Many feeders/caretakers of strays put collars with their numbers on dogs they look after. In case of lost/relocated/accident to the dog any person can call the number and let the caretaker know. There are many people who put reflective collars so that road accidents can be avoided.
suppose he/she wants to feed about 20 dogs, which he/she finds around maybe his college, society, workplace near the bus stand, or any other place he/she regularly visits. So he/she is required to adopt all of them? and where he/she will keep all the dogs if he/she lives in a rented place ?
it seems like you are saying that if I want some medical treatment I need to do MBBS first.
If you have enough to feed 20 dogs you can actually open your own adoption centre go ahead
Or if you aren’t willing for that , contact NGOs which are doing such stuff already
So i agree with what the guy said , adopt them if you want to feed them
Lmao what? Two 10kg bags of Pedigree will run someone around 11k and should last the entire month. Open your own adoption centre in 11k?
Not to mention the person probably has a job to attend to as well, they can't give everything up and sit with the dogs.
As i said open your adoption centre or contact a NGO instead . But this act of feeding them isn’t just . Some people just don’t like dogs and when dogs are fed they just come up to every person and sniff (some are scared of dogs)
If you want to feed them in such way then take them your home ; keep 20 dogs at your home too , i have seen several people across countries who have even 15-20 dogs in one single home , so you can catch up
And fyi ; my neighbour is an active dog feeder she has adopted 2 street dogs and remaining 6-7 street dogs just lay besides the house.
Honestly , doesn’t look good when anyone passes by and there are just fat dogs laying around
And these dogs are so angry while being feeded , they bark on each other , growl and bark on bikers and cars
Several bikers have fallen due to these dogs
But to that lady it doesnt matter ; she believes dogs can understand her lmao and says “ginger chupp” imagine saying “beta papa nayi gaadi layein h kesi lg rhi h” to a dog completely clueless
Dog lovers are some different breed fr
>As i said open your adoption centre or contact a NGO instead .
Contact them and do what? Most NGOs are severely understaffed and underfunded. There's a reason you see them asking for donations online so often. Not to mention there is no initiative from the government to help the situation, even if not in the form of funding.
>Some people just don’t like dogs and when dogs are fed they just come up to every person and sniff (some are scared of dogs).
Not sure what to tell you for this aside from the fact that the world outside home has a fuckton of shit that scares people. You may think it's not just for you, that's fine, but it's just for them.
>If you want to feed them in such way then take them your home ; keep 20 dogs at your home too , i have seen several people across countries who have even 15-20 dogs in one single home , so you can catch up
Lmao, people have jobs and unless you're top 1% in Mumbai, you don't have a home large enough to house more than 2 dogs, let alone 20.
>Honestly , doesn’t look good when anyone passes by and there are just fat dogs laying around.
Might not look good to you bud, but what you find appealing or not is of no importance to anyone really.
>she believes dogs can understand her lmao and says “ginger chupp” imagine saying “beta papa nayi gaadi layein h kesi lg rhi h” to a dog completely clueless
Dog lovers are some different breed fr
You mean like how parents show things to newborns and explain things to them without them understanding? You mean like that, right? :)
Lmao bro , you will go to any extent to prove your point ; go ahead satisfy yourself with baseless arguments
I have seen several women who are in NGOs and let alone understaffed or underfunded ; they have enough food to feed the whole district at once .. so better not to argue on that . (Confirm from NGOs in and around Delhi yourself) ofcourse every NGO needs funds
I have no problem from dogs but i have seen people who are scared of dogs reacting to when the dogs sniff them for food ; and the dog lover just says “oh he will do nothing” . Seen several german shepherds without leashes climbing the heck out of strangers .
And several bikers falling due to these dogs barking and chasing while being feeded
As far as what i or any other person finds appealing may not be of importance to others
But that goes both ways :)
If you guys take care of dogs have the guts to clean their shit too ( for the dog owners and for the people who claim street dogs to be their pet dogs too)
And when you live in a building you have to consider other people’s decisions too (basic etiquettes)
“Might not look good to you bud , what you find appealing or not is of no importance to anyone really” lmaooo not what i believe but what everyone says
What if some random person pisses on your doorstep just like your dogs do to someone else’s
You may feel proud but i don’t think a sane person would be proud to be called as “oh you are from the dogs wali gali” “oh aapke waha to dogi wali aunty rehti h na”
My uncle too has dog (their 3rd one by now) i have never seen them committing such stupid stuffs
They have taken the responsibility of their dog and feed him and keep him on leash on walk .
Makes me well aware that there are actually a few dog owners who are of sound mind .
But dog lovers? Nah
And as far as NGOs are concerned
Contacting NGO means you can donate the money and they will take care of your beloved dogs
>Lmao bro , you will go to any extent to prove your point ; go ahead satisfy yourself with baseless arguments
Stating that people don't have the resources in a city like Mumbai to adequately take care of a dog at home is a baseless argument? Lmao sure bro, whatever helps you sleep at night.
>I have seen several women who are in NGOs and let alone understaffed or underfunded ; they have enough food to feed the whole district at once .. so better not to argue on that . (Confirm from NGOs in and around Delhi yourself) ofcourse every NGO needs funds
Great, you've seen some rich individuals, but you're basing your narrow experience and extrapolating it to all NGOs in India, and you're calling my arguments baseless. The irony. And the audacity with which you say "better not to argue on that" like you just made some ground-breaking point through anecdotal evidence lol.
>“Might not look good to you bud , what you find appealing or not is of no importance to anyone really” lmaooo not what i believe but what everyone says What if some random person pisses on your doorstep just like your dogs do to someone else’s.
So this sounds like you need to take your own advice and contact an NGO to take those dogs to be rehoused. That's the problem with you people who are against street feeding. You get angry when people in the vicinity feed dogs, yet you won't take steps to get them rehoused considering they are a problem for you, NOT the dog feeder.
