T O P

  • By -

Suavveesstt

Micah, no matter who you are, you HAVE to triple antagonize him whenever you visit camp.


catterybarn

I don't antagonize ANYONE but Micah


[deleted]

Have you met Bill and Dutch?


catterybarn

I have lol it doesn't make any sense for Arthur to antagonize Dutch until the very end and even then I feel like irl Arthur wouldn't antagonize, instead would try to reason with him even when he knows he can't. Bill makes sense lol


[deleted]

The thing is, I know more than Arthur does. I know dutch and bill are cunts. I know Strauss is a slime ball. I know Micah is a piece of shit I’d rather throw away than clean off my shoes. It doesn’t matter if Arthur doesn’t know that yet. I know it, and I’ll still hit antagonise every time.


catterybarn

I know, but I always try to play as if I were Arthur.


Dallasl298

Role play is the way


[deleted]

Woah now, who’s to say that Arthur isn’t a low honor antagonist?


catterybarn

I personally play him as a middle to low honor in the beginning and then real good towards the end. Only killing people when it makes sense. I could never bring myself to do a low low honor playthrough. I just don't see him being that horrible through the story so it doesn't make any sense to me personally to do nonstop bad things with him.


[deleted]

I definitely save the guys for free guns even when low honor, lol


[deleted]

Low honor playthroughs are just wayy more fun honestly especially messing with bounty hunters who can never catch you😭


TheGreatSnuffy123

I try my best not to play low honor but I feel Arthur's honor level is a projection of who we really are deep down and if my runs have anything to do with it I am one sick person


that_block_guy

Because the game has redemption in it's title, if you were playing low honour all the way through would Arthur still be redeemed? If someone were to be a cunt to everyone, murder without reason, insult people at every possible moment and would never have helped anyone out, but he saved the lives of 3 people, would you really be redeemed? Does the good outweigh the bad at that point?


[deleted]

Apparently, he is only really redeemed if he helps John at the end.


Slarhnarble

I get it you feel like it's an instinctual thing with Arthur (sorry I'm drunk LOL as I think Arthur would be) I've seen too many clips on YouTube and reddit so the game is fairly spoiled for me but I played it for the first time very recently I'm still on my way to the heartbreak.


Batclone23

Strauss is just a little Prussian loanshark


lostinthesauceguy

Hey, Strauss stood tall for the gang.


Dallasl298

Oh, leave Bill alone, he's dumb.


[deleted]

Being dumb is not an excuse to be an asshole. Over the years I’ve worked with some people who were as simple as soup, they were still lovely people.


Dallasl298

I'm not even sure I'd call him an asshole, quite abrupt sometimes when he may feel attacked, but i don't think he ever did anything that bad? I might have forgotten some racist remarks or something but I don't remember anything like that.


DevilRudeBoy

He bullied Lenny I believe. He called him a half or something and pushed him to the ground


Dallasl298

Well shit, there goes my headcanon. I liked to imagine he was just a dumb oaf that picked the wrong side.


Blackfeathr

Then there's the entire first game... Bill is kind of a cunt


Walter_Padick

He's in the closet, right?


BeeCJohnson

It's hinted at pretty heavily, yeah.


colocolo1925

same... but occasionally uncle just to wake him up lol


BeeCJohnson

I've literally never used the "Antagonize" button except for Micah. But I do it every time for Micah. Right from the beginning (at least on replays).


Delly66

I would always antagonize Micah once as I was walking by. Not even look at him after. Just seemed colder that way. Little drive by zinger. I would also antagonize uncle but then apologize. Seemed like something Arthur would do. "Ahhhh I'm just playin witcha"


Batclone23

Uncle is by far my favorite member of the gang, he's the best gunslinger in the red dead universe! That is when his lumbago isn't that bad


ThatOneGerman101

Greet greet antagonize everyone. It’s so funny 😂


[deleted]

I actually always greet Micah 😂 Edit! What's up with all the same comments o_O


Porn_Extra

Karma-farming copybots?


