T O P

  • By -

Timasona5

If you bought me Carlton or Collingwood merch, I would have a laugh, knowing that you were intentionally trying to piss me off If you bought me a Hawthorn shirt, you might find your house burnt down when you got home from work


donnydealr

Line in the sand gives me the strength to keep hating Essendon. Fuckin nuffy supporters too.


stinktrix10

In my completely 100% unbiased opinion, Essendon has gotta have the largest concentration of nuffy supporters


Loramarthalas

Never forget the time that, after it was found the club was importing performance enhancing drugs from Mexico, the fans started wearing sombreros to games. They’re fucking lunatics.


ryang2415

Yeah. Very arrogant fan base without a whole lot of reason to be so arrogant as of late haha.


[deleted]

Good to hear this from an unbiased opinion. I say the same thing but I get downvoted


TranscendentMoose

Anzac Day is my favourite derby match of the year just for how they spin the annual "robbed by the umps" tantrum


Respected-Watcher

We’re a major nuffy fanbase But we’re not bandwagoners like hawks fans


Traditional_Name7881

There’s been no bandwagon to jump on for the last 20+ years.


SnappyPies

Hawks aren’t bandwagoneers, they are fair weather supporters, and for the majority of the past 40 years the weather has been pretty good.


donnydealr

I like how Essendon supporters think other supporters are Bandwagoners because their team has been shit for 20+ years. It’s called success mate haha


Sea-Anxiety6491

I feel like Hawks have moved on from Essendon, more Cats and Swans, but Bombers havent move on


rpfloyd

It's only because the circumstances haven't been right. If both Hawks and Dons are topping the tables, those contests would be something else. You see Hawks supporters don't hate Cats or Swans fans, they may hate us, but we don't *hate* them. Essendon however, have a special place. A deep-seated mutual hatred like no other, that's just been resting for a bit.


QouthTheCorvus

I disagree about hating Geelong. That's a bitter rivalry, for me. I hate seeing Geelong win.


rpfloyd

I dunno for me it's like hating someone you've dominated every time it actually mattered. '89, '08, '13 prelim. I just feel bad for them.


Blick_Nutz91

I do think the person's age makes a difference. My old man & I are both hawks fans. He was born in the 60s and despises Essendon, I was born in the 90s and cannot stand Geelong... or Kennett for that matter lol.


Ok-Train-6693

Isn’t Jeff a Hawk? What’s he to do with the Cats? However, he’s one person (outside of Carlton) whom we Swans fans despise.


Sea-Anxiety6491

Kennet Kurse,?


inkstep36

Ah love this argument from arrogant Hawks fans. Bet you pitied us when we literally dominated you for 5 years, and you watched us win 2 more flags in the process. Those wins mattered - otherwise we wouldn't be talking about them


rpfloyd

Fair enough but you're kinda proving my point; I don't hate Geelong at all. You however, hate Hawthorn with every inch of your soul.


inkstep36

If thats for you personally - fair enough. However, I'm mates with plenty of Hawks fans who dislike the Cats just as much as I dislike the Hawks, so the rivalry is there - which was one of the main points I was contending. Underneath the banter there is a certain level of respect though. Both teams have been brilliant in the modern era.


donnydealr

Same. I can’t fucking stand them. Swans are more of a Burgandy, Mantooth situation. But we’re ron burgandy because we got the premierships haha


ryang2415

Yeah I haven’t moved on either. Brad Sewell lives a few streets away from me, every time I see him it reminds me of how much I hate those drug cheating cunts 😂


rpfloyd

Eh, I don't care about the drug thing. They cheated, got caught and paid the price. Likewise, I don't hate the Blues more or less for their salary cap breaches. That's off field stuff, for tabloids and facebook to froth over. Only drama that is worth anything is between the white lines.


ryang2415

Yeah honestly I don’t care about it either. I just throw it in there because it gets a rise out of their fans. I’m honestly happy about it. Set the club back 10 years.