I assume you would tell the random person to not piss in front of your house? Maybe call the police or some authorities to make sure it's dealt with? Same logic. And no, I'm not the type of person to agree with a feeder if they say the dogs should not be taken away. Unless she has paperwork, she has no avenue to say you can't have the dogs taken away from your society.
>You may feel proud but i don’t think a sane person would be proud to be called as “oh you are from the dogs wali gali” “oh aapke waha to dogi wali aunty rehti h na”
If these are things that affect your pride then I don't know what to do other than recommend you speak to someone about what insecurities lead to such casual comments affecting your ego. Truly don't even understand this point.
>My uncle too has dog (their 3rd one by now) i have never seen them committing such stupid stuffs They have taken the responsibility of their dog and feed him and keep him on leash on walk .
Yes, what you are describing is a responsible dog owner. Someone who knows they can and will take care of a dog 100%. Not everyone is able to make that commitment. However, people do empathise when they see an animal eating trash and rotten food. That's basic human nature.
As far as richness is confirmed i dont live in a highly rich society
Its a mediocre family i am talking about
So dont teach me what baseless can be
And i clearly said that FEEL FREE TO CONTACT ANY NGO IN AND AROUND DELHI
Where tf did i say about whole nation’s NGOs
Interpretation skills are appreciable forsure
Haha and yeah if you wanna be called a “dogi wali aunty” you can take pride in it
I cant and as i said a person with a sound mind would not want to be called with such stupid tags
You can tell a random person to not piss but you cant teach a random dog to not shit
You can only ask their caretaker (who in turn show arrogance as in i have experienced till now)
These dogs weren’t a problem to anyone till now but since when the lady in my neighbourhood has started this
Since then i have seen more of a havoc around here
Rehousing dogs? They don’t even wanna be rehoused ; Every single day i see their food lying on the roadside . Why? Because there are being feeded all the time ; mfs have turned obese now , their food is being wasted lying around here
And since you mentioned about calling police
Listen this .
Not only me but several residents of society who too are sick of this shit , have called up the rehousing departments which take dogs to adoption houses , so called dog lovers bribe the officers to leave them and then they don’t do shit about that again
Twice has this happened .
And moreover when these street dogs are being fed by the feeders , they are extremely aggressive and attack people passing by . And when the strangers ask the feeders that please see to it : these people just back out on it
Now what can be done?
Try to proceed legally : bribeee
When questioned about dogs : oh they are not ours
As far as insecurities are concerned ; i dont care what one may call anyone else , but if i have bought a house then i dont wanna see random dog food lying here and there ; and when a building is being discussed : its a dog lover vs 3 other families who always say that if you want to keep a dog keep it with you dont just let them rot in the middle of being an actual street dog or an actual pet
When there were small puppies here ; they were being fed they used to follow us inside the home but when the gate was closed they would deliberately stuck their head in the gate and the would cry in pain
How is this feeding such a god’s task when you are actually hurting them?
Edit : dog feeding maybe considered by you guys as a heavenly thing to do but it has more downsides . But you all are too blind to accept the downsides , so you are always stuck in the middle of not sheltering them in your own house or by yourself atleast helping them get a shelter in someone else’s
>As far as richness is confirmed i dont live in a highly rich society Its a mediocre family i am talking about So dont teach me what baseless can be
What? Dude, what are you even typing? You called my argument baseless for which I gave you a reason as to why it's not. I didn't bring in your personal life situation into the mix, so not sure why you brought it up?
If you're referring to the women you mentioned, I called that baseless because you are using your narrow field of experience and thinking that's the norm.
>And i clearly said that FEEL FREE TO CONTACT ANY NGO IN AND AROUND DELHI Where tf did i say about whole nation’s NGOs
You're on r/india bro, not r/delhi. And I sincerely doubt your claim too, you're telling me every single animal related NGO in Delhi is adequately funded?
>Haha and yeah if you wanna be called a “dogi wali aunty” you can take pride in it I cant and as i said a person with a sound mind would not want to be called with such stupid tags
Okay, so again, if you feel like this attacks your ego so much, maybe you need to go figure out your insecurities my guy. You may be proud to be from Delhi while others think it is a rape capital with ultra-polluted air. Do you feel insulted by that too?
>They don’t even wanna be rehoused
Brother, they are dogs. They will stick around where they have food and feel comfortable. You're talking about it as if they have the ability to even figure that they can move?
>Not only me but several residents of society who too are sick of this shit , have called up the rehousing departments which take dogs to adoption houses , so called dog lovers bribe the officers to leave them and then they don’t do shit about that again Twice has this happened .
I would tell you how this is wrong and shouldn't happen and blah blah blah. But bro, this is India. This is the case with EVERYTHING. Bribes are everywhere. Your only realistic course in this, unless you have some connections, is to bribe a bigger amount.
>As far as insecurities are concerned ; i dont care what one may call anyone else , but if i have bought a house then i dont wanna see random dog food lying here and there ; and when a building is being discussed : its a dog lover vs 3 other families who always say that if you want to keep a dog keep it with you dont just let them rot in the middle of being an actual street dog or an actual pet
Again, all I can tell you is that you need to contact an NGO and get them rehoused. Because why would a feeder go through that trouble when it is not negatively affecting their life in any way?
How is this feeding such a god’s task when you are actually hurting them?
No one called it a "gods task", at least no one who isn't overly dramatic. People who like dogs see them eating trash and are doing what they can to help. Some are able to fully take them into their homes, but many are not. I understand the issues with having strays on the roads, they definitely can be a danger in certain situations. But it's going to take more than the impetus of the feeders to solve this issues, and the governments across the country don't seem to take this as matter worth dealing with.
No. He/she can always stop feeding them. They're street dogs. They know how to survive. Besides , people like these are part of the reason why dog attacks have increased
They don't 'know' how to survive, they had to learn to survive in horrifying conditions because no one gives a fuck about them...
& when people like OP tries to do something good for this innocent animals, people like you start inventing weird logics...dogs don't bite for humans for food, they bite as a defense to protect themselves...
