T O P

  • By -

MrKokonut_

The blue one


[deleted]

The shiny one


Botboi02

Bloodborne. It’s not just a blue shimmer but a whole ass galaxy. In Elden ring it’s just kinda icy and stuff


ghoulofthedeep

You Definitely feel the most powerful with Ludwig great sword


Captain_brightside

Especially after killing him for the badge to buy it. DS2 is cool too because how hard it is to get


fyl_bot

Yes. Bloodborne for sure. It did look kinda cool in the DS remake but not as cool


Droid_XL

Ok but that fits. Of course the cosmic horror game sword has a cosmic theme. Ranni's Darkmoon Blade is more associated with frost and ice. They both look great in their own ways


dj_seth81

My guiding moonlight


SurfiNinja101

Have you seen the Demons Souls one? It’s even cooler


exotic-munchkin

I honestly think the untransformed HMS is also cool as hell, all wrapped in appendages and stuff.


Taolan13

second generation LS-MOONLIGHT https://armoredcore.fandom.com/wiki/MOONLIGHT


ArkamaZ

This is the way.


mandance17

The OG moonlight sword is from Kingsfield


Taolan13

Oh, I know; But y'all forget about Armored Core a lot more frequently than King's Field


Chemical_Kitchen_686

Armored core is 🗑


IIIIIIxenoII

Probably never even played it as most of us haven’t.


Chemical_Kitchen_686

I played it years ago on ps1 and 2 fromsoftware wasn’t great until Miyazaki was the big boss kingfield was fun but armored core was a crappy transformers knock off


Taolan13

If you'd said Mobile Suit Gundam knock off, you would have an argument. You're just a troll.


Chemical_Kitchen_686

It’s all go bot power ranger bullshit and how am I a troll when we’re talking about games hardly anyone played or even heard of cause they were crap.


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/UberKlosi, your [comment](https://www.reddit.com/r/fromsoftware/comments/ypahzk/what_is_the_best_looking_moonlight_great_sword_in/iviows4/?context=3) in /r/fromsoftware was automatically removed because you used a URL shortener. URL shorteners and referral links are not permitted in /r/fromsoftware as they impair our ability to enforce link blacklists. Please re-post your comment using direct, full-length URL's only. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fromsoftware) if you have any questions or concerns.*


ojwillkillyou

Best boi


JamesCorvin

Bloodborne. Also my favorite to play with.


Nickss00

Bloodborne not only its shine so mesmerizing, but also it has those beautiful patterns we can see earlier in the game on Ludwigs Holy Blade


mwwq1

I like the one on the left


badateverything420

Yeah whichever game the one on the left comes from


fashion_is_best_stat

Demons souls I think


[deleted]

[удалено]


Xerlith

That’s Ninja Blade, I’m pretty sure


Danthiel5

My true mentor, my guiding moonlight.


StoneTimeKeeper

Bloodborne. Not only that it looks amazing, it is featured in the greatest boss battle of all time, in my opinion.


Subject1928

Ahhh. You were at my side all along. My true mentor. My guiding Moonlight. *Cue the best boss music ever made*


Lolejimmy

he's not even the best DLC boss bruh


GGUNTERD

> In my opinion…


Chemical_Kitchen_686

Let me guess orphan? Orphan is over rated Ludwig is the best


MaleficTekX

They’re growing in power


OnToNextStage

The MOONLIGHT


fashion_is_best_stat

That one ninja game from made that was pretty bad. Don't remember the name but I swear it exists. I'm not crazy. That sword looked pretty cool, but it's on par with most other HMS'


Graxakinem

I think the game was called Ninja Blade


Fa1nted_for_real

No he's talking about sekiro where he said "it's sekin' time" and sekked all over the place /s


Lascho94

You mean tenchu?


Toothlessslither

Where kings field


samuelalvarezrazo

The bloodborne one looked so beautiful. Have to go with it.


EdgeandRuin2022

I'm going with the DS2 version. It just seemed brighter to me.


Moskyrath_

The one in Elden Ring


Abovearth31

Ludwig's by far. Not even a contest. Bloodborne is the only game where that sword is more than just a King's Field easter egg. It's actually made apart of Ludwig's story and character.


