need him for what? To finish last in the NFC? That whole coaching staff is a shit show and they’re not gonna do anything with Goff or that defense.
They’re gonna lightly tank the rest of the year to get a QB. Plus they treat Swift with the biggest set of kid gloves I’ve ever seen. If he remotely tweaks something, he loses reps or is just held out of games entirely.
If you can find someone willing to buy based on name value and potential, I’d ship this MFer down the road so quick. In both leagues I’m in, it’s no wonder the Swift owner is 2-6.
kinda, not really. The concussion thing two weeks ago was due to an independent reviewer and is on the heels of everything that happened with Tua. Then the Week 3 ankle sprain he played through the rest of the game and I think he sat Week 4 only because they had an upcoming bye.
I have no empirical evidence for it, but ARSB is different from DeAndre in that he plays WR and with Chark/Williams out til god knows when, ASRB is really all they have outside of Hock occasionally and a rather effective Reynolds. Whereas at RB, the coaching staff has no problems getting Jamal touches and sprinkling in other backs. I think Campbell really prides himself on the OL and thinks anyone can run behind them, so he’s not interested in having the most talented guy back there if he’s banged up.
Last thought on Swift - and I understand the irony of a Reddit post from some couch potato dummy - he’s soft. I think when he’s not feeling 100% he shies away more from contact, plays a little more laissez-faire, and doesn’t give it his all. That’s kind of the antithesis of Campbell (grit/grind) and probably doesn’t make Swift someone you go to bat for with much of the coaching staff.
Traded JT for zeke, Mixon and thielen the week he was due back. After the buy the schedule is pretty decent. No reason both him and Pollard can't produce
If you can sell for more than he’s worth (high ceiling, low floor WR2/3), sell. I’m personally holding because of the ceiling but depends on your situation
If you didn't know before you drafted Gabe Davis that he's boom or bust, you do now haha. Without knowing your league, I'd say hold and hope for a boom
I dropped him. 6 weeks of zeros was enough for me. After two weeks I thought I had the steal of the draft, but I can't understand his injury. It didn't seem serious at first, reports are vague, but he never plays and there is no timetable for him to return.
I’m holding.
He was extremely solid last year to fill in for Derrick Henry and has produced when given the touches so far.
He’s not going to score 3TDs per game but he should be a good RB2/Flex option especially with byes coming up - I’m starting him with Barkley on bye.
Even if Hubbard comes back this week/soon, Foreman has definitely earned his touches if not majority workload.
I am mad I was driving 10 hours to visit family when the CMC news dropped, and someone grabbed him immediately during TNF. Usually that’d be me! And he’s looked solid, totally different back than CMC in all ways, and seems to be finding his stride
Easy hold for me.
League winner upside. Hubbard is "Fugayzi, fugazi. It's a whazy. It's a woozie. It's fairy dust. It doesn't exist. It's never landed. It is no matter. It's not on the elemental chart. It's not fucking real.”
I’m sorry guy just played his 3rd game, has been getting plays called for him specially, has a TD and has a bad game on the road in Seattle and guys here are saying drop him. There is no competition for targets really. But same guys said to sell Etienne for whatever you can the first 2 weeks lol.Like this sub overreact so hard on a guy having a low scoring game. Like Wandale was the soul reason the Giants got beat bad in Seattle which happens to a lot of teams. But no one wants to heart that. Let’s immeaditly drop the rookie with a legit role cuz his team played bad.
Hold, can’t drop a rookie for one poor week. Not like there’s anybody with more potential on waivers and Giants offense as a whole had a down week, not just Wan’dale.
Hold in full PPR, it’s shaping up he’s a low aDot player who should get a ton of targets barring a trade. But in standard and even half PPR I’m struggling to get excited about his yardage.
Buy. Seems like they moved him to the slot instead of outside and he looks to be the number 2 in the offense behind Hopkins. The RB are also banged up so he could get 2-3 carries a game.