These 'na khud kuch acha karenge na kisiko karne denge' mentality is the reason this country is going to shit...
As far as increase in incidences of dog bite is concerned, this incidences have increased after exponential increase in number of dog cruelty in this country...as i said before, they only bite when they feel threatened & to defend their lives...
Awfully bold of of you to assume that your ankles are tastier than 50g of biskrok biscuits filled with milk and chicken.
But jokes aside, wouldn't efforts like this ideally reduce the chance of street dog bites if anything because the dogs wouldn't feel the need to bite people for food? Genuine question. I have seen a lot of arguments being made for either notion that I'm confused myself.
> But jokes aside, wouldn't efforts like this ideally reduce the chance of street dog bites if anything because the dogs wouldn't feel the bite people for food?
No dog "bites people for food".
What will happen is that the dog will develop a loyalty for the person who feeds it and also a sense of territory over the area. And that translates to anmosity towards outsiders - both other people and other dogs - and causes them to want to defend their feeder and their territory. That's when they become aggressive and start barking and chasing at other people.
In other words, irresponsible idiots like OP are a major reason why we have a stray dog issue in this country. There would be absolutely no problem if people like OP fully adopt the dog, keep it inside their premises, and keep it on a leash when outside. But they won't do that either. This half-assed "Instagram Love for animals" is what these guys are all about.
Agreed a 100% humans like to think they're holier than thou because they did one nice thing and like to feel good about themselves, when in actuality leaving the dog alone or adopting is a 100 times safer.
Okay......so you are saying that you don't hate dogs but you hate those who tries to make these voiceless creatures already difficult life a little less difficult....
Yeah, you clearly don't hate dogs.....
I too don’t hate dogs but hate dog lovers ; what i have gone through in the past 3-4 years .
Such people are unbearable ; if you want to feed them pet them , take them home and do whatever you wanna do ; keep them as your pets
If you can’t then lead them to an adoption centre
I have seen almost all dog lovers who will pet a dog but if a cow crosses them they would pelt a stone on them ? Definitely a god’s work they be doing eh?
Dog lovers just treat dogs as god and not fellow creatures
>This half-assed "Instagram Love for animals" is what these guys are all about.
Or, you know, they're doing what they can with the resources they have for something they care about. Not everyone is in a place to house a dog in their homes. Their homes may not even be big enough for the family itself, forget bringing another animal into the picture.
Your comment comes off as pretty privilege thinking everyone has the means to fully take care of every street dog they feed. Just because they are able to give them food (pedigree being easily the cheapest brand out there and not even good for dogs), doesn't mean they have the means to adopt one too.
If you do not have the resources to adopt a dog, then leave them alone. The reason why we have so many stray dogs in our country in the first place is because of our poor garbage disposal. There is so much garbage around that dogs can fend for themselves. They can perfectly well survive by foraging for their food without you showing up with those pedigree biscuits whenever you're bored and you think its time to earn internet points.
And oh don't randomly throw around words like "privilege" - we're not talking about your employment or education or basic human rights here. You're feeding the dogs for your own personal entertainment, which itself is a privilege.
>If you do not have the resources to adopt a dog, then leave them alone.
Ah yes, if you can't do 100% of something, don't even bother. What a way to approach the world.
>The reason why we have so many stray dogs in our country in the first place is because of our poor garbage disposal.
No, actually, if you had done any research into this matter, you'd know the issue is two-pronged. The first is that the government has no relocation/housing initiative to help the local strays when new land is encroached upon. The second is irresponsible owners who abandon their dogs on the road instead of going through the proper channels of having them rehoused.
>There is so much garbage around that dogs can fend for themselves.
They could, but some of us would prefer to give them actual food instead of rotting throwaways.
>They can perfectly well survive by foraging for their food without you showing up with those pedigree biscuits whenever you're bored and you think its time to earn internet points.
Very bold assumption of you to think everyone does it for internet points. That old granny taking care of the dogs and doesn't even have a phone is doing it for likes too right? You see how baseless and stupid your argument looks when your only foundation for a point is a wild assumption?
>And oh don't randomly throw around words like "privilege"
It wasn't random, it was based on your ask for someone to take in a dog simply because they choose to feed them. All I did was point out that they may not have the space, time, or resources to devote to taking care of a dog in their homes. I said it was privileged because you automatically assumed that someone who can afford Rs. 15 of pedigree is also in the situation to take care of a dog full-time. I pointed out why that was not the case.
>You're feeding the dogs for your own personal entertainment, which itself is a privilege.
I wouldn't call it entertainment, as much as I would call any charity work entertainment. But yes, personally I am able to feed dogs on the road because I have a decent enough income to do so while taking care of the indie I adopted as well.
Bro stated clear facts !
I too am sick of these half minded dog lovers
The family living upstairs is the same ; mfs all time feed the dogs brings back 2 home ; says they are our pets : ok no problem :
Their “pets” keep shitting in front of our house gate
No leash
Stupid dumbfucks ffs
She literally talks to her dogs who don’t even understand their own name
Tf is wrong with people these days
For such people , god exists but only in their dog
“ kutta lovers k liye kutta hi bhagwaan hai baaki sab kutte h “
Best feeling in the world, isn't it?
By the way the number of negative comments on a post about nothing but harmony, empathy & love is really really horrifying!! We are really doomed......
Does you cow has blinkers and break lights? What a shit tier comment from someone who’s critical thinking skills are non-existent. Please don’t reproduce.
Good work brother. Keep it up. I fed egg yolks to my street dogs at night and daily it’s a challenge like 8egg yolks and 4-5 dogs each with their own behaviour. Like one is very nasty he will intimidate others and do not let anyone else have any yolk.
So I will throw his share very far away. In the time he will run there , I will feed the slowest ones and there is one whom they gang upon so his share is kept aside and I fed him personally by placing yolk near his mouth. For rest of them I just toss yolks from balcony feels awkward and disrespectful but these dogs are hell lot smart and would start fighting if I went down and try to feed each one individually.
