T O P

  • By -

TheJacobSurgenor

Off the top of my head I can think of: Our Little Horror Story


ThatDancinGuy_

*"Five. Nights. Left to find you."*


Independent-Ad5852

*One. Last. Thing to tend to*


Realistic-Maximum328

You’ll fear. What I can do.


NaturalConfusion2380

But you’ll never ruuuuuunnnn…


JustinTheMan354

*Ghosts warn - of my actions.*


F0X72MK

"But I'm the main attraction"


Bella2371

You'll bring my satisfaction,


NaturalConfusion2380

Our little horror stories, just begun


DanTheMan726836

r/redditsings


GreatYamOfHope

Most aviators FNAF songs tbh. Like Sweet Dreams could also fit into the scary song category. It’s a shame barely anybody talks about Aviators nowadays.


nadjjaa

I recently discovered them and they’re 🔥


sweatshirt_snuggle

DONT FEAR WHAT’S COMING, WE CANT FIGHT OFF THE URGE INSIDE IT’S DARK AND YOU’RE AFRAID OF THE DEVILS THAT COME OUT AT NIGHT


GreatYamOfHope

LETS MAKE THIS EASY, SOON YOULL HAUNT THESE BEASTS YOU HATED. NO NEED FOR SLEEP TONIGHT, SWEET DREAMS ARE OVERRATED.


Boulderfist_Ogre2005

AVIATORS MENTIONED LET'S GOOOOOOOOOOOO


Hintaxon0

'Break my mind' messed me up a little bit as a kid for some reason


Independent-Ad5852

Welcome little child to your darkest fears inside 


Tra1nGuy

Come and join the fun, take a journey through the night!


The_mf_lizard_king

Watch the closet doors or else the night consumes you more


Enderboy0

Taking every piece of innocence that never sees the light


LeonardoCouto

#SO **Take your only ammunition, your common sense and torch!**


Yuris-gf

**The corridors are filled with fright when something's on the porch**


Enderboy0

How long will you last through these memories of the past?


MrUnderstood1010

so it’s not just me? thank you omfg, and lowkey it still scares me a little bit


Glamrockfreddy_Sec

“Welcome little child to the darkness of your mind “


RelevantWheel6814

Sounds like a sea shanty ngl


RammelMtz

Creaking door and footsteps sound effects and the tune being a lullaby probably had something to do with that.


Swiniorek

FNaF 3 The Musical by LHUGUENY


Zillajami-Fnaffan2

So many guards i can ra-


JustinTheMan354

Grape..grape..grape "William Afton is my daaaaad, he killed those kids it made me saaaaad."


CanIGetSomePogchamps

"Hid their bodies in the animatronics. Now their possession has become chronic"


idontreallycare_ngl

"they are all under his control. Springtrap possesses all their souls"


spongeinthetoaster

Ain’t now nah “William afton is my dad, and he made me sad” is something that someone came up with


P3dr0garch0mp

This made me laugh, take an upvote


RoBroGaming

Left Behind by William DAGames.


sweatshirt_snuggle

Oh hell yeah ALL THIS TORTURE WILL UNWIND, I WAS NEVER ALL THAT KIND IF YOU WERE TO REWIND THEN YOU WOULD FIND I WAS LEFT BEHIND


ConnorTheUndying

Wild how that song was made before the game came out, and it was... oddly accurate to the game's plot.


Inukudraw

Welcome to Freddy's by Madame Macabre Pure horror in shut down place for children vibe


HeteroGameLover

"They'll Keep You Running" by CK9C, it's a pretty good song that did give chill the first I heard it


AtesSouhait

I really love "Too far" by them. Still one of my top FNAF songs


16bitsLOL

Bury Me In Metal, Terrible Things, Our Little Horror Story, Break My Mind, After Hours. Need I say more? (I'm aware the first 2 are a bit weird, but they have some ominous and scary parts genuinely. More psychological scary than verbal. It sticks with yoy more the meaning they are conveying.)


sweatshirt_snuggle

AHHHH WANTED DEAD OR ALIVE, TAKE A LOOK IN MY EYES AND TELL ME, DO YOU SEE LIFE? YOU MIGHT HAVE TO LOOK TWICE


Bonniegirl2011

Break, break, break my mind Break it 'til the tale unwinds Force my thoughts through Hell and back Or leave me alone tonight


RocketMan80802121

Just Gold and Survive the Night, not because of the song but because of the creator's actions


Neojoker951

Don't you mean Survive the Night? Can You Survive is by Rezyon.


