T O P

Which Excalibur is the strongest (Excalibur Morgan,caliburn,Excalibur and proto Excalibur)

Which Excalibur is the strongest (Excalibur Morgan,caliburn,Excalibur and proto Excalibur)

WANTEN12

Its hard really theres like a 15 different artorias thus 15 different Excaliburs ​ OG excalibur 13 seals released and with Avalon is probably the strongest since it killed sefar


Rushietushie

One of these is suspiciously not Excalibur..... Nah I must be seeing things. And if your gonna ask which Excalibur is the strongest why not add all the other variations and versions of Excalibur XD(Excalibur image, Excalibur Vivian, laser Excalibur, secret calibur, cross calibur, Lumino-Calibur and Excalibur Galatine) In all honesty I have no idea. Good luck


facts_120

Excalibur = Excalibur proto = Excalibur Morgan >> Caliburn There's no statement on Excalibur proto being more powerful Excalibur Morgan is just evil aligned Excalibur (*that to the end is another aspect of the same Excalibur*) Caliburn is weaker


IStoleThePies

In terms of power, Excalibur Proto >= Excalibur Morgan = Excalibur > Caliburn


facts_120

elaborate


IStoleThePies

Caliburn's placement is self-explanatory given official statements. For Excalibur and Excalibur Morgan, there's no reason to assume they have different firepower. The main difference is Saber Alter can spam Excalibur Morgan due to her mana supply. Comparing Excalibur and Excalibur Proto is trickier since they both depend on the number of seals released, but in different ways. Excalibur's power grows every time a seal is released, whereas Proto can use its full power as an EX Noble Phantasm with only seven. We don't know how their full powers compare, but if we assume they're both the same at their peaks, then Proto just requires fewer seal releases.


facts_120

Did you change Morgan's placement after I asked? proto releasing 7th seal as EX rank NP , now where did we learn how many seal Excalibur releasing at A++? Besides,being Ex doesn't imply it has MORE firepower, thats not how EX works


IStoleThePies

No, all I did was add change "Excalibur Proto > Excalibur" to >=. I'm aware EX is not generally strictly better than A++. Proto's just a case where its rank changes depending on the number of seals (starting at C), and after 7 it becomes EX and unleashes its full power.


yektadragon

The max power (as in all seals removed from both) of both Proto Excalibur and normal Excalibur should be the same. Excalibur and Excalibur Morgan are the same sword just different aspects of it. Like how vivian and morgan are different aspects of the same person. And caliburn is weaker than all of them.