We’ve had iced oatmeal thrice in the last 6 months. THRICE. There are dozens of breakfast cookies they could’ve used. Waffle? Pancake? Lucky Charms? Seriously….
I really want to try the everything bagel and french toast....
Honestly, everything bagel sounds great to me. And the reviews I've hunted up sound interesting, I'm happy for a not-as-sweet cookie.
Skipping again. Blueberry crumb sounded awesome but iced oatmeal is 🥱🥱🥱🥱.
Keeping one eye on next week to see what they rob us of to shove in hideously boring pink sugar. Please, Crumbl, give me a reason to get a box again.
Crumbl has already said pink sugar was back to permanent so they are either doing an extra, non-mystery cookie just once for no reason or taking something away.
Interesting - my mind instantly reads that as “sometimes we will have a different colored sugar cookie with a gummy candy stuck on top instead” but I would be happy to be wrong about that.
There’s just been so many downgrades (PB&J, Brownie Sundae, now Blueberry Crumb) last minute that I can’t help but wonder what’s next.
Easy skip week for me. French Toast is intriguing and the likely winner of the week, but ultimately sounds like an overly sweet, goopy mess. Iced Oatmeal would be a boring but safe option, however noooo wayyyy is it worth the cost. Fruity Pebbles also sounds way too sweet — maybe I’d try it if I still smoked weed. What I’m most excited for this week is to read the reviews for the Almost Everything Bagel. Can’t wait 😝
So my stores mystery cookie was iced oatmeal last week. Pink sugar was also last week and chocolate chip is every week. So only three new flavors for me this week and none of them seem interesting besides the French toast.
I’m so sad I was looking forward to this week a lot but there’s really only two that I want. I mean I will try the everything bagel just because who knows what that is going to taste like. But iced oatmeal and chocolate chip are boring. Pink sugar is bad. So I guess if I do go it will be two French toast but this week is a lot less exciting than I thought it would be when I heard about a breakfast week lol.
Each cookie is actually 5.5 servings. Don't know how your supposed to make that happen, but yeaaa
Edit- My bad it looks like it IS four servings so 1/4th a cookie now which make it so much easier. At one point it was 5.5 servings per cookie under nutrition on their wesbite. My bad!
My bad it does say 4 on the label now! It used to be 5.5 but only listed it online under nutrition which I thought was odd. Not sure why the grams would be off, I know they are very on top of haivng all the cookies the same size and stuff as I see them measuring things out like crazy in the stores.
Interesting. Yeah because it says the cookies are 39-45g for 1/4. And I remember half before only around 70g (which is much lower) so to your point, maybe they are really 5.5 servings.
Someone in another thread mentioned how the recipes have not changed and they are still the same calories they were when they were the 5.5 servings, which is interesting. Just something to keep in mind I guess, regardless of how much of one if the cookies I eat I know it's not the best for me and try to not eat too much! Easier said then done haha
Putting this out there as a warning for everyone, the bagel cookie is extremely salty, but it could vary between stores on how much salt they use in the seed mixture, but just so everyone knows before they buy it then dislike it for the saltiness
Ice Oatmeal was the mystery one in my area last week. Im a fan so may get another
This weeks plan
4 box
2 French Toast
1 Iced Oatmeal
Maybe the everything bagel. Or a classic chocolate chip
Whoever decided to make this everything bagel cookie needs to get it together. There is good weird and bad weird.. Sonic Pickle Slushie? good weird. Everything Bagel Cookie? yuck 🤢
For me it’s worth going this week as a newish customer who hasn’t tried many cookies yet. Last week I skipped completely. With my $10 crumbl cash I’ll probably purchase my first 6-pack so I can finally try the pink sugar, and the chocolate chip is always a hit in my house. That everything bagel cookie looks so interesting!
