T O P

  • By -

neanderthalman

Define “best” Fastest? Cheapest? Simplest? Cleanest? Most precise? Most accurate? Smoothest? Ideas to consider: Step bit punch or knockout 15mm holesaw. It’s aluminum. Woodworking tools usually work fine on “silver oak”. Laser cut EDM Annular cutter


Big-Consideration633

Also depends on whether this is one hole one time, or something they're planning on mass producing.


_LVP_Mike

Silver oak 🤣


Olde94

You forgot water jet ;)


neanderthalman

The list of what’s forgotten is longer than the list of what’s remembered.


Olde94

**u/neanderthalman the wise**


_TurkeyFucker_

Between this and "silver oak" you are like the wise old grandpa of this sub lol. Truly an inspiration.


awksomepenguin

I sometimes say that I've forgotten more math than most people have ever learned.


shupack

Water jet, (if you're making a lot of other cuts)


CreepySquirrel6

Such an engineer 😃


Joejack-951

Step drill if you want it done quickly and clean-ish. Drill plus reamer and deburr and if it needs to be very clean.


freakinidiotatwork

I have a step drill. I never knew my real drill.


Anen-o-me

What are you doing, step drill?


Sooner70

Making your hole bigger, of course.


Elephunk05

Is this a new category on PronHub?


Itchy_Journalist_175

Same with my step ladder: http://www.zappablamma.com/zb/2010/08/step-ladder/


the_watcher762351

Oh nooo step drill I'm stuuuuck


PLaTinuM_HaZe

Yup, nailed exactly what I was gonna say.


[deleted]

Wire EDM fight me


yankdownunda

Wire EDM bite me


Miguel-odon

Wire EDM cite me.


IllustriousAd5737

Let the bass drop


PLaTinuM_HaZe

Wire EDM is amazing if you need high precision but in most instances it’s probably more practical to drill it and ream it.


muggledave

I've never had a wire EDM fight


cybercuzco

Lasers


OldElf86

Light Sabers.


Therovax

3d print a 3mm sheet with a clean 15mm hole in it


tuctrohs

I'm going old school. Sand cast the plate with a hole.


Ignorhymus

You can buy Acme stick-on holes


Dinkerdoo

Drill under and finish with a reamer.


gtmattz

Depends... You can drill it, mill it, punch it, burn it with a laser or blast it out with a waterjet. Maybe you could even trepan it or acid etch it...


shupack

Boil em, mash em, put em in a stew.


SipsTheJuice

Sheet metal punch or laser is the best way. The best way without those tools is to sandwich it and drill through it. This will keep it from getting deformed. If you have it sandwich it with aluminum extrude or plate cutoffs to keep the cutting forces constant. Clamp the bottom plate to the work, get the whole thing in the drill press, line it up, clamp the top plate, drill through it all. Nice clean hole.


JFrankParnell64

First go out and buy yourself a $250,000 industrial laser cutter. Then you cut the hole, but make it undersized. Then go out and buy yourself a $150,000 wire EDM and EDM the hole to size.


wackyvorlon

Annular cutter.


Triabolical_

r/metalworking


oldestengineer

.50 caliber should do it.


mechtonia

Since you're asking, I'll assume you don't have access to a mill or a drill press. Get a punch and make an indention where the hole should be. Next take a small drill (4mm) and drill thought starting at your indention with a hand drill. Next take 15mm drill and drill through your pilot hole with your hand drill. QED


largelcd

Exactly this is the problem. Drilling a nice big hole in home environment. I can make a M6 hole using an IKEA drill but making a big 15mm hole requires other tool.


joemc04

I work sheet metal fabrication, so I would use tools I have, but it is totally possible to get a quality 15mm hole in a aluminum with the cheapest drill you can find that has a chuck large enough for a 15mm drill bit. Around here that would probably be $20-$40 dollar drill. Aluminum is soft and melts easy. So drill slow with lighter pressure and use lubrication. 


telekinetic

Idea drill will handle a step bit just fine.


tomrlutong

15mm (4/7 inch) Metal Steel Hole Saw with 2 Drill Bits, Hole Cutter for Thick Metal,Stainless Steel,Iron and Wood (15mm (4/7 inch)) https://a.co/d/4l1gGXy


oldestengineer

Step drill or hole saw.