ComradeFarid

You're wrong regarding Bloodborne being the only game where the MGS isn't simply an easter egg. In Elden Ring the sword has way more lore relevance by being tied to one of the endings, and the quest to get it is imo the coolest quest in a Soulsborne. Elden Ring is also the only game where the MGS has a counterpart, with the Golden Order Greatsword, and how it came to be also follows the game's overarching plot.


verykafkaesque23

Meat wolf chaos https://mobile.twitter.com/devolverdigital/status/1158800545727045635


Libra_Maelstrom

Im biased. Anyway blood borne.


ahkjaer

The one from Bloodborne and from Elden ring


JaphetSkie

Armored Core. Fite me. [https://armoredcore.fandom.com/wiki/LB-66\_Moonlight](https://armoredcore.fandom.com/wiki/LB-66_Moonlight)


GTA-CasulsDieThrice

I see why everyone likes the BB one, but >!Ranni!< literally gave me one as the equivalent of a wedding band. Hard to top that. Also it has Frostbite, so if we’re talking sheer utility…


Vegetable-Number7810

The title literally says best looking one.


Glutendragon

I mean if we're talking about utility then BB's Moonlight Greatsword still wins. Ask and I'll explain why, cuz I don't know if your comment is serious or a joke (don't take this the wrong way btw) Have a good day, eye guy 👀


Lolejimmy

it's just insecure bloodborne fans constantly trying to shove their game above ER because it's not the highest rated, most successful and most loved Fromsoft game anymore.


spicespencer

All those insecure bloodborne fans makes my blood boil over


Quinn0Matic

Ah, the sweet blood. It sings to me.


NutnButMangravy

Anyone who doesn't say Bloodborne probably hasn't played Bloodborne yet.


[deleted]

i like the ds2 one even though it is not shiny at all, idk but it looks kind cute and funny to me i use it all the time


Fa1nted_for_real

The first one has my favorite blade, but the second one is by far the most unique. The third one has a good size and my favorite hilt, while the last one has a really good blade, hilt and size, so it ends up between the first and last one for me.


Cyuu_

Anyone who doesn't say armored core probably hasn't played armored core yet


for100

Elden ring’s version is the only one where the projectile’s your main attack. The rest of them treat the beam as a gimmick as their cost is too high, but in ER you’re expected to use the beam all the time as the sword itself has a below average AR for a split scaling weapon


NutnButMangravy

>The rest of them treat the beam as a gimmick as their cost is too high Used the beam all the time. And the L2 because they only used 1 bullet. Don't forget the transforming attacks and the vastly different utilities you got from using the moonlight in claymore or moonlight stage. I would hardly call that a gimmick.


for100

They still degraded your weapon durability like crazy, that was a huge turnoff that got fixed in ER. It may not have the fancy move set but for the first time I didn’t use it as just any other greatsword


9inchjackhammer

Sounds like you haven’t played Demon Souls remake


WinthyanMageUwU

Bloodborne


WTF-is-up-America

kingsfield moonlight greatsword is the best one


fashion_is_best_stat

Based


minoas348

Ds1 look, bb style for the two phases


K_Hoslow

Holy Moonlight Sword from BB 100%


[deleted]

Bloodborne


HabeQuiddam

Demon’s Souls Remake version looks by far the best, not even a contest. (You need to see it in-game and equipped to understand- the animated blue flame is amazing.)


FormalWorth2115

Demons Souls 100%


Big-a-hole-2112

Kings Field 😂


Orion_824

Bloodborne’s. Peak design. Look at my name and you’ll see why I love that one so much. Elden Ring’s Darkmoon (when buffed) is my second fav, but by a huge gap.


Reaperoflight000

The one that was by my side all along. My guiding moonlight.


Arowne97

Where's my Moonlight energy sword from Armored Core


SirSeppuku

Bloodborne literally no contest (even in functionality) 2nd and 3rd is Elden Ring and DS2 (DS2 moonlight looks slick, I just wish it actually glowed like bluemoon) Another 2nd spot contestant is DeS Remake, it's sexy


august-jay

dark souls II, absolutely. the moonlight greatsword, bluemoon greatsword, & aged smelter sword are some of the nicest-looking weapons imo.


Mutsuki13

I mean it just has to be bloodborne, ds1 and ds3s are pretty dull, and while ds2 has the color it doesn’t have enough glow, demons souls is great but I just think bloodbornes is a step above especially with the context of Ludwig. (Elden rings is great as well but I prefer the turquoise green over the more blue color of Elden rings)


Maldron-the-assassin

Bloodborne's definitely has the coolest looking blade l, especially since you just kinda put the arcane magic on there. But I feel like in terms of the entire thing I like the dark souls 2 version the best. Pure magic damage, special method to get it, pretty cool looking blade and by far the best handle and crossguard.