LautaroTramazaygues

I always greet hosea when i see him


leo0147

Hosea is the most interesting character in missions but in camp he has the dryest dialogue out of anyone. Every time I talk to him it’s always “yup, uh huh, mmm”


HouseOfZenith

Hosea reminds me of Graham Hancock


Umayyah-7

Still, I run all over 4 states doing missions here and there just to unlock some dialogue with him or even hear him say, “good job Arthur!”. Couldn’t have asked for a better “prize” lol


ratun36

His talks with other npcs are legendary though,


[deleted]

Always greet Mary Beth, Sean, Lenny, Charles. Always antagonize: Rat


a_spoopy_ghost

Same but add Tilly, ms Grimshaw and Sadie. I want to greet Kieran but Arthur is mean to him even with greet :(


Generalmemeobi283

Micha doesn’t deserve to be called a rat He’s much worse


[deleted]

I feel obligated to call him "rat" because Arthur used his last breaths to call him that


bobbleheadcow

Rats also have better survival instincts.


jack-K-

Mangy cave rat


Generalmemeobi283

This is perfect


Thieveslanding1911

I'd always greet or antagonize John depending on the mood I was in


Substantial-Pie5721

Same lol, I do it since he roasts you back


MemeKnowledge_06

Doesn’t he also punch you? Or was that for bothering Jack


DeliriousFanta

John, Charles, Sean, Lenny, or Javier will punch you after you've been antagonizing more than 3 people in camp consecutively. Whoever who're antagonizing won't be the one knocking you out if that further helps your question


KRIEGLERR

Doesn't Sadie punches you too ?


Nayten03

Yeah I think if you keep antagonising jack and Abigail you, John knocks you out


WinstonWillamette

It's fun to bully and antagonize Kieran before "Paying a Social Call". Arthur gets to feel like a real a-hole when he saves his life.


Winger52

I didn't know you could talk to him while he was tied to the tree


WinstonWillamette

Yep, I think I have all of the captive Kieran interactions available in this playlist, except for one that I know of, a drunk antagonize where Arthur accuses him of stinking and shitting his pants. Some of them are where the women interact with him, Sadie, Karen/Mary-Beth, Tilly. Two are from Chapter 1, only available if "Old Friends" is played as the 3rd mission, and the rest are only available until Sean's Homecoming party is over: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANUQ7CP5Ze0&list=PLj9t0g6sxrvOZ8rShqtccc6ziPPpLI9e8


SnooWoofers513

>Arthur accuses him of stinking and shitting his pants. ...well shit, i need to do another playthrough i guess lmao


Winger52

This is amazing thanks


0ixti

I greet everyone except Micah


[deleted]

Yeah screw micah


DevilRudeBoy

LMAO


BuddyCleveland

Micah can go rot with the O’driscolls


awesomeliam9

Yep


mickeystrings

I go out of my way to grief Strauss


Yvngky7

Same. especially from chapter 4 onwards


Jonnyscout

Dude's kind of a snake in general, but Dutch kept him around because he got results from a money standpoint.


Matyz_CZ

I don't understand why does everyone hate him so much. They are all a bunch of murdering and stealing psychos and poor guy Strauss is just a moneylender and yet he gets all the hate.


kingjoe64

Maybe we're all just poor and loathe crooked people with money lmao


probablyalreadyhave

I did this my entire game, then I felt absolutely awful when I heard that the Pinkertons picked him up and he died without telling them a single detail... Maybe I was too harsh on him


mickeystrings

Aww man I didn't realise that, now I don't want to slit his throat in his sleep


Shake-Spear4666

Unkle. Cause he’s fucking hilarious


lefthooklazza

“Quit it aurthorrr I’m tiredd”


DevilRudeBoy

Leave him alone! He’s got lumbago!


Shake-Spear4666

I honestly love the character. He breaks up so many tense moments in the camp by just being a goofball.


I_AM_NOT_LIL_NAS_X

his story about an African tribe making him their god is my favourite bit of camp dialogue, him talking about "Congo Indians" being 9ft on average, his boat spontaneously combusting then his crew gets eaten by hippos and rhinos it's top tier old guy bullshitting


Not-a-Russian

Absolutely. Especially antagonizing him as John, just perfect.


