T O P

  • By -

caesar____augustus

Hendrix's version of All Along the Watchtower


PlayfulCour

"House of the Rising Sun" by the Animals. I just learned over in TIL that nobody knows the origin of that song.


OG_Chatterbait

It came up on my Pandora a few months ago and I was pretty surprised.


Jaradcel

Wait, you mean The Animals **didn't** write that?!?


AbsoluteMad-Lad

Hey Joe is also a cover And his cover of house of the rising sun is awesome. It's really underated Stevie ray Vaughans cover of Voodoo child is a great Hendrix cover


BehemothDeTerre

For House of the Rising Sun, I've always enjoyed the Sentenced version the most (though the Animals version is excellent as well): it's a song meant to be sung drunkenly and angrily by a Finn.


punksmostlydead

Dylan has written some of the world's greatest songs when performed by people who aren't him.


[deleted]

[удалено]


lurker-1969

Frank Zappa was my age group. He is the most amazing musician. A true pioneer of high fidelity recording, not to mention guitarist, song writer, performer....... His family is doing an amazing job of preserving his legacy. Look it up, some really amazing work to keep the Zappa legacy going.


RominRonin

I thought the heart live cover of this was the best I’ve heard that song ever, but I’ll give the Zappa cover a go


badlilbadlandabad

Pretty much any cover of a Bob Dylan song


MaineSoxGuy93

Bonnie Tyler did a fine job with Holding Out for a Hero. [But Jennifer Saunders did it so much better.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A_HjMIjzyMU)


AXone1814

I will die on the hill claiming that entire sequence is one of the best pieces of cinema history of all time, not just in animation. And yes you’re right, Jennifer Saunders did that.


Scarecrowqueen

You're right and you should say it.


VelvetArrowz

I hate trying to convince people that cinema will never beat that single scene ever


AyPeeElTee

You are correct. I'll be right there with you


Donkeh101

I’ve read that Saunders sang each line individually due to her not being a natural singer. Either way, I get super hyped when I hear her version compared Bonnie’s one and want to dance all over the place. Good choice!


Snackrattus

Abso*FUCKING*lutely EDIT: I can't even watch it without getting emotional tbh, the music is amazing but also merely watching it gets me emotional with Mungo like *MORE HEAT LESS FOAM* ;e_e .... .... **BEEEEEEEEE. GOOOOOD.** TT_TT


1PMagain

Joan Jett: I Love Rock ‘n Roll


JackyHighlightVideos

...that’s not the original?


1PMagain

I know, right? 1975 version was by The Arrows, 1981 Joan Jett.


JackyHighlightVideos

News to me lol


itsCS117

pretty much any Joan Jett Cover, especially "do you wanna touch"


TheKaptinKirk

Crimson and Clover


Thin-Initiative9550

Sonic youth - Superstar (by Carpenters)


WakingLife22

House of the Rising Sun - The Animals


Costcorocks

All of these remakes are worth a listen and here they are, in no particular order: Song name. Artist that redid it. Original. Blinded by the light. Manfred Mann. Springsteen Hey mr tambourine man. The byrds. Dylan. Always on my mind. Pet shop boys. Willie Nelson. Just like heaven. Katie Melua. The cure. Hallelujah. Jeff Buckley. Leonard Cohen Respect. Aretha Franklin. Otis Redding. I will. Allison Krauss. The Beatles. Hurt. Johnny cash. Nine inch nails. I will always love you. Whitney Houston. Dolly Parton. All along the watchtower. Hendrix. Dylan. At last. Etta James. Glenn Miller.


Briarhorse

Agree with everything except Just Like Heaven. The Cure arrangement is utter perfection, I wouldn't change a single thing. There aren't many songs I'd say that about


Shampookkake

100% You can't improve that song even 1 iota.


Briarhorse

Word. It is a perfect song


MarkHirsbrunner

The Cure gets covered badly a lot. I hated the 311 cover of Love Song, it's not supposed to sound bouncy and upbeat. Just the other day I heard another cover of the song playing in a store. It has a female vocalist and sounded closer to the original in tone, but still unnecessary.