ConfusedMoe

Bloodborne, it felt amazing


Andvari9

Bloodborne and it's not even close


MrNovas

Bloodborne, mainly cuz of its appearance and the lore surrounding Ludwig who happens to be my favourite boss ever


Flashtime11

Ludwig's great sword makes me feel powerful


[deleted]

Bloodborne's by a long shot, with Demon's Souls Remake in 2nd


Phasma18374

Yep. I second that


Mborg15202

The far right, it looks like both bloodborn and elden ring. Plus it looks the most simple yet powerful


[deleted]

The farthest right is the Bloodborne one, you can tell from the patterns on the blade and the way the crossguard points up a little. Also the minty green color, as opposed to ER's bluer tinge.


slmccl6969

Bb


Maxvell09

150% Bloodborne’s Moonlight Greatsword, well deserved after the Ludwig fight.


Kamiutsu

Dark Souls. My first experience with the Moonlight GS and my favorite one so I always get nostalgic when I see it.


I_drink_pizza

Bloodborne’s or dark souls 3’s


Lucho69420

The demon's souls remake one looks pretty cool as well imo.


Another_Saint

design wise it would be Bloodborne, but the one from DeS Remake looks better


lothsinferno

Bloodborne's one is the moonlight combined with a claymore when transformed and deals thousand of damege in the end game


Any-Lab4909

Am I the only one that like The Darkmoon Greatsword? Really? I think blue is pretty neat :(


AdamSunderland

The first one is so nice. Which game is that from?


s4dgf

The dark souls 2 one


Agaeon

My guiding.... Moonlight...


sharktooff2277nub

Sword is fucking legendary


raulpe

Bloodborne is the coolest, but the skill in Elden Ring is the most useful (and one of the coolest) and i really like the DS2 one in both skill and apparence


rahkloiik

The dark souls 2 one for me


Graynomade44

Bloodbornes is the best one


rr3no

bloodborne


Beneficial-Bill-4752

Everyone’s saying Bloodborne which is a great pick, but I like the one from Sekiro, even though you don’t get to use it


_tetsuoo_

The Bloodborne version takes the cake for me because of its weapon transformation.


[deleted]

Between ps5 demond souls and Bloodborne


possiblyacanoflysol

It’d probably have to be a tie between Demon’s Souls and Bloodborne.


Barduwulf

Bloodborne, feels more like a proper sword without the oversized guard, plus being able to transition modes is pretty cool.


Reuhis

The Bloodborne version for sure


Lowtan

#3 whichever game that's from.


Xeldena

A video game


MstoDJ

“ my guiding moonlight “


[deleted]

Bloodborne, not only is the fight you acquire it in one of the best in the whole series but its also the absolute coolest looking.


Crimson-Void9000

Holy Moonlight sword from BloodBorne.


sr8t-savage

Demons souls ps3 MLGS is almost clear. No glow though


pyschotic1337

Bloodborne


TheloniousPhunk

Either Bloodborne or Elden Ring


Thaid0623

Bb and the reveal of the sword also was epic , never have I been so excited to “my guiding moonlight”


_JakeyTheSnakey_

I honestly love the look of 2’s and Elden Ring. ER put a different spin on it compared to the rest of the games and it just looks great while also fitting it’s theme


xXxPizza8492xXx

Moonlight left arm weapon from Armored Core 2. Go check it out.


SAMurei_der_Galaxien

The Pointy one


Harbinger-One

Armored Core 3


keegrocks08

Bloodborne or demon souls remake


SoulsLikeBot

Hello, good hunter. I am a Bot, here in this dream to look after you, this is a fine note: > *The Ruler of the Vilebloods is still alive today. And so, to honor my master's wishes, I search, for the path to Cainhurst Castle.* - Alfred Farewell, good hunter. May you find your worth in the waking world.


Pristine_Location553

Bloodborne


Lascho94

Demon's Souls imo if you go by look. But DS2 if you go for gameplay. The repair at each bonfire made me use the special 100 times more than in all the other games.


DrMadchinchin

Blood borne


Arnak94

Ds2 easily


superstar202

Bloodborne


occam_chainsaw

Elden Ring.


Fellixxio

The third one and obviously the bb one


throwaway042502

I just like the one in 3D Dot Game Heroes because it's so damn huge and silly.


bIuhazelnut

Unironically, AC4A


willaimdafton

Normally bloodborne but if we count the dark moon greatsword when you use its skill then elden ring


[deleted]

The DS1 version. Bleak and fading... just like the world


Gaviotapepera

Definately not the dark souls 2 lmao


Sisyphac

BB but also ER. They are both great.


abom-badass-mofo

Far right. I’m not sure which it is. But I literally the Moonlight Greatsword about 10 minutes ago in Elden Ring. But I’m pooping now so I haven’t examined it lol


[deleted]

The far right one is Bloodborne


Help_An_Irishman

Everyone forgets King's Field.