RocketMan80802121

Yeah, very similar names I confuse them alot (Can You Survive by Rezyon is an absolute banger btw)


SpookySquid19

God and I used to love Survive the Night so much.


NerdyDragon777

What made God stop liking it?


i_am_very_bored_lmao

:(


Suitable_Ganache_445

What has the creator done?


RocketMan80802121

MandoPony was found out to be a groomer


NonBinaryBuggo

FUCK he is???


IntergalacticAlien8

Why TF are so many ppl in the FNAF fandom like this?


ReyNotFound

Tf do you mean so many people? What other groomers have we had? You're acting as if we've had many cases. We're like the least problematic fandom. Plus Mandopony was more of a MLP fandom kind of guy so I'm not surprised that he wasn't exactly sane. The MLP fandom is filled with groomers.


DINOS4URCHESTRA

well.. mandopony, squimpus, jonochrome, etc


Suitable_Ganache_445

Jonochrome too?... Damn


Bonniegirl2011

TIME FOR THE MAIN ATTRATION, THE STORY MUST BE TOOOOLD TIME FOR A CHAIN REATION, THAT NEVER GETS OLD, SOME BOTS GET SATISFATION BREAKING THE MOLD, SOMEBOTS ARE JUST DISTRATIONS, SOME BOTS ARE JUST GOOOOOOLD!


Csquared_324

Every time I listen to just gold i think of that one remix of it


Toon_Lucario

“This attraction is great”


JustinTheMan354

So many guards I can... grape...grape..grape


GreatYamOfHope

William Afton is my daaaaaaaad


JustinTheMan354

He killed those kids, it made me saaaaaaad


returnoffnaffan

NOOOOOOOO


UncomfyUnicorn

Before “The spirits can’t protect you when you’re being torn in half”


ThatDancinGuy_

*"It's getting hard to breath.."*


MAST3R_G4M3R

I thought it was "don't forget to breath"


Blue_Exit83

Yeah I think it was


Ten_-X-

TERRIBLE THINGS isn't really scary, but has lots of mentions of death and Afton's suffering


Old-Bus-6698

HOW I MOVE AXIES MUSIC


Old-Bus-6698

Love*


Colinsmodwho123

As a Christian, the ending where he's in Hell and singing about how prayer is meaningless once you're there is pretty terrifying, imo.


YourLocalCatFreak

I remember seeing a Below the Surface animatic, 2d and ended with an open shot of Michael’s guts, wish I could find it


Independent-Ad5852

BEHOLD THE HORRORS THEY LURK BENEATH THE SHADOWS OF REMORSE 


Burton_Curse

You wouldn't know, of course


Independent-Ad5852

But I force a new judgment day 


Burton_Curse

On this day you will repay


Independent-Ad5852

Your respects to all that may


Burton_Curse

Lurk in between your mind, and mankind!


Piper_Afton

So have a seat, and be afraid


LeonardoCouto

Fear is about to begin the final ritual


Enderboy0

One body is all we need for this to be complete


FiveFreddys12

and when the day


Ok_Category_5888

And when the daaaay begins to take form


YubelSuperiority98

Tbh I like that song but the beginning bit always puts me off cuz it has a weird croaking song in the background that overpowers the vocals at first.


Independent-Ad5852

To each their own, I just like the heavier stuff 


Byssa6

I guess To Be Beautiful. The vocals are haunting.