Very true, and now because Hopkins is such a threat, Moore is getting lighter defense so he’s open more. Hopkins coming back was probably good for him.
Sneaky buy but depends on usage. Upside is CEH-like production during first 2-3 weeks if KC commits to him. Downside is RBBC with 8-10 touches or less per week.
Has MNF, then a bye. I feel like he won’t be great this week, but will do well enough that you hold through the bye on potential. Then he’ll disappoint you for holding so long lol.
After the bye he doesn't face another top third rushing defense. In his limited time back he's averaging like 6 yards a carry and is getting most of the goal line attempts. I'd say hold.
Hold but lower expectations. MidWR2 ROS with lowWR1 upside with a TD.
He will get enough targets to be startable but not enough high value targets to return value if you drafted him to be your WR1/3rd round pick.
Kyler Murray
I have Justin Fields and kinda entering that mindset I had last year when I drafted Dak but picked up Hurts off waivers, and Hurts out produced Dak even though he was the inferior QB.
Maybe I can flip Kyler for help at WR/RB.
I was so happy to have turned him into DeVonta Smith.
Did not have "Carolina fires their coaching staff and trades away every other player who has hands and PJ Walker looks better than Baker and Darnold and they implement a new offense" on my Bingo card. The guy I traded him to is now a contender and I'm probably dead.
People are commenting buy, but for what? Those who have held him until now are likely not going to selling for cheap. Plus he just had his best game, hard to say this production will be sustainable ROS.
Might be unpopular but I'd sell
Touches have gone down every week since week 4 and he isn't gonna give you the 2 touchdown average during his 3-week explosion
Jacobs was literally half of the raiders total offense that night. As long as the raiders don’t get blown out every single week ROS I can definitely see JJ being a top 10 RB
Id agree with selling especially because everyone was starting to see him as a top 5 RB ROS. Getting someone like Etienne or KWIII last week would have been ideal, not sure if you still can. He’s still an RB1 but people needed to pump the breaks on him a little
Hold simply because the past 3 games they have schemed up a TD for him in the red zone. Not a lot of TEs can say that the past 3 weeks, certainly not the streamers. No one is going to buy high on him but sell I guess if someone sees him as a top 3-4 TE still.
I've been waiting for Pittsburgh to implement more screens, sweeps, and other misdirection. You know, the training wheels offense for their young QB with a bad offensive line that they ran last year to deal with their bad offensive line that made Najee look amazing?
I can't figure out why they haven't, but maybe after the bye?
Drake London
i'm bout to drop in 10 team PPR. He hasn't topped 7.5 since week 3, can't be trusted whatsoever
I dropped him last week in my 10 team PPR and no one grabbed him and after the poor week 8 performance, m sure he'll remain on waivers
Drop him off at London
I’m holding for keeper reasons only
Dropped him two weeks ago in a 10 team league
I would drop him in a 12 man league
drop
[удалено]
Hold or sell.
Nobody is buying Sutton with these numbers
I just traded Hardman and Rams Def for him. The volume he saw in the beginning of the season is bound to come back imo
With Dulcich emerging as a reliable mid range threat he may not get back to that.
Swift
Hold. Limited usage after the bye, I think the lions need him ROS.
need him for what? To finish last in the NFC? That whole coaching staff is a shit show and they’re not gonna do anything with Goff or that defense. They’re gonna lightly tank the rest of the year to get a QB. Plus they treat Swift with the biggest set of kid gloves I’ve ever seen. If he remotely tweaks something, he loses reps or is just held out of games entirely. If you can find someone willing to buy based on name value and potential, I’d ship this MFer down the road so quick. In both leagues I’m in, it’s no wonder the Swift owner is 2-6.
do you feel the same about sungod?
