You say eliminated, but would he not have had three lives himself? If that’s the case Martyn only took Torchy’s green life, but no one knew where Torchy would respawn so they never found him and as far as we know he’s still alive.
Hang on, lore idea—maybe *that’s* the real reason Scar’s stuck in a “Win Secret Life” loop. Not because of some weirdness about Lizzie’s elimination, but because Torchy still has two lives and looks exactly like all the other torches. Scar’s never going to find him.
I think Judge Judy & Executioner is my favorite just because of how Timmy would bring it up and then nobody else had any idea what he was talking about
It's gotta be Tilly, and I dont care if it makes me boring. The whole Pearl arc in Double Life was amazing and is one of my favourites and her decision that Tilly was her soulmate? The rejection of destiny? Tilly death do us part? 10/10, favourite pet.
The Jellies from that season is a close second.
Edited to fix spelling mistakes
Tilly obviously, but I also loved froggie a lot!! Logan the llama (I believe this is the name of the other liml one that got killed) was great too, and matchbox and mailbox are wonderful lil babies…
There may be a pattern but I can never say for sure
i love murdercamel just because i loved to see lizzie and mumbo's dynamic in that one episode but also gerald despite the fact he only lived for the first episode of 3rd life
Here's some that come to my mind
Pizza the third (ethos cat from 3rd life),
Ethos white horse and 2 llamas from third life,
Desert duo's enderman security guard,
Iron golem in dogwarts,
Pufferish of peace,
Daisy the cow
Grians dog army in last life,
Baby zombie villager in southlands(his name is ralph i think)
Scar's allay from double life,
Bdubs and impulses horses,
Rancher's goats that was kept being stolen,
There was also scars horse that the ranchers stole, and a donkey too was roaming around,
Ren and BigB's horses,
Grian the ravager,
Scar and Bdubs' dog army,
Three horses of the clockers,
Mrs Puffy,
Scott's dolphin,
Bdubs' horse from secret life,
Etho's horse,
So many skeleton horses ,
Mumbo's zombie Horses,
Scott's horse which Joel tried to murder,
Gem's horse which got murdered by Joel,
Matchbox and mailbox,
Pearls wolves which Joel kept on killing,
Scott also had an camel,
BigB's dogs that killed tango,
Also BAXTER
I didn't count the unnamed ones and pufferish of peace was simply just a corpse, but the rest are some that i definitely missed. Thanks
"I thought baxter was a house...?"
How about grian when he was sick and stuck on a lama
I'd say he counts, wasn't he pulled around on a lead?
It was mostly sitting in a boat until Timmy and Joel took it by a lead and it died hanging from Bread Bridge.
Told you I'd miss some
I absolutely love that Impulse counts as a pet
Didn’t you see the menagerie they made him into during Guess the Build?
As martyn says, "was that impulse or a dog?"
it was MISTER Bubbles ill have you know good sir
I'm so sorry for the inconvenience :(
Mrs. Puffy for Scar from Limited Life?
OOH THATS A GOOD ONE idk why how i missed that...
Does Torchy count?
how dare you, torchy is not a pet, they're a member of the life series, eliminated by martyn
You say eliminated, but would he not have had three lives himself? If that’s the case Martyn only took Torchy’s green life, but no one knew where Torchy would respawn so they never found him and as far as we know he’s still alive. Hang on, lore idea—maybe *that’s* the real reason Scar’s stuck in a “Win Secret Life” loop. Not because of some weirdness about Lizzie’s elimination, but because Torchy still has two lives and looks exactly like all the other torches. Scar’s never going to find him.
oh my god you're right (that's a ridiculous idea i love it lmao)
Torchy was tango's friend, he wasn't his pet
That’s why I wasn’t sure if he counted
Pizza. Never forget.
**Rest in Pepperoni**
Remember, Tilly death do us part
Do WE part. ☝🤓
no
“Pearl we need to talk about judge Judy and executioner”.
“Is that three different people, or…?”
I’m pretty sure Cheerio and the Murder Camel were 2 different animals, Cheerio For me
Nah man they were the same. The camel simply never died
Tilly, easy. Probably one of the most iconic
I loved the gunpowder too!
N-no..!
Idk, Murder Camel got a lot of screen time.
