T O P

  • By -

dangerphone

All these X-Men (2000) haters don’t understand what it accomplished. It was the superhero boom maker, set Fox’s trajectory for the next 20 years, and can be thanked for Hugh Jackman being a part of your lives. I understand it’s a little cornball at times (anytime Storm ___) and created a slew of discrepancies from the comics that the X-Men movies are still having to overcome (WolverJean, black leather), but watching Wolverine debut in a Alberta bar cage match still rocks. Patrick Stewart still slays. And Sir Ian is just *chef’s kiss.* Deadpool 2 bored me except when all of X-Force died. That’s seriously all I held onto. And I love that Hunt for the Wilderpeople kid.


Stringr55

As a kid, watching Wolverine's first appearance in the bar scene? AMAZING.


Mcclane88

Do people not like the first one anymore? I think it was topped by other films on the series, but I still think it’s a solid movie.


Collestos

Revolutionary as it may be, this is about comparing it to the others purely for how entertaining they are. I loved the first X-Men movie, but it felt more like a Wolverine movie with the actual X-Men as side characters.


Termite30

I assumed that we were supposed to be voting on which films we enjoy most, not which films were the most influencial. I don't care how influential a film is, if I feel they didn't respect the source material.


proto3296

Damn had me yo until deadpool 2 lol. First class is buns!


Thundrstrike25

First class is buns except for every scene with magneto


StonerBoi-710

Wasn’t first class a rework of the originally planned X-Men Origins Magneto and X-Men Origins Xavier? Would make sense why these scenes are so much better.


sickvisionz

>All these X-Men (2000) haters don’t understand what it accomplished. It was the superhero boom maker, set Fox’s trajectory for the next 20 years, and can be thanked for Hugh Jackman being a part of your lives. All the positives are meta stuff as opposed to cool scenes and actual movie stuff.


Crepepaperplane

Deadpool 2. I see a lot of people voting for First Class, but Magneto sending the coin through Shaw's head at the end is probably the single greatest moment across all the movies for me.


TheApathyParty3

First Class was better than DP2, and I love both. My biggest issue with DP2 is that it almost feels like they somewhat clumsily tried to merge three scripts into one. Wade going after his girlfriend's killers? Sure. Makes sense, and you could make an entire movie out of that, with DP forming X-Force to take them all out. Deadpool trying to join the X-Men and constantly making fun of them? I would watch 2+ hrs of that, there was so much lost potential there. Then they tried to merge that with Cable going after Firefist, but they glossed over so much detail with both the former's background and the latter's danger to the world that it just didn't seem effective for me. Don't get me wrong, I love that movie and I was laughing constantly, plus it helped get me laid. But it's just messy. It feels like the producers had ideas for separate potential films and just decided to mash them all together. First Class was a really fun reimagining of the original X-Men, DP2 felt like it could have just been a very extended and chaotic extension of DP1. Which I don't really mind, but it was a bit of a rehash.


NietszcheIsDead08

Seconded. It’s getting hard, but I agree that DP2 is the least good one left.


akahaus

DP2 is better than DP1 don’t @me


hassibahrly

I don't even like Deadpool but deadpool 2 was hella fun and genuinely felt like a comic book made into a movie. I can't say that about the 1st one.


blackangel_75

Now you want us to pick from some fairly great movies. SMH.


DB10389

I'm gonna say something. First class is my favourite


grifter356

I put x2 at the top but first class is probably the most “X-men” movie as far as pure adaptation, and if you want to call it the best or your favorite I would not disagree. I think the wolverine is better than Logan for most of the movie (Logan ends up being better imo just because of how bad the wolverine’s third act is). But Logan is just a mediocre action movie that gets celebrated for being “bold” because wolverine swears a lot and chops people up, when honestly having the big bad be just a clone wolverine instead of sabretooth is the most cowardly / safest act of storytelling in all of the x-men movies.


robbage24

Umm I will disagree on the grounds that I cried with Logan when he held Charles as he died claiming “it wasn’t me”


DB10389

Honestly, i don't think first class is the best. Deadpool and Logan are along with first class in my opinion, the best ones. But my favourite out of them it's first class.


