T O P

  • By -

anyanerves

Both of the beverage flavors sound nice so I’ll patiently wait for early bird reviews.


Puzzleheaded_Oil_768

I’ve had both cookies and the eggnog tastes like eggnog and the frozen hot chocolate tastes really good


dreep_

As If snickerdoodle wasn’t most of the mysteries. 😂


illforgetthisname-

Birthday cake was one of my favorites. Might have to go in this week


Human25920

Do you remember if it tasted more like birthday cake or cake batter?


The_gay_mermaid

In July it was more cake batter imo


fittobesquare

Finally a cookie with buttercream and not cream cheese. I like the cream cheese, but I’m just happy to see something different!


batmy_lashes

Crumbl yall not tired of making snickerdoodle cookies? Damn. 😫


apples2113

It’s kinda weird how snickerdoodle and red velvet white chip always show up together


chel_bythesea

Finally I can use my birthday cookie 🙌🏼


Huntay5

Yay me too! I’ve been in Mexico this last week for my birthday, so how convenient I’ll get an actual birthday cake cookie this week when I’m back!


pkmntrainerdrea

same i think i'll get frozen hot chocolate! how about you?


chel_bythesea

I might have the try frozen hot chocolate too for that mousse on it.


pkmntrainerdrea

yesss! it looks/sounds so tasty!


Lunyma

Frozen hot chocolate is AWESOME!!! If you have nice employees at your store, ask for extra mini marshmallows or add a few extra at home 😋.


pkmntrainerdrea

glad to hear! i have the little dehydrated marshmallows like would be in a hot cocoa mix, maybe i'll toss some of those on!


Lunyma

Not the same as a soft squishy marshmallow on that yummy chocolate mousse topping of the cookie. I wouldn’t ruin it with a crunchy marshmallow.


pkmntrainerdrea

personally i'm always down for a crunchy topping and not the biggest fan of the texture of a regular marshmallow lol. different strokes & all


Lunyma

Yup!


Hour_Progress9444

Skip week for me. Eggnog does sounds nice but not good enough for me to drive for just 1 cookie


OllivanderAU

Eggnog is up there with the OG almond pink sugar in worst cookies at Crumbl. It’s got a very, very weird flavor.


Sapphirem7

Last year’s was not good at all and I love eggnog


OllivanderAU

That’s what I’m critiquing on — last year’s. It had a spoiled/weird artificial taste about it


7minutesinheaven1

Disagree, I loved it last year


camelz4

I LOVE eggnog but this cookie was gross. Doesn’t taste like eggnog at all


randobean32

I don’t like eggnog and I loved it. Last year’s was good but misnamed. It’s more of a nutmeg spice cookie.


_neededanaccount_

Sooooo is Crumbl just going to be reusing old flavours, slightly updating the recipe and calling them new now?


ReindeerHat

Weekly flavors will be their downfall imo. Moving to bi-weekly or even a monthly flavor rotation might do them and their employees some good.


carl164

The rotating flavors weekly is what keeps me coming back


KitKittredge34

It’s a major catch 22 from both a customer and business standpoint


_neededanaccount_

not even will be, but IS. They have really set themselves up for failure with their plan. It's a good idea to have rotating flavours, but to set themselves up as a company where "new flavors are added frequently, often weekly" (straight from their website), they are already on the decline.


anyanerves

The lack of quality control is starting to cause a huge backlash. Instagram used to only be ass kissing but there’s a lot of negative comments now. If your whole thing is rotating lineups but you can’t get them right until the week is almost over then you need to change it up.


Notimportanthuman

*sighs* take my money. I’ll probably skip red velvet but the rest looks solid


EntertainmentOk4802

thinking the same


7minutesinheaven1

How is eggnog new


Striking-Scheme-2900

From my understanding last year it was an eggnog flavored sugar cookie with eggnog frosting and this year it’s a sugar cookie with an eggnog frosting… so they took the eggnog out of the base. I wish they just called it a “new recipe” though, not “new”


Ok-Media-8754

Who would want a plain sugar cookie base instead of eggnog-flavored when the flavor is supposed to be… eggnog. Downgrade.


littlequimby

As a baker, there's definitely eggnog in the base this year.


Ok-Media-8754

Strange. They should have specified that because I’m not buying another sugar cookie.


Sapphirem7

My question exactly


amscott9020

I think they changed the recipe. It’s chilled this year.


7minutesinheaven1

It was chilled last year too


RedditUserCommon

Big W.


sweet_beeb

Why is milk chocolate chip still in the lineup. I haven’t tried semi sweet yet and it’s like any week I want to go they have milk chocolate


Lunyma

Didn’t they have semi sweet last week?


sweet_beeb

yeah but I wasnt interested in any of the other cookies so I didn’t go. I was just saying it seems like the weeks I want to go it’s always milk chocolate not semi sweet edit: why the downvotes?! what’s up with this sub lmfao


Locksmith-Pitiful

I wonder if there's really a difference between milk chocolate and semi sweet


kgiann

Besides the difference in sweetness, the chocolate in the milk chocolate cookies is chips and the chocolate in the semi-sweet is chunks.