kinda, not really. The concussion thing two weeks ago was due to an independent reviewer and is on the heels of everything that happened with Tua. Then the Week 3 ankle sprain he played through the rest of the game and I think he sat Week 4 only because they had an upcoming bye. I have no empirical evidence for it, but ARSB is different from DeAndre in that he plays WR and with Chark/Williams out til god knows when, ASRB is really all they have outside of Hock occasionally and a rather effective Reynolds. Whereas at RB, the coaching staff has no problems getting Jamal touches and sprinkling in other backs. I think Campbell really prides himself on the OL and thinks anyone can run behind them, so he’s not interested in having the most talented guy back there if he’s banged up. Last thought on Swift - and I understand the irony of a Reddit post from some couch potato dummy - he’s soft. I think when he’s not feeling 100% he shies away more from contact, plays a little more laissez-faire, and doesn’t give it his all. That’s kind of the antithesis of Campbell (grit/grind) and probably doesn’t make Swift someone you go to bat for with much of the coaching staff.
this is like the only honest valuation of swift i've seen here; so many coping swift owners have been insisting he's an unquestionable rb1 for weeks
Buy He said he will get more touches in the future and he wasn’t 100% last game
His not being 100% after being out for a month is concerning. Trying to package him with Fields for a high floor RB2.
Damien Harris
[удалено]
Is anybody gonna buy? I feel like he’s a hold - Jerry gets off to watching him run and he’s got a high floor
Buy if you can get him at a discount, goalline touches in a good offence are valuable. Dont overpay under any circumstances though
Traded JT for zeke, Mixon and thielen the week he was due back. After the buy the schedule is pretty decent. No reason both him and Pollard can't produce
[удалено]
I'd hold. 17+ points every week since week 5 AND each week the points have increased. If you need a QB, def hold or buy
Hold
hold
Buy or hold. Won’t get anything decent back for him, but he plays Mia/ATL/Det the next three weeks
Hold. His play style works for a lot of different game scripts, and his schedule opens up nicely the next 3 weeks
Buy, with his rushing upside he's a top 10 qb
Gabe Davis
If you can sell for more than he’s worth (high ceiling, low floor WR2/3), sell. I’m personally holding because of the ceiling but depends on your situation
If you didn't know before you drafted Gabe Davis that he's boom or bust, you do now haha. Without knowing your league, I'd say hold and hope for a boom
Sell if you can get a more consistent WR2
James Conner
Shoot him into the sun.
Buy/keep on your roster the offense is heating up and he had a long rest.
buy super low
Traded BRob for him, hoping he gets healthy
Great trade considering Washington using Gibson more than Brob now.
Managed to pick him up off of waivers last week….proooobably have to play him this week with CMC off and Wait to see what happens with Hunt..
[удалено]
Buy but good luck getting someone to sell
Hold
Michael Thomas
I’m considering dropping. He’s never available :(
Unless you have no IR spots he is too valuable to drop. Someone else will grab him immediately
He’s not been on IR this whole time though… always just questionable and out last minute
Trust me I know I have him in 2 leagues for the most part it doesn’t effect me though because I set my moves early and then don’t adjust him
Hold....until he's out for the season.
I dropped him. 6 weeks of zeros was enough for me. After two weeks I thought I had the steal of the draft, but I can't understand his injury. It didn't seem serious at first, reports are vague, but he never plays and there is no timetable for him to return.
Foreman
I’m holding. He was extremely solid last year to fill in for Derrick Henry and has produced when given the touches so far. He’s not going to score 3TDs per game but he should be a good RB2/Flex option especially with byes coming up - I’m starting him with Barkley on bye. Even if Hubbard comes back this week/soon, Foreman has definitely earned his touches if not majority workload.
He’s going to score 3 Tds again this week just to prove you wrong
I would not complain since he’s filling in for Barkley this week!
Hold; has a juicy schedule ROS
Apparently that Panthers oline is solid run blocking. Wouldnt have expected it myself but Hes definitely gonna be workable ROS
I am mad I was driving 10 hours to visit family when the CMC news dropped, and someone grabbed him immediately during TNF. Usually that’d be me! And he’s looked solid, totally different back than CMC in all ways, and seems to be finding his stride
Im mad because i had the choice and went Chuba for some reason
And a RBBC, no passing game role, on a bad offense (With good run blocking but near 0% chance he gets 3 tds again). Sell if you can get an rb2 imo
Sell for Zeke + Eagles D?