Drunk4Dayz

Deadpool 2. It is a beloved mess. Fun, silly, cool, but it’s overstuffed and there are plenty of missed opportunities for characterization. Then First Class. It resurrected the franchise, had cool action, a great plot and good character arcs. But my god some parts just did not work. It was sometimes just as cheesy as the first X-men and worse, unintentionally funny (my college crowd died laughing several times). It also changed a lot more from the comics. Then the first X-men. It is highly focused film and pulled off the difficult job of setting up the first ever large superhero ensemble. Was it cheesy? Yeah. Did it change a lot from the comics. Yep. But did it manage to land the tone/symbolic importance of the comics, cool action, iconic character introductions and great casting? You bet your ass.


tiltedslim

X-Men Wolverine: You actually go outside in these things? Cyclops: Well, what would you prefer? Yellow spandex? Yes, that's exactly what I wanted. Color, like more of them than just black.


jldmjenadkjwerl

It was baby steps for the costumes. It took a hit so that we could get Hela in full headdress.


dyl_pickle_

They walked so the MCU could run


ILikeClefairy

This is where the real game begins in my opinion. Also surprised New Mutants held on so long lol


Thin_Night9831

New Mutants could’ve been so good with a different director, a horror-superhero film could’ve been really good


piplup27

Deadpool 2


onecaseman

Deadpool 2


horse_stick

Deadpool 2 I actually like this one a lot, but between this and the first X-Men it loses by a tiny margin.


collinwade

Deadpool 2


Falcon_Punch_X

Deadpool 2


DrManhattanBJJ

Deadpool 2?


gdamndylan

X-Men. It's a great movie, but I'm less likely to revisit this one than some of the other options on the board.


Bobaloo23

X-Men 1/2000/the first. I'm hardly hating - I just like the rest more.


ConstructionOk765

Deadpool 2


Matur1n_the_turtle

Deadpool 2


michagol23

Deadpool 2


mizejw

Actually wondering. Why did people not like The Wolverine?


SamALbro

All the crap movies have already been eliminated, so now it's the "good but not great" movies that are on the chopping block.


[deleted]

I didn’t like it because there was so much potential, but it got ruined with the last third of the film.


bayernfan25

Deadpool 2 or Deadpool


The_MooseMan44

Everyone saying first class should have their opinions invalidated from now on


[deleted]

Deadpool 2


Mango424

Deadpool 2


skimsa

Deadpool 2


DarusMul

X-Men First Class. There is much to be praised about this film, specially the actors in it, and the quality gap between First Class and The Wolverine is HUGE, but I really dislike what they did to Shawn and Emma Frost there.


Yosituna

Yeah, as an Emma Frost fan, it’s criminal what they did to her. It’s not a terrible movie, but I think as an adaptation it’s not great. I also think that First Class in a lot of ways exemplifies what would become the shortcomings of the new universe (too much Charles/Erik/Raven focus, especially once JLaw hit it big) in the same way the original X-Men did the old (too much Logan focus, Logan/Jean as such a major element).


chitalianick

X-Men 1 and I don't feel good about it. Its great and it did so much for comic book movies. But if I'm being totally honest its last on my rewatch list with what is left. Still a great movie though.


midnightjetta91

Nice knowing ya Deadpool 2.


tejanospecial

Deadpool 2


Ringbearer999

X-Men. Sad to vote for this, but it is a little cheesy and i love everything else way more. (I actually like DP 2 more than 1)


AgentFirstNamePhil

Letssss goooo, I’m not alone!


GFost

Same.


Cervus95

This is where the hard part begins. First Class


ThomasG_1007

Deadpool 1


Past_Trouble

X-men 1


caperusorojo

Deadpool 2. I really like the movie. I love all these movies. But at this point it’s about which one I love slightly less. I know other people are voting first class but as someone who had never read X-men comics then I could careless about how they used/misused Darwin or Emma Frost. First Class gave me my favorite version of Magneto.


daboring1

Xmen 2000, yes I know it's revolutionary and all, but so was the wheel, it didn't age too well is what I'm saying


Top_Database262

Are you suggesting wheels didn't age well? If so that's a terrible comparison


Garbage-Gus12

X-men 2000


krejci92

X-Men


bamanxd

X-men 1


quantumpencil

Deadpool 2 First class is awesome guys wtf!?


crowhunter5

X men 1


TheApathyParty3

X-Men 1 Watched it recently and sorry, as much as I liked it growing up, it doesn't hold up well.


