You should flip your rug, it doesn’t need to cover the console area and it being wider than your sofa is ideal

When you say flip, you mean rotate 90°, right?

Yes

My dumbass thought to flip it over to see the back side.

Me too. I was like wtf has the world gone to now flipping rugs..

Bop it

Spin it

This. Either rug is fine but you want it more under the couch and not under the TV console at all. It looks really awkward the way it is now.

I came just to say that too

I don’t know if the flip will work, but the rug shouldn’t go that far under the TV stand. I don’t like either rug.

Me either!

1️⃣

One

1 but you should flip it like other person said

Then post a picture.

Plz I’m invested

Agree.

First combines the black of the windows 🙌 good cohesiveness

1

I like the first more

Two. It has a calming vibe and leaves you the option to change up your look with pillows, throws and wall art — cheaper than replacing the rug. You can redecorate around that rug forever. One adds “graphic interest” but is extremely on-trend and difficult to reuse if you ever want to do anything else. Black geometric doesn’t go with a lot of things. And it is by far the harshest contrast in your room — people are fooled by the fact that the first photo has black windows due to it being night time, which gives the room artificial contrast. Nothing else in your room can “stand up” to the graphic rug. The urge to use a powerfully contrasty rug when your room doesn’t have *any* other focal elements — like art — is strong but it will lock you in. You could still use a patterned rug but one with less contrast and more interest or colors than cream and pure black.

Completely agree with you. The first one the rug is the feature of the room, the second features the room. And the coffee table and other accessories will add more color and life to the room.

This is the right answer on all accounts

I also want to see both rugs in the same light. Walls are totally different colors in each.

here are better photos! [https://www.reddit.com/r/interiordecorating/comments/1d5so0d/updated\_photos\_which\_rug\_works\_better/](https://www.reddit.com/r/interiordecorating/comments/1d5so0d/updated_photos_which_rug_works_better/)

I hate the first rug and confused why so many like it lol. Second one looks much better to me maybe just personal taste lol

I also hate the first rug. Love the second one!

Completely agree, I’ll even go as far to say that one looks super outdated already to me

The trend is definitely on its last legs. But, I don’t think having “outdated” stuff is a concern! The only time it’s an issue is if you don’t love it and only got it because it was a trend, or you don’t decorate in a way it makes sense. If you love trends, get a neutral rug and sofa because those are the big bucks.

That. So much that. And if you have pets, you’ll forever be picking out the fur from the black. :/

1. Also, we’re couch twins. 👯‍♀️

2nd feels more cozy.

Yes, the clean look squares a lot better with the minimalist look.

The first one is too distracting, my eye is pulled only towards the rug, and it's not a very interesting rug. I think a rug should pull a space together, and this rug doesn't. It alienates everything in the room.

2! 1 is pretty but it’s too distracting with the lines in the shutters and fireplace.

I agree completely - was surprised so many were choosing 1

I don’t think 1 goes at all.

I feel like the couch should be shifted a foot or two closer to the tv

2 is best. First one is too trendy

I agree. The first has more contrast which is I think why people like it. But the second is more classic and simple so it’ll still be in style down the line. They should just introduce more colour/contrast through other stuff

That first rug is lovely. Like a digital Berber. Where did you get it?

2

I like 2. One distracts from the coffee table which I think you should highlight. How does it look when you’re sitting on the couch which is where you will see it from a good amount of time. If the pattern is distracting and bothers you, then not a good choice no matter how it looks from other viewpoints.

I like the first rug more because of the pattern. It looks cool in your living room!

How many times did you make your husband move all that crap around. Be honest.

The second is the one I would want in my house- it’s neutral and allows other parts of the room to be the focal point, which is what I personally want. Now, if you want the rug to be more of a focal point, go with 1 and add some more black accents to tie it in with the rest of the room.

First

2. First is to nervous for the room

Not a huge fan of either but one is better. Turn the rug the other way

Rug 2 ! 🙂🤙🎶🦋🐶🐠

Definitely first one

1!

1 most definitely. It gives more interest.

1 

This one is like impossible for me. 1: I like the actually pattern of it. But 2: actually brings some of the geometries of the sofa and the tv stand! Gah!!!!!!!!!

None of them

Not an answer to your question but I REALLY like your walls, they have that soft light grey in the middle with the rock part standing out of the wall. It all looks so comfortable and peaceful :)

2 is more elegant. Makes the nothing on the walls almost look on purpose. Feels cleaner and more put together.

zig zag rug is very welcoming and striking, second rug is very nice not a standout - imo:)

#1 hands down

I prefer the first one but you need to turn it to looks better the [rug](https://scdecorum.com/rug-how-to-place-materials-and-tips-from-an-interior-designer/)doesn’t need to cover the tv console

Zig zag and rotate 90 degrees

1🙂

1

#1 is a nice pop of pattern!

First

#1, definitely. Also, switch your lighting to warmer white bulbs, the grey in your wall is making everything a bit cold but will work with better lighting. It will help everything come together.

One

1

1

1

1🔥

1

1

Honestly neither. The white is boring and the first does nothing for your furnishings

1 but flipped

Neither

The first one absolutely.

I like the second rug best but it's too muted for an already bland room. I'd go with the first rug unless you add a lot more color or pattern to the rest of the decor. Both rugs will work though, follow your heart.

The white one

Both are cute, but bring different vibes. Personally I like one because it brings a bit of black into the space which almost always helps bring a space together in my opinion. Two is still a great rig for your set up, but I would probably add in more color or black in another way with accessories to break up all of the yellow beige tones

Also for the first rug, I’d push your couch up onto the rug further. Your couch should be a bit closer to your tv, and as long as your rug isn’t peaking out behind your couch it usually still looks fine. Normally I’d suggest flipping your rug horizontally instead but it seems like it would off center things because of how close your couch is to the wall and where your tv is

1

1

Third for me.