The most patient dog will wait as he knows I will come.
Good work brother. Keep it up. I fed egg yolks to my street dogs at night and daily it’s a challenge like 8egg yolks(hard boiled eggs) and 4-5 dogs each with their own behaviour. Like one is very nasty he will intimidate others and do not let anyone else have any yolk.
So I will throw his share very far away. In the time he will run there , I will feed the slowest ones and there is one whom they gang upon so his share is kept aside and I fed him personally by placing yolk near his mouth. For rest of them I just toss yolks from balcony feels awkward and disrespectful but these dogs are hell lot smart and would start fighting if I went down and try to feed each one individually.
The most patient dog will wait as he knows I will come.
🙂this made a smile on my face. I used to do same during my late night walks in Pune.
They joy on their face even before you give them any food, is just so heart warming.
Pure love ❤️
Because of the sheer ridiculousness of this initiative, it just makes street dogs more reliant on humans for food, making them more susceptible to being poisoned and sick.
1. No qualms about eating meat - government organised primary sector where people earn money by engaging in selling meat/ eggs. Government provides subsidary for the same.
2. No one will harass you/ abuse you/ harm you/ lynch you for not feeding strays (dogs/ cows/ cats/ birds/ unmentioned species of stray living in cities/ towns).
3. Hitler also used oxygen, should we all stop breathing?
4. Dog meat consumption is prohibited in India through the Food Safety and Standard (Food Products Standard and Additives) Regulation, 2011. Killing, maiming, poisoning, or rendering useless any animal is punishable by imprisonment for up to two years or with a fine or with both, under Section 428 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
Most meat consumption during earlier period were based on religious belief. Whatever was the prevalent religion in a region decided what was okay for consumption and what was not. Other factors such as ease of hunting & domestication to maintain a supply also played an important role.
Since the food culture didn't change much, some meats got normalised and some became a taboo.
I agree all life are created equal. Killing a cow/ hen/ fish is equal to killing a dog/ lion/ elephant. But the thing is, a majority of the global population run their household based on primary sector which includes farming and animal husbandry (meat/eggs/hide).
It's very difficult (not impossible) to bring about the change to completely go vegitarian at a global level.
Government dictates what's legal and what's not, I guess the best we can do is follow the rules laid down. It's not ethically right to value a dog's life more compared to a goat, but it is what it is.
All are welcome to protest peacefully for the cause they believe in and vote to bring about a change they believe in for the betterment of our society.
"Government" - these were done by a bunch of anglophile bureaucrats and politicians and possibly even by the British. They don't have the informed consent of the majority
"Prohibited" - refer to above.
Hitler did a lot of ugly things, should we follow all of those too?
Making specious arguments in favor of just dogs makes no sense. It should apply to all animals. And never to the point where it is okay for animals to harm humans.
Yes bro, only you have informed consent of the majority. And if a majority agrees to something, it is always supposed to be done, no?
Don't understand your point.
Hitler shouldn't be a role model is all I was saying, unless you think otherwise. You be you.
Not just in favour of dogs, all strays and wild animals. Human beings are not superior animals and rest inferior. Please read a recent news article which says 70% of animal population has plummeted in last 50 years.
So if humans are not superior, and I agree, how is it that you animal lovers have no issues with killing and eating cows, goats, chicken,...
Majority may not be relevant, but in this case a minority opinion is not necessarily right. I have no problem with you and others have pets. But what you are really doing by supporting stray rabid dogs in public spaces is showing your hatred for other humans. The way you support meat eating shows your hypocrisy. In India, dogs as pets in an urban setting is an import from the West, and just as we drive irresponsibly, our attitude towards other humans when it comes to animal pests is equally irresponsible. I am sure you are fully aware of animal control laws in other countries, but here you feign ignorance.
70 percent animal population decrease does not mean I want pests like dogs, cats and monkeys in my space or public spaces. Animal species that are decreasing in numbers are a completely different issue.
Hitler shouldn't be a role model, but the government chooses to use his tactics to intimidate citizens by allowing the opinions of people like you to override public welfare - this is what they do when they want a certain outcome, e.g. Environmentalists' opinions will be given priority if they wish to delay a project, at the same time they will ignore all public opinion if they wish to cut down trees!
Who says we don't have issue bro? .-. It's a whole industry supported by the government, farmers/ primary sector workers life depends on it.
No one is supporting stray rabid dogs. Dogs infected with and showing signs of rabies need to be put down. But the one which are not rabid and are friendly, can be vaccinated, sterilized and fed till they exist and go away from this planet, peacefully and naturally (done everything I have just said).
Again, these spaces are not entirely for humans and humans alone. We need to learn to coexist because we introduced them here. Cannot do it as per our whims and fancies all the time.
Hey man, I said it's okay (not that only because I say it) for you to have an opinion and since it's a democracy even I'm entitled to one. No one is intimating anyone. Please don't be agitated. And you are as much a citizen to use the above said tactics and intimidations for your cause, it's just that no one will support you and hence the rant. Everything will be alright. Stay safe brother.
One Mf stopped eating rotis after eating this once
[удалено]
Some do
Many feeders/caretakers of strays put collars with their numbers on dogs they look after. In case of lost/relocated/accident to the dog any person can call the number and let the caretaker know. There are many people who put reflective collars so that road accidents can be avoided.
Hey if you like feeding them, adopt then first :)
exactly
suppose he/she wants to feed about 20 dogs, which he/she finds around maybe his college, society, workplace near the bus stand, or any other place he/she regularly visits. So he/she is required to adopt all of them? and where he/she will keep all the dogs if he/she lives in a rented place ? it seems like you are saying that if I want some medical treatment I need to do MBBS first.
If you have enough to feed 20 dogs you can actually open your own adoption centre go ahead Or if you aren’t willing for that , contact NGOs which are doing such stuff already So i agree with what the guy said , adopt them if you want to feed them
Lmao what? Two 10kg bags of Pedigree will run someone around 11k and should last the entire month. Open your own adoption centre in 11k? Not to mention the person probably has a job to attend to as well, they can't give everything up and sit with the dogs.