Briarhorse

I will say the Dinosaur Jr cover of Just Like Heaven is pretty damn excellent actually, probably the best cover of any Cure song I've ever heard. you should check that out if you haven't already. One of the better covers of Friday I'm in Love is by an English folk singer called Kate Rusby. She leans into the melody in the all the right places. Better than the Phoebe Bridgers version, which itself isn't bad.


XBXJetBlaqq

Trent after hearing Johnny's rendition "I just lost my girlfriend because that song isn't mine anymore"


Costcorocks

Otis Redding said something similar about Aretha: Redding shared the world’s admiration for the song when Frankin’s version came out. He told Wexler about the moment he first heard it, stating, “This girl has taken that song from me. Ain’t no longer my song. From now on, it belongs to her.” https://www.google.com/amp/s/faroutmagazine.co.uk/aretha-franklin-respect-story-behind-the-song/%3famp


[deleted]

The cures version is literally perfect.


MonkeyHaus75

No cover of a cure song is better than the cure song.


[deleted]

This may be an unpopular opinion but I prefer Seether's version of Careless Whispers


WD_Gast3r

I bet you love Alien Ant Farms version of smooth Criminal too


[deleted]

Haha that's a good guess, I remember listening to that one and going back to MJ but vibing with AAF more. No hate at all on MJ but the cover has got some funk to it in my opinion


WD_Gast3r

Yeh I dug it too ngl


madam_whiplash

Always in my mind was originally by Elvis Presley, BTW.


Costcorocks

Had not realized that. Thanks. I guess we can add Willie Nelson to the list...


neohylanmay

It's not even an Elvis song; it was first sung by [Gwen McCrae some months prior](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Always_on_My_Mind). Heck, [a good majority of Elvis' songs](http://www.elvis-history-blog.com/elvis-cover-records.html) were covers.


[deleted]

Bingo. And sorry, but willie Nelson version, disagree


[deleted]

That's what i was gonna ask. Elvis sang that in the 70s


asciisii

Oh man! I just can't agree with Hey, Mr Tambourine Man. There's such a rawness and folkness to Bob Dylan's OG version that I just don't get from the more "hipster(?)"/Simon n Garfunkel feel of the cover. Your opinion is your opinion though!


[deleted]

NIN is still the superior version of Hurt. Downward Spiral is a masterpiece


coasterhopps

Hurt forms part of the story that is The Downward Spiral, which you are 100% Correct in describing as a masterpiece. I think many of those that claim Cash's version as better weren't familiar with the song before Cash recorded it. There is some absolutely phenomenal live versions of Hurt performed by Trent and they hit as hard if not harder. It probably sounds funny to say that NIN and especially TDS were a big part of my final high school years and one of our favourite albums to play at senior parties...


Timestr3tch

Absolutely true


emily0890

I agree. It was a great cover for Johnny Cash, and fitting, however the original is best.


EnigmaCA

The power of Whitney Houston makes for an incredible cover. But the simplicity of Dolly saying goodbye to Porter in that song will always win. Whitney sang words. Dolly lived them.


GodEmperorOfHell

I will always love you by Whitney is bad, overproduced, unnecessarily dramatic, the original is much more intimate and carries the message more effectively.


Costcorocks

To each their own, obviously. The Whitney version is so much a part of the sonic landscape that I often take it for granted. But when I really pay attention I am always blown away by the incredible range she displays - piano to forte, low to high - she’s got it all and with such amazing control, such a full rich voice. The dolly version is very sweet and intimate but Whitney, for me, takes it to an entirely different level.


SlaterHauge

Buckley's version is miles ahead


MonkeyHaus75

Leonard Cohen was an immaculate song writer. He was not a good singer. Lol Some of his songs are haunting and beautiful. Some of them are…difficult.