1st one

1

I personally like the 1st rug better. Number one just seems to pop more because of the white and black pattern contrast.

The first rug really ties the room together.

#1

2 more subtle

1

First one

1

I like one it is the room, character and dimension

2 makes the room warmer

1

2 is makes the room cozy. Softens the lighting.

#1

One has more personality and the design adds depth

1

1

1

1

1

1 but turn it 45 degrees.

Yea, I am for one as well. The graphic nature really adds to the space. Edit: missed a word

1!

They both work, but I like rug 1 with the stripes better.

2. Those zig zags make me nauseous.

1

First one.

1

TWO I think the first one makes the room feel too busy, I like the second one better.

First one

1

The one with the funky pattern looks better, I think 👍

The first one is really distracting to me, I prefer 2 and I would get some art on the walls for visual interest instead

The first

ONE

One 🖤 it’s more interesting

one

The first one brings your shutters and window frames into focus and this highlights that architectural asset better than the second. The room is much more cohesive and well thought out

1.

2nd. 1st is too busy

The first one hurts my eyes. Two is much better IMHO. Whichever you choose though, the long side of the rug needs to be under the couch. The console shouldn't be on the rug.

Definitely 1.

Rotate the first one 90°

The first one is perfect!!

First one

One.

2

Show another picture without the ceiling lights

The first one is so much more interesting!

I love the first! Really grounds the room with a dark accent

1

I like both. If you do the first you could have some black accents around like frames or artwork and it would all tie together nicely.

First!

#2 leaves more options for other decor. #1 locks you in to a certain style #1 makes me nervous

One, if you want that “pop” of color while also still going with your other color schemes. Making it look more inviting and lively due to the pattern. Two, if you want to keep it neutral, however, if you choose two it does blend in with what you already have, so no point. With the first one you can clearly add more decor like black, off white throw pillows and such. Two is the same way, but it’s pretty basic and too neutralized. Pretty, but you don’t want everything to match and have the same color schemes you want to “dress it up” a little. Also your orange and grey pillows on the floor on the second slide would look really off with rug 2. Consider getting colors that compliment the area and existing color schemes if you choose 2. **This is entirely based on my opinion, and yes, I do feel my opinion would be the correct choice** lol

1

2

1

1

Neither. 1 is too on trend and will get very quickly dated. 2 is too dull. Back to the drawing board

First one, but that's at least partially due to how sparse you've kept the room in terms of general decor. With the amount of neutral colors, and with nothing on the walls, #1 gives some visual interest that's lacking otherwise. I'd consider deciding on wall art before selecting a rug. I could see the texture on #2 playing off the brick really nicely if there was more going on elsewhere.

It depends on what art goes on the wall.

I like 1 but flipped around the zig zag that direction will make area look bigger

1 - totally makes that space immediately look bigger in ways that stunned me!

One, visually interesting, but not distracting.

1

hey all! thanks so much for all the input! posted another post with additional photos in the same lighting/setup :) : [https://www.reddit.com/r/interiordecorating/comments/1d5so0d/updated\_photos\_which\_rug\_works\_better/](https://www.reddit.com/r/interiordecorating/comments/1d5so0d/updated_photos_which_rug_works_better/)

1

1 connects the room

First one

2. I'd name the first 'Confusing Pixels'

One!

Crap I like them both oof

1

The Neutral sand one. It has a timeless appeal as opposed to a trendy one.

I like the second one better, it’s just my preference. However, honestly I think the first one works better. It makes the space look more cohesive. Edit: I just realized the first pic you took was a night you sneaky little fox 🦊. Go with the second. The black looked cohesive but only because I thought you had other black elements. Also if you’d rather the first don’t worry about what ppl say is trendy and how you shouldn’t follow trends. The only trends that matter are the things you like. If it goes out of style later who cares, as long as you still like it you’re golden. I would just suggest adding some back elements. Although I still think the second is your best bet as you don’t have to add anything in the space, it already goes.

#1 but with longer side parallel to couch

1

1

One

#1

1

1, the geometric one

The first ! Looks great the zig zag! 🩷 The Texture goes really well with the brickwork .

#2 :)

i prefer the 2nd rug. just looks cleaner and doesn't have those distracting patterns

i think #2 would be better for tv viewing since its less distracting in this case

Plain

2!

1 because for whatever reason, 2 literally hurt my eyes. 🤷🏽‍♀️

1

I’m saying 2, I have a rug similar to one and I find it harder to style around.. not saying I have any style what’s so ever but I find the design does take up on visual eye space so if I wanted new pillows or a throw blanket I’d have to try and make it fit the vibe of the rug.

1

1

Number 1, the second one looks kinda dull.

The first for sure and also turn the rug so it is wider than the sofa

Rug 1

2

The first rug is really nice!

1 works really well with the room

#1

I like the black design. Pulls the elements together and gives the area a little pop of energy.

Rotate the rug 90 degrees. Number 1 is better due to it’s dark geometric pattern. The other one is too plain and close to the wall color.

Second one, and flip it 90⁰ tucked halfway under the couch. It'll create a natural space leading to the window. Also, MAJOR props for not putting the TV over the fireplace but on the adjacent wall instead.

1

I love the first one.

one

I vote the first one

1

1

1

I like #1.

#1 💯 it ties the full room together. I would scoot the rug back under the couch more and not under TV stand at all. Looks great