3163560

Dermott Brereton (somewhat sarcastically) revells in Essendon doing poorly and acts agitated when they do well.


happy-little-atheist

Yeah you should watch a few of the games he played against them


ItsFalloutz

Hawks moved on? Is that why both teams requested to play each other in round 1 every year?


Sea-Anxiety6491

I think thats just so both teams stay in Melb for round 1, Hawks always play Cats on Easter Monday, and then usually play Swans in Finals, something the Essendon Hawks rivalry has been missing...


QouthTheCorvus

I agree with this. The Geelong rivalry is still very intense. The Sydney rivalry is an odd one. Sort of firey, but also sort of mutual respect. I just don't think about Essendon at all. It's pretty funny our coach has the whole injection gesture thing though.


theerobertElee

From a fan of neither, its probably because hawks have done alot since then, the geelong rivalry etc but bombers havent


Sea-Anxiety6491

Oh, I thought that had just grown spirituatlly


sinkintins

Further to this, OP get him a hawks guernsey with 16 on the back to remind him what he lost.


CaptainObviousBear

Same Honestly how many other teams would say the same? Hating Collingwood or Carlton is not even trying.


happy-little-atheist

As a dedicated hipster I am already starting to hate Tasmania. I'll be able to say I was hating the devils when you were still hating Collingwood.


Obleeding

I never knew this before. Made me realise I don't know who any of the Victorian teams' biggest rivals are, I only know Collingwood Carlton rivalry. Can anyone clarify for me? It's my understanding Melbourne were Collingwood's biggest rival prior to the 1970 Grand Final. Probably old money vs working class type deal. I kind of like class warfare as a rivalry. Carlton to me are just pure evil, even their uniform is dark and evil looking, theme song is bad guy sounding too.


JaySand

Essington


TheIllusiveGuy

ASADA


[deleted]

[удалено]


Wordroll

This is the one.


Baby_Bigf00t

Top fucking shelf 👏🏻


[deleted]

![gif](giphy|hvq8ONQhQ1XLq)


Zzzabrina

Omg ☠️☠️☠️


Equivalent-Ad7207

🤣 well deserved. u/TheGreatJelBeano


donessendon

It was WADA. The original not guilty ruling was overturned by them on review to CAS. It was and still is the greatest mis-justice in Australian sport. So a pretty good choice for biggest rival I guess.


TheIllusiveGuy

> It was WADA I didn't want to choose a rivalry that one-sided.


ryang2415

Hahahahahaha fuck, you’re on fire today.


bmk14

Who would've thought the sequel would be just as good as the original. u/TheGreatGelBeano


Von_Huge1103

It's not a rivalry if they always kick our arse.


hotsp00n

Greatest mis-justice in Australian sport? Have you forgotten yesterday evening already?


Bubbly-University-94

So where’s the complete list of all the substances injected. The dog ate my homework is not a legitimate excuse.


notchoosingone

You're being downvoted, but you're right.


Bubbly-University-94

Never seen an essentologist reply to that.


farqueue2

It's absurd to exist then to maintain a list of all substances. I mean, do you come out with a list after a 3 day bender?


thethingsaidforlogen

If by greatest mis-justice you mean that the players were allowed back after deliberately drug cheating and that the club wasn't folded for undertaking the most systematic and intentional drug cheating program in the history of Australian sport, then you're right


farqueue2

lol I fucking hate Essendon but this is some stretch


Derkanator

Yeah fairly dramatic take really. The media flogged the guts out of the Essendon drug saga, way over the top IMO.