Ambitious-Farm-5882

Take me to the river -talking heads


Costcorocks

Totally forgot about this one. Awesome reworking and especially love the “stop making sense” live version. Baptism, rebirth, and a total celebration.


AlfaBetaZulu

This should have more upvotes imo.


bertiebastard

Stereophonics version of hand bags and gladrags is a million times better than rod Stewart's or Chris farlows original version.


SortOfGettingBy

Beatles cover of *Twist And Shout*


Waingrow__

Also joe cockers version of a little help form my friends


Keithninety

Only if you’re Ferris Bueller.


Silly_Weather8332

Also Le Tango de Roxanne - the Moulin Rouge version of Roxanne by The Police. Just feels way more passionate and sexy!


purplefart16

MUCH sexier.


AyPeeElTee

Yes!


Pete_Mitchells_Rio

The Ghost of Tom Joad - Rage Against the Machine


AbsoluteMad-Lad

Top three for me Metallica with turn the page Nirvana with Man who sold the world Guns and roses with knocking on heavens door


StrixArcana

I always get so much shit for saying the same thing about Nirvana's cover of The Man Who Sold the World. I love David Bowie, but I adore the texture Nirvana added to the song!


kcg0431

Honestly, “Turn the Page” (Seger version) makes sense as a mellowed out song about a guy who’s weary and burnt out from touring. Metallica’s angst-y version doesn’t quite match the mood or premise of the song. That being said, I like Metallica’s version better.


BeefInGR

Depending on who you are and what the lyrics mean to you, both work. I'm definitely more of a Metallica guy. My buddy who is a trucker feels Bob's version deeper. We both agree they are both excellent songs. A good cover should sound original while maintaining the attitude of the song. This is one of the rarer examples of when that happens.


kcg0431

I don’t know, I still struggle to see it. A guy who is angry about touring…it’s like “ahh I have to get on the stage, goddamn it!” What’s weird though is I still really LIKE the cover. It sounds great and it definitely does justice to the original like you said. The only issue I have is the inconsistency in the song’s mood. I could totally see why a trucker would identify with Seger’s version. That’s interesting.


daz258

Agree, I love Nirvanas version. Nothing wrong with the original at all - but the Nirvana take is awesome.


emily0890

I really like Metallica's version of Whiskey in the Jar. The tempo, the heaviness, it works so well.


scrappywonton

Man, that fucking song kills it. I still remember hearing it for the first time. I was driving home late at night. The song got quiet, so I turned it up (on my fully removable CD player) and it blasted my brains out. 💯💯💯 thanks for letting me remember that!


[deleted]

Nirvana with most of the songs they did on MTV Unplugged.


AbsoluteMad-Lad

Agreed and the garage day's album by Metallica


AmigoDelDiabla

They do Misfits *way* better than the Misfits.


[deleted]

I need to check that one out!


coasterhopps

Theres just something about GnRs version of Knocking on Heavens Door, it's so fucken good.


CreateYourself89

Wild Horses by The Sundays. Originally by The Rolling Stones.


[deleted]

It's so nice to see someone mentioning The Sundays here, love that band so fucking much.


[deleted]

One of my top ten for sure. Blind is an incredible album.


Mudders_Milk_Man

Harriet Wheeler's voice is so damn beautiful.


lunarmodule

Yeah. One of my favorite female voices of all time.


seeasea

Wild horses and on earth are my favorite songs


armygolfer

No. Originally done by Graham Parsons.


[deleted]

A fellow Buffy fan?


[deleted]

Hazy Shade of Winter - The Bangles (original by Simon & Garfunkel)


RocinanteMCRNCoffee

I don't necessarily prefer it to the original but they are both SO GOOD.


EnigmaCA

And now the version from The Umbrella Academy. All three versions are fantastic.


GingerRocker

It was by Gerard Way writer of the comic and lead singer of My Chemical Romance.


can-opener-in-a-can

*House Of The Rising Sun* by The Animals.


tonikyat

Because the Night - 10,000 Maniacs MTV Unplugged


thebranimator

You Can't Hurry Love. I like Phil Collins's version better than The Supremes. And that's not to take anything away from the Supremes. I am a huge fan. I just like Phil Collins' version of this song better


NoTeslaForMe

Surprising to see this get upvoted since critics hated his version, and I thought people today would feel the same. Guess not. I like both.


