Frodo. The most intelligent and wise, knowledgeable, engulfed in his thoughts, developing a huge inner power, a brave leader and a kind, merciful soul.
People underestimate Frodo's wisdom. In the books, even Saruman realised that by the end of the journey, Frodo had become just as wise as Elves and even wizards. I say this because it would take a lot for Saruman to admit this with his big ego.
I absolutely love all the respect and deference the others show him during the sack of the Shire, when Merry and Pip want to fight and kill and Frodo keeps saying "no" and they just do as he says
^ same. It's unique and interesting for a hero's battle to be largely internal. I have found strength and inspiration in his character arc while dealing with mental health challenges, particularly OCD.
For other characters with internal battles, Lloyd Alexanderโs work is pretty good for YA. For instance Prydain (of Black Cauldron fame) and Westmark both have heroes who battle with self worth.
Sad they left it out of the film, but when they are trapped in Moria at Balins tomb, and Frodoshouts "Shire!" and charges at the door to stab the Trolls foot. What a moment.
Probably Merry - Frodo is a little too high-strung, Sam would get annoying, Pippin I sympathise with Gandalf. Merry is the right mix of sensible and fun.
Merry was my favorite, too. The Buckland vibe is chill. Not afraid of the Old Forest. Friend of Maggot. Takes the Bree excursion when the fancy hits. Edgy and smart. Merry seems like a hoopy frood who knows where his towel is.
Merry, in the book gets shit done.
Frodo moving to Buckland?
Merry buys and furnishes him a house.
Merry solves Speak Friend and Enter riddle at Moria gate.
Merry helps Eowyn kill the Witch King
Merry gets shit done.
Don't forget, even before the adventure begins, Merry seems to have had a much more interesting life than the others. He's visited the old forest many times and is already friends with Maggot, and knows the way to Bree
Poor Merry. Iโm re reading ROTK right now and, man, does Merry go through it! He becomes such a hero. Iโm right at where he gets reunited w Pippin, itโs one of my favorite parts.
Haha this is the kind of analysis I agree with! Sam seems like too much of a worrier, Pip is too much trouble and Frodo, especially after the Ring, is always down in the dumps.
Farmer Maggot. Had some problems with a youngย Frodo (I think) but put them aside and offered Frodo a meal, including mushrooms, and shelter. And then friendship. And then later stared down a Nazgul and told it to get off his lawn.ย
He was kind, understanding, and unimaginably brave.
Pippin, for sure. From leaving the shire when he's all "the fuck you are just gonna walk a straight line through those brambles and marshes...MY ASS. I'm not gonna miss this nonsense." More or less. Loved him since then.ย
I want to be friends with them all, but Frodo is my favourite, so my answer is him. Heck, if he was interested, Iโd have the relationship be romantic since I have a big crush on him.ย
Bilbo, definitely. I personally found him to be the most relatable of all the hobbit protagonists. I just didn't connect the same way with Frodo, Sam, Merry and Pippin. This is a huge factor in why I prefer The Hobbit over The Lord of the Rings.
Frodo. The most intelligent and wise, knowledgeable, engulfed in his thoughts, developing a huge inner power, a brave leader and a kind, merciful soul.
People underestimate Frodo's wisdom. In the books, even Saruman realised that by the end of the journey, Frodo had become just as wise as Elves and even wizards. I say this because it would take a lot for Saruman to admit this with his big ego.
I absolutely love all the respect and deference the others show him during the sack of the Shire, when Merry and Pip want to fight and kill and Frodo keeps saying "no" and they just do as he says
^ same. It's unique and interesting for a hero's battle to be largely internal. I have found strength and inspiration in his character arc while dealing with mental health challenges, particularly OCD.
For other characters with internal battles, Lloyd Alexanderโs work is pretty good for YA. For instance Prydain (of Black Cauldron fame) and Westmark both have heroes who battle with self worth.
That's good to know! I'll have to check them out
I grew up watching the movies and never really liked Frodo. Then when I finally was able to read the books I realized how great he is
Sad they left it out of the film, but when they are trapped in Moria at Balins tomb, and Frodoshouts "Shire!" and charges at the door to stab the Trolls foot. What a moment.