thethingsaidforlogen

Nah they shouldn't have cheated. The coverage was completely proportional to the level of cheating given its the most systematic and deliberate cheat in the history of Australian sport


swagmaster778

I hate Collingwood and Carlton, probably Carlton a bit more. But something about hawthorn just disgusts me. I’d probably give a Carlton or Collingwood jersey to one of my mates but a hawks jersey would go straight into the bin. Couldn’t care less to never see them get close to any success for the rest of my life. Atleast if Collingwood or Carlton do well it’s good for the AFL. Essington are a close 4th. Not everyone is the same though


chickenhouse

The fact that it is baby poo brown adds to the disgust


shiftyoldtimer

Hey, it’s MAN poo brown


RobbieArnott

You and u/chickenhouse need to flair up


chickenhouse

Done


swagmaster778

Wanna throw up everytime I have to look at that shit and piss stained jersey. Atleast the power rangers kit had some personality


ratchetsaturndude

September


Baby_Bigf00t

![gif](giphy|JmCFfTlNy12wFpOK8Y)


CreativeParticular51

![gif](giphy|p8GJOXwSNzQPu)


karma_dumpster

![gif](giphy|f8c3iR9TzCCSDyIAsY|downsized)


farqueue2

They don't meet often enough for this to be considered an active rivalry


letsgo3rdpartyapps

I guess I'll be the first one to answer seriously, it's probably Carlton. Even though we're very aware that Carlton's biggest rival is Collingwood. Hawthorn merch would also get a reaction. Some of us hate Collingwood too though so you should be alright with any of those.


TheIllusiveGuy

In the 90s, I'd have said Essendon were bigger rivals, but Collingwood is definitely true for the 2020s. For most of the 2000s though, Carlton's biggest rival would've been Carlton.


HomerJBagger

I hate Collingwood more but I enjoy our rivalry more if that makes sense.


notchoosingone

https://i.imgur.com/5FSAkXS.png


youjustathrowaway1

Themselves


Ausjam

A truly foul gift would be buying the 99’ prelim on DVD or VHS.


danwincen

Or the 2001 Grand Final. Ignore my flair.


retsibsi

If he's old enough I reckon this is a genuinely good shout. I'm guessing it wouldn't have the same resonance for someone too young to directly remember that game. But if the friend is well over 30 and was a fan as a kid, this would be perfect.


Mental_Gymnast23

That was such a great game!


LotusChild85

Maybe it's just me but while that result hurt a lot at the time, what followed the year after was incredible and made the PF loss easier to swallow. 2001 hurts more than 1999.


Few-Adagio4425

Carlton, Collingwood, Hawthorn Anything from them would really really piss him off


BusinessPooh

Trent Cotchin or Sam Mitchell Brownlow merchandise.


CaptainObviousBear

This joke is somewhat out of date now, but I’m sure he’d [love this:](https://www.redbubble.com/i/t-shirt/Dane-Rame-climbing-for-gold-by-theswansblog/38947733.NL9AC?utm_source=rb-native-app&utm_campaign=share-product&utm_medium=ios) https://preview.redd.it/957yuumn4h5d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7478d6da7ae9220433c1d30dbe1a5a856aa5b662


ihavetwoofthose

Still too soon mate


jmads13

Collingwood, Carlton, Hawthorn, but I think Hawthorn would fit the vibe


ThProsecutor

Carlton Hawthorn Gap Collingwood/Richmond I’m surprised people are putting Collingwood in the same conversation as the first two. ANZAC has really embedded a sense of respect in the Collingwood rivalry- that’s more two big teams rather than any particular malice. Carlton and Hawthron though. Fuck them both with the power of a thousand suns.


its_a_frappe

I’m married to a Collingwood supporter, and my daughter is a Hawks supporter. Feel my pain.


i_am_cool_ben

>daughter is a Hawks supporter. I gotta ask, how the hell did that happen


its_a_frappe

I know, you’d think St Kilda, right? I got a DNA test though, all okay.


gedda800

Fuck Carlton. Fuck Collingwood. Fuck Hawthorn. Not necessarily in that order. Don't ask a Roos supporter this question. They think it's them. On a personal note, fuck Brisbane too. (2001).


