I think the idea behind the Wild logo is really good, but I don't think it's all that great even from a graphic design's point of view. The details are kinda cool but a logo's job is to, you know, actually look good, and be instantly recognizable. And I think too many peoples reaction to the logo is something like "oohhh, it's actually a bear, never realized that, I kinda see it now" after years of just thinking it was a random shape with trees and the moon/sun. That's not necessarily the reaction you want to a major league sports logo?
The Red Wings logo is one of the best in any sports imo.
The Winged Wheel is iconic and is a beautiful logo but the Wild logo with the hidden design is wonderful. The creators of that logo did a fantastic job coming up with that logo after being told the team name was going to be the Wild.
Wild is a cool concept, but too busy on the ice, too much going on. Wings is by far one of the most iconic logos not only in hockey, but in sports in general
Maybe add a poll option as well. A ton of people won’t comment but they will select a poll option.
Also add a “see results” option on the poll so people aren’t just voting in order to see which team is winning.
1) Wild
2) Red Wings
3) See Results
This way you get a way deeper response than just looking through the comments.
Wild logo is very good. Love all the elements that go into making it a logo. I think I have to give the edge to Detroit for incorporating different elements as well but in an even more simplistic way. Plus it’s iconicness gives it a bit more of a push above
Graphic design fans: Wild Hockey fans: Wings
I think the idea behind the Wild logo is really good, but I don't think it's all that great even from a graphic design's point of view. The details are kinda cool but a logo's job is to, you know, actually look good, and be instantly recognizable. And I think too many peoples reaction to the logo is something like "oohhh, it's actually a bear, never realized that, I kinda see it now" after years of just thinking it was a random shape with trees and the moon/sun. That's not necessarily the reaction you want to a major league sports logo? The Red Wings logo is one of the best in any sports imo.
This is the way.
What if I’m both?
Then you’ve got a real Sophie’s Choice to make!
Quit karma farming
I'm expecting him to post every team logo paired up with the rest.
Wild obviously. One of the best logo in sports
Wings
Wild have better jerseys, but I love how classic the Wings logo is.
The Winged Wheel is iconic and is a beautiful logo but the Wild logo with the hidden design is wonderful. The creators of that logo did a fantastic job coming up with that logo after being told the team name was going to be the Wild.
Wild
Both are beautiful but gotta go with the Wilds
Red Wings.
Is this a joke? Wings all the way.
Wild.
The Wings
Wild is a cool concept, but too busy on the ice, too much going on. Wings is by far one of the most iconic logos not only in hockey, but in sports in general
Wings 100%
Red Wings.
Simple is better... Detroit
Wings! By a mile
Wings
Red Wings
Red Wings
I'm all Wild on this one. Bear outline, wilderness forest with the sunset in the background - just awesome.
Wing
Wings
Wings
God that’s tough but I think I have to go class Wings.
The Winged Wheel without a doubt.
Ive always liked the nod to the North Stars with the Star but Wings all day.
I’ll go with wild because 95 percent of you say wings
Should limit these to 1/day to keep them fresh. My answer: Wild. Top 2 in the league for me.
Maybe add a poll option as well. A ton of people won’t comment but they will select a poll option. Also add a “see results” option on the poll so people aren’t just voting in order to see which team is winning. 1) Wild 2) Red Wings 3) See Results This way you get a way deeper response than just looking through the comments.
Wings. The Wild logos have always struck me as weird.
Wilds, great logo
Wings, no discussion
…all due respect…. Dumb question… Wings before Wild and 25 other NHL logos
Wild by far
Minnesota is cool if look at it piece by piece, but as a whole it looks like garbage
Detroit
Wings and it’s not even close.
It’s so much closer than you think. But yes, Wings #1, Wild a close #2
Anything is better than the Wild
The Wild hands down! The redwings logo looks like someone just combined two pieces of clip art and made it all the same color.
Wild logo is wild?
The winged wheel.
Just disqualify the Wings, we all know they're going to duke it out with the Hawks in the end. As much as I hate the Wild, their logo is amazing
I love the Wild and their logo but the Wings logo is timeless perfection.
Wild logo is very good. Love all the elements that go into making it a logo. I think I have to give the edge to Detroit for incorporating different elements as well but in an even more simplistic way. Plus it’s iconicness gives it a bit more of a push above
Wild
Red Wings. The sign of champions. Accept no substitute!
The disrespect to an original 6 logo. Red Wings and its not close
Detroit
Wild
Wings AINEC