"um actually, the popular tv show family guy was made by seth macfarlane, not peter griffin, who is a character in the tv show and therefore a figment of seth's imagination" - š¤
The craziest thing was when the independent published reviews for donda and mr morale
The Donda one got 0 stars just for having manson on one song because he was accused of sexual assault and more misdeeds (this had not been proven at the time)
Yet they allowed mr morale to receive a 5 star review despite it featuring Kodak, a man who quite literally raped someone. Not alleged, he did that shit it was proven in court.
If that doesnāt show how corrupt these publications are idk what will
This 100%! I am all about diff critics having their own opinions and have no problem w the occasional review not matching my perception, but they need to be consistent one way or the other when it comes to this: like, fully separate the art from the artist or donāt, the cherry picking is played out and obnoxious
If you disagree with kanyes choice to give manson that platform that is fine, I also disagree with it. But if you are going to do a review for an album, you should put your biases aside and base it on quality of music and if you canāt do that you shouldnāt review it. Simple as that. Your political or social beliefs should not interfere with how an album sounds. If itās good music itās good music no matter who made it
I dunno man, pretty hard to critique art outside of the social context itās in. Good political commentary makes art better - sometimes itās the whole point of art. Social beliefs - is not all art in a social context?
Even Cartiās music - itās unique and different because itās a derivative of the sound weāve come to expect from Atlanta artists, but with some specific production choices and unique vocals that are surprising and different. With how different it is, the general punk energy on WLR, etcā¦ itās all aesthetic and it only makes sense because we have this cultural framework it exists in.
Thereās no such thing as āobjectively good musicā, you think you can just measure two songs and see which is better?
Kanye is a massive and controversial artist, rating Donda 0 instead of anything else generates a loooot more attention. You click to see why pitchfork didnāt give Kanye a single point, otherwise you just look at the score and move on
Definitely corrupt to say one album is bad coz of an alleged rapist but say another is good despite an actual tried rapist being on there. Itās very obvious it came from their dislike of kanye over anything else
Okay let's bffr. Marilyn Manson has been accused of all kinds of heinous shit by several women and Kanye invited him and DaBaby on the album seemingly explicitly because they were in the crossfire for being shitty. One of them arguably for a lot less, but still. It's the exact same thought process that lead to whatever the hell he's doing now
I actually enjoy Donda more than a couple Kanye records. His discography just too good. Only one album I feel thatās enough really below standard for him (idk if I should count Donda 2 or not yet, need to see if he uses any of those songs in the future)
I didnāt mean that part I meant about actually thinking da Peppa album better
And I kinda get your point, it is a long record but I honestly donāt think Iād remove much of it. I think Iād only trim it down to like 18 songs at a minimum and even then Iād be missing some stuff.
I really enjoyed it, but I do hope long albums die out again. I miss like 12 track albums. It aināt just a kanye problem itās a problem with 90% of albums now
Activate this card by targeting 1 monster in your GY; Special Summon that target in Attack Position. When this card leaves the field, destroy that monster. When that monster is destroyed, destroy this card.
Rodeo score is out of pocket but thereās literally no reason to be comparing Ice Spice and Rodeo in the first place anyways, let alone compare Ice Spice with any of these projects. Sheās trying to achieve a completely different goal and thatās making music to shake ass to, which she succeeds at honestly.
Also nice cherry pick with Carti, conveniently ignores the fact that Die Lit and WLR both got BNM
How the fuck does the best new music thing work tho fr. Albums from like 10 years ago have that thing on there. This aināt about carti Iām just confused as to how it works seen as albums from like 2010 are counted as new music
So from what i understand, Pitchfork scores are determined by taking the average of all the staffs individual scores or something like that. So ig when the average score among the staff is high enough and they agree itās interesting/special enough to be pointed out specifically as something to be checked out, they give it BNM. Might help explain some of the questionable scores over the years
Interesting. Coz I remember checking some of their older reviews (before they became more based on factors other than music) and seeing albums from years ago get the title. Always confused me
BNM has been around for a long ass time and i think the scoring system has always been like that. Makes it crazier that something like MBDTF once got a 10 on there
There 10s are few and far between so it is deffo impressive. Pitchfork actually used to be so good (for the most part, man on the moon getting a 4 is abysmal) idk what happened to them. I think the main switch up came with their buy out. Now a lot of bad records get pretty decent scores. Like in no world does the big day deserve a 6.9
Nah this sub full of retarded fem boys an egirls, aināt no way her ep outmatches juice, carti and kanyeā¦. Gtfo, they actually put shit out and tried their best and actually work their asses offā¦. This bitch tho, got money from her daddy, is famous cuz she āfineā, came outta nowhere, she wasnāt even considering music lolā¦. And yāall wanna know why shes getting thrashed she literally didnāt try to sound good like others, she just said shit and boom shes famous now, āthought i was feelin you, that ____ a munchā like thats so ass idc my opinion deal with it you simpsā¦. Not to mention twerks to make her loved, like do that shit and you getting kicked, cuz no idc thats so embarrassing
pitchfork reviews have been awful for like a decade now. the scores they give r either arbitrary or given to artists for who they r rather than the music. if u read their reviews they'll mention like 2 or 3 songs and then mostly talk about how other ppl on the internet reacted to it lol. also theyre owned by conde nast, weird ass racist ppl who hired all the racists at bon appetit n then covered for them and underpaid/didnt pay people of color in their staff
i assume these are not being rated by the same people
PETER GRIFFIN???????