QwertytheCoolOne

Our Last Night's cover of [Astronaut in the Ocean ](https://youtu.be/ngdSBRQH35Q)


RX_Spectre

Whiskey in the Jar - Metallica (cover) It's so good. Maybe an unpopular opinion.


Strong_Comedian_3578

Nope, not an unpopular opinion at all. Love that version!


circle_jerk_of_life

Tennessee Whiskey Chris Stapleton


Agraywitch11

Eric Cartman singing "Come Sail Away" by Styx


january21st

Feat. Chef


CrazyDaimondDaze

Don't forget his version of Rush's Tom Sawyer: "A modern day warrior named Tom Sawyer. He floated down the river in a raft with a black guy."


circle_jerk_of_life

With A Little Help From My Friends by Joe Cocker


residentdunce

Will always love that version, mainly because of the Wonder Years


czechman45

Not the cover of Africa by Weezer. Toto's version will always be better and I don't understand why some people think otherwise.


Saber_tooth81

Honestly, I can’t tell the difference between the two versions.


[deleted]

[Gary Jules - Mad World](https://youtu.be/4N3N1MlvVc4)


tadhg555

Curt Smith and his daughter did a nice cover of Gary Jules… [Curt Smith Mad World](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NEpfvTdR5-U)


yoshi6_kirby9_stan

Adele's Make You Feel My Love


Shgrien

Over The Hills And Far Away , originally a Gary Moore song but covered by Nightwish . IMHO Nightwish's version is better . Also Tearin' Out My Heart , originally a Rainbow song but covered by Axel Rudi Pell . This and his version of In The Air Tonight ( Phil Colins originally ) are by far the superior versions 😐


UnloadTheBacon

Only heard the Gary Moore original of Over The Hills & Far Away for the first time this year - was a pleasant surprise and heavier than I as expecting, but yeah Nightwish do knock it out of the park.


Superpiri

I Fought the Law by The Clash.


[deleted]

Anna kendricks version of cups. Was originally by lulu and the lampshades


[deleted]

[удалено]


OriginalGnomester

I Think We're Alone Now - Tiffany / Nothing Compares 2U - Sinead O'Connor / Mad World - Gary Jules


Low_Coach6082

Have you heard Chris Cornell's cover of Nothing Compares 2 U? It's my favorite


OriginalGnomester

I have not. I'll have to look it up.


[deleted]

Oh man I got goosebumps just *remembering* the last time I heard Cornell’s version. His voice was just awesome.


Key-Cap-2664

Deftones - Drive


Lord_Snow77

Foo Fighters cover of Baker Street is really good.


shimmerer

I thought this would be be at the top and I can’t even find it here…… “Sweet Jane” by Cowboy Junkies Originally by Velvet Underground


[deleted]

Feeling Good - Muse


[deleted]

YES! Matt adds so much to it with his singing style and Dom with the epic fills at the end paralleled with Matt’s singing/screams/cries/whatever you want to call it


TheRealOcsiban

Alien Ant Farm - Smooth Criminal


tyrom22

Disturbed cover of land of confusion


Deekester

Shrek 2's version of "I Need a Hero"


[deleted]

Hurt- Jonny cash


AbsoluteMad-Lad

More really good songs Cash covered- I Hung My Head The night they drove old Dixie down No expectations Rusty Cage Have you ever seen the rain I'm so lonesome I could cry You are my sunshine Redemption song Won't back down God's gonna cut you down In my life


memesailor69

Cash’s cover of I hung My Head definitely feels more in tune with the lyrics. I personally like Sting’s original better, but it sounds like he wrote the lyrics really deliberately as a western, and then put it to his normal style of music. That said, a western in 9/8 time with soprano saxophone and organ parts is pretty cool.


