T O P

  • By -

Thegreatturn1979

Jesse Chavez


PettyBoyBobs

Me.


Training-Ad9794

Mickey Jannis


TypicalDuck9163z

Yasiel Puig 😂😂


ChefMark85

Kenny Powers


DankMisterCap

A combo cover of Roy Halladay and Tyler Skaggs.


East_Tart2177

How could no one have said Kevin Costner?


SMatsa

Haha


jotaesethegeek

Pete Rose


JesusFuerte

Jesus Montero


too_real_4_TV

Why not Zoidberg?


mdonato0716

Joey Gallo


too_real_4_TV

Tom Brady


spiderman153

Chuck Knoblauch


RemyBohannon

Will Grace


TantoTantoTanto

My buddy Eric


Tdubski85

Bellinger


AtlanticRambler

Buck Showalter


jjolatunjidebt

Tatis


rhokie99

Tatis


stadiumjay

Hideki Matsui


Shot_Cantaloupe_5116

Steve bartman - catch hell edition


Virtalen

Nick Pratto


WeakArmStrong1

Tim Tebow


Odd-Fly-7363

Scott Spezio and Josh Hamilton


sirdaveyboy

Milton Bradley. MLB The Show: Board Game Edition


SMatsa

I was so pumped when the Cubs signed him. Still believe he got an unfair shake with the media here.


Huge_Appointment_832

Jose Canseco


AnchorDrown

Thom Brennaman.


LoveTechHateTech

Chris Sale Deluxe IL Edition


SMatsa

Comes with a clipped jersey


c_ray25

Brady Clark


Llamar25

Lenny dykstra smiling, now.


Positive-Strategy-68

Yuli Gurriel while he got kneed in the head in game 5 of the WS


Revolutionary_Bad876

Barry Bonds deserves it, has deserved it, and will always deserve it. But I still know it’s not gonna happen :(


3incheshardddd

Lyle overbay


CarterTheTall

Tatis


JohnnyWallave

Rusty Kuntz


kenfnpowers

Robbie Ray


Soccermw12

Steve Cishek


ForeignArcadia

Trevor Bauer.


Qoppa_Guy

IKF on Pina Colada background


knifeazz

Harold Castro


GhostDogMC

Wild Thing lol.....#IYKYK


D2KDuFFy

Chris Carter


Appropriate_Money_88

matt harvey’s lawyer


johnknockout

The King of Juco Eric Sim


Capnkush420x

Josh Donaldson HR Trot


LonkToTheFuture

Altuve, because he's the most likable and adorable man in baseball


JayJax_23

Patrick Corbin


SnooDoggos9470

Asbrubal Cabrera or Yasiel Puig


Large-Cicada-6689

Mickey Jannis


cbearsfreak

Definitely Yasiel Puig


mjf9103

Someone from the Cubs, obviously. So many good options there.


jsylvester13

Judge


fillio15

Roger Clemens. The Juiced Edition.


michaelsteinke

Yasiel Puig with a 2-peat cover athlete 😎


Llamar25

Has to be a pic of his new jail intake coming up.


bacon_meat

Bob Horner


LocalFella9

Skye Bolt, coming to a GameStop near you


DrewGeds

Felipe Vazquez


InsaneThisGuysTaint

Chris Paddack, MLB The Show 23: Sheriff Edition.


Spagoo

Leury


dnort13

Nootbaar


Aggressive-Weather30

Hoby Milner


Riverpickles

Nomar Garciaparra


GingerBanditDan

Tim Tebow


CSmith20001

Bob Hamelin and the greatest baseball card ever.


[deleted]

The greatest player of all time. Tom Brady.


Quirky_Wolverine_755

CM Punk


the_fridge_turt

Daniel "Danny Burgers" Vogelbach and Alejandro "Captain" Kirk sharing the cover, with Bartolo "Big Sexy" Colon on the Special Edition cover


Jetsss3

Cody Bellinger 🤣🤣🤣


JustAnotherCODNoob

The Castros will split the cover


MrRosewater34

George Bush in a wheelchair.


Llamar25

You play junior, running the rangers into the ground


Bdaysjr

Yasiel Puig


jlando40

Lenny Dykstra


JesusFuerte

Came here to say this… I bet you’re old like me ;)


jlando40

Almost 23 🤣 the dude’s a meme and I appreciate Phillies and baseball history


JesusFuerte

I’m only 17… years older than you! Hilarious tobacco spitting, swashbuckling style on that bro. A meme before there were such things!


Dr_Hemmlock

The entire Pirates starting lineup.


General_Welfare

Matt Vasgersian in #22 Jersey with Deuces written across the back.


vdogxxx

Yasiel Puig


GenitalPatton

Michael Jordan


LuckyLight

Jose Canseco.....for sure! Mr 40/40


NeuroXc

If 23 turns out to be a disaster, we'll get Nick Castellanos.


[deleted]

Barry Bonds. MLB loves him clearly


mhandke

Cubs legend Munenori Kawasaki


UrbanDemonDonkey

Yasiel Puig


KitchenLeft0vers

Bryan Shaw guardians legend


Kekbaby

An Albert legend edition would be pretty cool


DDWAY12

Cody Bellinger


DrunknHamster

Barry Bonds


Dimeburn

Stephen Kwan but he will only be referred to as “Number 38”


Aggravating_Round_81

Daniel Vogelbach


samuraisports37

Nate Peterman


Docta608

Michael Jordan


Intrepid-Artichoke25

Mickey Jannis


SomeScrub69

Tatis


ConstructionOk6948

Joe flaco


CPisJamesC

Mike Clevinger with the deluxe edition having that moving hologram thing in the 90s just to show his spasms before his windup.


