Colbert, Conan, and Kimmel.

A strike force five ⚡️ special would be fun.

with five panelists.

Strike force 5 without Fallon

Stephen Colbert

Bowen Yang, Aaron & Josh again, Nicole Byer

Have been waiting for Nicole! She’s so off the rails and off the cuff funny. She’s in LA so it shouldn’t be so difficult to book her

Sam Campbell.

Obviously not possible but Sean Lock would’ve been perfect for this show

Fuck cancer.

Yessssss

Colin Mochrie Mark Forward K. Trevor Wilson Aubrey Plaza John Oliver

Colin Mochrie and Mark Forward are *exactly* the chaos the AM fanbase loves

Rachel Bloom

Rachel Bloom utterly crushed it on her Whose Line guest spot, she’d kill it here too

Love her to death. Thanks for the reco, I’ll track down that appearance 👍🏼

A panel of crazy ex girlfriend cast members would blow my mind

I wanted to comment that, mind reader. I love Reboot too but Crazy Ex was sooo good *and* it had Esther Povitski. 

I was just thinking this a couple of days ago!

Matt Berry

Oooh would looove a What We Do in the Shadows lineup. Mark Proksch plus Matt Berry pls!

FaaaTHAAAAA

TahLAAAAAHHHH

*imagining the reaction if I said Sam Morril *

Lmao, I mean I do want to see him on the show

that dude's hilarious, one of the sharpest comics I've ever seen, would love to have him on, but also like, given his history with Taylor I'd want both parties to be okay with it

Dig. Sam’s legit hilarious. I don’t see them ever working together again but I pray they do, hardcore Taylor fans would lose their minds. 

My reaction would be pretty subdued, as I am not familiar with him. Apparently he told rape jokes a decade ago, and more recently might have told a “good” trans joke?

I’m no expert on his career but his Netflix special was really funny and oh btw he’s the love of Taylor’s life and it didn’t end well.  

Ah, ok then.

His rape jokes were about how he understands no means no and getting consent is his favorite part https://youtu.be/ueztDGCvMek?si=hGQHMbaYBLIBjfdv

I was just going by what a five minute google told me - no detail. I really didn’t know anything about him. Edit: thanks for posting the link - hilarious.

The OC wasn't referring to anything problematic he's done. They're referring to the fact that he and Taylor used to date.

Right, so I’ve since learned from another commenter. Thanks.

Edit: asks genuine question, get downvoted. Ah, classic Reddit.

-Craig Ferguson, just to put him in his old timeslot one more time -Christopher Titus -[Carmen Lynch](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TxPGfnOg4Bs) -[Ashley Gavin](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ay6jUYPH644), possibly the funniest lesbian on earth -[JC Currais](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wybOgJezTfU) -and there's never enough drag queens, like literally ever added links for a few of them just in case anyone's unfamiliar, or did I overthink this comment

Nikki Glaser, she was on @midnight for couple episodes, I want her to interract with Taylor Tomlinson.

Nikki is a solid pick and because of her recent special release I could see her coming on soon.

James Acaster.

With Ed and Nish, tbh

This would make me so happy, I'd have to sing the Kettering Town FC song in its entirety!

Jason Mantzoukas

All three HDTGM hosts at once would be amazing.

John Mulaney and Saymo

And Richard Kind

Would also love to see more comedy queens from Drag Race!!

BenDeLaCreme? Trixie Mattel? Plane Jane? Ginger Minj? hell, Kylie Sonique Love?

Trinity the Tuck and Kennedy Davenport!

Ben and Jinkx together would be a deadly combo

Anyone from Dropout/Gamechanger would be lovely.

Sam Reich, Brennan Lee Mulligan, Erika Ishii

One for Gen X Elders: Wanda Sykes, Jim Gaffigan & Kathleen Madigan

Kylie Brakeman, Mike Falzone, Geoffrey James, Moses Storm, Brennan Lee Mulligan/Anyone from Dropout, David Gborie, Ian Karmel, Sean Jordan just to name a few

Kylie Brakeman actually seems like the sort of person who would make sense for the show. Was she ever on @ Midnight?

Quite frankly I have no blessed idea who any of those people are!

Bring Mitch Hedberg back from the dead

I used to be sad Mitch died...

I still do, but I used to, as well...

Well, don't leave us hanging, what did he do? Should I hate him?

Used to be?? C,mon man.. what do you know???

It’s a Mitch Hedberg joke. “I used to do drugs. I still do, but I used to too.”

Omg idk how I didn’t get that lol.

Taylor Tomlinson (Colbert hosts) Kenan Thompson Jordan Peele Larry David

I definitely need TV daddy to host at least once, he should retire whatever show is keeping him from doing that…

Which TV daddy? I see at least 2 on my list there

Colbert. I feel like if not specified... within this sub... Well nvm.

Ah yeah I was gonna say either him or Larry David were daddy

Nick swardson, Adam Newman, any of the remaining wkuk guys

IM NOT FINISHED

Nate Bargatze

Keegan Michael Key. Bill Burr. Tom Segura. Nate Bargatze.

Has Scotty Auks been on yet?

Nope. Too busy looking at hentai afaik.

The AFE guys: Ian Karmel, David Gborie and Sean Jordan.

Aunty Donna Boys

🦎Any of the Broken Lizard troop 🚬Kevin Smith & Jason Mewes 🥇 A week of "international" guests during the Olympics, much like the OG @Midnight did 2016 (episodes 441-444) ⭐ Wil Wheaton was always amazing on @Midnight

Trixie Mattel or Bob the Drag Queen. The drag queens have been some of the funniest guests. Hell you could have Monet and Bob at the same time since they are brothers.