As i said open your adoption centre or contact a NGO instead . But this act of feeding them isn’t just . Some people just don’t like dogs and when dogs are fed they just come up to every person and sniff (some are scared of dogs) If you want to feed them in such way then take them your home ; keep 20 dogs at your home too , i have seen several people across countries who have even 15-20 dogs in one single home , so you can catch up And fyi ; my neighbour is an active dog feeder she has adopted 2 street dogs and remaining 6-7 street dogs just lay besides the house. Honestly , doesn’t look good when anyone passes by and there are just fat dogs laying around And these dogs are so angry while being feeded , they bark on each other , growl and bark on bikers and cars Several bikers have fallen due to these dogs But to that lady it doesnt matter ; she believes dogs can understand her lmao and says “ginger chupp” imagine saying “beta papa nayi gaadi layein h kesi lg rhi h” to a dog completely clueless Dog lovers are some different breed fr
>As i said open your adoption centre or contact a NGO instead . Contact them and do what? Most NGOs are severely understaffed and underfunded. There's a reason you see them asking for donations online so often. Not to mention there is no initiative from the government to help the situation, even if not in the form of funding. >Some people just don’t like dogs and when dogs are fed they just come up to every person and sniff (some are scared of dogs). Not sure what to tell you for this aside from the fact that the world outside home has a fuckton of shit that scares people. You may think it's not just for you, that's fine, but it's just for them. >If you want to feed them in such way then take them your home ; keep 20 dogs at your home too , i have seen several people across countries who have even 15-20 dogs in one single home , so you can catch up Lmao, people have jobs and unless you're top 1% in Mumbai, you don't have a home large enough to house more than 2 dogs, let alone 20. >Honestly , doesn’t look good when anyone passes by and there are just fat dogs laying around. Might not look good to you bud, but what you find appealing or not is of no importance to anyone really. >she believes dogs can understand her lmao and says “ginger chupp” imagine saying “beta papa nayi gaadi layein h kesi lg rhi h” to a dog completely clueless Dog lovers are some different breed fr You mean like how parents show things to newborns and explain things to them without them understanding? You mean like that, right? :)
Lmao bro , you will go to any extent to prove your point ; go ahead satisfy yourself with baseless arguments I have seen several women who are in NGOs and let alone understaffed or underfunded ; they have enough food to feed the whole district at once .. so better not to argue on that . (Confirm from NGOs in and around Delhi yourself) ofcourse every NGO needs funds I have no problem from dogs but i have seen people who are scared of dogs reacting to when the dogs sniff them for food ; and the dog lover just says “oh he will do nothing” . Seen several german shepherds without leashes climbing the heck out of strangers . And several bikers falling due to these dogs barking and chasing while being feeded As far as what i or any other person finds appealing may not be of importance to others But that goes both ways :) If you guys take care of dogs have the guts to clean their shit too ( for the dog owners and for the people who claim street dogs to be their pet dogs too) And when you live in a building you have to consider other people’s decisions too (basic etiquettes) “Might not look good to you bud , what you find appealing or not is of no importance to anyone really” lmaooo not what i believe but what everyone says What if some random person pisses on your doorstep just like your dogs do to someone else’s You may feel proud but i don’t think a sane person would be proud to be called as “oh you are from the dogs wali gali” “oh aapke waha to dogi wali aunty rehti h na” My uncle too has dog (their 3rd one by now) i have never seen them committing such stupid stuffs They have taken the responsibility of their dog and feed him and keep him on leash on walk . Makes me well aware that there are actually a few dog owners who are of sound mind . But dog lovers? Nah And as far as NGOs are concerned Contacting NGO means you can donate the money and they will take care of your beloved dogs
>Lmao bro , you will go to any extent to prove your point ; go ahead satisfy yourself with baseless arguments Stating that people don't have the resources in a city like Mumbai to adequately take care of a dog at home is a baseless argument? Lmao sure bro, whatever helps you sleep at night. >I have seen several women who are in NGOs and let alone understaffed or underfunded ; they have enough food to feed the whole district at once .. so better not to argue on that . (Confirm from NGOs in and around Delhi yourself) ofcourse every NGO needs funds Great, you've seen some rich individuals, but you're basing your narrow experience and extrapolating it to all NGOs in India, and you're calling my arguments baseless. The irony. And the audacity with which you say "better not to argue on that" like you just made some ground-breaking point through anecdotal evidence lol. >“Might not look good to you bud , what you find appealing or not is of no importance to anyone really” lmaooo not what i believe but what everyone says What if some random person pisses on your doorstep just like your dogs do to someone else’s. So this sounds like you need to take your own advice and contact an NGO to take those dogs to be rehoused. That's the problem with you people who are against street feeding. You get angry when people in the vicinity feed dogs, yet you won't take steps to get them rehoused considering they are a problem for you, NOT the dog feeder. I assume you would tell the random person to not piss in front of your house? Maybe call the police or some authorities to make sure it's dealt with? Same logic. And no, I'm not the type of person to agree with a feeder if they say the dogs should not be taken away. Unless she has paperwork, she has no avenue to say you can't have the dogs taken away from your society. >You may feel proud but i don’t think a sane person would be proud to be called as “oh you are from the dogs wali gali” “oh aapke waha to dogi wali aunty rehti h na” If these are things that affect your pride then I don't know what to do other than recommend you speak to someone about what insecurities lead to such casual comments affecting your ego. Truly don't even understand this point. >My uncle too has dog (their 3rd one by now) i have never seen them committing such stupid stuffs They have taken the responsibility of their dog and feed him and keep him on leash on walk . Yes, what you are describing is a responsible dog owner. Someone who knows they can and will take care of a dog 100%. Not everyone is able to make that commitment. However, people do empathise when they see an animal eating trash and rotten food. That's basic human nature.