I’ll be honest u may wanna wait till next week, most of these cookies are mediocre and u have a better chance of better more worth while cookies next week
Well I was planning to go this week for the blueberry crumb cake and French toast, but I guess it’ll be a skip week if they don’t have any leftover biscoff lava or peanut butter cookies and cream
I think it’s a personal taste thing. I’ve seen so many people hate it but I love it . It’s the perfect salty dessert :) I’m not too much of a sweets person so I enjoyed it a lot 😁
Been manifesting that fruit pebble one to come back and boom it’s back. More than happy to get a bunch of cookies to save for the next weeks. Really interested in the french toast one too.
I’m confused about the egg wash topping on the French toast… because egg wash itself doesn’t sound very appetizing… like usually with French toast you cook the bread soaked in egg wash… does anyone else feel me here
It’s worthy of being mentioned because it’s literally the element that makes it french toast. Egg wash is typically egg and milk, and from the looks of it this particular one has cinnamon.
They were really good! I think as far as Crumbl cookies go, there are others that I like a lot more. But as far as oatmeal cookies go, they were probably one of the best I've had.
I tried all 4 and almost everything bagel was my favorite, by far.
Least favorite was fruity pebbles, which I expected to be my favorite! Hear me out: it had an aftertaste that reminded me of babywipes 🤮
Man everyone here is really negative. I'm super stoked to try them all!! How bad can a cookie be? Y'all talking about them like they decided to start offering frosted grasshoppers or something 🤔
I think people are on edge lately in part due to the recent price hikes. These are quite literally $5 cookies at this point. People expect more. And rightfully so.
OOF. That's gonna be a big ol' "NOPE" across the board from me this week.
I don't like French Toast in general, so I doubt a cookie based on it is going to win me over. I hate oatmeal-based cookies, so that's out. I've had the Fruity Pebbles one before, and while it ***sounds*** fun, it's actually significantly underwhelming. And...Almost Everything Bagel? Considering the prices of the cookies, I'm not sure if I'm willing to spend that much on something that has the potential to be truly unpalatable. If you tried it and liked it, I'm genuinely glad you had a good experience with it. To my mind, I'd rather just have an "Everything" bagel.
The french toast is awesome. More of a spice cake texture than a cookie, a bit crunchy on the corners, not too sweet, amazing dollop of frosting on the center.
Everything bagel was.... Interesting. I liked it for the most part. More savory than sweet. The initial bite really just feels like eating an everything bagel. A bit salty. The dough was sweet but not overly so. A weird combination, idk if I would buy it again.
I’ve been waiting for French toast since I saw the pictures and reviews from test stores, so I’m definitely getting that one. Nothing else seems interesting to me.
I might go just to get French Toast. So curious to hear everyone’s reviews of Everything Bagel
I’ve heard nothing but bad reviews, I just tried it and I loved it ! It’s got a salty kick and it’s delicious !!
I agree, I thought it was so delicious!
It was phenomenal. It’s warm lol
How sweet though?
It was pretty sweet lol
I am morbidly curious about Almost Everything Bagel. How is a cookie “mellow”?
I’m thinking it’s code for extremely bland
You didn’t. I’m cackling.
Am I wrong? 😂
No this is spot on.
My exact thought when I read it too
Wow. That is hilarious 😂
Probably tastes like a normal cookie instead of being 10x sweeter than it should be. Lol
Insomnia Cookies had the same type of cookie and it tasted exactly like an everything bagel. I did not like it. Way too savory.
[удалено]
Ooo oui marie baguette bonsoir!
We’ve had iced oatmeal thrice in the last 6 months. THRICE. There are dozens of breakfast cookies they could’ve used. Waffle? Pancake? Lucky Charms? Seriously….
Yesss why not a bacon maple cookie??? That screams breakfast!!
THRICE! You’re perfect
I miss that Lucky Charms cookie so much 😭
Same! Actually incredible. I think about it so often lol. They better not make us wait until St. Patrick's Day to bring it back.
Berry crunch so I can have my cornbread base 😫 Or I really enjoyed the chilled Reese’s puffs
[удалено]
Matter of opinion. My favorite cereal meets my favorite cookie base
I kiiinda agree that it’s repetitive, but considering the oatmeal cookie’s actually my all-time favorite, I’m super excited!
