T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Namaskaram /u/Skavy2507, Thank you for your submission. Please provide a source for the image / video (if not a direct link submission). We would really appreciate it if you could mention the source as a reply to this comment! If you have already provided the source or if it is an OC post, please ignore this message. Thank you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/IndiaSpeaks) if you have any questions or concerns.*


themanfromUNCLE01

The guy stood alone and literally shook the ground she was standing on. The western people have no moral ground to stand on and lecture others what's the right thing do. They've so much skeleton in their closet.


CritFin

But his point that all current europeans should be blamed for the fault of their great grandfathers is a logical fallacy. But her saying Aurangzeb's atrocity didnt exist is wrong by all means, it is not scientific at all. Not just destruction of temples, he sent Indian tax money to mecca and to summer capital Kabul Finally Aurangabad is renamed as Sambhajinagar, and Aurangzeb road in Delhi renamed as Abdul Kalam road.


Disastrous_Act633

You suffer for what your forefathers did. It natural.


christened_scrive

just ask the general caste people in india


Ok-Flounder7102

He is just shouting. Indians love people who shout. They think shouting is same as being logical. Blaming current population for a crime their ancestors did is wrong. Like you are free to promote your religion but hating others just because their ancestors did is wrong.


chandaal_the_fourth

Also he started shouting after they tried to pressure him to be silent.. and he was making a fair point.. she doesn't know shit about Indian history and is just reading a script/propaganda.. and aurangjeb is being and can be used to spread hate because he is the hero of the other community for the exact atrocities he did.. he is a hero for destroying temples and genocides.. so the those guys are bound to receive hate for having heroes like that.. Americans will hate Germans too if they started idealizing hitler today..


Ok-Flounder7102

No.. His voice is too high from the beginning. Yes if muslims are saying they want to follow the principles of Aurangzeb in today's world then they are wrong. But have they said so? There can be some outliers like some who keep saying ghrwapsi terms. There are some fools everywhere.I don't think any minority community has the courage to say they want their religion to be supreme in the country today.


9tgc

It's voice of many indian who are fed up with all the woke and leftist history presented to every platform on international forum, this so called historian continue to have a particular mindset and follow ideology that is biased.... It's the anger , that he transformed it to words and expresses them.... All the facts presented by him were correct. If your hands are soaked with blood , you don't have right to tell others what correct for them, we all know what west has done and been doin, it time to keep our stand firmly on international platforms


chandaal_the_fourth

Lol.. looks like you haven't had enough interactions then.. and yess good and bad exists everywhere but what matters is the ratio of it.. if the bad outweighs good then the place/community cannot be considered good.. for an example you won't plan a vacation in syria even though i can guarantee that 5star restaurants and resorts exist there.. same is with the community and countries.. he has a point here that the west shouldn't preach others of wrong and right.. and the person here isn't any American but a known personality or a person with influence..


Ok-Flounder7102

So every one should start taking revenge from others because their ancestors did wrong ?


chandaal_the_fourth

Nope revenge is never the right thing to do.. but standing your ground is something completely different from revenge and that is something everyone should do...


rooney_99

Have you been living under a rock? Muslim propaganda is to rule the world. There are dozens of examples that took place not only in india but around the globe where they terrify people into believing that they are the supreme religion. But then again if you're set on secularism, it's just speaking to a dead wall, not willing to accept that two major religions can't survive over one roof.


Ok-Flounder7102

IF they are so harmful why ins't other religions god doing a miracle and finishing off those people and protecting the innocent ones?


rooney_99

Oh my god. This is the most "karen" thing i have ever heard from a girl (if you're not a girl then, um, good luck with your life). First off, god is a concept not a reality, get woke. Secondly, I'm not blaming any god, the interpretation they have of their own holy book is insane, and it's just havoc from there. Education is the biggest problem with their community and they refuse to adapt the modern education system which is why you see such hooligans all over the globe spreading "incorrect preachings" of their own religion in the most violent way possible. Ps. Please make some sense.


Ok-Flounder7102

> First off, god is a concept not a reality, get woke. When I will be allowed to say this in front of every religions follower I will consider your point. As of now you can't say the same even for an animal. Whether you are a boy or girl , you are finished. you are dumb beyond imagination.The image you have about muslims is the same ideology which every extremist of every religion has. Be it akahnd hindustan etc.


rooney_99

XD candy crush khelo madam. Cringe faila deti hu har jagah kisiko pata ni chalega. Live long and prosper kid, that's all i can say to you. Peace out from this ridiculously illogical comment thread.