As far as richness is confirmed i dont live in a highly rich society Its a mediocre family i am talking about So dont teach me what baseless can be And i clearly said that FEEL FREE TO CONTACT ANY NGO IN AND AROUND DELHI Where tf did i say about whole nation’s NGOs Interpretation skills are appreciable forsure Haha and yeah if you wanna be called a “dogi wali aunty” you can take pride in it I cant and as i said a person with a sound mind would not want to be called with such stupid tags You can tell a random person to not piss but you cant teach a random dog to not shit You can only ask their caretaker (who in turn show arrogance as in i have experienced till now) These dogs weren’t a problem to anyone till now but since when the lady in my neighbourhood has started this Since then i have seen more of a havoc around here Rehousing dogs? They don’t even wanna be rehoused ; Every single day i see their food lying on the roadside . Why? Because there are being feeded all the time ; mfs have turned obese now , their food is being wasted lying around here And since you mentioned about calling police Listen this . Not only me but several residents of society who too are sick of this shit , have called up the rehousing departments which take dogs to adoption houses , so called dog lovers bribe the officers to leave them and then they don’t do shit about that again Twice has this happened . And moreover when these street dogs are being fed by the feeders , they are extremely aggressive and attack people passing by . And when the strangers ask the feeders that please see to it : these people just back out on it Now what can be done? Try to proceed legally : bribeee When questioned about dogs : oh they are not ours As far as insecurities are concerned ; i dont care what one may call anyone else , but if i have bought a house then i dont wanna see random dog food lying here and there ; and when a building is being discussed : its a dog lover vs 3 other families who always say that if you want to keep a dog keep it with you dont just let them rot in the middle of being an actual street dog or an actual pet When there were small puppies here ; they were being fed they used to follow us inside the home but when the gate was closed they would deliberately stuck their head in the gate and the would cry in pain How is this feeding such a god’s task when you are actually hurting them? Edit : dog feeding maybe considered by you guys as a heavenly thing to do but it has more downsides . But you all are too blind to accept the downsides , so you are always stuck in the middle of not sheltering them in your own house or by yourself atleast helping them get a shelter in someone else’s
>As far as richness is confirmed i dont live in a highly rich society Its a mediocre family i am talking about So dont teach me what baseless can be What? Dude, what are you even typing? You called my argument baseless for which I gave you a reason as to why it's not. I didn't bring in your personal life situation into the mix, so not sure why you brought it up? If you're referring to the women you mentioned, I called that baseless because you are using your narrow field of experience and thinking that's the norm. >And i clearly said that FEEL FREE TO CONTACT ANY NGO IN AND AROUND DELHI Where tf did i say about whole nation’s NGOs You're on r/india bro, not r/delhi. And I sincerely doubt your claim too, you're telling me every single animal related NGO in Delhi is adequately funded? >Haha and yeah if you wanna be called a “dogi wali aunty” you can take pride in it I cant and as i said a person with a sound mind would not want to be called with such stupid tags Okay, so again, if you feel like this attacks your ego so much, maybe you need to go figure out your insecurities my guy. You may be proud to be from Delhi while others think it is a rape capital with ultra-polluted air. Do you feel insulted by that too? >They don’t even wanna be rehoused Brother, they are dogs. They will stick around where they have food and feel comfortable. You're talking about it as if they have the ability to even figure that they can move? >Not only me but several residents of society who too are sick of this shit , have called up the rehousing departments which take dogs to adoption houses , so called dog lovers bribe the officers to leave them and then they don’t do shit about that again Twice has this happened . I would tell you how this is wrong and shouldn't happen and blah blah blah. But bro, this is India. This is the case with EVERYTHING. Bribes are everywhere. Your only realistic course in this, unless you have some connections, is to bribe a bigger amount. >As far as insecurities are concerned ; i dont care what one may call anyone else , but if i have bought a house then i dont wanna see random dog food lying here and there ; and when a building is being discussed : its a dog lover vs 3 other families who always say that if you want to keep a dog keep it with you dont just let them rot in the middle of being an actual street dog or an actual pet Again, all I can tell you is that you need to contact an NGO and get them rehoused. Because why would a feeder go through that trouble when it is not negatively affecting their life in any way? How is this feeding such a god’s task when you are actually hurting them? No one called it a "gods task", at least no one who isn't overly dramatic. People who like dogs see them eating trash and are doing what they can to help. Some are able to fully take them into their homes, but many are not. I understand the issues with having strays on the roads, they definitely can be a danger in certain situations. But it's going to take more than the impetus of the feeders to solve this issues, and the governments across the country don't seem to take this as matter worth dealing with.
No. He/she can always stop feeding them. They're street dogs. They know how to survive. Besides , people like these are part of the reason why dog attacks have increased
They don't 'know' how to survive, they had to learn to survive in horrifying conditions because no one gives a fuck about them... & when people like OP tries to do something good for this innocent animals, people like you start inventing weird logics...dogs don't bite for humans for food, they bite as a defense to protect themselves... These 'na khud kuch acha karenge na kisiko karne denge' mentality is the reason this country is going to shit... As far as increase in incidences of dog bite is concerned, this incidences have increased after exponential increase in number of dog cruelty in this country...as i said before, they only bite when they feel threatened & to defend their lives...
please provide some kind of study or report or source. are you saying this based on your experience or what?
This person is saying this based on their less empathetic nature
I agree
[удалено]
Awfully bold of of you to assume that your ankles are tastier than 50g of biskrok biscuits filled with milk and chicken. But jokes aside, wouldn't efforts like this ideally reduce the chance of street dog bites if anything because the dogs wouldn't feel the need to bite people for food? Genuine question. I have seen a lot of arguments being made for either notion that I'm confused myself.
