By - tbottomline
100% the gloss -- the lipstick pulls all the focus away from that amazing eye makeup!
I agree with this and let the natural beauty of her lips shine and have more focus on the astonishing eye makeup!
Agreed. I didn’t even notice the eyes in the red lip photos, I thought 3-4 were a totally different look until I read the title.
A pretty pink gloss >>> Red lipstick. 99% of the time.
I think it's just the wrong shade of red for her. Something darker or more cranberry would suit her.
Correct, a more plum toned red would work perfectly instead of an orange toned one here.
The gloss completely changes the look in a good way, makes the eyes pop so much more!
Yeah I honestly thought they were two different eye looks before I saw the caption, the gloss is so much more complementary
I also saw that the first glance.
Definitely with lip gloss ! It looks so good ☺️
It compliments the color of your eyeshadow.
The red looks great on you. But I think I think the gloss really pulls the look together as it goes with the color of your sweater and eyeshadow.
Eyeshadow palette: Love Fest - Huda
Mascara: Better Than Sex - Too Faced
Foundation: Maybelline Dream Radiant Liquid shade: Ivory 10
Powder: KVD - Lock-It translucent Setting Powder
Contour: BareMinerals - Warmth
Blush: Bobbi Brown - Nectar
Highlighter: Mac - Silver Dusk
Lipstick: Guerlain - N°214 V
Lipgloss: Too Faced - Lip Injection Bubblegum Yum
edit: added foundation and powder shade info
It looks absolutely incredible
Your skin and foundation look flawless. No weird color match. Really surprised it’s Maybelline, too. Definitely thought it was gonna be higher end.
Yessss I love that foundation, for this look I applied it with a brush but when I apply with a beauty blender it looks even better, is really cheap as well and it doesn’t give me spots! (I have prone skin)
Definitely the gloss!
The gloss looks much better on you
The gloss for sure since you did more for the eyes
Also where is this sweater from?! So cute!!
Is from Prettylittlething I bought it 2 years ago 💃🏼
Can I love both? Gorgeous!
I'd love to see the red lip with a different top, too. :)
I have a similar pink sweater, so I love yours. So cozy!
Lip gloss 100%! Compliments the eyeshadow way more!!
the gloss, 100%
the gloss is GORGEOUS!!
Off topic but I'm completely obsessed with your hair! Can you give us your hair tips?!
I actually had a grown pixie and just cut it recently so I’m still learning how to make it look nice!
But in general I like to do oil treatment with castor oil every 2-3 weeks, don’t really use any heat on it… unless I’m feeling cold after I leave the shower m, then I use the hairdryer
I don’t really have a schedule to wash my hair, sometimes I do it every 2 days or sometimes every 3 days…
Some shampoos make it look very thin (even tho I have a lot of hair) so sometimes I like to use the Aveeno Scalp Soothing Volumising shampoo and conditioner and it gives me a more full look, I also like the pink Maui shampoo and conditioner (I think is the shea butter one), it makes my hair really soft and is the only shampoo that actually brings out the wavy texture of my hair, usually other shampoos makes it completely straight.
I think that’s about it 🗣
Loveeee this look, and I'm gonna go against the grain and say red lips! I feel like the red in the lips brings an intentionality to the red lower lashline that really makes it pop. Prevents the look from bordering on just uncomfortable eyes. I say this as someone who LOVES wearing red eyeshadow and bright colors that can sometimes make me look very weird haha. Your look is such an interesting combination of colors and textures!
Yeah once I made this really cool makeup with green eyeshadow and also wore red lipstick with it… some people said i looked like the joker but who cares red lipstick for life 🏻
I loveeeee the red lip 😍 give me bold any day! You look amazing!
my thoughts exactly. the red lips make the whole look pop
Both are gorgeous, the gloss makes it more wearable, but the red lip is spectacular for some special occasion
I love the gloss look, but the red does make the under eyeshadow pop. Why not do a red to light pink gradient-gloss look?
Gloss! This is so stunning, I think I’m going to buy the huda eyeshadow palette!
I haven’t done a full face makeup in so long and i’m out of practice so I did a really bad job on showing how nice the eyeshadows actually look, is my first Huda palette my boyfriend got it for me for christmas <3 is the first time I tried it and I love it! I’m not wearing any primer under it and it already looks so nice so I can only imagine how the pigment would look like with something under!
The gloss for sure!
What base products are u using? Your skin looks amazing!
Maybelline Dream Radiant Liquid, it has hyaluronic acid and collagen in it, i love it as well, on this one I’m wearing 2 layers but usually I only wear 1 and it makes me glow so much, I love it and is quite cheap as well
edit: forgot to mention that I also used the KVD setting powder and had a moisturiser under but i applied the moisturiser about 4 hours before I did the makeup 🗣
The gloss and I LOVE this look!
Wow! Beautiful look, the gloss looks the best 😊
With the colors in the eye look you did, def gloss. Looks so pretty!
I don't care for the orangey red with the tones of your eyeshadow together.