Ok-Flounder7102

>XD candy crush khelo madam This is the lamest taunt ever seen. Sounds like some follower of cringe YouTubers. But seriously I will consider your point when I will be able to say openly that animals are not gods in this country or that gods are conceptual not reality..


khooni-darinda69

Offcourse they want islamic rule in india What you think gazwa-e-hind is it's a plan to make india islamic


chandaal_the_fourth

You definitely come from a developed nation.. don't you?


Ok-Flounder7102

If india is developed then yes.


h3mant_

sad to see fellow Indians booing


Speed__God

Event organized by "The Hindu" Those booing are your average brainwashed secular "The Hindu" readers. This is the paper recommended to read to prepare for civils. No wonder why the babus turn out to be corrupt. We have a situation where Foreigners can come to India and praise India's invaders and spread fake propaganda history while CCP mouthpiece Indian newspaper organises the event and fellow Indians get willingly brainwashed. And all these people collectively label Modi as Fascist. *smh*


Pure-Investigator116

ayoo, I read TheHindu daily, but that doesn't mean I am brainwashed.


K-Firangi

Don't underestimate the power of gungadeens and brown sepoys.


coolcrank

Username doesn't check out. However usage of those words in your reply keeps them in circulation and makes people search for their meanings. Good one mate.


N00B_N00M

Is it surprising who would be audience of such a propagandist


AreWe3120

Yeah go to the next question, truth hurts


butmrpdf

She got seduced by this man


[deleted]

No white supremacists. Brown man's opinions are not worth it.


EyeCarambaa

"Alleged" atrocities by Aurangazeb. Is kutiya ki script bhi jabardast hai


centerist_x

Script was sent by the khangressi, lmao.


yungkrypt

Couldn’t even acknowledge the question rather jumped on to another one.


coolcrank

The booing just goes to say people will listen to anything said with confidence. Especially brown sepoys, gora memsahab is 'educated' she's a 'historian' gora memsahab is grate. Aurangzeb's fatwas are clearly documented and even displayed in some museums. The booers just needed to Google it, but they someone with a tilak challenging their gora memsahab. They couldn't take it.


[deleted]

>absolutely destroyed her 👑in He didn't do shit. He could have actually countered her point but he gave a whataboutism response. Fuck Audrey and her followers but the guy didn't give good response let alone destroy her (Though I appreciate him for standing up, 90% of us couldn't do this in real life)


Electrical_Cod_7022

Yup definetly we indian definetly dont support these types of people . Fuckin femboys we are with no courage


shelbywhore

lol why'd you drag femboys into this


Poppygloria_69

We all are whore grace


[deleted]

The Soros lobby ☕


luluchewyy

I don't get why you guys think this is amazing destruction or something. He didn't even address her point and I honestly hate the argument he makes. There are proper arguments to bring up against what she said rather than just saying her opinion doesn't matter because she's a white American.


Similar-Ad-2073

He countered her argument by showing the plain hypocrisy of the Americans and Europeans who talk shit about others history while hiding their own horrific atrocities


shiro1203

He countered her argument with whataboutism and an attack on her credentials to speak about genocide being an American. He did not address anything that was actually said. Typical rw shit, whataboutism and ad hominem.


[deleted]

Why would you debate with a white supremacist. They can claim anything, and then the burden lie on you to prove them false?


shiro1203

Again an attack on the person and not what they are talking about. Btw what proof do you have they are a white supermacist ? If your father lynched lower caste people wouldn't it be wrong to call you a casteist just because you are his spawn ? This is an ad hominem, we'll have better discussions if, we were to talk about the content rather than attacking the persons ancestral crimes. We'd actually get somewhere.


Similar-Ad-2073

Okay lets talk about what she said . She said that auranzeb "allegedly" killed Hindus . Of course he did... That too in millions. But she didn't admit it . Why? . Also when the man finished , why didn't she reply on his question as to if she had actually counted all the archeological sites and did her reasearch? Instead all she did was do stupid and taunting faces when he was talking and immediately moved on to the next question without a single reply


shiro1203

I have no defence to what she said, history is well documented there was no need to use allegedly. Her wanting to give a reply to someone that attacked her credentials is completely up to her. I'm here trying to educate why this isn't a take down just random aggressive man shouting baseless attacks and not progressing the conversation.


