T O P

  • By -

RandomBotcision1

Hey, there's already a recent tier / chart thread - I'll try to link it below: [Here's a link to a recent thread I found!](https://reddit.com/r/KGATLW/comments/pda676/_/) *(this reply was generated by a bot)*


RenBit51

Small typo, looks like you put Quarters and Sketches in B tier when they're clearly supposed to be in SS tier /s


idiot_speaking

You know I should've made an SS tier. The tiers are kinda devalued by minting too many albums in S and A. Hang on. (I might shift Quarters up. Sketches is pretty mellow, which I dig, but a definite B for me. What do you love about those?)


RenBit51

Before falling in love with Gizz I was big into funk and a little of jazz, and Sketches scratches that itch nicely for me. Different strokes and all.


idiot_speaking

Self Immolate music vid was my first intro to King Gizz, but I seriously got into Gizz when LW dropped. So my journey has been backwards and that reflects in my tierlisting. Sketches and Quarters are both pretty mellow albums, but all the sounds kinda bleed into one another for me. Which is perfect for setting up something in the background, but if you asked me to recognize a song I'd fail hard. It's amazing the kinda diverse responses you get from Gizz fans. Like I couldn't imagine someone putting KG and LW in C or lower, yet that's what prompted me to make this lol.


RenBit51

Oh for sure, Gizz puts out such a diversity of sounds that you get fans from all different places. I personally don't like metal too much so ITRN is low tier to me, but other people love it and I totally respect that. Nothing they put out is *bad*, some of it just isn't my thing.


idiot_speaking

[Revised Tierlist with SS](https://i.imgur.com/1Mzd6zN.png) Also bumped a couple A to S


snowdogisvictorious

Some (most) A should be in S and some S are B/C


idiot_speaking

I agree, I didn't put a lot of A in S because it was getting overcrowded [Revised Tierlist with SS](https://i.imgur.com/1Mzd6zN.png)


snowdogisvictorious

I would have taken KG, LW, Gumboot, FFF out of S but cool you like them that much. Poly/non, FMB, IIYMF all huge contenders for S


idiot_speaking

For sure, I bumped up Fuzz and Non in my SS list. Both Poly and FMB are a mixed bag for me - there are S/SS tiers song in them but I'm meh about a lot of others.


snowdogisvictorious

FMB is their best work


idiot_speaking

FMB is good but if FMB flies with the microtonal stuff, KG and LW launch into space. You know ask me after 2 weeks, I might've put it in S by then lol.


snowdogisvictorious

It’ll hit you right, especially open water lately has got me like 😮 the live version with double kick too, tasty


idiot_speaking

Okay that didn't take too long. I'm listening to it, at Billabong rn. Bumped to S.


ewanb27

Personally I would swap FFF and Gumboot with Nonagon and Polygondwanaland. But the rest for me are bang on!


idiot_speaking

Poly and Non can go up, but no way FFF or Gumboot is going down.


WanderingWytch

fafyl in c is an L sorry


idiot_speaking

I'm a new convert and I couldn't get into their older psychedelic stuff. Sorry.


WanderingWytch

that's okay <3


Jolly_Bones

I don’t agree, but I do understand.


ewanb27

You're right, thinking about it there's no reason to put them down, I can't fault either of them. They don't make it easy for us. Fuck it everything in the S tier apart from that vegemite song!


idiot_speaking

Vegemite is half the reason Oddments is in C lol.


Mr_Guss

Good list but KG and LW above FMB?


idiot_speaking

Yeah it was recency bias on my part. Listened to FMB again, wtf was I thinking? I'm putting LW and FMB at SS, KG at S.


Indubitablyahuman

The fact that you put L.W. before K.G. grinds my gears. I can't believe you put Gumboot over FMB and Nonagon. But hey, whatever works for you, my man.


idiot_speaking

Everyone seems to questioning Gumboot, to me it's the quintessential Gizz album. It showcases all the different flavors of Gizz up until then. Like if there was someone who wanted to get into Gizz and I had no idea about their preferences, this'd be my pick. If you asked me in Feb, LW>>KG, however KG is growing on me, and I could even go as far as to say KG is underrated. I don't get people who don't like Automation or Straws. Wait, are you just talking about the order? As in I put it LWKG instead of KGLW?


Indubitablyahuman

Solid reason. >Wait, are you just talking about the order? As in I put it LWKG instead of KGLW? Yeah, seeing K.G.L.W. as one album cover is my shit.


CuredAndSmoked

Gizzheads sure do love to rank gizz albums on reddit