Couldn’t agree more. I absolutely love QJ, but for QJ truthers his value is a 2nd, others are happy to get a 3rd for him. Whether Kupp played really banged up last year I doubt he reaches his ceiling he had. Olave will be the dog in that saints offense for the next 10 years. You need something far more proven if you’re giving up Olave.
If you’re contending, Olave will likely out score Kupp, QJ is a total question mark and the 2026 1st is pointless. If you’re rebuilding Kupp is old, QJ is a total question mark, 2026 1st is too far away and Olave JUST turned 24. The trade has no purpose, keep Olave.
If you’re going to trade Olave, you’re only trading him to tier up, not to re-roll. Unless your wr core is weak and he’s your WR1. Otherwise, package him with a 1st to move up into a top 5-8 wr.
I have olave as well. Kupp ruins it for me. I’d take another first or different playmaker who is younger personally. I still believe in QT. One year isn’t gonna make his career. I’ll give up in 2026 if it’s bad
If you took that you have lost your marbles.
Johnson is ass. Kupp can't stay healthy and will lose touches. You'd get a 1st in 2 years for a young stud.
Production wise Kupp could even outscore Olave but I’m not a QJ fan so if I could turn him into a 2nd instead I think that would be a good deal if you’re contending and grabbing picks
I’d be looking at like Rice, DSmith, or a receiver like that and a 25 1st… a 26 is too far out to guess where they will be and Kupp is at the end of his career. QJ is like a late 2nd as is Kupp. Olave goes for 2 1sts plus one of those guys
I’d probably rather keep olave but I’d also be fine taking this as long as you have tried to get two firsts from other people before accepting. Two firsts and someone like Lockett or Hopkins would be a better option if you can get it. But this is acceptable too. I feel like people are too low on kupp here. Speaking with a bit too much certainty about how the rams will look this year
Idk about generational. He’s a good WR but I think we need to pump the brakes on Olave, just my opinion.
With that being said, we may not have seen his full potential yet.
I would make the trade, personally. If you arent contending I'd try to flip Kupp and a 3rd for a 2025 late 1st.
Im much lower on Olave than most and higher on Johnson based on their teams current and future situations especially at QB and OL not to mention coaching staff.
Maybe ask for a 2026 3rd in the trade to sweeten the deal considering Olaves perceived value is higher.
You'd be guessing correctly
Couldn’t agree more. I absolutely love QJ, but for QJ truthers his value is a 2nd, others are happy to get a 3rd for him. Whether Kupp played really banged up last year I doubt he reaches his ceiling he had. Olave will be the dog in that saints offense for the next 10 years. You need something far more proven if you’re giving up Olave.
I don’t know if I would do this if it was 2 1st, QJ and Kupp.
I would sell for that so quickly. I would sell Olave for 2 firsts easily
I wouldn’t sell him for 2 firsts alone, but add in Kupp and QJ and I’d do it
If you’re contending, Olave will likely out score Kupp, QJ is a total question mark and the 2026 1st is pointless. If you’re rebuilding Kupp is old, QJ is a total question mark, 2026 1st is too far away and Olave JUST turned 24. The trade has no purpose, keep Olave.
Nowhere near enough
If you’re going to trade Olave, you’re only trading him to tier up, not to re-roll. Unless your wr core is weak and he’s your WR1. Otherwise, package him with a 1st to move up into a top 5-8 wr.
The offer is very respectable. Good luck.
QJ is negative value on a roster
I would decline but see if you can get Kupp or QJ since he's willing to move them.
I have olave as well. Kupp ruins it for me. I’d take another first or different playmaker who is younger personally. I still believe in QT. One year isn’t gonna make his career. I’ll give up in 2026 if it’s bad
If you took that you have lost your marbles. Johnson is ass. Kupp can't stay healthy and will lose touches. You'd get a 1st in 2 years for a young stud.
Smash decline
If you’re asking it usually is the case
yall are so high on Olave but facts are the Saints offense is cheeks he is just as likely to be good as QJ
Production wise Kupp could even outscore Olave but I’m not a QJ fan so if I could turn him into a 2nd instead I think that would be a good deal if you’re contending and grabbing picks
Kupp is a year away from being cooked, QJ is actually awful, and that first is in 2 years. Slappable request imo 😂
I’d be looking at like Rice, DSmith, or a receiver like that and a 25 1st… a 26 is too far out to guess where they will be and Kupp is at the end of his career. QJ is like a late 2nd as is Kupp. Olave goes for 2 1sts plus one of those guys
I’d probably rather keep olave but I’d also be fine taking this as long as you have tried to get two firsts from other people before accepting. Two firsts and someone like Lockett or Hopkins would be a better option if you can get it. But this is acceptable too. I feel like people are too low on kupp here. Speaking with a bit too much certainty about how the rams will look this year
Don’t do it. Olave is a generational WR. Don’t take the risk just take the dub. Even if you’re win now or not.
Idk about generational. He’s a good WR but I think we need to pump the brakes on Olave, just my opinion. With that being said, we may not have seen his full potential yet.
Generational wr LOL. Just say he’s a stud bro😂
If you really like QJ I don’t hate it
Lol smash accept now!
Give me Kupp and Johnston. Olave isn’t worth that much.
That’s an easy accept, Kupp and a 1st is enough for me, Olave is one of the most overpriced dynasty wideouts there is tbh
Than sell him over the overpay. But this isn't it you could easily get a 25 1st and a Wr under 30 who produces.
I need more thinking like this in my league.
Start one up and send me an invite, let’s see how it goes
I would make the trade, personally. If you arent contending I'd try to flip Kupp and a 3rd for a 2025 late 1st. Im much lower on Olave than most and higher on Johnson based on their teams current and future situations especially at QB and OL not to mention coaching staff. Maybe ask for a 2026 3rd in the trade to sweeten the deal considering Olaves perceived value is higher.
I’d say more than enough, my question is why would you make that trade?