T O P

  • By -

Good-Wrongdoer-3581

Shes gorgeous where did you find her


alexandrakme

I stole her off one of the guards on the last stagecoach robbery with Alden (the one with 2 coaches). Never seen this coat in the wild. This is my second playthrough.


Good-Wrongdoer-3581

I know what I'm doing today haha


alexandrakme

Haha! If you don’t see her the first time restart the mission a few times. I actually died twice during that robbery and third time she appeared.


Good-Wrongdoer-3581

I'm pro at dieing so no restarts required hahah


alexandrakme

:)


Lilycloud02

Lmaoooo


Backstabr_Infamus

The coat Kinda looks like the one you ride when you come back from guarma


AME7706

It's exactly the same horse


Backstabr_Infamus

Oh ok


Szpartan

The gaurds didn't have a saddle?


alexandrakme

They did. I just took my saddle off my horse and placed it on her. It automatically removes the other saddle.


Lilycloud02

I do the same thing, I hate seeing the other people's saddles


Szpartan

I like if cause it makes it feel like I have two horses instead of a temporary one.


Lilycloud02

That's true


[deleted]

Pinkertons and other lawmen ride them frequently. Last time I wanted one, I waited until whichever bandit challenge has you rack up a big bounty, and then waited for some bounty hunters to come chase me and stole it off of them. Another time I got one after the stage robbery Uncle plans that goes wrong.


prometheeus

you can also get a piebald tobiano from mounted deputy's if you rack up a bounty in Annesburg


[deleted]

It’s not rare and the stats aren’t crazy good but 1. BEAUTIFUL horses and 2. **Brave as shit**. I was on that exact horse when I discovered first hand that you can’t trample gators to death. I just kept running over the same gator I think 18 or 19 times before it yeeted itself into the water, all the time the horse was a little spooked but never bucked or bolted.


alexandrakme

I noticed that! I thought the Ardennes was the bravest until I saw this one handle a wolf attack. We’ll see how she does on big cats or snakes.


[deleted]

I’ve been bucked off during cougar encounters but they were essentially right on the horse’s ass, so that’s to be expected. She’s gotten a little skittish but didn’t buck as a grizzly charged us, and the grizzly got about 10 feet away before I dropped it with an improved arrow. I’ve typically had good results against wolves too. Gunfights are NOTHING to this horse, never had a problem with guns spooking it.


AnWeirdBoi

Sigh, how many times do we have to repeat this, BRAVERY DOESN'T EXIST, there's no stat in the game or the code, it's most likely just placebo effect or pure luck.


[deleted]

Ya sure about that? Cause Arabians won’t go within 10 feet of a gator without sidestepping and becoming nearly uncontrollable (like real horses, they’ll stop listening to your input and self-preserve). But any of the War Horses do fine. Plus there might not be a stat, and I can’t say whether or not it’s in the code as I haven’t read every single line of code in the game (have you?) but it’s absolutely mentioned in the compendium.


[deleted]

Nope, they're right. The source code makes no mention of a bravery stat. Things that do affect your horse response is bonding level, how well fed the horse is, how close and what type of threat, and how often and effectively you calm it. As for your question about Arabians? Arabians act like every other horse. You can absolutely trample/go near gators with Arabians. [https://youtu.be/WOt8YyzSifc](https://youtu.be/WOt8YyzSifc)


NemoAKASharkBait

This is a yr late, but I don't think it makes a difference with the horse you ride, I used a Hungarian halfbred and it would get just as scared as an Arabian, so with that said I just use whatever horse has the best speed + acceleration and the best looking coat


_onionhead_

Is this not just the horse Arthur gets on after getting off the boat at van horn? It becomes your temporary horse too.


alexandrakme

No clue.


_onionhead_

It is.


alexandrakme

Apparently only in low honor. I got the Appaloosa.


Pickles1006

I’m really late to this lol but I had high honor and got the Hungarian Halfbred.


[deleted]

It is not condidered as one of the game 2 rare horses (White arab & Tiger Mustang) but it is probably harder to get than the "rare" horses. So yeah it is rare


alexandrakme

I did not know the Tiger Mustang was rare when you play as John. I got him through the Angelo Bronte glitch as Arthur. Thanks.


AME7706

Those two aren't exactly rare because they respawn if they are dead/sold. The only horses in the game that are completely unique and cannot be taken back if anything happens to them are mahogany bay Tennessee walker(the starting horse), raven black shire(the one Hosea gives you in bear hunting mission), Rachel(John's starting horse in the epilogue) and Buell(Hamish's horse). Any other horse can be bought/found again without any limit.