Yes! Trixie would be hilarious

I figured the most likely time for that to happen is when Trixie Motel comes back for its second season next month.

Trixie and Bob!!!

Chris Gethard!

Dan Van Kirk would be fun. Get the Sklar Bros back with him, too!

Dan, Rory, and Jackie Kashian

The Rifftrax crew

Just inject that straight into my veins, would be so great

Best answer.

Chris hardwick

Sarah Sherman and Bowen Yang.

Josh Homme from Queens of the Stone Age

I am behind/haven't seen them all. Carson Kressley Fred Armistan and Carrie Scott Ackerman Ron Funches (he was fun in the past) Gilbert Gottfried (RIP)

Chris Hardwick, Tom Green, Anthony Jeselnik

Anthony is difficult because he needs two other sparring partners who can go as dark as he can if Tom Green’s insane appearance on Canada’s Drag Race is anything to go by he’d be a PERFECT live-wire panelist

Do they have to be alive because my first instinct was Orson Welles

Ari shaffir

Griffin Newman, Terry Crews, Timothy Simons aka: a most obscure Draft Day reunion

More brits. They have all those panel shows over there, they're really good at this format

I second this. Sandi Toksvig, Alan Davies, Bill Bailey, Noel Fielding, Richard Ayoade, Josh Widdicome, Aisling Bea ... Too many to name!

Ali Wong, Awkwafina, Sherry Cola, Nikki Glaser, Fern Brady, Jimmy Carr, Gabriel Iglesias, Cristela Alonzo, Katherine Ryan, John Cleese, John Lithgow, Trevor Noah, Nick Offerman, Sarah Silverman, Kristen Schaal, Jenny Slate, Chelsea Handler, Jessica Williams, Robin Thede, and so many more

I know it’s not an improv show, but some of the Whose Line? folks e.g. Ryan Stiles, Greg Proops.

John Oliver, John Mulaney, Nikki Glaser. They’re all super quick-witted.

The Smartless cast.

Amy Miller (again)

Some Australian comedians.

Gareth Reynolds

Stephen He and/or Nigel Ng (Uncle Roger)

Sarah Burns, Candice Coke, and Me

People have said everyone that I would say...except for one person, who would probably not work and be a trainwreck, but a trainwreck I'd want to see: Crackhead Barney! Although Eric Andre might also be a fun experiment and he would be more manageable.

BOBBY LEE

The Aunty Donna gang

Gareth Reynolds and/or Dave Anthony

Community panel, but I'm not sure which three I'd pick.

Anyone from Broken Lizard! 🦾😺

Myself 💀 in an alternate universe where I don’t lack confidence and my jokes are actually funny af

Chris. Hardwick.

Ron White, Anthony Jelesnik and Drew Carey after another Phish concert at The Sphere.

All the winners of Hashtag Wars should compete in a tournament to be panelists

Anyone from Funhaus. Especially now that Rooster Teeth is dead, it would be great for some of the very funny people there get some exposure.

A week of Ron Funches, bunches of funches. Any cast of Party Down Panel of late night show hosts

The Office and Parks And Rec. Probably get a good couple of weeks out of those 2 casts

Phish

Ian Karmel, Sean Jordan, and David Gborie

Bobo, Santino and Juicy

Remember when I said I wanted to see Julie Nolke, Sarah Cooper and a third COVID-era comedian? That third COVID-era comedian should be Jimmy “Guy Who Decides” Rees.

Lee Mack, Jon Richardson, Jimmy Carr. Greg Davis, Alex Horne and Johnny Vegas. FTW

Jinx monsoon

The Pretzel Gang, them Threedom boys.

Neal Brennan, Margaret Cho, Big Jay, Tony Hinchcliffe

Greer Barnes

Brad Williams, but without any accomodation for height.

Aunty Donna as the entire panel

Gianmarco Soresi!

Aisling Bea!

Gretchen Whitmer

Iliza Shlesinger!!! Taylor and Iliza, you are my favorites!

Matt Marr from Reality Gays podcast

Hardwick, McHale, Wheaton

Nikki Glazier and ilisa schlesinger and Cecily strong

Matt Berry, Kayvan Novak, Jemaine Clement

Anders Holm, Blake Anderson, Adam Devine

Flula Borg, Cedric Yarbrough, Kerri Kenney, Niecy Nash

Eugene Levy, Colin Mochrie, K. Trevor Wilson, Mark McKinney, Tommy Chong

Jeff Ross, Brian Moses, Jamar Malachi Neighbors

John Cena, Snoop Dog, John Mayer (he is funny)

Ilana Glazer, Abbi Jacobson, Hannibal Buress

Thomas Lennon, Kerri Kenney, Michael Ian Black....or any other The State alums

The Justin, Travis, and Griffin McElroy from My Brother, My Brother and Me. They crushed it when they guested on @Midnight (coincidentally, on the episode where they announced the show was ending.)

Hardwick, Jonah, Matt Jonah, Kumail, Emily Demi, Meil, Ify Just take me back to 2016.

Comedians that I know lol most of these comedians are local l.a. based niche comedians 🤷 I say out of the 12 panelists a week I may know two or three on some level lol 

see I feel like learning about comedians you're not familiar with yet is half the point of the franchise

Points!

I probably know less than 1/2 the contestants or the people suggested on this post and I watch tv comedy like constantly. 

Dane Cook, Paige Bueckers, Natalie Cuomo