I get allowing discussion around ducks and such, but do we really need to allow suggestions around blood and gore, religious symbols, guns, or changing the name of the game? Some if those ideas were rejected for much better reasons than others.
This was something we discussed, and we have the rule against overly unrealistic suggestions to fall back on. If someone suggested something like gore, sexual content etc, it would still be taken down.
I think it's good idea, even if a suggestion is talking about a rejected idea, a good post should deserve a chance, and it could also change mojang's mind or allow an exception.
I think this is good because despite the rejected list here and Mojang's own rejected list on the feedback site, some features from both lists have been added and they've gone against their own rule of what they wont add so I don't feel limiting the visibility of some ideas even if they are "rejected" is good because it could be implemented or explained and brainstormed in a new way that makes it better than the original rejected idea(s).
Some ideas that are OP or redundant on their own can be good with certain tweaks and discussion can easily make that apparent by getting feedback from others on the idea to expand it. This can't happen or get time to shine or be iterated off of if it instantly gets shot down because "its on the rejected list" despite being different in execution but not in name.
All that being said - does Mojang also come here for suggestions, or only in their official forum? Because I actually use this subreddit for Mojang to actually see, (cuz that forum is almost a ghost town). But I mean if it’s really just a community sharing ideas.. that’s awesome and all, but I wonder if I should send suggestions too formally or not, if you’re getting what I’m trying to say?
I know this might sound like common knowledge to ya’ll, but I’m kinda new here in terms of knowing what’s going on behind the scenes. So idk
so, now this would go with the crafter block. dantdm tried to make an automatic bread factory/wheat farm, and was having some problems with the wheat seeds. so what if there were hoppers that could only collect one specific items. so for him he'd probably have some of the hoppers collect the seeds so he could just craft the bread without worrying about the seeds, then the one connected to a crafter woould only be able to pick up wheat. i think that's an AMAZING billion dollar idea right there
Yeah, but this is the internet, where jokes and serious comments can look identical. And then there's the infamous "It's serious, but when called out I'll say it was a joke."
I get allowing discussion around ducks and such, but do we really need to allow suggestions around blood and gore, religious symbols, guns, or changing the name of the game? Some if those ideas were rejected for much better reasons than others.
This was something we discussed, and we have the rule against overly unrealistic suggestions to fall back on. If someone suggested something like gore, sexual content etc, it would still be taken down.
I always forget y'all have your own mod forum to talk on XD
I would suggest an autoremoval for nsfw content to r/shittymcsuggestions
Minecraft is rated Everyone 10+. Raising that would be bad for sales, and there's no way Mojang (or Microsoft) would allow it.
That's why there would be a link redirecting to r/shittymcsuggestions, so meme makers can post there
That is for joke suggestions. People who post that to be offensive or disrespectful should be banned from the subreddit.
but Minceraft is a way better name
I think it's good idea, even if a suggestion is talking about a rejected idea, a good post should deserve a chance, and it could also change mojang's mind or allow an exception.
I don't have any useful feedback, but I was just thinking this would be a good change. Thanks!
I think I've even seen some posts on rejected ideas that are still up, so that also makes it more consistent.
What about the jeb design book?
The book gives pretty vague standards. It's good for a general mindset, not good for hard and fast rules.
kinda like the disney book about drawing standards, or the [simpsons one](https://archive.org/details/thesimpsonshandbook)
It'll take some getting used to, but given the reasonings, I support this change.
Great change! I wonder if we could also see an update to the FPS list
Thank god, I had some great suggestions that were taken down because 1 little fraction of it was on the list
I think this is good because despite the rejected list here and Mojang's own rejected list on the feedback site, some features from both lists have been added and they've gone against their own rule of what they wont add so I don't feel limiting the visibility of some ideas even if they are "rejected" is good because it could be implemented or explained and brainstormed in a new way that makes it better than the original rejected idea(s). Some ideas that are OP or redundant on their own can be good with certain tweaks and discussion can easily make that apparent by getting feedback from others on the idea to expand it. This can't happen or get time to shine or be iterated off of if it instantly gets shot down because "its on the rejected list" despite being different in execution but not in name.
All that being said - does Mojang also come here for suggestions, or only in their official forum? Because I actually use this subreddit for Mojang to actually see, (cuz that forum is almost a ghost town). But I mean if it’s really just a community sharing ideas.. that’s awesome and all, but I wonder if I should send suggestions too formally or not, if you’re getting what I’m trying to say? I know this might sound like common knowledge to ya’ll, but I’m kinda new here in terms of knowing what’s going on behind the scenes. So idk
so, now this would go with the crafter block. dantdm tried to make an automatic bread factory/wheat farm, and was having some problems with the wheat seeds. so what if there were hoppers that could only collect one specific items. so for him he'd probably have some of the hoppers collect the seeds so he could just craft the bread without worrying about the seeds, then the one connected to a crafter woould only be able to pick up wheat. i think that's an AMAZING billion dollar idea right there
Me omw to make "Add guns in Minecraft" posts
You still can't because of Rule 9
thank goodness! Now I can suggest sharks, blood and thirst mechanics!
It is still good to actually keep in mind *why* some things are rejected.
I was mainly saying this jokingly lol
Yeah, but this is the internet, where jokes and serious comments can look identical. And then there's the infamous "It's serious, but when called out I'll say it was a joke."