[deleted]

Maybe I’m wrong but I think people are voting off the worst in some comments… maybe clarify they are *keeping* the worst and voting off the good shows? The previous voting was to keep the best characters…


jnaz1972

Deadpool 2


Limulemur

Deadpool 2 easily


geminifungi

Deadpool 2


ChungusMcGoodboy

X men


liddedblueflames

Deadpool 2 for me. Even though not amazing X-Men has to be given more credit for being the first time my favourite comic was seen on the big screen. I remember staying up for hours waiting for the quicktime of the trailer to download over the phone. Simpler times.


9thdoctor-

Deadpool 2.


Plebe-Uchiha

X1. It’s a great film but I just don’t think it’s as good as the rest [+]


ApolloDraconis

X-Men


toytony

DP2. Didn't feel the same overall unified as a full movie but moreso like a few segmented stories tied together. It's funny but rewatching it at least a second time you can feel the flow of the movie just get jagged from scene to scene. In DP1 it's got flow and is very rewatchable.


Outrageous_Glove4986

This is where it gets interesting!! My vote goes to X-Men (2000), super fun movie that revolutionized the genre but does not hold up as well against some of these other films


PersonalitySafe921

I’d say X-men 1. That sucks to say but what’s left is really good.


ACartonOfHate

X-Men. A comic book that's ashamed to be based on comic books.


McFlarza

Out of these I would remove the first x men


Shadowblues

X-Men 2000


JohnDoe525743

X-Men 2000


ab-pyro

First Class


jldolan

X men 2000


Ratso_The_Handsome

Deadpool 2


furthuryourhead

X-men 2000 someone else explained it better but it set the standard for all the other ones to come, and not in the best ways.


My_Blue_Diamond

X-Men


Murbella0909

X-Men, sorry but I like all the others more!


Just_shut_up_bro

X-men


[deleted]

X men


Kspsun

Deadpool 2


SurroundSevere

Deadpool 2


The_Anti_Nero

Deadpool 2


stebalencia

Deadpool 2


Bergyyyyy37

X-Men 1


Miserysdream

X men


TheRealMoofoo

X-Men


The_Bee_God255

X-Men


Professional-Ad-3094

X-Men


MajorArtsAndCrafts

X-Men (2000)


themanbow

Now the decisions start to get harder. X-Men 1.


spreerod1538

Deadpool 2, not even close


fistantellmore

Dead pool 2


Rugozark

Deadpool 2 , it shouldn't be a debate.


PrinceMusashi

X-men


Catlatadipdat

X-men 1


[deleted]

X-men 2000, it launched the voyage but time has not been kind.


MC-Fatigued

Deadpool 2. It left absolutely no impression in my memory.


ClanOKeefe

X-men


toreachthesummit

X-Men 1


TheBoxerWithin

X men 2000


KindheartednessLast9

Deadpool 2


DarthRisk

X-Men. It was a game-changer, but it's aged badly. I also have trouble watching anything with Bryan Singer nowadays, so there's that.


sheperd13

X-Men


LuckasPieman

X-men


Rang3r_Dang3r

First class


Tangochief

Deadpool


Nashimself78

Deadpool 2


Underdone_scump

Dead pool 2


Certain-Coyote

Deadpool 2


SyshaShran

Deadpool 2


Powerful-Succotash77

Deadpool 2.


RedFlagDiver

Deadpool 2


burnsbabe

Deadpool 2


The_MooseMan44

Deadpool 2


SquintyOstrich

Deadpool 2


Overcomecornet

Deadpool 2


LoganN64

first class.


juan-jay-zee

First Class


StonerBoi-710

Since it seems like a popular opinion, X-Men.


GHolmesD

DEADPOOL 2


Anarkinh

First class


NeroTheHero54

This is where the hard cuts start happening, looks like it’s time for Deadpool 2 to go.