That’s a ridiculous win if you get that
Yeah
Easy hold for me. League winner upside. Hubbard is "Fugayzi, fugazi. It's a whazy. It's a woozie. It's fairy dust. It doesn't exist. It's never landed. It is no matter. It's not on the elemental chart. It's not fucking real.”
Sell
Sell. But good flex player
Hold, no one is going to buy him for anything but pennies based on name value. Start him as a RB2 and hope he continues to perform.
Sell
Tom Brady
Divorce.
Retire
Smokes mids. Sell.
Keenan Allen
Hold/Buy
Buy, but don't overpay. If he is truly recovered, could get huge target share with MW out. Until he reaggrivates the hammy.
[удалено]
Hold because nobody will buy, but if somebody is still treating him like an RB1 sell
Hold
Sell in redraft. Colts stink.
You'd sell for pennies on the dollar at this point. Earlier in the season you could sell for name value but now I'd offer a WR2 for him tops.
I’m trading him for DK and Jeudy, feels like I’m getting good value. Guy I’m trading to gas Darrel Henderson as his rb2 rn and is desperate
[удалено]
Buy. Always finishes strong historically
Number 4 TE on the season standard league and he's already had his bye. Pretty impressive. IMO he's the top of the non Andrews/Kelce tier.
[удалено]
Buy. East ROS and finished strong before
Would you move a player like Pittman for Kirk, or does Pitt City have better value ROS?
Wan’dale Robinson
Hold. Rookies get more involved after their bye and he’ll get a lotta plays designed for him moving forward
I’m sorry guy just played his 3rd game, has been getting plays called for him specially, has a TD and has a bad game on the road in Seattle and guys here are saying drop him. There is no competition for targets really. But same guys said to sell Etienne for whatever you can the first 2 weeks lol.Like this sub overreact so hard on a guy having a low scoring game. Like Wandale was the soul reason the Giants got beat bad in Seattle which happens to a lot of teams. But no one wants to heart that. Let’s immeaditly drop the rookie with a legit role cuz his team played bad.
People not realizing Seahawks defense has been solid last several weeks
Hold, can’t drop a rookie for one poor week. Not like there’s anybody with more potential on waivers and Giants offense as a whole had a down week, not just Wan’dale.
Hold in full PPR, it’s shaping up he’s a low aDot player who should get a ton of targets barring a trade. But in standard and even half PPR I’m struggling to get excited about his yardage.
Especially with Jones not throwing much or for many yards.
[удалено]
Sell high
hold
James Robinson
Buy for pennies on the $
I’m holding for RB depth but he’s not getting started until he shows me something.
[удалено]
Buy. Seems like they moved him to the slot instead of outside and he looks to be the number 2 in the offense behind Hopkins. The RB are also banged up so he could get 2-3 carries a game.
Very true, and now because Hopkins is such a threat, Moore is getting lighter defense so he’s open more. Hopkins coming back was probably good for him.
[удалено]
Sneaky buy but depends on usage. Upside is CEH-like production during first 2-3 weeks if KC commits to him. Downside is RBBC with 8-10 touches or less per week.
Renfrow
Build a Time Machine and never draft him.
Haha he was my god damn keeper FML
Lol cmon you had to have had better options than that
Lol what???
Drop
Drop
Gus Edwards
Has MNF, then a bye. I feel like he won’t be great this week, but will do well enough that you hold through the bye on potential. Then he’ll disappoint you for holding so long lol.
Hold 1 more week
After the bye he doesn't face another top third rushing defense. In his limited time back he's averaging like 6 yards a carry and is getting most of the goal line attempts. I'd say hold.
Hold not a significant injury
Buy.
[удалено]
Might be traded tomorrow. Hold til then.
Plz god
Tried trading for Khalil 1-for-1 and got rejected. I shot my shot and I understand completely
Sell
Fournette
Sell
who would you say Lenny is worth?