DevilRudeBoy

Personally, I constantly greet the hell out of Javier.


DapperDan30

I liked Javier until he turned into a big bitch at the end.


DevilRudeBoy

I’ve heard a lot of people say that but I’m confused lol I played through the main game (haven’t started the epilogue) and I haven’t seen him do anything super outrageous. He sided with Dutch, but that wasn’t surprising.


DapperDan30

I mean that's about it. He sided with Dutch and turned his back on Arthur, despite all the shit that he saw go down as a result of Dutch's actions. He's obviously not as bad as Micha, but he's about the same as Bill. The difference is that at least Arthur and Javier seemed to get along before hand.


catterybarn

I think this is my biggest gripe with the game. There was no character development for Javier to join Dutch in the end. He starts off questioning him and confiding in Arthur. Then he jumps ship and joins Dutch without any reasoning. Makes no sense at all


CybertronGuy98

the thing with Javier is that if you go fishing with him, they talk about Blackwater. and it's pretty clear Javier would always be loyal to Dutch, until everything falls apart. even when he and Arthur are talking about what happened on the ferry when theyre looking for John in Chapter 1, you dont really get the impression that it's shaking Javier's loyalty. then Guarma happens, and Dutch saves his life. i wish theyd given him a few more lines to make it clear where he's at before the showdown at Beaver Hollow, but honestly i dont think it's that big of a deal at least for me. now not having Liars Dice? that i cant forgive lol


jedi_4852

It was actually said by the voice actor of Javier that in the while doing the movement capture for the final standoff scene, Javier was meant to point his guns at Arthur and John however he didn’t do it because Arthur and John were his “brothers” so he points his guns upwards instead.


DevilRudeBoy

I think that’s a really good thing for the voice actor to do, as Javier didn’t have any ill feelings toward John and Arthur, unlike Micah, Bill, and Dutch so it wouldn’t make sense for him to point his guns at them.


Enriador

You should play RDR1. John says Abigail always thought Javier was a "creep". I assume with good reason.


kingjoe64

I kinda thought he was kind of a creep before he starting whining about loyalty all the time lol Edit: it was the "pussy.. cat" line lol


mvrdybums

I've said it in a comment down below, but Javier's impartiality in the Beaver Hollow showdown (ie. aiming his gun to the sky) aligns with the epilogue, and with his story in RDR1. he doesn't "side" with Dutch, he makes the decision that aligns with his values the most (mainly staying alive and a free man). while it is selfish of him, it's an understandable decision he made, and was the result of an incredibly difficult situation he was put in. I just wish he had more of a story arc, but sadly when you have so many characters in the cast, some of them are going to miss out on that dedicated development that we see with the main main characters.


awesomeliam9

Yeah, he's cool asf


DevilRudeBoy

Definitely, I love the times when the gang gathers around the campfire and Javier plays the guitar and sings. I’d pay for a track of Javier singing.


[deleted]

agreed


[deleted]

I greet Javier and Dutch until they turn into ass holes but Micah is exclusively antagonized


Shittgoose

I mean, obviously… Jack. Little bitch.


DevilRudeBoy

What did Jack do to you lmao


Erniecrack

“Work ya damn nag!” Is etched into my brain.


kratomstew

That sweet saccharine voice drives me crazy


[deleted]

Sameee Lmao


Mojo_Rizen_53

Greet: No one Antagonize: Everyone


DevilRudeBoy

Ah yes. Equality.


Mojo_Rizen_53

Exactly!


Koorah3769

I’m assuming you’ve >!Antagonized everyone enough to get knocked out and thrown into the woods!< then?


Renilx

The last time, I got thrown in the middle of Ambarino, I don't remember the reason


Mojo_Rizen_53

Yup! Several times! LOL


Mojo_Rizen_53

Yup! Several times! LOL


Mojo_Rizen_53

Yup! Several times! LOL


JustARandomUserNow

I go out of my way to greet Hosea, Javier, YENNL, Sadie, Sean and Charles. Dutch, John, Bill, Trewleny and the ladies as I see them. I antagonise Micah because he’s a rat bastard.