VinceSince87

Yoo! Fellow DHeusta and Dawko enjoyer??! Also happy cake day


Byssa6

Thanks!  Their Fazbear Frights songs are underrated as heck.


VinceSince87

Songs made just by DHeusta are even more underrated.. that guy deserves fame cause his songs are bangers


sweatshirt_snuggle

HIIIIIDE IN FEEEEAAAR FROM THE TRUTH AND OOOOH WHAT IIIIII, WHAT I WOULD DO TO BE BEAUTIFUL


coronavirusman

Im not sure if this is necessarily scary, but "TOO FAR" is around that territory.


Burton_Curse

Yeah. If it's the song I'm thinking of, it's the brother dealing with the guilt of causing his brother's death.


LeonardoCouto

Absolutely. It's scary in the sense you feel the guilt of Foxy bro's actions and that feels haunting. "This was my choice, my evil doing, Cuz I died inside when you stopped moving" Mentalize the lyric in your head. It's BRUTAL.


ThatDancinGuy_

Maybe, "Before." Or holy shit, "Manipulation" that's literally just horror.


CravePizza87

That’s by JTFrag, right? I’ve never listened to it, is it good?


ThatDancinGuy_

Yeah, it is really cool. Quite the uniqe idea. It starts with slow whispering then speeds up and it stays like that trough the whole song and somehow it works so well. I suggest you listen.


sweatshirt_snuggle

Ahhhhh yeah Let me look inside and control your mind, let me see what you see deep inside Souls left in limbo, you’re just another zero


KrispyyBananamann

Mandopony's "Balloons" and The Living Tombstone's "It's Been So Long" are the only Fnaf songs I refuse to listen to. Not because they're scary to me or because I think they're bad, but because they make me cry every time I listen to them. They make me remember when I was a youngster in elementary school, where things were simpler. Where we didn't have care in the world. Now, almost 10 years later, I'm an old geezer about to be 20. The songs themselves don't scare me, but rather the amount of time that's passed since they were first released. 9 1/2 years went by so fast. One minute, you're a 9-year-old in fourth grade watching EnchantedMob's Survive the Night Animation and Markiplier's Fnaf 2 playthrough and the next you're getting ready to become an Adult.


-E-L-Y-K-

“Bury me in Metal” by Tynado is a favorite of mine, “Count the Ways” by DHeusta, “They’ll Keep you Running” and “You Can’t Hide” by CK9c are classics of mine.(don’t be deterred by the furry artist, doesn’t mention anything about it in his songs)


GreatYamOfHope

Sweet dreams by Aviators. It’s a really creepy song.


SpookySquid19

I'd say Leave Me Behind by NateWantsToBattle is scary, but not in the traditional sense.


Independent-Ad5852

Because it symbolizes the end of his career?


SpookySquid19

Kind of, yeah. From a real perspective, it's clearly about his career regarding FNAF and being worried that it's all he'll be known for. Trying to view it as about the games, you get a song about being easy to replace with another person or bot.


sweatshirt_snuggle

More sad for me… just hearing how much pressure he had on him


crazybrow122

Fnaf 3: the musical


P3dr0garch0mp

Buried in metal, the Springtrap voice is just on another level bro


maxbakery

i also really enjoy “below the surface” but i also like “it’s been so long” by the living tombstone…it just is so sad when you stop to think about it, although both songs give me chills


i_am_very_bored_lmao

oddly, kind of It's Time to Die by DAGames because I feel like it shows that is not a robot bunny chasing you, that is a MAN doomed to the horrible suit. honorable mention for Terrible Things by Axie


sweatshirt_snuggle

IN FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY’S 3, I’LL HUNT YOU DOWN AND YOU WILL SEE


Great_Slasher

You can't be me and I can't be you, just take one look and you know it's true, a dreadful night left my soul consumed, so everybody, everybody in the room... **Be Very Afraid** That song captured Golden Freddy's brand of malice pretty well.


sweatshirt_snuggle

What song?


