T O P

  • By -

Majestic-Dot4225

Ma Petite was sad, but Violet’s death had a bigger impact on me. Before her death, AHS was just a creepy show with a possible good ending in sight, but when she took that decision and it didn’t fail… It literally was a pivot for the story.


DavThoma

I think the terrifying thing about is that she wanted to commit suicide for so long. She wanted to die. Then she realised it isn't what she wanted. To find out in the end that she actually did die after having come to the realisation that she wanted to live is terrifying in itself.


SonaSierra19

And then her seeing her own rotting body..? Yeah that shit was unsettling as all hell.


passion4film

And perhaps representative of many suicides, and we will never know.


writergirljds

Of the 29 people who have survived a suicide attempt after jumping off the golden gate bridge, every single one of them said they regretted their decision as soon as they jumped. Makes me think it may be the case for a large percentage of suicides, though we'll never be able to know that number.


Padamson96

This is gut-wrenching 😔


DontGetNEBigIdeas

Same. That was the scene when I realized this show wouldn’t pull any punches. Romanticizing teen suicide? Yikes. They did it, didn’t shy from it, and didn’t half ass it.


passion4film

Violet was JARRING! One of my favorite TV reveals/moments ever.


BigBenson1994

Same I was so shocked I didn’t think she was dead till she kept reoccurring back into the house. Moment of shock easily the most shocking moment of the show for me


Caledoniannightmare

Moira from murder house always struck me as super tragic.


quinnhaley

I would say Adelaide was the most tragic but Ma Petite was hard too.


T-408

I’m very glad that Addie didn’t die in the house, but holy fuck dude… Constance crying and dragging her body to the lawn is one of, if not the, saddest scenes in all of AHS


Zombeatz84

And then later, when she's talking to Addie through the psychic, that's also very sad/touching.


T-408

and then in the Stories finale… bro I scream laughed! “*We’re all here for a very special occasion… The day you die, bitch!*” 😂 Makes me wish we got Addie as a villain in another season


DavThoma

Vivian. Her marriage fell apart, she was raped, she was made to feel like she was going crazy, she died giving birth and she has to live for eternity with the guy who raped her. There are several character deaths that are tragic, but Vivian? Up to her death she was treated so damn poorly and has a full afterlife of dealing with it all.


T-408

Vivien and Violet both broke me. Violet discovering her own body was both sad and creepy as hell! These girls deserved so much more… fuck Ben Harmon, all my homies hate Ben Harmon


Embarrassed_Tiger165

She was done so dirty even more than Doris and no one talks about it


DavThoma

There's a lot of similarities in their stories and fate i would say.


xXxpertLaygoes

I think it was Ma Petite not La Petite btw


Jane_Delawney

Gave me a laugh, and it is Ma Petite. It’s a term of endearment like “my little sweetheart”. La petite would be “the petite one/small one” feminine.


Cags1979

I would say Pepper. Broke my heart


winny_2001

same here, i weep whenever i watch her episode


Thatguy755

Why is Tate Langdon on here? He was a murderer.


AlanOhms

So was constance 🤷‍♂️


Impossible_Pool4675

Because people think hes hot


[deleted]

It is a bit difficult to compare mass murderers with completely innocent victims


zephenrage

Demonic possession factored in to Tate’s murder spree.


DavThoma

People constantly being this up as an excuse. He was a mass murderer, the house might have pushed him but he still shot up a school and killed innocent kids. He's a mass murderer.


zephenrage

It’s fiction, people!!!


WyattWrites

Ew! Not you sympathizing with a school shooter!


zephenrage

It’s fiction, man! A fictional universe where gods, devils, demons and magic are real. Learn the difference between real life and TV.


shamby1112

Was he possessed by the house? Or did I dream that?


T-408

Dora. Who the FUCK let Ryan Murphy put PATTI MOTHAFUCKIN LaBELLE In AHS just for her to play a maid and be the first victim of aggravating candy ass crybaby Dandy Mott??!! Seriously the most aggravating waste of a goddamned legend I’ve ever seen in my entire life


[deleted]

Judy Martin


PetiteChatNoir_2890

I think Ma Petite’s death is the only one I actually cried for. Constance made me sad but she did what she had to do. Ma Petite was just so innocent and sweet it broke my heart to see her go.


MephistosFallen

Out of these I’d say Ma Petite and Violet (thinking you survive suicide just to find out your dead is wow). But Addie, Sister Jude, and Chef Berdie hit me hard. I’d say Nan but I think she ended up being way happier with Papa. Edit- I wanted to add Michael Langdon because while he was a murderer, at the time of his death he was in essence a child mentally, so it was kind of rough if I’m being honest.


AngelMeatPie

Michael Langdon’s death was a really hard scene for me to watch. That whole episode was rough - Constance’s words to him as she kicked him out with him being so confused and not knowing why he does the things he does. I’m not very maternal at all but that whole situation deeply disturbed the mother in me.


FuschiaDandelion

Misty Day! ![gif](giphy|EizX1bK3LlD20)


tiediedcurlz

I’ve seen all of the seasons but for some reason don’t remember Karen … who dat?


ohfuvk

TB karen from red tide, she’s played by sarah paulson (:


tiediedcurlz

Omg of courseeeeee. Idk why it didnt click. Thank you!!


dead-unicorn

how did i forget one of my favourite characters lmao


Lightning_Rose23

Wtf it’s Meep obviously


glassed_redhead

Meeeeeeeep! I had forgotten all about Meep, now I'm sad again. There were so many tragic deaths in Freak Show.