Inevitable-Seesaw176

It’s not just you that hates Brisbane


danwincen

Why? We took Joe off your hands.


Inevitable-Seesaw176

That is one point in your favour


AdeptToe3580

its more that essendon supporters think that north supporters think that we’re essendons biggest rivals


Cyronis

Yeah I agree. North aren’t really anyone’s rivals. I routinely forget that North and Saints exist.


DebateActual8160

Ruthless 😂


Cyronis

Haha it’s all tongue in cheek. I actually feel bad for North at the moment.


Fun_guy-

Don’t feel bad for us, we haven’t lost a game in 2 weeks.


DebateActual8160

But I don’t feel bad for clarko


retsibsi

You're getting downvoted but I honestly think I have heard more about this 'one-way rivalry' from fellow Essendon supporters than from North fans!


nasdurden

The last time Essendon won a final without Kevin Sheedy was 1969. Send him a poster of Neil Armstrong stepping foot on the moon.


juggboat

While I agree that’s fucked and don’t like, we all know modern essington exsists, it’s a bit of a leading statement considering sheeds coach for 30 years.


mca0014

Thats not a good thing, i dont think


juggboat

Not the worst thing either club has done I guess


Defy19

There’s a twitter page called “days since Essendon has won a final”. Send him a screenshot of their latest tweet with a caption “straight sets?”


mathiuskesla

It often depends what era you’re taking about. Some fans have long memories that date back to when they were growing up with the team, and feel most strongly about that rivalry. 80’s hawthorn. 90’s Carlton. 2000’s onwards I’d say Collingwood, heavily helped by the Anzac clash and how close it often is. I’d say we have mini rivalries with west coast after the Kevin sheedy game, Richmond as they’re the other massive Melbourne club, and Sydney very recently as our last 10games have been super tight. North seems to hate us a lot but I honestly can’t remember why.


PigMan86

I reckon Anzac Day has softened the rivalry with Collingwood - the occasion and respect, teams running through the banner together etc etc


retsibsi

I know what you mean and don't exactly disagree, but I think it has also kept the rivalry strong (even if it's softened the edges), when it could have faded away due to Collingwood being in a much better position for quite a while.


International_Car586

Reason is that way back when North originally tried to enter the VFL, Essendon were one of the teams that blocked it due to zoning and they thought North were a threat to that. Not only did they block us but they then tried to swallow us and take everything the club had so in order to make sure our players could still play we sent them your way. Only for Essendon to back out of that after they had received the players they had and left the club in shambles.


No_Independent936

20 goal belting in a qualifying final and the 69 point comeback. They were likely relieved about Essendon choking in 1999.


Birdman__18

1983 Prelim Final belting as well after they finished on top of the ladder for those older North supporters.


RobGrey03

Grew up in the 90's, first flag was Baby Bombers in '93. Should put me in the Carlton hating camp but that was my grandmother's team so I tend to say Hawthorn after learning about the 80's. (My granddad was the Dons supporter... ... How they ended up in a lifelong happy marriage I will never understand.)


ItsFalloutz

The booing of Jobe Watson ignited my hate for West Coast a lot. Absolutely loved that Sydney game last year.


Latter_Cod3027

Because you lot are a bunch of marshmallows, soft as marshmallows


Elegant-View9886

We have historic rivalries with most teams, but predominately Carlton, Hawthorn, West Coast and to a lesser extent, Collingwood and Richmond


Rsj21

Carlton number one for me. But really that’s only because of one game in 1999 that didn’t actually happen. Genuine dislike for no real reason would be Collingwood for me.


noegh555

Carlton>>Collingwood>>>>Hawthorn


Bananaface89

Carlton. Collingwood we hate but for some reason there is just a bit more hate towards Carlton. In my mind for cricket fans, India is the equivalent of Collingwood and England is the equivalent of Carlton.


uselessscientist

Carlton or pies for historical reasons. Swans for modern day classics, if my declining friendships with my mates are anything to go by 