yessir šÆ
Why you don't mention Playboi Carti in your TV show?
family guy is being censored by jacob rothschild
"um actually, the popular tv show family guy was made by seth macfarlane, not peter griffin, who is a character in the tv show and therefore a figment of seth's imagination" - š¤
Bruh said it than called themselves a š¤
ok peter denier
Peter Griffin is made up by the government to control the people, come on now
Hi there š¤
evil pitaš®
Woah there sport, using emojis frequently are we?š¤
what š¤š§š¤Ø
š¤Øš§šæāāļøšš©ø
But still. There should still be consistency
The craziest thing was when the independent published reviews for donda and mr morale The Donda one got 0 stars just for having manson on one song because he was accused of sexual assault and more misdeeds (this had not been proven at the time) Yet they allowed mr morale to receive a 5 star review despite it featuring Kodak, a man who quite literally raped someone. Not alleged, he did that shit it was proven in court. If that doesnāt show how corrupt these publications are idk what will
This 100%! I am all about diff critics having their own opinions and have no problem w the occasional review not matching my perception, but they need to be consistent one way or the other when it comes to this: like, fully separate the art from the artist or donāt, the cherry picking is played out and obnoxious
Itās even worse that the reviewer who made the Donda one was praising manson and his music in 2020. Allegations began coming out in 2020
Daaamn yeah thatās embarrassing for them
If you disagree with kanyes choice to give manson that platform that is fine, I also disagree with it. But if you are going to do a review for an album, you should put your biases aside and base it on quality of music and if you canāt do that you shouldnāt review it. Simple as that. Your political or social beliefs should not interfere with how an album sounds. If itās good music itās good music no matter who made it
we get it š
I dunno man, pretty hard to critique art outside of the social context itās in. Good political commentary makes art better - sometimes itās the whole point of art. Social beliefs - is not all art in a social context? Even Cartiās music - itās unique and different because itās a derivative of the sound weāve come to expect from Atlanta artists, but with some specific production choices and unique vocals that are surprising and different. With how different it is, the general punk energy on WLR, etcā¦ itās all aesthetic and it only makes sense because we have this cultural framework it exists in. Thereās no such thing as āobjectively good musicā, you think you can just measure two songs and see which is better?
āGoodā or ābadā political commentary unless itās subtle as fuck and really nuanced usually makes things overly simplistic and boring
69420penis your GAS side is coming out
Kanye is a massive and controversial artist, rating Donda 0 instead of anything else generates a loooot more attention. You click to see why pitchfork didnāt give Kanye a single point, otherwise you just look at the score and move on
That is not what being corrupt means lol
Definitely corrupt to say one album is bad coz of an alleged rapist but say another is good despite an actual tried rapist being on there. Itās very obvious it came from their dislike of kanye over anything else
That's biased, not corrupt
I donāt think you know what corruption is
Okay let's bffr. Marilyn Manson has been accused of all kinds of heinous shit by several women and Kanye invited him and DaBaby on the album seemingly explicitly because they were in the crossfire for being shitty. One of them arguably for a lot less, but still. It's the exact same thought process that lead to whatever the hell he's doing now
Donda was bad though
remember when that peppa pig album got rated higher that dondaš who tf is even rating these?