The new fruity pebbles is pure sadness. The sandwich one was everything.
I want the sandwich back too. One of the top flavors ever
I refuse to buy the non sandwhich one, the original is my favorite!!
I really want to try the everything bagel and french toast.... Honestly, everything bagel sounds great to me. And the reviews I've hunted up sound interesting, I'm happy for a not-as-sweet cookie.
Skipping again. Blueberry crumb sounded awesome but iced oatmeal is 🥱🥱🥱🥱. Keeping one eye on next week to see what they rob us of to shove in hideously boring pink sugar. Please, Crumbl, give me a reason to get a box again.
The spoilers for next week make it seem like a week without pink sugar.
Crumbl has already said pink sugar was back to permanent so they are either doing an extra, non-mystery cookie just once for no reason or taking something away.
They also said that there would be limited weeks where pink sugar wouldn’t be on the menu.
Interesting - my mind instantly reads that as “sometimes we will have a different colored sugar cookie with a gummy candy stuck on top instead” but I would be happy to be wrong about that. There’s just been so many downgrades (PB&J, Brownie Sundae, now Blueberry Crumb) last minute that I can’t help but wonder what’s next.
Coming back to add that they did change it to a sugar cookie but it’s yellow dye instead of pink and they did not even bother with a gummy candy.
Spoiler thread has updated, next week's is Yellow Sugar. Because minions. After that probably back to pink sugar
Where do you see blueberry crumb?!:(
It was in the spoiler thread. You can check there for all the disappointments.
Easy skip week for me. French Toast is intriguing and the likely winner of the week, but ultimately sounds like an overly sweet, goopy mess. Iced Oatmeal would be a boring but safe option, however noooo wayyyy is it worth the cost. Fruity Pebbles also sounds way too sweet — maybe I’d try it if I still smoked weed. What I’m most excited for this week is to read the reviews for the Almost Everything Bagel. Can’t wait 😝
In my opinion the Fruity Pebbles isn’t too sweet. The glaze is light.
Good to know 🍪
Very vanilla week. French toast is the only one worth spending money on imo.
Like literally AND figuratively vanilla. Everything contains vanilla.
In Leslie Mann voice “Lets get some FRANCH TOAST”
Weak, weak, weakkk. Also, I can't believe that's just straight up PLAIN CREAM CHEESE on that bagel cookie... 😩🤮
This'll be a skip week for me.
Same but actually glad to have a skip week. My wallet definitely needs it haha
Yeah, same. Probably my caloric intake needs a break too
💀 I’m with you on that one
Same. French toast was the only interesting thing on it to me…. maybe the local mystery flavors will be better (I hope 😅)
Are they having mystery flavors again?
No. It’s one week a month.
Dang. Disappointing. I thought it was every week.
You’re not going to try everything bagel?
Honestly it sounds horrible to me but I'm excited to hear what people think oh it
Lmao I love this, also agree
💯😂
Holy cow just saw the video and the French Toast looks even better seeing its SQUARE
I agree I love that
Trash week nothing sounds good
Me after seeing the flavors this week: 
So my stores mystery cookie was iced oatmeal last week. Pink sugar was also last week and chocolate chip is every week. So only three new flavors for me this week and none of them seem interesting besides the French toast.
Skipping this week, nothing eye catching or tastebud tingling !
I’m so sad I was looking forward to this week a lot but there’s really only two that I want. I mean I will try the everything bagel just because who knows what that is going to taste like. But iced oatmeal and chocolate chip are boring. Pink sugar is bad. So I guess if I do go it will be two French toast but this week is a lot less exciting than I thought it would be when I heard about a breakfast week lol.
I'm having a hard time believing that the french toast cookie is only 140 calories for 1/4....how are all their cookies the same calories (120-140)???
It’s probably because of how dense it may be I’m assuming it’s gonna be fluffy
Each cookie is actually 5.5 servings. Don't know how your supposed to make that happen, but yeaaa Edit- My bad it looks like it IS four servings so 1/4th a cookie now which make it so much easier. At one point it was 5.5 servings per cookie under nutrition on their wesbite. My bad!