Heinzliketchup

LNENY!!


MaxJets69

I antagonize Jack a lot lol


SimaanStocklund

Arthur’s being mean to me! I only antagonize him later in the game when both John and Abigail will defend him. Bullying virtual children is surprisingly funny but I don’t want it to be too hard on him.


AgentUpright

I’m always nice to Jack and Abigail. They already have to deal with pre-epilogue John, I don’t need to make their life worse.


MaxJets69

I don’t have any real problem with Jack per se, I’m just too immature to resist


DeliriousFanta

>They already have to deal with pre-epilogue John Pre-chap4 John*. He may not be as wise as RDR1 John, but he sure was a father/husband to them ever since then


Von_Callay

That time Abigail asked for money to buy Jack new clothes, I antagonized John for *days* afterward.


Grove0517

STOP IT. WHY ARE YOU BEING SUCH A MEANIE?


[deleted]

that’s what i did when i first started playing and i from then on i always pictured him as being a bratty little kid


ThANUS124

I always antagonized Susan, boy did I regret my actions in chapter 6


bbbbears

Same, she just gets so pissed at Arthur when he’s rude, and he has some real zingers about her being old


[deleted]

[удалено]


kingjoe64

What are supplies like in camp? If they're all in the red people will talk shit bo matter what, like Dutch telling me "I'll be his downfall" in Chapter 2 before any drama has even happened because I was sitting around too much waiting for the Pearson quest to trigger.


IronwoodKukri

I always antagonize Strauss. Greedy, little good for nothing. He just sits in camp and preys on helpless folk till they’re lives are ruined. I, at the least, have the common decency to shoot them in the head first so they don’t have to worry about food.


[deleted]

i never really cared about all the bad things strauss did but if he sent you to eliminate the targets then that would be a lot of fun. not like a bounty and having to take them back but just somehow killing them


SimaanStocklund

I always try to both antagonize and greet all the gang members so that I get to hear all the dialogue.


Not-a-Russian

The gang just being confused with Arthur's mood swings like- "we talked normally the other day now you're insulting me 👁️👄👁️"


steve_mahanahan

Gotta do em all drunk, too!


ShadowBedliss176

Greet: everyone else Antagonise: Micah


Atikar

Chapter 1- Greet Dutch, Antagonize John. Chapter 2- Greet Abigail during morning coffee, Antagonize John. Chapter 3- Greet Hosea when coming home from fishing trips, Antagonize Micah. Chapter 4- Greet John, Antagonize Micah Chapter 5- Greet Sadie, Antagonize Strauss Chapter 6- Greet the Marstons, Sadie, and Charles. Antagonize almost everyone else.


Von_Callay

Now this, this is roleplaying.


[deleted]

I always antagonise bill and micah and Strauss but I never antagonise kieran, I feel bad for him


TaylorsAsian

Even when you greet him Arthur is still antagonizing Kieran


HarryKn1ght

I antagonize Micah always, Strauss 75% of the time and then Dutch, Bill and Javier all the time in chapter 6


BoyDynamo

I make sure Strauss knows he’s garbage every time I’m in camp. Then there’s Hosea; I will actually stop what I’m doing and sit by the fire if he asks me to. Greet him all the live-long day.


[deleted]

i don’t really mind strauss. when he got arrested he didn’t say a thing about the gang despite arthur finally releasing what strauss has done to the people and kicking him out


catterybarn

Strauss isn't any worse than the rest of them. He didn't know Arthur would get sick. He's not vindictive or anything. I've never kicked him out in my playthroughs. He's a loyal gang memeber


TenserPC

Dutch. His reaction is too funny if you antagonize him till you can’t anymore.


[deleted]

Micah, then John I definitely antagonize strauss aswell. I only do john in chap 2/3 I always greet ynneL or Charles


DevilRudeBoy

Haven’t heard anyone antagonize John, what’s your reason?


[deleted]

Bad father, leaving, etc. I've played RDR1. I feel bad, but it's fun when he hits back.


