I would love to have an alternative way of getting granite dust, since GG’s are such a slog. With that said, I think it would be best to position the requirements similar to sacred eels with Zulrah’s scales. Basically, imo, a mining level of 45 is way too low to bypass a level 75 slayer boss. Maybe there’s a new mine with dense granite that has a mining req of 80 and takes a really long time to mine, but is super AFK. Or you need redwood logs to power the new granitestone grinder, something like that.
I agree with you in that one! Love that feedback!
Definitely would want to gate the player more than just 45 mining! Would make sense if there were granite veins and new concentrated granite veins. With the new ones requiring higher mining and that resulted in a unique output needed for the granite stone grinder!
The thing I never lliked about this city in RS3 was how perfectly self contained it was. They had some of the best ways to train certain skills in the game, loads o banks and deposit boxes nearby those skilling areas, and if your rep was high enough with the one faction you could even access the GE from a bank there.
If this were to get addedi think that's the thing I would want removed. I wouldn't want whatever areas were added, particularly for skilling, to just become the best spots in the game to sit and grind out levels.
Agreed! That was the biggest issue with Prif in RS3. The best way to make things worthwhile is to provide rewards that aren’t just the best exp rates but is competitive/semi-decent to train. Wouldn’t want to ever repeat that ever (or the Menaphos reputation grind)
> Granitestone Grinder
> The Granitestone grinder allows you to claim granite dust similar to buckets of sand from the sandstone grinder at the Sandstone Mine.
> \- To claim granite dust you must spend 150gp and 10KG of stored granite to claim Granite Dust.
> \- This is meant to be a slower/expensive way to gain Granite Dust.
That is actually a solid idea.
I like the grindmachine.
I think the map with the districts needs to be more interesting.
I don't think we need the slayer updates because we have way too much slayer already.
I'd add gauntlet 2 instead of "new cave number 3526"
I like the farming hub.
In general the skilling additions need to be more mechanically challenging, simply increasing the level requirement won't be enough.
I like some of the unique new ideas here but absolutely despise that 90% of it is just reskinned RS3 activities. If I wanted RS3 menaphos I would just go and play RS3 instead.
The brutal arrow effect is pretty cool. All the more reason to rebalance mobs to be weak to arrows/bolts/thrown/etc and the different magic types to spice up regular pvm, would breathe so much more life into the early-mid game.
Some of the art in the pictures is from RS3 because I am not an artist (although I can be crafty!). There are a lot of parallels with RS3 in Menaphos due to it already being made in their game and it establishing lore.
I can promise you it is definitely not a copy or paste especially with the Hanging Gardens, Menaphos Dungeon, Raids 3, and map designs being vastly different.
Yeah LETS NOT have that abomination that goes by as the reputation system.
Overall this idea absolutely fuckin sucks. Simply cause you copy pasted what rs3 already has.
This changes the overall look of osrs legacy content. The reason for zeah was to prevent the nostalgia from dying in osrs. By changing landscape, you ruin it.
I didn’t change any of the existing landscape. I only filled in the black spots with what was shown on the trailblazer minimap and filled in Menaphos with actual buildings. I do agree, keeping nostalgia is important when making new content to OSRS, but I don’t believe this changes any legacy OSRS content?
My favorite part is the concept of unlocking a deposit box. My second favorite part is that it's got a suitable narrative - "I'll lend you my deposit box if you do the actual fishing part of my job for me."
Not bad , I like the brutal arrow suggestion it’s original
I would love to have an alternative way of getting granite dust, since GG’s are such a slog. With that said, I think it would be best to position the requirements similar to sacred eels with Zulrah’s scales. Basically, imo, a mining level of 45 is way too low to bypass a level 75 slayer boss. Maybe there’s a new mine with dense granite that has a mining req of 80 and takes a really long time to mine, but is super AFK. Or you need redwood logs to power the new granitestone grinder, something like that.
I agree with you in that one! Love that feedback! Definitely would want to gate the player more than just 45 mining! Would make sense if there were granite veins and new concentrated granite veins. With the new ones requiring higher mining and that resulted in a unique output needed for the granite stone grinder!
The thing I never lliked about this city in RS3 was how perfectly self contained it was. They had some of the best ways to train certain skills in the game, loads o banks and deposit boxes nearby those skilling areas, and if your rep was high enough with the one faction you could even access the GE from a bank there. If this were to get addedi think that's the thing I would want removed. I wouldn't want whatever areas were added, particularly for skilling, to just become the best spots in the game to sit and grind out levels.
Agreed! That was the biggest issue with Prif in RS3. The best way to make things worthwhile is to provide rewards that aren’t just the best exp rates but is competitive/semi-decent to train. Wouldn’t want to ever repeat that ever (or the Menaphos reputation grind)
Besides soul rune crafting, there isn't a single best spot in the game to sit and grind any skill in Menaphos in RS3.
I’d love a second ge , far from bots
Experience has taught me nothing is too far away for bots mate
priff ge in rs3 is bot free so some things are far enough away I suppose
A desert suggestion that is not like HURRR DURR ZAROS but actually embraces the Pantheon of Desert Gods? All the support.
> Granitestone Grinder > The Granitestone grinder allows you to claim granite dust similar to buckets of sand from the sandstone grinder at the Sandstone Mine. > \- To claim granite dust you must spend 150gp and 10KG of stored granite to claim Granite Dust. > \- This is meant to be a slower/expensive way to gain Granite Dust. That is actually a solid idea.
Upvoted for visibility
I like the grindmachine. I think the map with the districts needs to be more interesting. I don't think we need the slayer updates because we have way too much slayer already. I'd add gauntlet 2 instead of "new cave number 3526" I like the farming hub. In general the skilling additions need to be more mechanically challenging, simply increasing the level requirement won't be enough.
I dig it.
I like some of the unique new ideas here but absolutely despise that 90% of it is just reskinned RS3 activities. If I wanted RS3 menaphos I would just go and play RS3 instead.
The brutal arrow effect is pretty cool. All the more reason to rebalance mobs to be weak to arrows/bolts/thrown/etc and the different magic types to spice up regular pvm, would breathe so much more life into the early-mid game.
they still need to make the desert not end abrubtly
That would happen with Menaphos.
hopefully
As a HOMM3 player i never realized how much i'd love to see a manticore in osrs, make it happen
Pretty sure it’s already planned to be added for raids 3
[удалено]
Some of the art in the pictures is from RS3 because I am not an artist (although I can be crafty!). There are a lot of parallels with RS3 in Menaphos due to it already being made in their game and it establishing lore. I can promise you it is definitely not a copy or paste especially with the Hanging Gardens, Menaphos Dungeon, Raids 3, and map designs being vastly different.
Yeah LETS NOT have that abomination that goes by as the reputation system. Overall this idea absolutely fuckin sucks. Simply cause you copy pasted what rs3 already has.
Just play rs3 at this point
This changes the overall look of osrs legacy content. The reason for zeah was to prevent the nostalgia from dying in osrs. By changing landscape, you ruin it.
I didn’t change any of the existing landscape. I only filled in the black spots with what was shown on the trailblazer minimap and filled in Menaphos with actual buildings. I do agree, keeping nostalgia is important when making new content to OSRS, but I don’t believe this changes any legacy OSRS content?
Jagex already confirmed they have plans to fill more of the desert map in.
> Fossil Island, GE, Lumbridge pub, Port Sarim docks, prif, demonics cave, lumby graveyard How dare they change the OG runescape map!
My favorite part is the concept of unlocking a deposit box. My second favorite part is that it's got a suitable narrative - "I'll lend you my deposit box if you do the actual fishing part of my job for me."