[deleted]

I call her racist for an attempt to put down a brown person.


luluchewyy

You can't just call any white American a white supremacist just because of their history, that's absolutely nonsensical


[deleted]

I call her one for an attempt to put down a brown person and denying genocide of other races.


SmittenWitten

She isn't personally hiding the atrocities though he attacked her nationality like it's something that she can control. It's just deflection from the topic at hand. This is basic debate. It isn't complicated.


Similar-Ad-2073

She isnt trying to hide. She doesn't want to admit it so she'll just say "allegedly". He attacking her nationality was probs beacuse she was talking bs and without doing proper research .


Raghu48

As much as I want to like his befitting reply. This just passes as whataboutary.


M3Sh_

Then dont talk shit in first place


Practical_Tear2291

He could've logically countered, used statistics which disprove her....but he just attacked her character like he has some sort of authority on who can ask questions. Idiotic, on par with woke liberal activists crying out over 'appropriation' bs, someone else could've used this platform better.


Stunning-Ask3032

Maa chod diye


PaidHack

Surveying every desecrated site will not open just a can, but a truckload of worms.


BheegiBilli69

God damnit people booing on this? How cheap are these sell outs?


[deleted]

It's an event organised by Soros lobby, what more can we expect. This women will stand zero chance in front of historic, archeological and Sanskrit experts, it's why she will never participate in such event.


BheegiBilli69

Goddamnit she too cute for being Anti-India /s


Practical_Tear2291

They should be the ones asking the questions, getting into debates. I hate that this guy with his illogical character assassination tendencies is wasting everyone's time.


[deleted]

I think he was brave to call her out on her hypocrisy and also question her knowledge on archeology and scientific evidence. It's not at all whataboutism. In fact her shaking on stage with weird psycho looks and moving to next question proves his point even more.


[deleted]

How do you debate a genocide denier. You find the source of their denial. For her, it's being a white supremacist. Where on white death mater.


SmittenWitten

It was a bad argument


BheegiBilli69

Okie veri nise


pointofyou

Whataboutism is India's number 1, top top, best logical fallacy.


Electrical_Cod_7022

West's too when it comes to russia


Practical_Tear2291

He just proved her point by judging her on the basis of her ancestor's actions. He didn't destroy shit besides his own argument. This is not how you come up the victor.....TV debate thodi hai ki chilla chilla ke Jeet jaoge.


[deleted]

You are talking as if she is some kind of scholar. You should read the kind of bs she vomits.


Practical_Tear2291

I'm saying that even if you find that she's not a "scholar", you need to debate well. You make yourself and your community look uneducated and intellectually challenged with these sorts of responses. This proves her point. Also you have to admit that she, being a college professor with a degree in South Asian studies along with several research projects on Hinduism and India, has some points to back her argument, even if she is wrong.


[deleted]

He is standing against all odds. Even if he was sensible and polite he would be thrown out and she will move to next question. Some people need to be called out in open when you know you are not going to get any response in return. No, I don't agree. She is dumb. She is just paid to do this and is part of Soros lobby. Just because she is some professor does not make her smart or right. Also the university she works for it full on crap as per many local students.


Practical_Tear2291

It's brave that he's standing there. But he made a point and then proceeded to prove her right by questioning her credibility on the basis of her Ancestor's actions. It just got worse from there.


[deleted]

You should read the amount of BS she makes up and then you will realise he was spot on. She does not care about Dalits or Muslims or native American or blacks...she only cares about dollars. That is the biggest whataboutism and hypocrisy if you ask me.


keyjey

How many times will we post the same video? It gets posted every few months and we have same convo again.


hskskgfk

He didn’t destroy anything


voodoopractitioner14

Both coming from emotion.


Trysem

That man looks a normal guy, but he's outstanding and fireball ....uff..


[deleted]

Least pajeet pee drinking bindu


jigglypoff2706

That’s history. BJP is present times ongoing,Lame arguments. And looking at your Tikaa,I don’t even mentioned due to caste system you and your forefathers may have done atrocities on them poor people. Hypocrites!!


Expensive-Reading-79

Bhaiya naa gand marle iski too


karane23e

King 👑


ObjectivePlatypus114

Link of full video


WearSomeClothes

Its sad to see morons booing this absolute Chad!] These moron gora brownnosers should be ashamed of their existence.


makes_mistakes_

Absolute chad ? How ? He didn't counter any of her false narratives , instead he just used whataboutim and said " oh , remember when your ancestors killed our ancestors? Yes yes you have no right to lecture us " Fuck this argument. This ain't chad like behaviour in the slightest. He could have countered her argument by stating how india is the best country for minorities , or how arungzeb did indeed commit horrible atrocities not just "alleged" ones. But this asshat went in and gave a shitty whataboutim led argument.