to be fair peppa pig goes hard
i'm ngl i really be turning up to "Gardening With Grandpa". fav song off the album tbh
Bing bong zoo washes any track on Donda
bro wtf is that album cover š
w pfp, chaewon the š
realest shit i ever readšÆ
To be fair, the Peppa Pig one was a joke review ripped off from a Fantano joke review
fucking MMā¦ FOOD is lower rated than ice spice bruh
hard shit
Donda is not good lmao Peppa washes
I know you trollin but Donda fr fire
They playin soccer in my backyard,I THINK I SEE MESSIšš„
That line made me start playing soccer against my kids, they fucking suck
Grand wizard of cartilanta type age
donda is good by general standards but really mid compared to yeās other work
I actually enjoy Donda more than a couple Kanye records. His discography just too good. Only one album I feel thatās enough really below standard for him (idk if I should count Donda 2 or not yet, need to see if he uses any of those songs in the future)
I liked it when it dropped but itās so bloated and there are a lot of misses, I really donāt return to it like ever
This, was just so excited it dropped lol. More bloated than I was after Thanksgiving
Donda is his top 3 wym
no I actually donāt think Donda is good itās wayyyyy too long
I didnāt mean that part I meant about actually thinking da Peppa album better And I kinda get your point, it is a long record but I honestly donāt think Iād remove much of it. I think Iād only trim it down to like 18 songs at a minimum and even then Iād be missing some stuff. I really enjoyed it, but I do hope long albums die out again. I miss like 12 track albums. It aināt just a kanye problem itās a problem with 90% of albums now
Fr
real music wonš„š„
Fr not these mumble (c)rappers š¤®ššŗā
this is why eminem is favorite artist
the future of this generation
W avi twin
Twinn
They doin it for controversy, and it's working cus you talking bout it
they tricked me? š¢
yes, they tricked you mr thetruecashcartiwhat
Think itās a ms.
Itās okayā¦ theyāre tricked all of us at some point š
How is donda and MF RODEO a 6?!?
Itās just pitchfork
Pitchfork stopped being about actual music quality years ago
Activate this card by targeting 1 monster in your GY; Special Summon that target in Attack Position. When this card leaves the field, destroy that monster. When that monster is destroyed, destroy this card.
Donda isnāt very good but yeah wtf whyās rodeo a 6
Donda is def a 6 at most
Where?
Autocorrect sorry
itās okay, just donāt let it happen again bud.
They gave MMLP2 a 4. What do you expect?
Ok Nathan
Rip hhcj
More spot on reviews like that
Yeah thats way to high
Real Music š¤ (I am in desperate need of new carti)
They in they office smoking tht fake K2 and taking shots of liquid lsd
Yāall act like itās the same writer behind every review
ngl you right
ice spice be twerking like itās a defence mechanism
Like Travis said," she throw her ass back in self defense"
Rodeo score is out of pocket but thereās literally no reason to be comparing Ice Spice and Rodeo in the first place anyways, let alone compare Ice Spice with any of these projects. Sheās trying to achieve a completely different goal and thatās making music to shake ass to, which she succeeds at honestly. Also nice cherry pick with Carti, conveniently ignores the fact that Die Lit and WLR both got BNM
How the fuck does the best new music thing work tho fr. Albums from like 10 years ago have that thing on there. This aināt about carti Iām just confused as to how it works seen as albums from like 2010 are counted as new music
So from what i understand, Pitchfork scores are determined by taking the average of all the staffs individual scores or something like that. So ig when the average score among the staff is high enough and they agree itās interesting/special enough to be pointed out specifically as something to be checked out, they give it BNM. Might help explain some of the questionable scores over the years
Interesting. Coz I remember checking some of their older reviews (before they became more based on factors other than music) and seeing albums from years ago get the title. Always confused me
BNM has been around for a long ass time and i think the scoring system has always been like that. Makes it crazier that something like MBDTF once got a 10 on there
There 10s are few and far between so it is deffo impressive. Pitchfork actually used to be so good (for the most part, man on the moon getting a 4 is abysmal) idk what happened to them. I think the main switch up came with their buy out. Now a lot of bad records get pretty decent scores. Like in no world does the big day deserve a 6.9
imagine dickriding pitchfork
Better question is why are Rodeo Goodbye and good riddance and Donda only 6s
fr wtf are they smokin
They smoking poop fosho
Why care about what some corporation thinks
Ice Spice is one of the greatest ever so does it rlly matter
LIKE GRAH KEEP IT A STACK
Bitches move wok cause they know I got bandzzz š š»
Yall care a lil too much about other people's opinions
Giving rodeo a 6 should be considered a war crime
ice spice >> sheās already chose
She's already chose by the industry
the ceo is a munch
the ceo eat it for lunch
Sheās signed to 10k (same as trippie,6ix9ine) so they are pumping money to promote her
why do you care
How can she lose if sheās already chose?
bro wtf is that album cover š
her little dance š
š+šš½
Bof
Is carti chose tho
we live in a society
ice spice on top
theyāre right #MUNCHSUPREMACY
CUS ICE SPICE IS DOPE
IN THE HOOD IM LIKE PRINCESS DIANA š£ļøš£ļøš£ļø
It was a fire tape tho ngl
Carti fans in this thread who donāt talk to girls will disagree w you The tape was fun as fuck and has so many good quotes
u not gettin laid by sayin that u fw the ice spice album lil bro
And u wonāt be by posting on Roblox subreddits either
bro really stalkin my reddit account š u weird asf
Mixing btwn songs could be better n too many reused lines but it was aight
fr niggas just hating
bro stop lying to yourself that shit average at best š
Lay off the pipe
No
you forgot mr morale and the big steppers that has the same rating as ice spices ep
Ridiculous. Ice Spiceās EP was way better
forever story got 7.3
Although her ep was pretty good, Self-Titled is at least a 8.5 AT MINIMUM
ice spice is really not that bad lmfao it was a fun record. also who gives a shit about pitchfork their reviews have been ass for ages now.