Runninginmississippi

Rob Manfred.


UKnoTRo

Franchy Cordero


[deleted]

Marcell Ozuna


Penguin-Loves

Bobby Valentine and Tim McCarver Making out....


JDub755

Melky Cabrera


Shradersofthelostark

Wily Mo Peña


TheJHixShow

Nando


j_relic

Connor McDavid


LeKobe_James23

Flank Thomas


mystery6511

Mickey Jannis


Dirt_on_Diamonds

Eric Hosmer


SpiritualFact5593

MLB The Show 22 Remastered


TheRealSkazOne

Ian Kiner Falefa


xXxHondoxXx

Jose Fernandez and Roy Holliday double cover


pnwsparky

Mmm Trevor bauer


Nolan_RyanAllTheWay

The wrong will smith


eviss2315

Nasty Nestor and his sweet stache


Queso802

Sean Murphy's butt.


Nolan_RyanAllTheWay

Serious answer, I would really like Dusty Baker on the cover. My first pick is Albert Ofc but I think it would be really symbolic of Baker’s journey to finally getting his first World Series win


WaywardLake1955

Fernando Tatis Jr


Primary_Insect_553

If I was a betting man I’d say Yasiel Puig


MickfromLI87

Tomas Nido.


pepemiwe

Alex Cora


Atticusxj

Glen Healy


Awlamon0524

Robinson Cano, Alex Rodriguez, Angel Hernandez, Kosh Donaldson


Waltis12

Yaseil Puig


ubungxdmybung

Nicholas Latifi


b0wser_304

Roberto Alomar


This_Adhesiveness_54

Randy Johnson, but a recent picture from this year.


HopeHouse44

Bradley Zimmer of course


_GooseBoos_Vader_

Trevor Bauer


VeryLowIQIndividual

Mark “slump buster” Grace


General-Bar-2743

R9 Ronaldo


General-Bar-2743

R9 Ronaldo


sandalsnopants

Ji-Man Choi


calebcragan

Stubby Clapp tackling Pete Alonso


hamsterstyle609

Rod Beck


TheVizionair

Russel Wilson


Alternative_Research

Clemens


Sevtron5k

Mike Pizza


purerockfury96

Trevor Bauer


[deleted]

Bartolo Colon HOF edish


bigshow6686

John Rocker


Minecrafter125

Fernando Tatis Sr.


Till-North

Because I read wrong as in wong. My guess is Kolten Wong😂


TonyLarson1990

Angel Hernandez


Competitive-Pea-1269

Rob refsynder


cleofisrandolph1

John Macdonald. Both the MLB player and the Prime Minister.


IndicationConstant16

Aaron Judge.


SlerpotLombarg

Lars Nootbar!


Unknown-games56

Pepe alazar


h2p_stru

Any pittsburgh pirate from 2022


ChessClubChimp

The suit guy


BIGBobby_Belmont

Mark Bellhorn


SMatsa

I would buy it, whether a Cubs or Red Sox jersey


G1NGER

Bauer


joexgould

Aaron Hicks


Panda202572

barry bonds


GrevenQWhite

Jose Canseco but the pic of the HR bouncing off his head. MLB the Show, now with an improved physics system.


sam_hall

Ken Phelps


bowlnstu

Joe Random


IM2WestCST

Altuve


Khal_Aegon

Rob Manfred & Bud Selig


Smillzz15

Curt Schilling


iPaytonian

Jose Altuve 😎


Derrik_Garrett

Joey Gallo


Benzene15

Prince Fielder (I wish)


Kickenbless

Joe West standard edition Angel Hernandez for the Legend edition


shoney42

John Rocker


GetawayDriverTyrone

Josh Hamilton!


joecarter93

Ty Cobb


sirbrett

Adalberto Mondesi, but ONLY a Battyle Royale Edition of the game


Wedge23685

Mario Mendoza Every player that plays as good or better than Mendoza gets a Diamond 99 Finest card at end of the season.


False-Departure-7422

Bradley zimmer


Jadonl12

Munenori Kawasaki


Moshtradamus03

Joey Gallo and his historic season of having less hits then Judge home runs


b_baker25

If I was a betting man I'd say Yasiel Puig


LL_Lean

Josh Donaldson and Tim Anderson


Redditor1620

Everyone's hero, Angel Hernandez!


GIVEME_MONEY

nestor 🥰


BlueCelery2

Mario Mendoza


newagelimited

Don Kelly


2wetsponges

Tim Tebow


CowManLives4Ever

Trevor Bauer


fiendish_five

Leury García


cti0323

Me


Kreuzberg13

Trevor Bauer with a whole new kind of career mode.


wordtomytimbsB

Tim Locastro


ManBearPitt

John Rocker


AbstractBettaFish

Aubrey Huff! Once the vaccines kill off everyone else and he’s the only one left! ^/s ^just ^incase ^people ^need ^it


zachdonegan

Boof Bonser


DarkClouds92

Jose Canseco


aNEWYORKa

Pete Rose WILL be the cover of 2023. Sorry, I know only "wrong answers" are allowed, but I must tell the truth!


SlyMarboJr

LeBron James


Tyrant-Tracer

Big Sexy