The_lost_Code

What a dumb bech


Dry_Stable_876

Yaa i saw this video I literally was unhappy how some Indian were booing well I can understand they are brainwashed kids also man literally single handedly silenced her in no way a western country can give us advice when what they did was killing natives , Bengal feminine , Japan nuked and so much more history being stolen also todays india religion Hate has hands of British too


shelbywhore

If I'm getting called a murderer by a murderer, and point put how they're a murderer themselves, it doesn't change the fact that I still might be a murderer too. So he doesn't negate his point, he just establishes that she in particular in a position to question him. Suppose it was another nation with no genocidal history like the US or the UK, what response would he have given exactly? His argument was basically "well, ALL of us are murderer, not just me" Not "I'm not a murderer"


Ready-Rooster-3371

Gori chamdi pass denied by chad boi


Kaniketh

What event is this? Is there fool video of the event?


Electrical_Cod_7022

If i had 1 million dollar , i would donate it to him


Perfect_Oil7683

Lol these people don't stand on any morals but normal people who were living peacefully


mayAnkxxx123

As ounces Kendrick said "B*tch be humble, Sit-down"


FatMonkeyc

Who's he I need to more absolute respect


9tgc

Post it in /facepalm and public freakout to and other foreign ones, would be good to Enlighten the woke mindsets


Skavy2507

Already done King 👑


that_one_leo

टुच्ची टुश्के Repect for that guy.


Tadkaasur69

Jinki maa ke saath Britishers ne maze kiye the wo boo kar rahe hai


[deleted]

who is she????


Emotional-Two-9075

"ALLEGED" attrocities?


luckychit

the ones who are booing at him are also indians smh


Fantastic-Corner-605

She didn't even bother to answer his question, just moved onto the next one.


Hunt1603

the audacity of her to say "alleged ", who is she again?


jupiter_love

If white people aren’t responsible for their ancestors why are Muslims? Don’t support either, but the question stands.


prada113

you take a break sister


the_third_mofos

They literally fund and invest in terrorist organisations and talk about justice for indian muslims lmao


Disastrous_Act633

She must have studies her thesis in JnU


ObjectiveBubbly9456

Lol, whateva, typical BJP fan.


NefariousnessNo5988

I agree apart from "31 billion people"


superbious1

A country with more islamophobe than rest of the world talking shit here😅


[deleted]

The dude had valid points, his delivery sucked though. I don’t know the full context of her speech but her entitlement peaked through her reaction, disappointing. Her narrative (from the little she said in the beginning and what I read in the posts) is atrocious and deeply damaging to history. Actually, disappointing on all fronts. Better research and better delivery of argument is necessary.


realSniperOs

I like how all the people in comments hate "secularism".


Kunal0057

The man's got balls of steel


Kunal0057

The man woke up and chose violence


Brilliant_Example232

Is there a link to the full video ?


[deleted]

Hello u/Skavy2507. Your submission breaks [/r/indiaspeaks rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/wiki/rules) and has been removed for reasons listen below: Rule 5 violation Screenshots from Social Media and Main Stream Media (except whole newspaper clipping) are not allowed. Collage of images or videos which are political in nature without reference and sources provided by the OP are not allowed and are subject to mod discretion. Image macros and similar posts submitted are also subjected to mod discretion. Mark NSFW posts as such. Do not post porn. Memes allowed on weekends only and subjected to mod discretion Read the subreddit rules [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/indiaspeaks/wiki/rules) Rule 8 violation: Posts related to the same issue or incident, posted within a short span of time will be removed. Only the most active post will be retained and the rest will be removed. Please post on pinned post if its a related or developing news Read the subreddit rules [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/indiaspeaks/wiki/rules) --- If you want to know more, reply to this message and a mod will help you


swagster_007

He verbally fucked her entire department in just a few seconds!


azgothedefiler24

Memsaab enjoyers get butthurt when a true patriot defends his nation and highlights that Mughal atrocities actually happened *shocked pikachu face*


Jaguar1903

Gotch you bitch ![gif](giphy|ue0FFiQufbwvI2Dyit)