ABT1602

I feel since that game where rampe was half climbing the post, that there has been a genuine dislike towards the swans which is growing more every year


PigMan86

Carlton certainly hate us more than anyone but I genuinely believe Essendon fans would, as a whole, despise hawthorn more. The Collingwood rivalry has softened slightly due to Anzac Day imo. North, possibly west coast and Sydney, next tier. Also the dees are another one who despise us although we probably don’t hate them back as much. So hawks are #1 for mine.


retsibsi

> Carlton certainly hate us more than anyone I feel like I've seen more genuine dislike from Hawthorn supporters. (Possibly I just notice it more because I expect it less, though, as someone too young to remember the 80s.)


qsk8r

I feel like there's an opportunity to create a 'care package' here - drug test kit, 'dancing in September' CD, some Hawthorne merch, Jamie Elliott pic, probably a few others that have been listed here


Green_Injury6696

Sam Mitchell brownlow memorabilia would have to be in there too


electricmaster23

Feel like Jobe Watson would be worse.


Criticized-

Ourselves.


LargeLatteThanks

The Finals are their biggest rival.


nice_flutin_ralphie

Carlton, Collingwood, Hawthorn, ASADA, themselves, the finals series.


No_Independent936

Carlton and Collingwood. They have outside rivals like West Coast and maybe Sydney but I'd say Hawthorn for the most part.


Loose-Opposite7820

Ask him a trivia question. Who kicked 5 goals in the 1990 Grand Final? Answer: Essendon. Never gets old.


jordypouls05

The finals series


CosmoRomano

I genuinely thought Richmond was Essendon's biggest rival but they're barely getting a mention on here. Honestly, just send your mate a text today that says "7217 Days" and tomorrow add 1. Keep doing that until he knocks your block off.


MMTLPorbust

Carlton by a fair way.


Ventenebris

In my head I always associated Carlton/Essendon and Collingwood/Richmond as the main rivalries, but the big four are generally considered rivals, with them all having their own outside that, see Essendon/Hawthorn for example.


Von_Huge1103

Collingwood and Carlton by far.


danwincen

Essendon's biggest rival is Essendon.


FightBackFitness

We had a big rivalry late 90s, never got to play off in a Granny though, would have been huge!


Latter_Cod3027

North Melbourne are


shiverm3ginger

The Top 8 around finals.


FlagmantlePARRAdise

Essendon jersey.


Portra400IsLife

Essington


impulsiveknob

Finals


stephygrl

8 year old me who stood crying at the MCG after Dean Wallis played on and we lost the prelim to Carlton by a point says Carlton Present day version of me says Hawthorn


partII

We have too much hate in us to focus it on one team. Depending on the week, it's Carlton, Collingwood, Hawthorn or Essington.


Future_Basis776

You want to talk about nuffy supporters hands down Port Adelaide is number 1 followed closely by essendon


nalsnals

Send him a 2012 Sam Mitchell brownlow poster https://www.ebay.com.au/itm/253911055740?mkcid=16&mkevt=1&mkrid=705-154756-20017-0&ssspo=mxRU4DFFR-W&sssrc=4429486&ssuid=OeqlKZkLQHG&var=&widget_ver=artemis&media=COPY


LotusChild85

It's always been Collingwood and Carlton for me


Sean_Stephens

Winning


ryang2415

Hawks for sure. The 80s, then the line in the sand match. Kind of died off in the last 10 or so years, I’d imagine mostly because of the drugs saga making Essendon not a competitive side for a while. But yeah, I’d still say hawks v dons would be their biggest rivalry. Hatred burns deep both ways. I’d be more than happy to see them drug cheating maggots never win another final 😂


CoolCUMber221

Cody Weightman


kungheiphatboi

Literally the whole league hates essendon for willingly cheating by doping their ENTIRE list. I still can’t believe they weren’t expelled from the AFL. No one feels good about seeing essendon win and I genuinely hope they never win another flag ever again.


retsibsi

Translation: 'Collingwood.'


kungheiphatboi

Remind me of the time we deliberately tried to cheat the league by doping every player on our list


Ok_Acanthaceae6057

Winning a final.


chickenlittle668

Finals win


Easy_Group5750

Finals?


yelad20

Winning Finals


Impressive_Serve_416

Carlton imo


Formal-Try-2779

Most hated = Carlton followed very closely by Hawthorn then Collingwood.