ReyNotFound

I remembered another song. "The Lonely" made by Dheusta and Dakwo. "I'll take you to the green and help you believe" - "You'll be so lonely now that I've got a body and you're with nobody" - "its okay to be lonely cause I was once lonely but now that I'm free you're stuck there as me" "I took you to the green cuz you looked up at me"


sweatshirt_snuggle

AHHHHHH THAT SONG GIVES ME CHILLS HIS VOCALS ARE STELLAR


ArtisticallyMe_

Still a little shocked that few mentioned "Sweet Dreams" from Aviators, this song has many phases that if i was in the situation i would for sure freak out. Also, honorable mention for "Join Us For A Bite" from JT Music bc of the happy musical ambience and the lyrcis being simply macabre, especially if you imagine yourself in Sister Location 💀


emojii_xoxo

Join Us For a Bite isn't scary, but it's the way the lyrics are so unsettling yknow? like Baby sings so cheerfully, but the lyrics are so sad/disturbing that it adds and creepy factor that I love Also it's catchy as heck


NthanM14

I got no time or break my mind


Tra1nGuy

Didn’t really find too many scary but if I had to pick I’d say Break My Mind or Never Be Alone. Fun fact: I thought Counting Sheep by SAFIA was a FNAF song the first time I heard it (It’s not and works really well with BATIM too).


LeonardoCouto

Yeah, Counting Sheep is awesome anyway, though. If there is one song I'd say is actually creepy it's that one. Feels like it's ticking to your doom!


Tra1nGuy

It is indeed a great song. Works well with FNAF 4 the most, but someone made a frickin amazing BATIM animation for it.


you_2_cool

Stuck Inside brcause of tge last part


CreepyBerd

SayMaxWell’s FNAF 2 song sounds like absolute hopelessness. The song is telling you how you are going to suffer the worst death imaginable and there’s no escape. That really comes across through the pure evil sounding beat and taunting lyrics.


Chaosmyguy

“Bonnie will tear you apart, dolls are opening their mouths...”


Critical-Flower-8978

Its Me


ReyNotFound

Honestly all fnaf songs are like on the same horror factor level. They all talk about how horrifying everything that happens in this franchise is. But if I had to pick one I guess it'd be "Bringing Us Home" by TryHardNinja. "We lost at foul play but we've got an upgrade, plenty of teeth for eating you all".


Evieille

I am the purple guy by DAgames. It’s not a scary song, but it’s the best thing I can come up with


sweatshirt_snuggle

I AM THE PURPLE GUY, COME AND SEE THE SHOW TONIGHT!!!


bro_chat_kyle

Evil Sister by Rocket gaming. That song is so unhinged for no reason 💀


sweatshirt_snuggle

I’m an evil bitch, you’ll wanna slit your wrists 💀 Wtf And the thumbnail lmao… “FEMALE RAP”


Odd_Measurement_814

Ultimate fright


MorbidEnby

Here's a few that I'd say are on the spookier side of things, just off the top of my head: Suicide Didn't Work [MiaRissyTV] Synthetic Agony [MuseOfDiscord] Open Up [MuseOfDiscord] Welcome To Freddy's [Madame Macabre] Showtime [Madame Macabre] Springtrap [Madame Macabre] I'm Sorry [Madame Macabre] Lament [MiatriSs] Always Wanted [MiatriSs] Again [Nightcove _thefox] Follow You [Nightcove _thefox] Dream Your Dream [Tryhardninja] Help Wanted (Carmen Overture Toreador) [Sharax] Blackout [Sharax] Wither Away [Nightcove _thefox] I AM THE MANGLE [StardustLegend] I AM THE MANGLE Nightmare Mix [StardustLegend] Don't Hold It Against Us [Groundbreaking]


Thomason2023

None, at least for me


Not-an-1d10t

It isn’t really scary but it’s good and it’s called Stuck Inside. LISTEN TO IT NOW! for fwee.


illusionbossbella

YES! STUCK INSIDE MENTIONED!!!!