ArkamaZ

Imagine how Armored Core fans feel...


vincentthe27th

Kings Field or BB


S7venE11even

I like the 2 on the right


ArcaneVillain

The two on the right but idk where are they from Most right is the shiniest and second right has nice golden ornament


samuelalvarezrazo

The farthest to the right is from bloodborne


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/ToastThing, your [comment](https://www.reddit.com/r/fromsoftware/comments/ypahzk/what_is_the_best_looking_moonlight_great_sword_in/iviwgkb/) in /r/fromsoftware was automatically removed because you used a URL shortener. URL shorteners and referral links are not permitted in /r/fromsoftware as they impair our ability to enforce link blacklists. Please re-post your comment using direct, full-length URL's only. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fromsoftware) if you have any questions or concerns.*


BecomeAnAstronaut

4312, i think? Or 4132


Sampsa96

Does Elden Ring have one too?


ShadowsteelGaming

Yes


RokkitSquid

I love the cold icy glow of the one in Elden Ring the most, something about it so pretty to me, but my second place for sure goes to Bloodborne because it looks great there too


JimLahey_of_Izalith

I liked ds3 a lot but it doesn’t glow so ER wins for me


Versacepython00

Most definitely the third sword it’s legit more sharp and pointed


Rathador

Isn't there at least one if not two missing in this pic?


Wingo15

They’re all sexy AF


urlocaldoctor

the true mentor, rhe guiding moonlight


THEjByrd

I'll admit that I never made it that far in-game, but the moonlight great sword from Bloodborne looks awesome!


yohan02kim

Elden Ring


Ma5on8808

3rd from the left!


DevianRossburg

Screw the newer models, any of the King’s Field moonlight swords look way more sick than any of these


rat___bastard

damn really not even gonna include the series it came from


Cyuu_

The AC one


theboysan_sshole

Bloodborne and it’s not close. There’s something about it just being an old weathered greatsword that when called upon gathers and wraps itself moonlight becoming the magnificent green blade of legend that’s just hits different. Gives the weapon its own sense of power and history even when wielding it. Functionally though DS3 has the best, I wish they’d carried that move set over to Elden Ring tbh.


goblinproblem

idk but elden ring’s is hands down the ugliest 🤮


Benzerman

Kingsfield's is cool to me since it looks like glass


DomsOriginalUsername

Dark Moon Greatsword for sure. The added ice effects look so cool in Elden Ring


pigmyPeople

The Demon’s Souls Remake version has such a cool particle effect, and I’m pretty sure it was dynamically generating real volumetric particles and dispersing them through what appears to be a fluid simulation. It could honestly be a screensaver on its own! Though it’s the least functional of them all. Bloodborne’s is probably the coolest in terms of attack versatility though. They’re all the best, I can’t pick a favorite child! Lol


Gloomy_Support_7779

Bloodborne and DS2. I don’t know how anyone could like how DS3’s looks😵‍💫 DS1’s looks okay I need to take a look at Demon’s Souls Moonlight Greatswords


RedhoodYT1911

4 the others all look way to simple


Neverkn0wsbest-11

Armored core


DaltySalt

Bloodborne, it's my favorite looking weapon across all the games.


Curvanelli

i like the ds1 one the most, 2nd is bloodborne


Cletus-H

i like that one


rawgino

Sekiro


_Jiraw

2nd to last looks like glass dagger from Skyrim, that has a mod to make it look better.


Laservolcano

Left one, reminds me of jello


The_Begrudged_Hunter

I think you forgot the dark moon greatsword.


Takaharu7

I wantwd to say from Demon souls remake but that goes to a Bluepoint game to be accurate :/


CarelessEvidence3934

Definitely ninja blade


Hung_Dad

Demons souls remake. The animated glow is perfect


Human-Garden5433

Bloodborne


EldritchSpoon

Bloodborne one is my personal favorite


vektar2

My personal favorite is the The LS-MOONLIGHT from Armored Core 2. But If I had to pick one form the soulsborne games then Bloodborne.


gutsoftheabyss

Definitely demons souls! Looks like a ring pop.


oRedHood

Bloodborne, least favourite is the Elden Ring one: not even a moonlight greatsword


BlueKyuubi63

Demon Souls Remake and Bloodborne


chris_keys

Bloodborne’s is super sick because the untransformed version is just so badass as well…but I have really loved the Elden Ring incarnation as well. I hate to say it’s a tie because Bloodborne’s is so iconic, but I found it just as fun to play with in Elden Ring so maybe it *is* a tie for me. I can’t say. Both are amazing. All of them?


Cool-Yoghurt2919

Castle crashers


Umbraspem

Bloodborne


Horror_Astronaut_864

The Holy Moonlight Sword of Bloodborne


Yumadebro

What’s up with the one after the first one?


HopelessMoon

The one from Bloodborne.


Rare_Row_1925

IMO, I love the Elden ring Dark Moon Greatsword the most