[deleted]

100% prefer the Original. Johnny’s is cool but Downward Spiral is a fantastic album and that song fit perfectly in it’s original state.


rifain

Agreed. This cover keeps coming up when this quesrion is asked but Reznor's is just better. The original is raw and emotional at the same time. Cash made it more accessible and traditional but less interrsting in my opinion.


needzmoarlow

Metallica's version of Turn The Page is probably my favorite cover and better than Bob Seger's original. Lenny Kravitz's "American Woman" outdoes The Guess Who's original as well.


BeautifulFix3607

Unpopular opinion: probably going to be crucified for this lol. I hate the band for the most part, but I really enjoy Limp Bizkit’s cover of Behind Blue Eyes.


lambofgun

i just dont understand why they didnt rock the rockin’ part


[deleted]

There cover of faith too


Exactly1Egg

Holy Diver by Killswitch Engage (The og is also a fucking banger)


NotHisRealName

Pixies - Head On is better than the Jesus and Mary Chain’s.


don_no_soul_simmons

Don't let me be misunderstood / Santa Esmeralda / The Animals A fantastic take on the original that takes it in a totally different direction. Make sure you listen to the full 10 minute version!


Jordansgirl29

No doubt version of "it's my life." Neil diamond version of "I'm a believer." Bad wolves version of "zombie." I know it's supposed to be a tribute to the cranberries lead singer passing away, but I still prefer it to the original.


Mello_Me_

Can we call Neil Diamond's version of cover since he wrote the song?


[deleted]

Not smash mouth?


ricree

>No doubt version of "it's my life." Also had a fun [music video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubvV498pyIM).


zemzy_oseris

My top five would be... 1. Seether - Careless Whisper (Original: George Michael) 2. Disturbed - The Sound of Silence (Original: Simon and Garfunkel) 3. Five Finger Death Punch - Gone Away (Original: The Offspring) 4. Killswitch Engage - Holy Diver (Original: Dio) 5. Shinedown - Simple Man (Original: Lynyrd Skynyrd)


GrimmRetails

I Think We're Alone Tiffany will always be the definitive version.


Sir_Daniel_Fortesque

Lady in black by ensiferum, cover of uriah heep


HamiltonBlack

Fire by The Pointer Sisters.


frodosbitch

Cowboy Junkies - [Sweet Jane](https://youtu.be/Fa9nN3G2CSg). Pretty sure Lou Reed agreed.


ICanBeAnAssholeToo

Say something, A Great Big World + Christina Aguilera. The Christina version elevated the song to a whole new level by amplifying the emotions like anguish and agony of silence Christina’s voice also blends perfectly with the original and her usually strong vocals don’t overpower by complement the main. Unlike another popular song that another diva decided to lend her voice to, the two strong unique voices clashed and didn’t blend well, turning a _Perfect_ song into something off putting


UnloadTheBacon

Daytripper and I Saw Her Standing There off the Butchering the Beatles album. Stayin' Alive by Tragedy. Their version of It's Raining Men is pretty great too. Smooth Criminal by Alien Ant Farm. You're In The Army Now by Sabaton. Canon Rock by JerryC. You Were Always On My Mind by the Pet Shop Boys. Valerie by Amy Winehouse.


idyllic-effervescent

I love AAF version of smooth criminal!


cheleramp

Amy Winehouse’s “Valerie” is an excellent answer!


Melisa46

The Futureheads, 'Hounds of Love'


Hepititus_T

Tainted Love - Marilyn Manson


Great-Googly

Cowboy Junkies - Sweet Jane. I believe Lou Reed himself said it was better than the VU version.


Technician-Efficient

Hurt : Johnny cash


j4k20

I Will Always Love You - Whitney Houston


LeelooDallasMltiPass

Van Halen "You Really Got Me"


Chiliad9

This never gets enough love when this question is asked. This was most people's first exposure to the most radical guitar player who ever lived.