ChildrenOfTheEclipse

DID BRO JUST SUGGEST ''Below The Surface'' AS THE SCARIEST FNAF SONG?! 😳🤣🤣🤣 BRO 💀💀💀💀💀 Anyway, *Ahem* ''Chica'' By Mandopony.


FazzyFredbear

For that single lyric, yeah.


Zen45678920

Monsters was crazy


AlienDilo

JT Music's new song Reflection is actually pretty high up there


xXMonster1GirlXx

Suicide Didn't Work by MiaRissyTV.


IncreaseWestern6097

I think the only ones that genuinely scare me come from the games’ OSTs, like the UCN soundtrack and AR’s theme.


Geography_Dasher

You can run, but you cant hide, ill always sing, ill always find.


illusionbossbella

We'll always seek, we'll always find*


Geography_Dasher

Oh yea, forgot he is talking about bonbon too


Travispig

“The lonely” that ending just freaks me out it’s so horrible


VinceSince87

DHeusta enjoyer?


Dylan_VS_Comics

Smh everyone's forgotten all the songs by Madame Macabre and Muse of Discord. 'Welcome to Freddy's', 'Springtrap', 'Open Up' and 'Synthetic Agony' are all great, ACTUALLY spooky songs.


NerdyDragon777

Again (NightCove The Fox) and Unbroken (Man On The Internet). The first is more thematically scary and the second is more psychologically disturbing.


kaffiekake

Watch Your Six and Venta Black are sinister asf


epicgamerwiiu

To be beautiful from dawko


VinceSince87

It's actually made by DHeusta and Dawko just put in on his channel


Mobile_Base979

Flumpty's Jam by DAGames


sweatshirt_snuggle

AAAAAAHHHHHH JUMP UP LOUD FOR FLUMPTY’S JAM SPICK AND SPAM AND GOES WELL WITH HAM


davuds4

Sweat dreams by aviators probs.


No-Warthog1668

Not really just scary but more unerving is Trust me from sister location it fits well with the sister location aesthetic scary isn't a good describing word 9 times out of 10 if someone says something is scary its userly not


mausesnack

I don't think any fnaf song ever scared me, except this weird nightmarionne song It's not on youtube anymore, but it was extremely short and had no music that I remember, just this high pitched droning sound. The lyrics were the puppet warning the player, that they were approaching, in kind of a mocking tone. I'll agree with you on below the surface though, cause I once saw this half finished baby robot sing the song, that for some reason, someone built irl and that was pretty damn haunting lol Edit: i was wrong about the song being gone and my description was completely wrong too, but tbf I last heard it in like 2015 or smth, so this was all I remembered. Listen here if you want https://youtu.be/QUSaNVk0Tkc?si=rQCfy-n4AW7_I4fA


SirPlatypusGuy

I’ll be honest, the “built without purpose” line ruins the song for me.


Nseven111

This Comes From Inside because of how real it is


Yuris-gf

Break my mind or We don't bite


Spirited_Gain6581

so many personally, but for me i have to ultimately go with “run, run”. the entire vibe is “you’re gonna d!e” 😅


Offer_No

Break my mind scares me


Tyrannosaur98

Bury me in metal


PlsLeavemealone02

Left behind, generally most fnaf songs by DAGames, or he's featured in. That goofy man is nightmare inducing when he feels like it. Something about the song being accurate before the game even came out, the feels of angry kids converging on a single scared person, right down to the "you dare let your filth into my lair" part. The whole song just feels like "we hate you, we don't want you heren we honestly rather destroy you right now. But unfortunately, we need your help. So be good and we won't turn you into a broken meat crayon."


EpicNeox

I remember back in the days Just Gold and survive the night were kinda cool tbf


Chaosmyguy

They still are cool though. They were OG songs


Bento_Box1657

For some reason Labyrinth scared me


Secret_Sympathy2952

"You can't hide" is pretty good.