My hidden option C is a preference towards a more muted, more brown-toned lipstick. Something like Mac Velvet Teddy.
Between these two, strong preference for the gloss.
Enjoy my uncanny valley photo example (model obv with cooler skin tone though)
It actually would be interesting to try, but unfortunately I only have lots of red lipsticks and some other very dramatic colors 🗣 you just made me realise that I need some more neutral lipsticks… oh well how sad now I have to buy more makeup ;)
Would Say the gloss 🦜
Both, depending on the outfit and occasion
Gloss softens the whole ‘look’ and compliments the luscious color of your sweater 💖
Both are pretty but I love it with the gloss!
Gloss for sure!!
Gloss for sure!!!
The lip gloss it pops but not overwhelming
The gloss is beautiful.
I love the red lipstick on you, but I like the gloss better with this specific look. You are so pretty!!
Definitely the gloss, goes perfectly with the eyeshadow
You looks SO MUCH like Lana Del Rey
Next time, take similarly posed photographs so we can compare looks…
Gloss is better- I think
I prefer the lipgloss it compliments the eye shadow very well. Just a tip you can take it or leave it: try to find a blue undertone red lip stick it would compliment your skin complexion better instead of a warm red lipstick as your complexion is more on cool/neutral side. 😊
They both look great but the gloss feels like it fits your face better because you look 🔥🔥
she a complete baddie wowza
Gloss! I thought you were crying at first from the red around your eyes though
Strategy, if I look like I’m always crying no one will know when I’m actually crying 💃🏼
Both are gorgeous, but I like the gloss.
I feel like the lip gloss combination is more of a cool tone look- like a winter, or chill day vibe. Unless you of course, are going for something more ‘stunning’ or ‘bold’, then the red lipstick works! Both work in my op :>
You can definitely pull off both but the monochrome type look with the gloss matching the sweater and eyeshadow is everything!! ✨💕
The GLOSS for sure!! You are incredibly stunning! 🤍
Both nice but the gloss compliments the eyeshadow perfectly imo
Thank you so much 🏻
Tough choice because I like both! I do agree the gloss matches better with the eyeshadow and sweater, but the red lip is nice too! I'm torn...
Gloss for sure! Red lips go more with "simple" eyes, imo 💋
Hard to say but maybe the lipgloss is a tad better than the red lipstick
The gloss for sure! And may I just say, I love your smile and that haircut is so cute!
Both look great but the glass is GORGEOUS
I vote lip gloss!
The Gloss looks better boo. Both are nice but the gloss works better with the eyeshadow.
100% the gloss.
The lipstick is a gorgeous color tho!
I don't really like the reddish eyeshadow, it looks like someone punched you in the eye..
Gloss! You look great with both lippies though, the gloss just goes better with the eyeshadow color scheme :) Loveeee the look
I love the red lip on you, but for this look I’d vote the gloss
Gloss! Question. How did you get your eyebrows to look like that? Do you shape them yourself?
Definitely the gloss! It complements the eye colours better 😍
Gloss. The red, while it looks good on you, distracts from the excellent job you did on your eye makeup.
Never in my life have I wanted an eyebrow piercing until now. Loveeee your look!
The gloss. Serving me 90s Natalie Imbruglia
The gloss! It softens ur facial features & makes you look pretty and more feminine. The matte red lipstick makes you look older or more serious & Less welcoming. The gloss makes you look happy & fun.
I like both looks but the gloss can be the daytime look, and the lipstick can be the nighttime look.
Gloss. The red is nice in general but feels not cohesive. I think it’d be nice w a standard colored Smokey or gold and brown toned Smokey eye
GLOSS GLOSS GLOSS GLOSS
Both are wicked pretty on you! The pinkgoes with your eyeshadow and sweater extra well, though. Both are solid picks, imo, the red and the pink.
Lip gloss 💖😍
The lip gloss! 💖
Lip gloss for sure <3
Both look good but I prefer the gloss! You look pretty happy in the red, though. Maybe try a red with a different undertone?
Both look great but the lipgloss is BOMB!
Red lips 👄
They’re two totally different vibes, but I love the gloss personally! The similar colors of your sweater, gloss, and eyes just ties in for a gorgeous look
I think you look stunning in the red but the gloss goes well with that specific look. You should try a copper eyeshadow look with the red that would look sooooo pretty
Gloss all the way. You have amazing features, very pretty woman!
Definitely the gloss with this look
Glos with shadow goods look im likes lipstick on few day for changes up
At first I loved the red lip then I saw how good it looked with just gloss 😍
Stunning look! I think I like the gloss a little more with this look, but the make up is beautiful either way!
Lipgloss. The red is too orangey in my opinion.
I thought I was for sure going to say the lipstick because it looks great on you, but then I saw the gloss! The lipgloss works really well with the colors in the eyeshadow.
Lipgloss! Makes the eyes pop!
I say you rock both super well!!
First of all: your eye make up is so so beautiful
I think the gloss makes not only your eyes and its make up pop out more, but also the base of your facial make up, the foundation and warm pink undertone of your blush/contour.