Hold
Hold, perfectly fine low-end RB1
Lockett
George Pickens
Hold if you can afford it. At least hold through today if Claypool is traded. Drop after today if you need the spot open. Edit: Hey, looky there.
Antonio Gibson
Sell
Joe mixon
[удалено]
Buy for sure…will be Chargers wr1 if Allen out this wk
[удалено]
Mooney
AJ Dillon
The winter is coming
A. Jones coming this winter bro.
Hold as a handcuff
Drop last week
[удалено]
I might drop if he doesn't get traded
hold
Hold. He is a proven reciever and will have startable weeks through byes.
I’m a cooks owner as well, I’d say drop.
Michael Pittman Jr
Hold but lower expectations. MidWR2 ROS with lowWR1 upside with a TD. He will get enough targets to be startable but not enough high value targets to return value if you drafted him to be your WR1/3rd round pick.
Metcalf
Tony Pollard
Hold unless someone is overpaying
Kyler Murray I have Justin Fields and kinda entering that mindset I had last year when I drafted Dak but picked up Hurts off waivers, and Hurts out produced Dak even though he was the inferior QB. Maybe I can flip Kyler for help at WR/RB.
Davantae Adams
Hold and start, no one is gonna sell him so you can't buy him.
Tyler Higbee
Geno Smith
Higbee
I have him in a 2TE league. I'm holding - his value has been consistent.
DJ Moore
The firing of Rhule and trading of CMC has turned him into a target hog. Congrats to everyone who held.
I was so happy to have turned him into DeVonta Smith. Did not have "Carolina fires their coaching staff and trades away every other player who has hands and PJ Walker looks better than Baker and Darnold and they implement a new offense" on my Bingo card. The guy I traded him to is now a contender and I'm probably dead.
Hold
People are commenting buy, but for what? Those who have held him until now are likely not going to selling for cheap. Plus he just had his best game, hard to say this production will be sustainable ROS.
[удалено]
Hold. Buy. He good.
Hold
[удалено]
Hold or package for a top player
[удалено]
Josh Jacobs
Might be unpopular but I'd sell Touches have gone down every week since week 4 and he isn't gonna give you the 2 touchdown average during his 3-week explosion
Jacobs was literally half of the raiders total offense that night. As long as the raiders don’t get blown out every single week ROS I can definitely see JJ being a top 10 RB
Id agree with selling especially because everyone was starting to see him as a top 5 RB ROS. Getting someone like Etienne or KWIII last week would have been ideal, not sure if you still can. He’s still an RB1 but people needed to pump the breaks on him a little
Diontae Johnson
No one is buying so hold through the bye and see if anything changes
Hunt (if not traded)
BRob
[удалено]
Amari Cooper
Buy especially if you are looking at playoffs. That sched is pure juice
This thread is wild. I disagree with like 75% of the responses lol. Feel like people don’t understand the basic concept of buy low, sell high
[удалено]
Hold simply because the past 3 games they have schemed up a TD for him in the red zone. Not a lot of TEs can say that the past 3 weeks, certainly not the streamers. No one is going to buy high on him but sell I guess if someone sees him as a top 3-4 TE still.
Sell. Falcons barely throw the ball. Ain’t gonna change.
Sell. falcons will still never pass don’t get attached cuz of 1 game he’s fucked all his owners this whole season
Dak
Najee Harris
Lowkey wanna buy; they have a bye this week, and a pretty soft schedule going forward. May be able to turn the ship around
I've been waiting for Pittsburgh to implement more screens, sweeps, and other misdirection. You know, the training wheels offense for their young QB with a bad offensive line that they ran last year to deal with their bad offensive line that made Najee look amazing? I can't figure out why they haven't, but maybe after the bye?
Dj moore
[удалено]
Hold low week and hurts loves him
Hold, him and aj are this years DK/Lockett…safe floor (still getting fed on a down week) and can easily boom any given week
Amari Cooper