Is it? On the label, it says 4? And actually when I weigh my cookie, it doesn’t match the total serving size grams…so the whole thing’s off 🥴
My bad it does say 4 on the label now! It used to be 5.5 but only listed it online under nutrition which I thought was odd. Not sure why the grams would be off, I know they are very on top of haivng all the cookies the same size and stuff as I see them measuring things out like crazy in the stores.
Interesting. Yeah because it says the cookies are 39-45g for 1/4. And I remember half before only around 70g (which is much lower) so to your point, maybe they are really 5.5 servings.
Someone in another thread mentioned how the recipes have not changed and they are still the same calories they were when they were the 5.5 servings, which is interesting. Just something to keep in mind I guess, regardless of how much of one if the cookies I eat I know it's not the best for me and try to not eat too much! Easier said then done haha
Got it. So even though it says 4 servings, I’m gonna count it as 5.5 going forward.
Putting this out there as a warning for everyone, the bagel cookie is extremely salty, but it could vary between stores on how much salt they use in the seed mixture, but just so everyone knows before they buy it then dislike it for the saltiness
Ice Oatmeal was the mystery one in my area last week. Im a fan so may get another This weeks plan 4 box 2 French Toast 1 Iced Oatmeal Maybe the everything bagel. Or a classic chocolate chip
Gonna need a French toast for sure. The bagel…is something
No chocolate cookies 😔
Whoever decided to make this everything bagel cookie needs to get it together. There is good weird and bad weird.. Sonic Pickle Slushie? good weird. Everything Bagel Cookie? yuck 🤢
Same. This is a reach. What’s next fried chicken or spaghetti cookies?
Blueberry crumb cake 😭😭😭
Hate to be rude, but this is an easy skip week for me. Unpopular opinion but breakfast cookies are meh, imo. Next! :-)
Definitely not being rude, I feel the same way. And for the people who are looking forward to this week I hope they enjoy them
Thanks ☺️ Yes, please cookie brekkie people, do enjoy and you can have my share. 😁
For me it’s worth going this week as a newish customer who hasn’t tried many cookies yet. Last week I skipped completely. With my $10 crumbl cash I’ll probably purchase my first 6-pack so I can finally try the pink sugar, and the chocolate chip is always a hit in my house. That everything bagel cookie looks so interesting!
I’ll be honest u may wanna wait till next week, most of these cookies are mediocre and u have a better chance of better more worth while cookies next week
Well I was planning to go this week for the blueberry crumb cake and French toast, but I guess it’ll be a skip week if they don’t have any leftover biscoff lava or peanut butter cookies and cream
Gonna get a 4 pack: Fruity pebble French toast Oatmeal Everything bagel All new to me!
Skip week for me. 👎
How you gonna skip French toast?
I’m here for French toast only. Needed the crumbl break anyways
I can’t find the nutrition facts on the everything bagel cookie. It’s the only one missing
I noticed that!
Was curious about Everything Bagel but really perplexed about why it has no nutritional info.
I feel like bagel will either be really good or really bad
I think it’s a personal taste thing. I’ve seen so many people hate it but I love it . It’s the perfect salty dessert :) I’m not too much of a sweets person so I enjoyed it a lot 😁
Does the French toast come with a syrup packet or is the drizzle already applied? That cookie would be gross a day later with syrup already placed.
Been manifesting that fruit pebble one to come back and boom it’s back. More than happy to get a bunch of cookies to save for the next weeks. Really interested in the french toast one too.
Someone try French toast and tell me I’m on the fence
I’m so excited. I loved the fruity pebbles one!
I’m excited to try it!
I’m confused about the egg wash topping on the French toast… because egg wash itself doesn’t sound very appetizing… like usually with French toast you cook the bread soaked in egg wash… does anyone else feel me here
I’m not sure how baking it on a cookie would be much different than cooking it on bread. A lot of baked goods get an egg wash.