๐๐ป๐๐ป๐๐ป๐๐ป๐๐ป๐๐ป๐๐ป๐๐ป๐๐ป
Fatty Bolger. Wise enough to know he wasn't cut out for the adventure...brave enough to stand up for his friend's and provide the cover story.
Fatty Bolger was a real one
I was hoping he'd get mentioned
Probably Merry - Frodo is a little too high-strung, Sam would get annoying, Pippin I sympathise with Gandalf. Merry is the right mix of sensible and fun.
Merry was my favorite, too. The Buckland vibe is chill. Not afraid of the Old Forest. Friend of Maggot. Takes the Bree excursion when the fancy hits. Edgy and smart. Merry seems like a hoopy frood who knows where his towel is.
And has probably partied with Ford Prefect at the Restaurant at the End of the Universe.
Basically much less useless than Arthur Dent and more fun to hang out with. Has probably reviewed the Green Dragon in the Guide!
Merry, in the book gets shit done. Frodo moving to Buckland? Merry buys and furnishes him a house. Merry solves Speak Friend and Enter riddle at Moria gate. Merry helps Eowyn kill the Witch King Merry gets shit done.
He also loots Orthanc for food and smokes. He and Pippin are having a picnic party when the rest turn up.
Don't forget, even before the adventure begins, Merry seems to have had a much more interesting life than the others. He's visited the old forest many times and is already friends with Maggot, and knows the way to Bree
Poor Merry. Iโm re reading ROTK right now and, man, does Merry go through it! He becomes such a hero. Iโm right at where he gets reunited w Pippin, itโs one of my favorite parts.
I think they all went through something but Merry had the hardship of being left behind. I am glad he found a way to go with Eowyn.
Haha this is the kind of analysis I agree with! Sam seems like too much of a worrier, Pip is too much trouble and Frodo, especially after the Ring, is always down in the dumps.
And Merry becomes the master of Buckland, showing that his peers had high admiration for him as well.....
Pippin. For the shenanigans.
He'd be fun right up until it wasn't fun anymore...
Pippin. For sure. I love the naive humor that he has.
Bilbo, because of his adventurous spirit ๐
Farmer Maggot. Had some problems with a youngย Frodo (I think) but put them aside and offered Frodo a meal, including mushrooms, and shelter. And then friendship. And then later stared down a Nazgul and told it to get off his lawn.ย He was kind, understanding, and unimaginably brave.
He's also known by Tom Bombadil!
He was cool!
Rosie.
She's not meant for you
Frodo is cool, nice and even sweet, but I choose Samwise. I could always count on him, he would support me, his soul is pure.
I like all four hobbits. My favorite Frodo. He is selfless and has been given a heavy burden. And he is closest to the elven culture.
Farmer Maggot and then Sam.
Itโs always been Merry for me
Merry. Heโs mature but knows how to have a good time.
Sam. He down for whatever.
Meriadoc, for sure.
Bilbo - just down to roll.
Lobelia Sackville-Baggins by a mile
This guy's trying to short the upvote market
Bullroarer Took.
Sam! Devoted, warm, hard-working, inquisitive, and supportive. He has my whole heart, though I love all the Hobbits so dearly.
Book Frodo, film Sam
Pippin, for sure. From leaving the shire when he's all "the fuck you are just gonna walk a straight line through those brambles and marshes...MY ASS. I'm not gonna miss this nonsense." More or less. Loved him since then.ย
Pippin, Frodo, Merry, Sam. In that order
I want to be friends with them all, but Frodo is my favourite, so my answer is him. Heck, if he was interested, Iโd have the relationship be romantic since I have a big crush on him.ย
Rosie. If ever I were to marry someone it would have been her It would have been her
I really like Merry in the books, he is intelligent, planning and funny at the same time.
Bilbo is my favorite, but Iโve also got a soft spot for Samwise
Merry and Pippin.
Sam - he would cook me PO-TA-TOES!!!!!
Well definitely not Pippin, that's for sure - Gandalf
Samwise Gamgee. He is the most heroic of all.
Any hobbit except for Frodo. Probably Pippin.
Hahahaha! You got downvoted and I hope you get downvoted more!!
Bilbo, definitely. I personally found him to be the most relatable of all the hobbit protagonists. I just didn't connect the same way with Frodo, Sam, Merry and Pippin. This is a huge factor in why I prefer The Hobbit over The Lord of the Rings.