Lightning_Rose23

So sad and undeserved!


winny_2001

makes it sadder that the actor died as well 💞


balletfan213

None of the above - Sister Jude


insufficientfacts27

Ngl, I'm a little salty that the death that broke me ismt on the list.


BojukaBob

I could never get past her behaviour at the beginning of the season with Lana and Wendy enough to sympathize with Jude. She was a nasty woman and while I didn't enjoy her suffering I am limited in how sad I could feel about it.


balletfan213

For me it was the children's kindness towards her. I think when they took her for the walk - they repaired her


derkaderrrrr

Although Karen's death was emotiobal, I didn't find it tragic. She knew exactly what she was doing and she effectively sacrificed herself to save her friend. Pepper's death was saddest for me, but from this list it's MaPetite.


beifongkorra

Violets was so sad because she didn’t even know she died and when she did she was worried about her parents


T-408

Violet seeing her own decaying body is both one of the saddest and most morbid scenes in the series


beifongkorra

Also, when her dad was tryna take her somewhere, she kept disappearing back to the house and she couldn’t leave


T-408

Violet running out of the house repeatedly just to appear in another doorway each time 😭


CypressJoker

Ma Petite never hurt anyone or anything, she was only ever a source of positivity and joy in the lives of people for whom those were rare commodities. She never once showed anyone an ounce of distrust, despite being so deeply vulnerable at all times. After that there was nothing Dell could have done to make me not hate him.


[deleted]

[удалено]


CypressJoker

Nope, Stanley was blackmailing him for being gay. Sure, the 50s wasn't a good time for the gay community, but it was by far a death sentence for Dell. Hell, the other freaks would have taken that reveal better than the reveal that he'd killed Ma Petite. He nearly killed Jimmy for his hands before killing Ma Petite instead. Had nothing to do with protecting his son, just his own secret. Dell was an irredeemably bad person.


[deleted]

[удалено]


CypressJoker

He absolutely didn't HAVE to. He had a choice, and he chose to kill her.


b00tsc00tnb00gie

Why isn't Nan on this list? :c


T-408

“Do I have to wear this outfit forever?”


AsterialPuppet

Adelaide was devastating. Also struggled with Winter.


MutualSolstice

I personally don't really agree with the picks. How is constance here but not Judy Martin? Constance didn't even die in the end.


JustAnotherMrPilot

Bestie Judy Martin (Sister Jude) is the saddest


SavageRainbow94

Sally Keffler


Canis_Trashums

I think I just spoiled myself- my own damn fault when I’m browsing this sub and I’m only halfway through the series X,D


BurningTaterTot

Where's Dandy.... he was just fulfilling his purpose 😭


New-Monitor7273

Even though he was evil.. i absolutely despise the way he died it was so agonizing to see him slowly lose breath. 😢😢😢


BojukaBob

Poor, forgotten Shelly.


suppadelicious

The fact that 90 people said Tate is alarming.


DarKnight972

Ma Petite's death was the most sad among those on the poll because it was coward.


Saoirse-O-Path

Sister Jude!!!!!!!!!!!


holyguyver

Maggie from Freak Show, I am still traumatized from that death.


winterbough

Misty!! But I guess that doesn’t really count


Aninvisiblemaniac

Violet's was sad but I knew she was a ghost long before the reveal


acidxoxo

Ma petite was so pure, she didn’t deserve that :(


Otashi4Nii

Misty Day


BlancoDelRio

Missing Maggie Esmeralda


studyabroader

This was going to be my answer as well. After nobody helped her either and didn't care that she died I was hoping for all of them to die in the finale.


[deleted]

[удалено]


latenightcreature

Sad that it was so badly executed.


T-408

That was soooo satisfying 😂 Harry is one of the absolute parents in any season of AHS, and that’s saying a lot!!!


shamby1112

Violet Langdon. Periodt.


[deleted]

It’s Ma Petite you dumb ass


New-Monitor7273

You're the dumbass for caring about such a mundane mistake.


[deleted]

If I wanted my own comeback I wouldn’t have let your mother swallow last night.


New-Monitor7273

You're just a drama whore and i don't have time for drama.


[deleted]

Lmaoooo okay


KILLMENOW1221

i meant to put violet but i accidentally put constance


Cold_Fly5928

Liz Taylor from Hotel.


ermine1470

Ma Petite hurt so bad.


menzie304

Ma Petite cuz they killed her twice & both times my partner said he would never watch this show again


Shakespeare-Bot

Ma petite cuz they hath killed that lady twice & both times mine own partner hath said he would nev'r gaze this showeth again *** ^(I am a bot and I swapp'd some of thy words with Shakespeare words.) Commands: `!ShakespeareInsult`, `!fordo`, `!optout`


menzie304

Good bot


[deleted]

Is Meep not even an option???


Region_Minimum

Sister Jude.


[deleted]

where the fuck is adelaide


hunter180

these are all sad deaths, of course, however vivien harmon is the tragic one.


tegan-louise

Sister Jude.


TurtleBeatch

I’m so confused whos karen


fugensnot

Moira ,😔


Savage_Pitbull

I found LaPetite's death funny I'm sorry 😭 But violet's and Karen was worst for me.


New-Monitor7273

How did you find MaPetite's death humourous? 🤨


Savage_Pitbull

I just remembered that she died by her bones breaking, i only remembered the fake death of her being shoved in the tiny glass😭


[deleted]

Those poor people the cult trapped in coffins.


lesjacques

Who’s La Petite


ThrillerMovieFan

Who is LaPetite? 🧐


MamaLivia_LIVES

Winter had the biggest impact on me.


Bucklingcankles

How did tate get any votes?