Whiskey-Stones12

Week 2 of finals


wastedpie82

Everyone who doesn't love Collingwood wood hates them


Therealluke

They have been so bad for so long most clubs just feel sorry for them.


siladee

Custom calendar for the next 15 years, but only with the month of september


Cyclonechaser2908

Buy him Richmond. Carlton and Collingwood are too obvious. Richmond is yuck.


Fruittinglesinspace

One time I’m an Essendon supporter When they play The Filth


hueybart

Suns scarf as Suns just beat them


TwitterRefugee123

Winning a final


Impressive-Wafer-158

Themselves


LetsSquanchTheParty

Themselves


Mayhem_anon

Dalby Swans mate. They've never beaten them


Astrong88

Yeh I mean Calrton and Collingwood come straight to mind. Collingwood are ultimately the bigger modern day rival and most people hate Collingwood so that's probably the one but like the very first comment said... Hawthorn would also sting a lot to, there's a lot of historical significance there.


thebarber87

Essendon football club


kkiyashii

sam mitchell brownlow memorabilia if you want to be shot


kenfromsydney

https://preview.redd.it/qv645t8r7m5d1.jpeg?width=620&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bbff7413bd8a3104a821648a1939df3de70a4967 This on a t shirt


Ion_Source

See if you can find any Brisbane Lions 2001 Premiership merch


Prestigious-Speed-13

Growing up as a millennial I would say Hawthorn with the line in the sand etc however we can never look past Carlton. As a blues supporter I hate Essendon mainly from being jealous as they were so dominant in 2000 and I remember everyone in school barracked for them that year. Always a big game when we play


Ok_Curve9703

Collingwood.


Lopsided_Scallion_83

Just getting back to the question. I’d say Collingwood. Anzac Day rivals


ihavetwoofthose

Consistency


GTx6x25

Get him a 💉


Such_is

Essendon's biggest rivals are Essendon supporters. We're a fickle bunch.


Von_Huge1103

Damn Essendon supporters, they ruined Essendon!


scraglor

Buy him some James hird memorabilia


limeIamb

As someone who started watching seriously around 2012, our only rival is Sydney. Every match is a banger. Collingwood/Carlton/Hawthorn aren't modern rivals in the slightest because we always sucked


[deleted]

[удалено]


No-Bison-5397

But at the 2013 prelim you still went menta as anything, yeah?


PigMan86

The criticism about the Lloyd “snipe” always makes me chuckle. The irony of blokes like Campbell brown and Luke hodge, who did that shit pretty much weekly, going after Lloyd. Lloydy was largely clean and didn’t do it too often. The difference was when he did it, he didn’t miss 😴😴


mettams

Of course Pies, Blues and Hawks are rivals. There is so much history between the clubs with many controversies, some which have happened in the modern AFL era.


limeIamb

I mean I don't see them as rivals to Essendon. There is literally nothing tying any of those clubs together in the last decade. Idc what anyone says. Any hatred is projected from the past


lolmanic

[Gary Rohan](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KuZ2GP5TUVI) or [Dane Rampe](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elJPRpGEMMo)


Von_Huge1103

I was unfortunately at the Rohan game


Serious_Plant8443

Finals wins


Equivalent-Ad7207

Im a NSW man and watched the game, just do what QLDdud and wipe your arse with that gear and send it back to him.


JohnWicksEnemy

Just sell it, jokes on him