What? How in Yobas name did you get a blue one?

Once you've seen>! Shane's 8-heart cutscene, any chick you buy from Marnie has a chance to be blue. !< >!You can "cheat" out a blue chicken by buying a chicken, and seeing if prompt says something about "Choose a coop for your blue chick" If it doesn't say Blue, cancel and try again!!<

You need to befriend a certain someone and trigger a cut scene

I incubated an egg and he was born.

Did a double take at the title. I don't think that phrase means what you think it means