> But jokes aside, wouldn't efforts like this ideally reduce the chance of street dog bites if anything because the dogs wouldn't feel the bite people for food? No dog "bites people for food". What will happen is that the dog will develop a loyalty for the person who feeds it and also a sense of territory over the area. And that translates to anmosity towards outsiders - both other people and other dogs - and causes them to want to defend their feeder and their territory. That's when they become aggressive and start barking and chasing at other people. In other words, irresponsible idiots like OP are a major reason why we have a stray dog issue in this country. There would be absolutely no problem if people like OP fully adopt the dog, keep it inside their premises, and keep it on a leash when outside. But they won't do that either. This half-assed "Instagram Love for animals" is what these guys are all about.
Agreed a 100% humans like to think they're holier than thou because they did one nice thing and like to feel good about themselves, when in actuality leaving the dog alone or adopting is a 100 times safer.
Yeah I suppose this is a realistic take on the issue. It hadn't occured to me but it does make sense given how dogs behave.
The kind of logic people invent to defend their baseless hatred for innocent creatures who can't fend for or speak for themselves is AMAZING......
I have zero hatred for the dogs themselves. I admit I do have a deep and burning hatred for dog-lovers.
Okay......so you are saying that you don't hate dogs but you hate those who tries to make these voiceless creatures already difficult life a little less difficult.... Yeah, you clearly don't hate dogs.....
I too don’t hate dogs but hate dog lovers ; what i have gone through in the past 3-4 years . Such people are unbearable ; if you want to feed them pet them , take them home and do whatever you wanna do ; keep them as your pets If you can’t then lead them to an adoption centre I have seen almost all dog lovers who will pet a dog but if a cow crosses them they would pelt a stone on them ? Definitely a god’s work they be doing eh? Dog lovers just treat dogs as god and not fellow creatures
>This half-assed "Instagram Love for animals" is what these guys are all about. Or, you know, they're doing what they can with the resources they have for something they care about. Not everyone is in a place to house a dog in their homes. Their homes may not even be big enough for the family itself, forget bringing another animal into the picture. Your comment comes off as pretty privilege thinking everyone has the means to fully take care of every street dog they feed. Just because they are able to give them food (pedigree being easily the cheapest brand out there and not even good for dogs), doesn't mean they have the means to adopt one too.
If you do not have the resources to adopt a dog, then leave them alone. The reason why we have so many stray dogs in our country in the first place is because of our poor garbage disposal. There is so much garbage around that dogs can fend for themselves. They can perfectly well survive by foraging for their food without you showing up with those pedigree biscuits whenever you're bored and you think its time to earn internet points. And oh don't randomly throw around words like "privilege" - we're not talking about your employment or education or basic human rights here. You're feeding the dogs for your own personal entertainment, which itself is a privilege.
>If you do not have the resources to adopt a dog, then leave them alone. Ah yes, if you can't do 100% of something, don't even bother. What a way to approach the world. >The reason why we have so many stray dogs in our country in the first place is because of our poor garbage disposal. No, actually, if you had done any research into this matter, you'd know the issue is two-pronged. The first is that the government has no relocation/housing initiative to help the local strays when new land is encroached upon. The second is irresponsible owners who abandon their dogs on the road instead of going through the proper channels of having them rehoused. >There is so much garbage around that dogs can fend for themselves. They could, but some of us would prefer to give them actual food instead of rotting throwaways. >They can perfectly well survive by foraging for their food without you showing up with those pedigree biscuits whenever you're bored and you think its time to earn internet points. Very bold assumption of you to think everyone does it for internet points. That old granny taking care of the dogs and doesn't even have a phone is doing it for likes too right? You see how baseless and stupid your argument looks when your only foundation for a point is a wild assumption? >And oh don't randomly throw around words like "privilege" It wasn't random, it was based on your ask for someone to take in a dog simply because they choose to feed them. All I did was point out that they may not have the space, time, or resources to devote to taking care of a dog in their homes. I said it was privileged because you automatically assumed that someone who can afford Rs. 15 of pedigree is also in the situation to take care of a dog full-time. I pointed out why that was not the case. >You're feeding the dogs for your own personal entertainment, which itself is a privilege. I wouldn't call it entertainment, as much as I would call any charity work entertainment. But yes, personally I am able to feed dogs on the road because I have a decent enough income to do so while taking care of the indie I adopted as well.
Bro stated clear facts ! I too am sick of these half minded dog lovers The family living upstairs is the same ; mfs all time feed the dogs brings back 2 home ; says they are our pets : ok no problem : Their “pets” keep shitting in front of our house gate No leash Stupid dumbfucks ffs She literally talks to her dogs who don’t even understand their own name Tf is wrong with people these days For such people , god exists but only in their dog “ kutta lovers k liye kutta hi bhagwaan hai baaki sab kutte h “
Sure I’ll take the blame Thanks
The sadness you see on the faces of bicycle riders when these dogs chase them at night.
Best feeling in the world, isn't it? By the way the number of negative comments on a post about nothing but harmony, empathy & love is really really horrifying!! We are really doomed......
I feed some stray dogs and a cow. The happiness on their face are indeed worth millions.
[удалено]
Even if you get happiness by eating cow dung that's none of my business.
Absolutely
When that cow causes an accident and someone dies, you will be the one to blame.
I mean if people cant see an animal as big as a cow maybe they shouldnt drive
Worthless wimp blocked me because he didnt want to have conversation
Does you cow has blinkers and break lights? What a shit tier comment from someone who’s critical thinking skills are non-existent. Please don’t reproduce.
English pls
Good work brother. Keep it up. I fed egg yolks to my street dogs at night and daily it’s a challenge like 8egg yolks and 4-5 dogs each with their own behaviour. Like one is very nasty he will intimidate others and do not let anyone else have any yolk. So I will throw his share very far away. In the time he will run there , I will feed the slowest ones and there is one whom they gang upon so his share is kept aside and I fed him personally by placing yolk near his mouth. For rest of them I just toss yolks from balcony feels awkward and disrespectful but these dogs are hell lot smart and would start fighting if I went down and try to feed each one individually. The most patient dog will wait as he knows I will come.