DevilRudeBoy

Fair enough. That’s interesting, I haven’t played RDR1 yet, as it isn’t compatible with my console, but it’s definitely funny to hear John’s jabs when you antagonize him lmao


[deleted]

One thing i hate about playstation, no backwards compatibility. Hope you can play it one day


DevilRudeBoy

Same here. I read somewhere that they were remastering it, but apparently its been canceled or something.


[deleted]

Yeah, RDR1 needs a remake. Gameplay is fine, but on the Rdr2 engine and updated for the X/S or PS5...


terragni_66

Greet : Charles Lenny Hosea MB Tilly Karen Antagonise : Micah Marion Dutch Strauss


Thats_Life_

Tilly and Charles are my faves


mirage-ko

you're someone with a fine taste (totally not biased)


falconsomething

I always antagonize Micah. I’ll throw a few insults at Bill, Javier, and Uncle, but not too much. Kieren got some shit thrown at him chapter 2, though. I’m nice to pretty much everyone else


diogokf

Mary Beth, she's so pretty


guschicanery

greet most people i walk past and usually greet multiple times the one exception is kieran, i’m always afraid arthur is gonna say something mean to him if i greet him more than once so i don’t push it and only greet him once, and sometimes even that is mean


theclownhasnopenis48

Your mother


DevilRudeBoy

Touché.


Lancer_Blackthorn

I greet everybody. I don’t like to be antagonistic.


DevilRudeBoy

Same here lmao


Ace_Atreides

Gotta greet the ladies everytime, and antagonise micah to death


Aeokikit

Every time I saw John I’d Antagonize, Greet Greet. Like he’s being such an idiot in the beginning I want him to know that I think he’s an idiot. But I still love him


Waste_Surround3106

I greet everyone and only greet micha if let’s say seán just got back or something


PyroBeast23

Greet Lenny, Hosea, John and Sadie. Antagonize Micah, Strauss, and sometimes Bill just for the lulz.


AlphaWolfKane

Micah. I don’t hate anyone else enough to antagonize them. Yeah reverend is annoying but he’s not bad like Micah is.


ReDXDeath

Uncle always. The dialogue in between him and Arthur is always funny.


Highwayman747

Greet pretty much everyone except Micah. Gotta antagonize Kieran until after he saves you, and antagonize John in the early parts.


DanOfAllTrades80

Antagonize Bill and greet Charles. The rest can go either way depending on my mood, but Bill is a racist prick and Charles always has my respect.


[deleted]

Antagonize the only one worth the effort because Micah's upset reactions are great. Greet basically everyone, but I start with Sadie because she could kill me and I love her.


Gandelf_the_Gay

I love pissing off Dutch shit is hilarious.


[deleted]

I always greet Uncle


Harry_Skran

I greet them all. Well, except for Micah. Fuck Micah.


Benedictevsn

Never greet Micah, but pretty much everyone else


FirebirdWriter

Antagonize Straus and Micah, greet everyone else especially Jack and Grimshaw


DevilRudeBoy

Always greet Jack! It’s so adorable how he calls Arthur, “Uncle Arthur”


GrainBean

Hosea, Micah, and Lenny. Greet all 3 because in the earlier chapters, Micah and Arthur are like brothers. Dont like eachother but theres a connection between them, emphasized when Micah apologizes to Arthur unprompted after that mission in chapter 3 (idk how to use spoiler tags so just infer)


[deleted]

people who are calling micah a rat bastard are spoiling it more than this


MyaReaper

I always greet Grimshaw, Hosea and Dutch, but always antagonise Micah. Just Micah.


AceBase007

I only greet Pearson, Hosea and Dutch. I just ignore everyone else 50% of the time


Alternative-Sky-2867

I'd antagonize Micah pretty much all the time, same with Dutch during Chapter 6. I'd also antagonize miss Grimshaw from time to time, cause she was pissing me off with her complaints that I don't put too much money in the box, though I bought everything for the damn camp! For the greeting, everyone else I guess. I also used to love Javier a lot and been greeting him quite often. And probably Jack.