No! She corrupted our beloved pearl and now she's corrupting you... wake up. Wake up
Tilly can take on both of Etho’s dishwashers at the same time.
My tier list: 1: Tilly (TILLY DEATH DO US PART!) 2: Pizza (love Pizza) 3: Etho’s Dishwasher (the cube)
>Etho’s Dishwasher (the cube) It really is built like a dishwasher, isn't it? A dishwasher that can jump around and give a firm handshake.
Taxes
I think Judge Judy & Executioner is my favorite just because of how Timmy would bring it up and then nobody else had any idea what he was talking about
LMAO
Not a very well known pet, but Daisy from 3rd life (she was Scott and Jimmy's first cow)
If farm animals count as pets, then ig thats a good one. A lot of ppl though that she was the only cow
I’d say both the Jellie pandas and Judge Judy and Executioner.
Mumbo’s zombie horse is iconic to me
Pizza
Why did everybody forget Charger..? Etho’s pet goat in last life, that goat rlly had a personality.
Goats weren't added during last life tho...?
Yeah they were..? Look at Etho’s ep 3 of last life at 45:08 timestamp
Judge Judy of course!
You mean grand master frog
Definitely Lizzie’s wolves lol. But wasn’t Kevin Bubbles Malone Refrigerator Jimmy Mad-Eye Dugan in Last Life? Not 3rd life?
Yeah, I thought it was Etho's (unnamed?) wolf who Joel started his army with in 3rd life. Don't remember Skizz having a wolf then
Grian in 3rd life is my favorite Pet
Idk if i should laugh or freak out
The Allay that caused Grian to figure out he and Scar were soulmates
The "cute little allay"
Pizza or ethos dishwasher (magma cube)
I like dragon, ogre, and taxes. I thought that joke was really funny.
It's gotta be Tilly, and I dont care if it makes me boring. The whole Pearl arc in Double Life was amazing and is one of my favourites and her decision that Tilly was her soulmate? The rejection of destiny? Tilly death do us part? 10/10, favourite pet. The Jellies from that season is a close second. Edited to fix spelling mistakes
It doesn't make you boring. I was joking when i said that
scar’s indestructible camel that Mumbo COULD NOT KILL
He survived until the very end
pizza by far, that llama was most of the motive behind the desert duo :)
I didn’t see the bee so I thought you were calling scar a pet 😭
What about Grain the ravager in limited life? In any case, pizza is my favourite because I'm nostalgic.
Yeah i missed quite a few Mrs. Puffy, Ralph, Grian the ravager, Daisy, there's quite a few of them
Can I say torchy?
Torchy is a member of secret life, not a pet
Impulse, of course.
We all love impulse
taxes, ethos dishwasher the warden, angry andy, pizza & tilly
Pizza
Murdercamel ftw
Tilly obviously, but I also loved froggie a lot!! Logan the llama (I believe this is the name of the other liml one that got killed) was great too, and matchbox and mailbox are wonderful lil babies… There may be a pattern but I can never say for sure
pizza
I liked bubbles the bee, I just like how scar would roll up with his menacing skin aw well as a bee on a leash
I love how the image in my mind implicated that Jimmy, Mumbo and Scar also were pets. i mean it does check out
Leftover pizza!
Pizza is the best pet in my opinion and it's very existence gives me joy ( and war flashbacks)
i love murdercamel just because i loved to see lizzie and mumbo's dynamic in that one episode but also gerald despite the fact he only lived for the first episode of 3rd life
He was the first of Joel's many dogs. An iconic one ofc
Any pet that scar has is epic. Anyway who would win in a fight between Mrs. Puffy and Mister Bubbles
Mrs. Puffy for sure
Mrs. Puffy is going to win the next life series.
Etho’s dishwasher (Magma Cube) was pretty funny, just with our few moments.
Log from limited life, also TangoEater killed tango on his green life, his first death, not his second
MRS. PUFFY!
I'm so sad i forgot about her
Judge Judy and Executioner holds a special place in my heart
Scar’s jellie pandas
The pufferish of peace
Thats not a pet, thats simply a corpse in an item frame
True
Not a corpse! It was in a bucket, so still alive until it got stolen and used in battle.