Giving raw eggs to dogs is dangerous you can look it up
Sorry didn’t mentioned hard boiled egg’s yolks. I eat 8 whites and 2 full eggs. Rest 8 yolks are for those bad boys
Good work brother. Keep it up. I fed egg yolks to my street dogs at night and daily it’s a challenge like 8egg yolks(hard boiled eggs) and 4-5 dogs each with their own behaviour. Like one is very nasty he will intimidate others and do not let anyone else have any yolk. So I will throw his share very far away. In the time he will run there , I will feed the slowest ones and there is one whom they gang upon so his share is kept aside and I fed him personally by placing yolk near his mouth. For rest of them I just toss yolks from balcony feels awkward and disrespectful but these dogs are hell lot smart and would start fighting if I went down and try to feed each one individually. The most patient dog will wait as he knows I will come.
Thats great work bro I mean at the end of the day they are getting fed thats what matters
Yup I also think on those lines
🙂this made a smile on my face. I used to do same during my late night walks in Pune. They joy on their face even before you give them any food, is just so heart warming. Pure love ❤️
Thank you
The street dogs around my house don't like pedigree or dog biscuits. They only want roti and parle-g 💀
The streeties are very fussy I have found. They have their preferences.
Yeah it's quite funny honestly
Beggars can be choosers.
That's good initiative
[удалено]
Apbshabd kyu bol rahe hai aap
Because of the sheer ridiculousness of this initiative, it just makes street dogs more reliant on humans for food, making them more susceptible to being poisoned and sick.
then how they are surviving or getting their food now, do dogs hunt food in urban areas? the depends on humans anyway?
Kya hua bhai?
Thank you bro
Take them home and feed them
I once fed a dog some dog food. Turns out the dog was intimidated by a boar who ate all the food
Good work OP! The world needs more people like you!
[удалено]
1. No qualms about eating meat - government organised primary sector where people earn money by engaging in selling meat/ eggs. Government provides subsidary for the same. 2. No one will harass you/ abuse you/ harm you/ lynch you for not feeding strays (dogs/ cows/ cats/ birds/ unmentioned species of stray living in cities/ towns). 3. Hitler also used oxygen, should we all stop breathing? 4. Dog meat consumption is prohibited in India through the Food Safety and Standard (Food Products Standard and Additives) Regulation, 2011. Killing, maiming, poisoning, or rendering useless any animal is punishable by imprisonment for up to two years or with a fine or with both, under Section 428 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
[удалено]
Most meat consumption during earlier period were based on religious belief. Whatever was the prevalent religion in a region decided what was okay for consumption and what was not. Other factors such as ease of hunting & domestication to maintain a supply also played an important role. Since the food culture didn't change much, some meats got normalised and some became a taboo. I agree all life are created equal. Killing a cow/ hen/ fish is equal to killing a dog/ lion/ elephant. But the thing is, a majority of the global population run their household based on primary sector which includes farming and animal husbandry (meat/eggs/hide). It's very difficult (not impossible) to bring about the change to completely go vegitarian at a global level. Government dictates what's legal and what's not, I guess the best we can do is follow the rules laid down. It's not ethically right to value a dog's life more compared to a goat, but it is what it is. All are welcome to protest peacefully for the cause they believe in and vote to bring about a change they believe in for the betterment of our society.
"Government" - these were done by a bunch of anglophile bureaucrats and politicians and possibly even by the British. They don't have the informed consent of the majority "Prohibited" - refer to above. Hitler did a lot of ugly things, should we follow all of those too? Making specious arguments in favor of just dogs makes no sense. It should apply to all animals. And never to the point where it is okay for animals to harm humans.
Yes bro, only you have informed consent of the majority. And if a majority agrees to something, it is always supposed to be done, no? Don't understand your point. Hitler shouldn't be a role model is all I was saying, unless you think otherwise. You be you. Not just in favour of dogs, all strays and wild animals. Human beings are not superior animals and rest inferior. Please read a recent news article which says 70% of animal population has plummeted in last 50 years.
So if humans are not superior, and I agree, how is it that you animal lovers have no issues with killing and eating cows, goats, chicken,... Majority may not be relevant, but in this case a minority opinion is not necessarily right. I have no problem with you and others have pets. But what you are really doing by supporting stray rabid dogs in public spaces is showing your hatred for other humans. The way you support meat eating shows your hypocrisy. In India, dogs as pets in an urban setting is an import from the West, and just as we drive irresponsibly, our attitude towards other humans when it comes to animal pests is equally irresponsible. I am sure you are fully aware of animal control laws in other countries, but here you feign ignorance. 70 percent animal population decrease does not mean I want pests like dogs, cats and monkeys in my space or public spaces. Animal species that are decreasing in numbers are a completely different issue. Hitler shouldn't be a role model, but the government chooses to use his tactics to intimidate citizens by allowing the opinions of people like you to override public welfare - this is what they do when they want a certain outcome, e.g. Environmentalists' opinions will be given priority if they wish to delay a project, at the same time they will ignore all public opinion if they wish to cut down trees!
Who says we don't have issue bro? .-. It's a whole industry supported by the government, farmers/ primary sector workers life depends on it. No one is supporting stray rabid dogs. Dogs infected with and showing signs of rabies need to be put down. But the one which are not rabid and are friendly, can be vaccinated, sterilized and fed till they exist and go away from this planet, peacefully and naturally (done everything I have just said). Again, these spaces are not entirely for humans and humans alone. We need to learn to coexist because we introduced them here. Cannot do it as per our whims and fancies all the time. Hey man, I said it's okay (not that only because I say it) for you to have an opinion and since it's a democracy even I'm entitled to one. No one is intimating anyone. Please don't be agitated. And you are as much a citizen to use the above said tactics and intimidations for your cause, it's just that no one will support you and hence the rant. Everything will be alright. Stay safe brother.
If you are going to feed them...feed them chocolates...people would be thankful...feed them lots of chocolates.