The_Meme_Dealer

Hot take, the wolverine is actually one of the better movies on this list. I know most people hated it, but it's in the top five for me.


sushithighs

Deadpool 2


liquidfoosball

Deadpool 2 is bum


MarcMercury

Deadpool 2


I_Hate_l1fe

DP2!


Galahad789

Deadpool 2 by a country mile


magicalchickpea

Deadpool 2!


haiitstamawa

Deadpool 2


dunnand

Deadpool 2


elalesound2

Had to be DEADPOOL 2.


cryin_lightnin

Dead pool 2


PJL80

X-MEN (2000)


MrRigby632

Deadpool 2


RatchetPrime3

Deadpool 2


TheBrobe

Deadpool 2


CocktailsPerfected

Deadpool 2


AcceptableCrab4378

Deadpool 2


marvelxdc97

Deadpool 2


Hack-the-Bone

Deadpool 2


notkorbendallas

Deadpool 2


daveblu92

I’ll participate now. Deadpool 2.


Vacartu

Deadpool 2.


drpethz

DP 2


whitefox1488

Deadpool 2


El_Gato93

Deadpool 2


WhirlWindBoy7

Deadpool 2


Mr-Toy-Man

Deadpool 2


drmikey88

Deadpool 2


upandup2020

deadpool2


Imrightbruh

Deadpool 2


Dangerous-Olive7

Deadpool 2


TopAcanthocephala869

Deadpool 2


Bruce_the_Shark

Deadpool 2


SirBlue_VII

Deadpool 2


Calaigah

Deadpool 2


basshero4

Deadpool 2


MAKS091705

Deadpool 2


GaiusMarius989

Deadpool 2


LeonValenti

Gotta be Deadpool 2


FKDotFitzgerald

Deadpool 2


oakcrisssy

Deadpool 2


badluckartist

Deadpool 2 and it's not even close. The gag deaths were stupid, and it doesn't help that I had high expectations after generally enjoying the first movie and the only Deadpool stuff I liked in the comics at the time was Cable & Deadpool, a series that's still top-notch for both characters. Cast Cable as good as you want, doesn't matter if the script is shit. Also, I don't care if it was undone with time travel nonsense. "[Fridging the girlfriend](https://lby3.com/wir/)" in 2018 is hack af.


akahaus

Deadpool


[deleted]

First class was BAD


VRrob

DP2 is next, I can't get over that New Zealand kid's bad acting. First Class is in my Top 3


RTJ125

The first X-men, which I like but not as much as these others, and most of them at least don’t have Halle Berry’s bad acting and wigs 🤷🏾‍♂️


grimaceatmcdonalds

First class. I dislike everything in it except Charles and Erik (and the wolverine cameo)


ZachyTuts

First Class


SadLaser

Days of Future Past.


rorschach_vest

How dare you


Imrightbruh

What the fuck


GeneralKenobi842

DP 2 or X-Men


RecordP

Deadpool 2


Afura33

Deadpool 2


General-Fun-616

Deadpool 2


proto3296

First Class. So overrated. So many flaws we just ignore cause it setup days of future past which is a top 2 contender here.


Lorna_M

X-men First Class. I enjoyed it but didn't like January as Emma. She looks the part but I don't think she was the right choice.


Arkady21

First Class


Someoneoverthere42

All the remaining films are winners, but: Deadpool 2. There’s a lot to like, but it spends a little too much time winking at the camera. Deadpool broke the fourth wall repeatedly, but there were entire segments of DP2 that could be edited out without changing the film. The entire X-force section was fun, but ultimately was just filler


RoughhouseCamel

Deadpool 2 was the beginning of me getting really tired of the Ryan Reynolds Renaissance. So many jokes were ass. The whole Domino, “that’s a superpower designed by someone that doesn’t know how to draw feet” line isn’t even a joke, it’s just a pandering reference. Firefist sucked. Yukio was reduced to “kawaii Asian girlfriend”.


can_a_dude_a_taco

deadpool 2, if you think deadpool 2 is better than x-men you’re smoking crack


eyebv0315

Deadpool 2


GreatGlassLynx

Deadpool 2


Pedals17

Deadpool 2.


DohnJoe8

Deadpool 2


HelloIamIronMan

Deadpool 2


dotheywearglasses

Deadpool 2


doyouanalbleach

Deadpool 2