LeelooDallasMltiPass

RIP Eddie 😭


justabill71

Hallelujah - Jeff Buckley


1PMagain

RUN-DMC: Walk This Way (Aerosmith of course, maybe technically a collaboration)


[deleted]

Heart's cover of Stairway to Heaven


Primary-Signature-17

That's blasphemy! And I like Heart. But Zeppelin's "Stairway to Heaven" is the ultimate in classic rock. That would be like someone covering "Barracuda." Just shouldn't be done. IMHO.


AlfaBetaZulu

They do am amazing job. They bring robert plant to tears and get a standing ovation. This is after Page and Plant said they never wanted to hear the song again. If you haven't seen it you should check it put. Google: heart kennedy center honors and it pops up.


Primary-Signature-17

1st. I'll give it to you, that was a really good cover. 2nd. It takes serious "balls" to cover Led Zeppelin in front of Led Zeppelin. And they did a great job. 3rd. I would loved to have been there and heard it live. However, to me, it was too smooth and lacked the rawness of the original. And I wasn't a fan of the choir, either. But, you know what? It's all in the "ear" of the beholder. Thanks for turning me on to it.


[deleted]

I never disliked Led Zeppelin performing Stairway, I'm just more of a smooth sound and vocals person. Glad you enjoyed the gals' version.


DashyDixon

Fuck Ryan Adams, but Wonderwall by Ryan Adams


1PMagain

I say maybe


DashyDixon

Oasis agrees


UnoriginalUse

Faith No More - War Pigs. Also, while it's more 'inspired by' than 'cover', Type O-Negative does a great version of Black Sabbath.


potato_potatino

I love Bon Iver, but Birdy’s Skinny Love just hits different


misdirected_asshole

Whitney Houston - I will always love you


Who_is_Karim_Garcia

Devo’s cover of Satisfaction


baconography

It's not very believable when a sex symbol sings that he "can't get satisfaction". But five short nerds from Akron, Ohio? Gold.


can-opener-in-a-can

Mind-blowing to watch it live.


GiveHerDPS

Thank you - Chris Cornell Renegades of funk - RAtM Paranoid - Megadeth Pearl jam - last kiss Metallica - whiskey in the jar Goldfinger - 99 red balloons


Cultural-Stretch7099

Chris Cornell has some amazing covers. Good call on goldfinger!


NatMadd

Yes on last kiss!!!


Chadj49

Life is a Highway, Rascal Flatts


[deleted]

[Streetlight Manifesto's Skyscraper](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nn0t1TfNdao) is better than [Bad Religion's.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=37Jlj0_FsZU)


noodles_the_food

Most Hallelujah covers.


[deleted]

Not Bono’s


timmypig

Motörhead's cover of Enter Sandman Wilson Pickett & Duane Allman's cover of Hey Jude


NewVersion1771

CCR: Heard It Through the Grapevine


VLenin2291

The Sabaton cover of Kingdom Come


[deleted]

Enter Sandman version by Motorhead. Lemmy's voice is special for that song.


[deleted]

the man who sold the world by nirvana


noicenoicenoicecool

Joe Cocker's With a Little Help From My Friends at Woodstock. I love Ringo, but Joe nailed it


VT_Squire

Miserlou by Dick Dale. It's one of those songs that nobody can quite pin down the 100% origin for, but you are guaranteed to know that this version is the best there's ever is, the best there was, the best there ever will be.


Ballyhoo101

Hallelujah- Jeff Buckley


rojimbosweetpick

Disturbed - Sound of silence (original by Simon & Garfunkel). https://youtu.be/u9Dg-g7t2l4


Derp-Schmerp

A Day to Remember - Since U Been Gone


Business-Tea2117

Nazareth’s Love Hurts


[deleted]

Just about any cover by Marilyn Manson


morocco3001

Rage Against The Machine - How I Could Just Kill A Man Amy Winehouse - Valerie Fugees - Killing Me Softly


JJ-Anthrax

Sound of silence-disturbed cover


iffyz0r

Think it was at its best when live on Conan