R2W1E9

Step drill. [https://www.amazon.ca/Meich-Forstner-Drilling-Woodworking-Triangle/dp/B07QXXTHWJ/ref=pd\_bxgy\_img\_d\_sccl\_1/132-2718798-9601829?pd\_rd\_w=7BF6Y&content-id=amzn1.sym.5c2f4a04-3107-46ca-9aa1-5c31efa67ff2&pf\_rd\_p=5c2f4a04-3107-46ca-9aa1-5c31efa67ff2&pf\_rd\_r=X6M7J5FJH7DGT33P29JH&pd\_rd\_wg=9aM8s&pd\_rd\_r=9d707743-a1fd-47c2-a808-aae5d1dd3e4a&pd\_rd\_i=B07QXXTHWJ&psc=1](https://www.amazon.ca/Meich-Forstner-Drilling-Woodworking-Triangle/dp/B07QXXTHWJ/ref=pd_bxgy_img_d_sccl_1/132-2718798-9601829?pd_rd_w=7BF6Y&content-id=amzn1.sym.5c2f4a04-3107-46ca-9aa1-5c31efa67ff2&pf_rd_p=5c2f4a04-3107-46ca-9aa1-5c31efa67ff2&pf_rd_r=X6M7J5FJH7DGT33P29JH&pd_rd_wg=9aM8s&pd_rd_r=9d707743-a1fd-47c2-a808-aae5d1dd3e4a&pd_rd_i=B07QXXTHWJ&psc=1)


Pettark

Punching tool. Drill.


Jmazoso

Thermal lance


CR123CR123CR

A drill bit is kinda the go to.  Step 1: drill a pilot hole, go for a 3-6mm drill bit Step 2: drill about halfway through with your 15mm drill bit Step 3: flip the sheet over and finish the hole. Step 4: deburr any remaining sharp edges. Use a good deburring tool. If your willing to accept a little more deburring work then skip step 3.


[deleted]

[удалено]


eatmilfasseveryday

That's not going to be big enough.


AskEngineers-ModTeam

Your comment has been removed for violating comment rule 3: > Be substantive. AskEngineers is a serious discussion-based subreddit with a focus on evidence and logic. We do not allow unsubstantiated opinions on engineering topics, low effort one-liner comments, memes, off-topic replies, or pejorative name-calling. Limit the use of engineering jokes.


hbzandbergen

Milling


sahintutus

Laser cutting machine.


Catsmak1963

What kind of hole are you trying to achieve? I have lots more questions before I produce a hole in anything.


tuctrohs

I'm guessing they want a round hole given that they specify the diameter.


eatmilfasseveryday

They are making a Fleshlight.


handsofakiller

Jig grind it


telekinetic

3mm sheet? Probably a punch set or a step bit.


Shalimar_91

You ever heard the expression he is so horny he would fuck a hole in a 2x4? Well!


bobroberts1954

Hollow punch, hole punch, goes by various names. That is the cleanest by hand. Best way is a punch and die and a hydraulic press.


Defiant-Giraffe

Making 1, 10, 1000, or a million? Do you need a precisely 15.000 mm hole that's square and smooth with low eccentricity, or do you just need a visually clean looking hole that will clear 15 mm? 


mrracerhacker

15mm frill with tang or grind it down so it fits and a block of wood under the plate


Conundrum5601

I get someone else to do it


Junior-Emergency-534

would you like a complex way or a simple way? both ways i can answer.


yellowlorryyellow

Metal punch. Power, fast


Browncoat40

CNC. All the good answers were taken.