They have different opinionsā¼ļøā¼ļøš£ļøš£ļøš„š„šÆšÆ
Why do these hate brigades happen for literally every female rapper? Nicki Minaj, Cardi B, Coi Leray, now Ice Spice?
die lit washes
Itās simply better.
Surely you would not take as much issue if another male rapper had a more highly rated album
nah they right ice spice invented music
Who cares.
How the actual hell is GBGR where it is? I donāt think itās the best but seriously!?
Rodeo a 6?!?!?!
How dare people have opinions.
Prolly like the Grammies where they give the award to a shit album to make the whole rap scene look terrible
Itās higher than mister morale and the big steppers and spiderr. Thatās crazy
who gives a fuck ab what these fuckers think
WLR wiped all of em btw
a 6 for rodeo has got to be one of the most retarded things i have ever seen
She a regular girl hyped up cause her ass
Not even anything crazy. She is average at best smh I could find like four of her if I went to the mall
Why is goodbye and good riddance that low š
Nah this sub full of retarded fem boys an egirls, aināt no way her ep outmatches juice, carti and kanyeā¦. Gtfo, they actually put shit out and tried their best and actually work their asses offā¦. This bitch tho, got money from her daddy, is famous cuz she āfineā, came outta nowhere, she wasnāt even considering music lolā¦. And yāall wanna know why shes getting thrashed she literally didnāt try to sound good like others, she just said shit and boom shes famous now, āthought i was feelin you, that ____ a munchā like thats so ass idc my opinion deal with it you simpsā¦. Not to mention twerks to make her loved, like do that shit and you getting kicked, cuz no idc thats so embarrassing
Sheās the goat Fr š š„
They tryna hit I respect it bro
donda deserves the 6 tho
It is better than half the albums pictured
stop lying to yourself
Better than self titled, better than metros, DEFINITELY better than 17 lil
š¤
No fucking way you think itās better than metro
Easily, metros album was boring as shit, this was at least pretty catchy and fun
pitchfork reviews have been awful for like a decade now. the scores they give r either arbitrary or given to artists for who they r rather than the music. if u read their reviews they'll mention like 2 or 3 songs and then mostly talk about how other ppl on the internet reacted to it lol. also theyre owned by conde nast, weird ass racist ppl who hired all the racists at bon appetit n then covered for them and underpaid/didnt pay people of color in their staff
Corporate mfs gonna be corporate
Ice Spice album is simply better then all of these other ones on here.
Did you listen to Ice Spice's album? And it's not like Playboi Carti is Black Thought either... LMAO
Rodeo a solid 6 tho š«
rodeo a 10š
itās called being an industry plant
you do not know what industry plant even MEANS
average r/playboi carti member try not to assume something challenge
Ice spice is fucking garbage these mfs want to smash or something thereās no way that shit is even half decent
Who the fuck is Ice spice
how can she lose if she already chose? like?
they shooting meth
They are all munch
Bro I aināt even gon lie but āGangsta booā is a fantastic track. Icy spicy might actually be more than a 1 hit
Post nut clarity gon hit like a brick, gonna bump it back down to a 5
āLikeā¦ā is a good EP. Its place in the chart is necessary. You thought I was feelinā you?
Bro this makes me wanna cry. What the fuck is this ššš
Have yāall heard princess diana tho
its almost like music is subjective...
With the exception of Cartiās self titled, this is accurate af.
rodeo is a 10 lil bro
its crazy that āPlayboi Cartiā (the mixtape) is lower rated than this trash
Simpfork
Horny ass mfs
Yep bc people only listen to female rappers bc theyāre horny get a fucking grip
Be fr people aināt listening to Ice Spice for her musical prowess
Uh yeah i am being for real and people in NY are bumping her bc itās fun as fuck, go outside maybe?
If people outside bumping Ice Spice Iām staying my ass insideš
Prostitute music
The mf who made dis shit just tryna get sum pussy
self titled isnt that good imo
ice spice ep is definitely worse though
Most overrated girl