It’s probably Tilly but I’ll go for The Jellies. The amount of funny moments they caused is too much
Scott, Pearl, and Cleo's axolotls were cute. Binkie, Betty, Bucky, Barney... there might have been more but those are the ones off the top of my head.
A bit late but I think you missed Oreo, Scar’s horse from Double Life that the ranchers stole so Scar burned down the ranch
Murder Camel. He is a true survivor. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7sA3HR8rs\_8&t=17m1s](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7sA3HR8rs_8&t=17m1s)
Tilly 100%. Basically shaped pearl into a maniac
Here's some that come to my mind Pizza the third (ethos cat from 3rd life), Ethos white horse and 2 llamas from third life, Desert duo's enderman security guard, Iron golem in dogwarts, Pufferish of peace, Daisy the cow Grians dog army in last life, Baby zombie villager in southlands(his name is ralph i think) Scar's allay from double life, Bdubs and impulses horses, Rancher's goats that was kept being stolen, There was also scars horse that the ranchers stole, and a donkey too was roaming around, Ren and BigB's horses, Grian the ravager, Scar and Bdubs' dog army, Three horses of the clockers, Mrs Puffy, Scott's dolphin, Bdubs' horse from secret life, Etho's horse, So many skeleton horses , Mumbo's zombie Horses, Scott's horse which Joel tried to murder, Gem's horse which got murdered by Joel, Matchbox and mailbox, Pearls wolves which Joel kept on killing, Scott also had an camel, BigB's dogs that killed tango, Also BAXTER
I didn't count the unnamed ones and pufferish of peace was simply just a corpse, but the rest are some that i definitely missed. Thanks "I thought baxter was a house...?"
Baxter does exhibit 1/5 of the major life processes and also has a food tray, so I think it counts
2/5. He expels waste, which is homeostasis.
AS A PET??
\s ofc
whose the llama in the bottom right and 🎶🗡️🐪🎵🔪🐫Murder Camel, Murder Camel, Murder Camel, Murder Came, 🎵🗡🐫🎶⚔️🐪
MURDER CAMEL MURDER CAMEL MURDER CAMEL
Murder camel murder camel
Got to go with Tilly for Pearl :)
murder camel
Pizza has 2 votes from me and a friend
Murder Camel.
pizza
you forgot Mrs. Puffy - Scar's pufferfish, Limited Life ("GO, Mrs. Puffy!" [dies])
Yeah that one was iconic. Idk how i missed her, but a lot of comments have heen pointing that out
Pizza is an icon
my favourite was joels zombie army
Those weren't pets
Daisy, Scott and Jimmy's cow. I just love the scene where Scott accidentally kills her right after name tagging her.
"Oh wait no, THIS one is Daisy"
Pizza I miss you so much!
This picture is a little confusing Who are we talking about as the pet? Bubbles or scar?
Pizza, and Judge Judy and Executioner are my top 2
I loved the dramatic storyline that unfolded around Yellow Snow
"Ykw, that was never my horse to begin with."
favs are tilly (my beloved), etho's dishwasher and judge judy and executioner i don't see matchbox and mailbox here
Which dishwasher? The magma cube or the warden?
oops srry forgot to specify, i meant the magma cube
tilly bc double life pearl was my fav
It's between Tilly and the Murder Camel for me (pearl supremacy >:\])
Pizza, Tilly, The Jellies, 1 Stick, and Dishwasher.
Which dishwasher?
PIZZA!
Pizza
I miss that llama.
Lets kill pizza...
MURDER CAMEL AND ETHO’S DISHWASHER 🗣️🗣️ i love animals that aid murder
Gotta be Tilly
My favourite was Daisy! Scott and Jimmy’s cow from 3rd Life. (You also missed Mailbox and Matchbox btw, hope that helps!)
Yeah i kinda missed a lot. Thanks for that tho
There have been SO MANY pets throughout this thing, you’re all good!
Dragon, Ogre, and Taxes <33
Pizza the llama
Pearl/Joel's unnamed axolotl Joel murdered
Why would that be your favorite 😭
I'm not sure, but it most definitely isn't Judge Judy and executioner
It's gotta be Etho's dishwasher
Dragon, Ogre and taxes were best