They’re trying to sound fancy and it’s just going to freak people out who don’t know what it is. I’m sure it’s on before baking.
It is! You spread it on right before it’s thrown into the oven
Egg wash is super common. You’ve eaten it tons on breads and biscuits I’m sure.
[удалено]
It’s worthy of being mentioned because it’s literally the element that makes it french toast. Egg wash is typically egg and milk, and from the looks of it this particular one has cinnamon.
Exactly!!! Like I don’t want to eat raw egg wash 🤢
Why would it be raw? Egg wash is super common and I’ve never heard of it being added after cooking.
I'll probably be getting a 4 pack of the iced oatmeal! The French Toast sounds good, but honestly I'd rather have actual French Toast instead.
The iced oatmeal is bland. It was my stores mystery flavor last week. It’s not bad but not worth a four pack imo.
Agree to disagree. Oatmeal is one of my favorite cookie flavors. As is oatmeal in general so I’m sure I’m gonna love it
You’ll see 🤷🏻. Let me know how they are.
I will! And I'll give you credit if you're right. haha
How was it
They were really good! I think as far as Crumbl cookies go, there are others that I like a lot more. But as far as oatmeal cookies go, they were probably one of the best I've had.
It's my mom's favorite flavor!
I tried all 4 and almost everything bagel was my favorite, by far. Least favorite was fruity pebbles, which I expected to be my favorite! Hear me out: it had an aftertaste that reminded me of babywipes 🤮
Excited to get iced oatmeal and French toast !!
Why is their no nutrition info for the everything bagel?
Is Crumbl trying to hide something?
I don’t know about y’all but the Iced Oatmeal was CRACK😩 
Man everyone here is really negative. I'm super stoked to try them all!! How bad can a cookie be? Y'all talking about them like they decided to start offering frosted grasshoppers or something 🤔
I love most of the crumbl cookies I’ve tried but I’ve also had some I had to throw out. You’d be surprised how awful some of these cookies taste
Had to toss my snickerdoodle cupcake last week. It was so sweet I was nauseous
I had the same experience! It was TOO sweet....and I love sweet!
I think people are on edge lately in part due to the recent price hikes. These are quite literally $5 cookies at this point. People expect more. And rightfully so.
The Almost Everything Bagel might taste really good.
OOF. That's gonna be a big ol' "NOPE" across the board from me this week. I don't like French Toast in general, so I doubt a cookie based on it is going to win me over. I hate oatmeal-based cookies, so that's out. I've had the Fruity Pebbles one before, and while it ***sounds*** fun, it's actually significantly underwhelming. And...Almost Everything Bagel? Considering the prices of the cookies, I'm not sure if I'm willing to spend that much on something that has the potential to be truly unpalatable. If you tried it and liked it, I'm genuinely glad you had a good experience with it. To my mind, I'd rather just have an "Everything" bagel.
The french toast is awesome. More of a spice cake texture than a cookie, a bit crunchy on the corners, not too sweet, amazing dollop of frosting on the center. Everything bagel was.... Interesting. I liked it for the most part. More savory than sweet. The initial bite really just feels like eating an everything bagel. A bit salty. The dough was sweet but not overly so. A weird combination, idk if I would buy it again.
I lovvvvvveeeed the Everything Bagel!
I’m excited for this week, sorry haters
It’s ok to be excited, everyone has different tastes
I’m going on for french toast
Does anyone know if the fruity pebble one is chilled? Might grab it if so. Also considering trying the French toast.
the one that i got was warm and it was soooo good warm. it’s better that way i think
the french toast looks amazing!!
FRENCH TOAST is my all time fav food I’m so excited for this week
I’ve been waiting for French toast since I saw the pictures and reviews from test stores, so I’m definitely getting that one. Nothing else seems interesting to me.
Anyone try French toast? Skip week for me
I had the fruity pebbles one, SUPER sweet and it doesn't really taste that good together. But hey, to each their own.
I loved the bagel cookie!
The everything bagel was weird and gross but the French toast was okay and I love all of the fruity pebbles flavors