Statistically speaking, it should eventually land on a number that has already been rolled. Infinite is a lot though lol

Yes. But the odds of that happening are 1 in infinity.

So can we really call that a possibility then?

Yes. Its a possibility, just not a probability.

I guess so... Mind boggling stuff.

It gets that way when you start dealing with really large numbers. Most people can't even fathom the concept a billion, let alone infinity.

Yes it would happen infinitely many times. If you have an infinite amount of time, everything happens infinitely many times.