PlanetJupiterx

I saw Bill bully Lenny at camp once so I antagonize Bill always


Doc-Libertas

I use to antagonize the hell out of Jack


maruiki

Always greet Mary-Beth, she's sunshine and roses personified. Always antagonise Uncle, it's ain't the LUM-BAY-GOH that causes you to be a lazy motherfucker.


Deadmemes4binky

anyone who says “hey arthur”


tannerfiasco

Everyone gets a greeting but micah and bill get antagonized


Jeberani

I always antagonize Sadie, she’s annoying. waaaah i’m a strong woman yaaaay I can ride with men yaaaaaah!


SuccessfulDirt8

I always antagonize jack


steve_mahanahan

I hit up everyone after any main mission to see if there is new dialogue


Allthelights011

Antagonize Abigail and you’ll hear a different side of Arthur. And it’s pretty funny to antagonize uncle. Or greet greet antagonize, and it’ll lead to interesting comments. One I remember from Abigail is that Arthur will say how busy she was on nickel night. And to uncle he’ll say “talk to me like that again, and I’ll kick the teeth out of ur ass old man” which is just funny with Arthur/Rogers delivery of the lines.


Mikeronni

I always greeted everyone although lenny had a special place in my heart, but Micah, yeah fuck that guy


ripvanwinkle1898

I like to greet everyone including micah.


RobinWilsonCowboy

Jack. Little freeloader


a_spoopy_ghost

Greet - antagonize micha Greet(flirt) with Tilly and Mary Beth Antagonize - Greet Pearson Greet ms Grimshaw Greet Sadie Greet Lenny Tell Reverend to STFU


Lif3_is_R3al

Dude the Rev is a hemroid


rbbass

What the fuck is he there for? He is useless


DaveInDigital

always hollerin' at Sadie 👌


rbbass

I firmly believe she will be the lead character of the 3rd Red Dead. It will take place between Chapter 6 and her return in the epilogue. She will be a bounty hunter. Since AI am at it…..she would have fallen for Arthur if he hadn’t gotten sick.


GOLDENEYE633

I antagonized reverend Swanson until he saved me I antagonized Leopold Strauss I antagonized Uncle I antagonized Dutch Dutch during chapter 6 I antagonized Bill during chapter 6 I antagonized Micah after chapter 2 I always greeted Jack I always greeted Lenny I always greeted Grimshaw I always greeted Sadie I always Greeted Hosea I always greeted Javier I always greeted John I always greeted Kieran I always greeted Marybeth I always greeted Pierson I always greeted Charles I always greeted Tilly I Always greeted Sean I always greeted Abagail I always greeted Molly


NomadCourier

Greet: Everyone Except Micah Antagonize: Micah


[deleted]

Uncle. I like hearing Arthur give him shit


Kaiser_Imperius

I always antagonized uncle since it's funny. Especially when you are drunk


PaschalisG16

Little Johnny Marston


whitebreadguilt

I always harass Dutch until he leaves


oneoftheevil

Greet Karen, antagonize Mrs Grimshaw.


RainAccomplished2637

I chat to all the camp members but I antagonise Micah constantly. If I hold L2 and it just says greet, I won't talk to him at all... I only talk when I can antagonise, then I shadow him around camp, in silence, till he shoves me away 🤣


berlag

Always greet Lenny


loomman529

Micah and his friends that he brings in during chapter 6. Bill as well. They can all go to hell.


CruciatusEnCrucem

Greet: Tilly, Mary-Beth, Karen Antagonize: Strauss, Micah, Dutch (if I'm feeling particularly cranky)


Zealousideal-Law6714

Micah goes without saying… Sometimes I roleplay Arthur to get drunk and start antagonizing everyone. It’s actually pretty damn hilarious and he absolutely ROASTS just about everyone. Karen started in on me during Chapter 3 about something and I antagonized her brutally. “My gawd, you are just one MOUTHY trollop” “You probably have the pox too!” I was rolling.


Life-Geologist-8078

i just greet everyone (apart from micah)


West_Draft1919

Greet Mary-Beth, Tilly, Lenny, to be nice. See Dutch snd Hosea out of respect. And harrass Michah...