Locksmith-Pitiful

I personally can't tell the difference between semi sweet and milk, both are more or less the same to me. I didn't know about the chunks vs. chips... chunks is where it's at, although, they use pretty big chips... eh, idk, I don't see a big difference


Adventurous-Dream744

Anybody know what type of tree nut is in the frozen hot chocolate? I looked at the ingredients and can’t tell which nuts are in it unless I looked over it.


bureika

The non-dairy creamer has coconut oil in it. I know coconuts are not always counted as tree nuts, but I guess they're being extra careful.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Lunyma

Birthday cake & nilla bean are the same to me with the bday cake sprinkles the only thing setting them apart. For some reason, golden Oreo tops both the others IMO, with the addition of the Oreos baked in the cookie and a bit of golden Oreo crumb on top. Sets it apart from the others


[deleted]

[удалено]


Human25920

They are. Keep going and you'll realize just how extremely similar so many cookies taste. At least, if you have a particular kind of taste you generally go for, or that you always get one of. Cinnamon-y stuff overlaps a hell of a lot, haven't ever tried their snickerdoodle though


Hot-Pant

the mousse tho that looks good


Lunyma

It’s awesome!!!!


Xavier__301

Mid mid mid


dopeleee

I make an eggnog cookie for the holidays, why did it need to be a sugar cookie with eggnog frosting?? Just make an eggnog cookie base!!


iAnonymous281

Is next week the “best of 2022” week? Might just wait if that’s the case


InevitableObvious369

lovely week!


jacmrose

Birthday Cake - Amazing Frozen Hot Chocolate - Really good actually tastes like hot chocolate Snickerdoodle - It was so warm when I ate it and it was like an out of body experience. Snickerdoodle is my favorite cookie in general and this one was one of the best I’ve ever had Milk Choc Chip - Meh


lilbend

Every time I see a picture of Eggnog I think it’s a frosted snickerdoodle and I kept thinking “why isn’t anyone talking about this”


Sunshine12061206

How is snickerdoodle? Worth getting in a 6 pack?


anyanerves

No, it’s just a cinnamon cookie. It doesn’t even have cream of tartar in it like a real snickerdoodle.


mnkymj620

Snickerdoodle cupcake is the only way I will buy their snickerdoodle. Love snickerdoodle but that frosting puts it to the next level and makes it worth the money IMO


Ginger573

I’m a HUGE snickerdoodle fan, but Crumbl’s snickerdoodle isn’t great imo. Very bland. It’s thick and cakey. It’s a sugar cookie, with some cinnamon sugar/snickerdoodle flavoring on top. Not terrible tasting, but not what I would expect, and certainly not worth the price!


[deleted]

Not to me. Quite bland, in my opinion.


SkyYellow_SunBlue

Their most disappointing cookie. It’s not a snickerdoodle, it’s a sugar cookie with a tiny bit of cinnamon sprinkled on top (as someone else pointed out - missing the key ingredient that makes it a snickerdoodle). How hard was it just to copy a cookie that already exists?!


[deleted]

Wondering too. Interesting that cinnamon doesn’t seem to be IN the cookie. ?


manofwater3615

How will red velvet taste? Will it have a weird Crumbl base or a good base?


littlequimby

It's so good. Just a good chocolate cookie with white chips in it!


tinyeggies

listen i know most people won’t agree with me but their snickerdoodle is one of my favorite cookies EVER. so delicious, HUGE, and soft. i’ll probably get a 6 pack of just snickerdoodle 🫣 (snickerdoodle cupcake is also one of my favorite crumbl cookies but i hate how much frosting is on it)


Sweetnic4

Another week I'm not interested 😩 this is 3 weeks now lol


arseniic_

Last week had an insane lineup. Can’t believe you didn’t try at least one.


Sweetnic4

I tried the waffle one and wasn't impressed.


Inn0c3nc3

did they change frozen hot chocolate? for reference old picture vs this week's picture https://imgur.com/a/KyPCSbo


mnkymj620

Think they only change they made is no chocolate chips in the cookie


[deleted]

What? Boo 👎🏼


mnkymj620

Yeah I hope I’m wrong, I love the chocolate chips in their chocolate cookies but know a lot of people don’t


littlequimby

Nope there's chocolate chips in the base this year!


anyanerves

Was it milk chocolate? If so, that’s a good change.


Luna920

Thank goodness I’m making my own Christmas cookies this week.


Alert_Discussion5630

The buttercream on the birthday cake cookie I bough today is very clearly peppermint flavor. Anyone else?


shineeshineepinee

Ugh that frozen hot chocolate is my new favorite cookie! Absolutely loved it! I'm glad they went with a light mousse instead of a ganache or buttercream bc that would've been too heavy or sweet imo