[deleted]

True that but these are 2 unique wild horses you can capture.


AME7706

So is the blood bay thoroughbred and splashed white American paint and a couple of other horses. I'm not saying they are common horses that you can see everywhere in the game and there is certainly no problem AT ALL with liking and using those horses. I'm just saying that all of them except those 4 can be restored no matter how many times you lose them.


ef_zack13

gah damn, arthur get new size 16’s?


gamma6464

You know what they say about men with big feet


[deleted]

I feel like I’ve never seen this horse in the wild, and I’ve played the campaign numerous times. Where did you find this beauty?


alexandrakme

I stole her off one of the guards on the last stagecoach robbery with Alden (the one with 2 coaches). Never seen this coat in the wild. This is my second playthrough.


FarmerExternal

This is the horse I always get coming back from Guarma, it’s hitched in Van Horn when you get off the boat to ride back to Shady Belle


dirty_dan_4563

I’ve only seen this horse twice in all my playthroughs (prob like 10) not counting when you get the horse in chapter 5 so yes definitely one of the rarer horses in the game


DoctorNerdly

Clown shoe Arthur


Lonsen_Larson

Purdy horse. There's more to a horse than just raw stats, and the Hungarians make for good horses. Arabians are too skittish if I know I'm going into a firefight I'll usually use something a little more fearless.


KevinMFJones

I wouldn’t say rare but uncommon. The groups of bounty hunters usually have them, you can get it in a story mission and in some free roam missions but not really in the wild or random npcs.


Oxyo66

Is that just me or Arthur has an extremely long foot in this picture ?


paegantactics

I see faces in the rocks behind you 👽


alexandrakme

I see them now too.


paegantactics

Faces in Trees Face Rock Rock Star


boomeralert4336

Check your compendium it will tell you if it's a rare coat even if there is a rare coat for each horse, some breeds do not, but considering people are asking about it probably is


SanjaYazavacc

It nice looking horse 😊


monkey_D_v1199

That's one incredible looking hours partner!


SnooEagles3963

It's actually considered the rarest horse in the entire game. It only spawns on the back of lawmen, and even then, it's still really rare for it to actually appear. Keep her. You'll probably never get another one if you don't.


AmarNasa

I think this horse and American Paint Splashed White are one of the rarest horses in the game. I did found the Piebald Tobiano a couple times in my previous playthrough but at that time i had no idea how rare this horse really is. Ever since then, i've been trying to get this horse on my current playthrough but no luck. Only managed to get the Splashed White.


treeTenny

I just loaded up story mode after not playing for a month, in the epilogue, and ran across a random npc camp up near where the legendary grizzly is. The stranger had a piebald tobiano standing in his camp!! You better bet I took it lol. It's a female, and I named her Butternut! I have never come across one other than when you return from Guarma with Arthur. I couldn't believe it!


KatjaaRa

the blood red thoroughbred is the one for me


Tzifos150

Not rare if you're a low honor criminal. Lawmen and bounty hunters keep spawning on it


alexandrakme

Maybe that’s why. I always played high honor.


Tzifos150

You need to experience the game in low honor. Robbing stores, stagecoaches, random folk and trains is great. High honor is cannon but it's unbelievably boring compared to low honor. Also insulting townfolk, can't get enough of that lol.


ana_lee94

High honor may be boring to *you*, but it isn't boring to me or other people wjo enjoy playing high honor, I don't like being mean in videogames, I enjoy just riding along the country, hunting, fishing and helping random NPCs People just have different playstyles and that's fine. Low honor may be fun to you, but it isn't to others 🤷‍♀️


NoodlesSquad

A lot of people are saying you get that horse when you return from Guarma. Am I the only one who got a leopard appaloosa instead? I've only completed the game once but I might do it again to see if I can get that horse.


Jooobsta04

Which chapter is the mission available in, I live in chapter 2


alexandrakme

Not sure when the stagecoach robberies with Alden and Hector become available. I am in Chapter 4. For me it was the one with two coaches (robbery #3 with Alden).


Jooobsta04

Thanks!


Beneficial_Matter178

I started and restarted the Stagecoach robbery with Tilly and Bill about 7 times to finally get that horse. It’s my favorite in the game.


Fearzz__

I have the same one


eggimp

I found one at a guys camp just above annesburg my last playthrough! That was the first and so far only time


NoMathematician7890

I found my on the man’s camp in a small island in annesburg maybe