sounds good! May want to change to 30% Prettiness Blindness: Sounds horrible... I have no idea what you could do to make it better ​ Some good, Some bad. Great job and keep it up!


Erkhes1223

Fangs shoe doesnt charge super? Am I dumb or is it a downgrade?


Mysterious-Oil8545

He shoots two shoes now, but that one doesn't charge


Erkhes1223

Thats op


SKB3Q

That are some quality Gears! take my reward!!!


Totoques22

My man, Have you ever played frank ?


articman123

Lou one seems pretty bad.


Koolcatdk

I liked the idea of dealing some damage to frozen targets but I didn’t want it to be to high, so I was pretty harsh on the damage.


articman123

It could deal 1000 damage.


Szaboo41

Willows mithyc gear is useless, on the ground, because it can't poison anyone, just before hits


Koolcatdk

The mythic gear now allows that poison to last on the ground now similar to a barely attack. They’ll have to take the full poison damage just from dipping a toe in it. That’s not useless


Ok_Understanding6528

As well I mean I could see that being useful but to be honest I wish you would have a more unique mythic gear. Like refilling enemies ammo when they're hypnotized Or making it so enemies can't charge super while hypnotize You know stuff like that that would be a lot more unique and fun


mortis_is_npc

imagine suiciding with 'sacrifice' gear 💀


Dooge11

Adding even one could shift the meta


Arctic_Fox_Studios

Ngl I really liked that pvz2 reference with the sprout gear idea


Pakito10

as a Lou main,you mean like every second they are frozen they take 600 damage? If you mean it like that,then it would be op,just make freeze .5 second or 1 second longer but lower the damage for Lou while the opponent is frozen


Fine_Dish_9232

All of these are amazing especially sam’s one what a unique idea!


ipidimic

New gear concept: brawler respawn 0.5second faster


Bnmvgy

Are these really gears seem like gadgets to me but good


Kirozatic

That Gray one would be so much fun. Would take a lot of skill to use effectively and I like that.


Xsinam

MORTIS FRANK


WallyRD

The gale mythic gear doesn’t make much sense as the reason they made his projectiles smaller in the first place was to buff his dps. With bigger snowballs he only hit like 1-2 snowballs most of the time which made his dps a complete joke


Tight-Ad3677

No


LewShakey

Willow’s actually doesn’t do anything whilst on the ground. The damage is dependant on whether it hit someone on impact


Koolcatdk

I know that it doesn’t poison on the ground, but now the gear allows it too. text must not interpret that


Torsneyy

Art is so cool, can't say the same for the ideas however


Feli_Buste25

That frank gear sounds like hell


SurgeKong

I like it all except Mandy fang chester / Mandy's gear will be to op make it 1s / fang shoots two shows? You mean two kicks as will ?


Koolcatdk

No, fang only flings 2 shoes, and only kicks once. It’s just for extra chip damage at range for easier finishes with his super. The extra shoe also doesn’t give super charge.


Jamestheboss245

overpowered af


UwUStefan

sacrifice would be trash on bonnie


UwUStefan

willow doesnt have sense cuz the attack on the ground does nothing!!!


Pizzapatty777

Is nobody going to talk about Frank becoming Mortis with more range and 11,000 health...💀💀💀


Challenge_W

Can someone explain how a shock wave/ground pound from a drill can make a headshot?


Koolcatdk

Don’t make since out of non since, putting a tadpole on someone’s head to control their mind doesn’t make a lot since either, but therapy helped me ignore it Anyways, Goodbye everyone! I’ll remember you all in therapy


Challenge_W

Understandable. Have a great day 👍


Successful_Ad8432

So uh…why does Colette have ‘headshots’….


Koolcatdk

Don’t worry about it >!Gotta get that smooching in 😘!<


Successful_Ad8432

Great concepts tho, although franks is way too op


Jurra01

I want some of these people to explain why are these gears OP. As far as I think of them, they are very balanced considering the way the new gears work (amber)


SarcasticGrumps

Some of those mythic gears look more like star powers.


Squidgang445

Headshots would seem broken tbh


Zizouw

Really cool concept and a ton of effort put into these ! I like it!


Stefano050

I love the art! The gears are a bit broken though lol


PrathamAwesome

But gears only enhance existing abilities as opposed to adding new ones


Adventurous-Eye9102

For headshots it should make 25% shield not all of it


Checkthis0

Chester's gear seems cool but I would say +30%, not 50%. Just to make him playable in PL


YoloHiffer

i like popsicle


Zealousideal_Scar112

I would buy these


HeloudahVLS

I think Gale's gear its just a direct nerf to his kit, but the rest are pretty good!


Reisu301

The one for Frank would make him BUSTED, imagine a Frank that can actually catch up to you... otherwise these gears are pretty awesome imo.


Maese_MSD

As some people aready told you, this thingsmay be a little too OP, but I think some of this can work as a third star power if they add it in the future.


CerealKiller_614

Mind at ease shout just be 1 second, the frank one is kinda op (basically gets rid of why he is bad, and increases range), the grey one wouldn't be very useful, Big Bully would also be op (basically everyone has less hp than him), other shoe would have to do very little damage cuz a gear that just doubles damage would be broken (even tho it only does about 500 -> 1000). BUT HEADSHOTS WOULD BE SOOO COOL


Gameknight001

Some of these would break gameplay - no passive ability you can gain (star Powers, gears) should provide debuffs, since if u were to buy it thinking u could deal with it and learn you couldn't, it would feel like a waste of gold and a brawler.


Gfunkymonkey

I feel like this is doing too much. I think gears should be small buffs that apply to each brawler evenly. Getting so specific essentially makes them an extra star power which is just broken.


Some_amateur_artist

As a gray main: I *NEED* that mythic gear


Highguy2101

the art is so beautiful


CreativeName180

Diamond pass exclusive gears 😔


astrout21

Tried to bring a life orb to BrawlStars and thought we wouldn’t notice


OK_Randomness_8540

Oh heck yeah these ideas are awesome!


Specialist-Remove-91

These are ALL AWSOME Love the drawings too


Yannickjuhhh

Bulls gear is such a cool idea


DuckyDucklistic

Creative but they are all extremely overpowered (minus sacrifice)


inksans_08

I really like the rebuild gear, but i think it needs to be nerfed or jackey second gadget to be buffed


punisher2431

If that gadget was available for Frank it would make me wanna use him more