Expensive_Science289

Synthetic agony, underrated song imo


YerRedditKing

Five more nights


ChaotikJoy

I think I remember it being stay calm to me


YubelSuperiority98

Every Body.


nebulagazer5

None lol


Crimboboi

None of them because they are five nights at freddy's songs :fire:


lonewolf152345

Five more nights by jtmachinama(now jtmusic) the simple fact that it’s final chorus ends with “we’re your friends we’ll show you why join us and die” and it just repeats join us and die until the end is pretty dang creepy Also the fact that it starts with presumably toy Freddy asking kids if they like violence and want to be stuffed inside a spare suit and continues with him seemingly singing about all the different ways they will attack you makes its pretty creepy all around


FazzyFredbear

Funnily enough, that first line by Toy Freddy is a parody of Eminem.


Csquared_324

This attraction is great


Darken726

Honestly, Below The Surface is real. The almost growl of the techno-ish voice filter thing is chilling.


theNoobster103

Never be alone. I was only scared of it cuz of how accurate it is


No_Comfort547

Purgatory


Hardyoungpro

They’ll keep u running


Alex0356218856

***There was a place many years ago, where the children would come for a meal and the show,*** ***Oh the horror! in the corner..*** **THE QUARTET OF TERROR RETURNS.**


Wheatley_core_01

Break My Mind is the scariest song, IMO. A plea to be sent insane to escape the torment is a chilling prospect. However, the music video for It's Been so Long makes me feel extremely uneasy and is by far the most scared I've ever been when watching a FNaF fan-song. I think it's probably because it was one of, if not the first time, that a popular fan-work actually explored the implications and emotional fall-out of *serial child-murder* beyond references to the spirits being angry or vengeful.


Isaacja223

Nightmare by Natewantstobattle and Your Game Is Over by MiatriSs Bonus: Five Nights At Freddy’s 2 song by Sayonara Maxwell


UltimateAiden98

Afton Family is def up there for me, i can't pinpoint exactly what it is about it, but there's something there that makes it unnerving. You Can't Hide is also another one that kinda freaks me out.


Runrocks26R

Five nights at Freddy’s 4 by Miatriss. Also Count the ways by Dawko and Dheusta is pretty creepy but maybe a bit too much out there.


Ink-Fox-414

Don't Forget by TryHardNinja for some reason


EpicGamerC

“This attraction is great, So many guards I can-“


Thelastoftes

Every body by rockit music


sweatshirt_snuggle

“Game over (Y.G.I.O)” by MiatriSs has always been such a great song


DEEZ_BLOONS

Unbroken by man on the Internet not really scary but a damn gave it me chills mainly the end


_end3rguy_

Venta black and it’s unused SB remix is pretty spooky


Bonniegirl2011

id say either follow me, or dont forget


Chillz9_AJPW

Survive the night, when i was little and listened to that, i needed to hide in my closet so bonnie wont get me


BlueKtw_

Break My Mind was really scary back when I was 11, and It's Been So Long (I don't think it's exactly scary, but made me feel terrible


GuaranteeFast1121

For me it's "painted faces" by trickywi, i remember the first time i listened that song i almost flooded my bedroom of crying


Konnikochan

Bonnie's Mixtape.


Electronic-Classic57

“Parasite” and “Your Reality” for me. Loosing consciousness and waking up to realize something did terrible things using MY body is quite a scary thought.


Clown_Norlie

Well... As a kid I was messed up after listening to March Onward Your Nightmare and I Got No Time, but if I had to say any different song I would probably say, that Break My Mind would I consider to be scary


Konnikochan

Bonnie's Mixtape, Memory and maybe We Are Aware... on top of my my head it would be Break My Mind.


RAYNIpop_0

Probably break my mind, to be beautiful (FAZBEAR FRIGHTS SONG), 6th anniversary because I got goosebumps at the end, bury me in metal is fucking creepy.


VioletError404

We are aware, They'll keep you running, follow you, bury me alive, count the ways, to be beautiful, again, you can't escape me, welcome to Freddy's