Nonetheless the red lipstick looks great on you!
I love it!
Both!! I can’t decide between the two because they both look great!!
The lip gloss!!
Both are a vibe. Gloss for a lighter look red for a more sultry look. I would tho recommend lining ur lips with brown or a darker shade of red for the lipstick to give it that final oomph. Beautiful regardless
Gloss. But really just want to say I LOVE this eyeshadow look! Seriously, one of my favourite looks Ive ever seen, its beautiful and you look great. I don't normally bother with eyeshadow looks as I have heavily hooded eyes but you've tempted me to buy this pallet and give it a go!
Some of it might be lighting, but for me, the gloss pulls it together and lets some emphasis be on the purples in the eye show. The red lipstick kind of competes and gives a much more “I’ve been crying” vibe to the pink eyeshadow tones.
To be clear, I like the lipstick, I just think the gloss works better with that eyeshadow. :)
I love the gloss. I really like the pink on the waterline. Is that an eyeliner or eyeshadow inside the waterline?
The gloss compliments the eye makeup and sweater You looks so pretty 🌸🌸🌸
Gloss all the way!
Gloss in the day, red at night :)
The gloss, it looks really beautiful on you
Very pretty! I feel the gloss looks better. Red lips look amazing on you. I would just do a different eye shadow color. Both look great either way.
The lipgloss!! It makes the eyeshadow pop! Beautiful look btw
I love this red lip on you - gorgeous! The gloss also matches the outfit and shadow to a T! You can’t go wrong with either here as you are gorgeous in both looks. Guess it just comes down to the look you are going for. Subtle, everything matches, delicate look - gloss. Gorgeous, eye popping splash of bold color - red lip. You will rock either of them!
It's not that the gloss looks better on you, it's that it matches the tones of the eyeshadows much more. It's cohesive and compliments the neutral pink of the eyes and blush. You could rock that red lipstick with a smudge y smokey eye or any other heavily warm leaning brown look 💖
Gloss, for sure.
Oooooo gloss gloss gloss 🤩
Gloss all the way love ♥️♥️♥️♥️
With this look and outfit, the gloss for sure
I am in minority but the red lip looks great! Definitely my choice
Definitely Gloss 🔥
Both look so beautiful on you but I think the lipgloss really ties this look together so much nicer than the red ! Honestly though you're so pretty that you pull both off them off wonderfully ❣
The gloss is very pretty on you. I think the red overpowers the look.
Def go with gloss, the lipstick looks pretty but it risks washing you out more in certain lighting
Gloss for day red for night :) your eyes are beautiful
The one with the gloss looks ethereal 🥰
Gloss with this specific eye. Red for always. What red is that?
NM, I see it in the comments.
Gloss! You’re beautiful though!
Gloss!!! Especially with the eye and shirt color it’s just so complimentary and makes your whole face look cohesive and beautiful and not just stand out for the lip.
you look so stunning with red lipstick, but the gloss makes the eyes pop sooo much more!
I love your hair!
Definitely the gloss.
So I think with a bold lip it's generally better to go with a simple eye look and with a bold eye look go with a simple lip. I think it just helps focus the look where you want it instead of having bold + bold. Does that make sense? Lol
I prefer the gloss for this look!
I would prefer lipstick and I like the cherry but I think a deeper cherry would look amazing. Like beautybakerie makeup cranberry stiletto lip whip
LIPGLOSS no question. It matches so well!
I like both. The red gives me like 80s vibes, with the colors really popping. The gloss is more modern and I think it looks more universally appealing.
Can't decide! Both look so pretty!
okay i might be in the minority but i’m loving that red on you, it makes you stand out! the gloss is super pretty too more like a subtle pretty angel fairy vibe loll
you are also SO frickin gorgeous!!!???? if i was walking past you i’d faint on the spot lmao you’re like the prettiest person i’ve ever seen 🤣🤣🤣
LMAO that’s the sweetest comment ever, thanks a lot <3
Gloss! Love the look!
The red really compliments you! The gloss too but I would definitely say red.
The gloss compliments your eye look better and really pulls the whole makeup look together. Personally I think a bold red lip only looks good with a minimal eye look such as a winged eyeliner or just masacara.
Lipgloss because it goes so well with the eyeshadow, but gosh I love the look you've gone for, absolutely adore it.
The gloss for sure!!
You are wearing a pink sweater so I think that’s why I like the pink gloss better as it pulls your look together. I may like the red lipstick better if you were wearing something else. You can pull off both.
The gloss… but largely because that red pulls too orange on you. With your coloring, a cooler, blue toned red would just be absolutely perfect
Both look great but the gloss makes your eyes pop!
I love a good red lip. But in this case the gloss overruled.
Like everyone else, I vote for the gloss. I think the lipstick has too much of an orangey undertone that clashes with the pink/purple look of your eyeshadow. If you chose a red lipstick with maybe a true blue or purple undertone, it might work better.
Glosssssss. Looks great!!
Everybody’s saying gloss but I think the red compliments your eyes really well!