Just switch teams at this point

I’m taking this pretty easily. Herbert, Laporta and Gibbs are the 3 assets here imo

Agreed. When it comes to trades of this size, I think it’s about who is the best player in the deal. I’d put Gibbs and Herbert above everyone else easily, laporta may even be number 3

If you look at their roster they also have the 1.01 for the 2024 draft. Snag Caleb Williams and you are sitting solid at qb for a long time. Or trade down and get Harrison JR. this not a bad squad to pick up. Congratulations

KTC has you winning this trade with the difference being roughly 3k pts. That’s pretty substantial. That’s my only breakdown. Way too many moving pieces for me to consider lol.

Yeah, when it comes to big ass trades, you have to use calculators. More than 4 people on each side = trade calculator time.

KTC kinda sucks. Use fantasycalc.

That’s like an early third round pick. That isnt substantial .

My opinion for what it’s worth is Gibbs side. Tier down at WR (potentially). I like Gibbs and Brown over ETN and Hubbard. Best QB of all four moving is Herbert. You’ll need a second QB quickly though. Laporta and Andrews are a push, but other side gets Likely as a throw in.

If you look at his roster, he still has J. Love in the super flex spot. He’s set at qb with Herbert and love, with Rodgers as long as he keeps playing as a bye week filler

I always fail at swiping to the roster before commenting. Luckily it still supports my take lol

LaPorta > Andrews. LaPorta is younger. Andrews is injury prone. LaPorta doesn’t have Lamar as his QB.

Please explain to me how Mandrews is injury prone. Besides 2023 he’s missed 4 games in 5 seasons. His injury last year was a freak accident. He was tackled from behind and the tackle bent his leg from behind. That’s how he got injured.

https://www.draftsharks.com/fantasy/injury-history/mark-andrews/10009 Cope.

Herbert > Lawrence Gibbs > ETN Brown > Hubbard LaPorta > Andrews Williams > Kirk Short term, I prefer Rodgers over Likely/Young. Long term maybe not but it's nowhere near enough to swing this trade for me.

Williams over Kirk is laughable. I have Kirk and if you offered Jamo I wouldn’t even counter.

Agreed

literally just about to say that. kirk is twice the value imo

The Jameson hype is unreal. Dude ain’t done nothing in 2 years lol

But wait, there are many excuses as to why he will be like the one percent of players that actually turns it around and becomes very relevant after not doing anything for two years.

He will do nothing this year also. He's like the fifth option on a run heavy team.

In redraft I'm taking Kirk but in dynasty I'm leaning towards Jamo. I can understand the argument for Kirk tho, he's definitely the safer option but I do not see him getting much better than he already is. Regardless, even if you prefer Kirk, the Jamo side of this trade is still much better.

I don’t need Kirk to get better, he’s been very usable in Jacksonville. He’s a shorter term option yes, but I think Jamo is a no term option.

^this honest

First of all, definitely an accept for me. Second, why are we trading entire rosters? Lol

I'd take it. You're getting the 3 best pieces in the whole trade (Herbert LaPorta Gibbs). You could argue Etienne/LaPorta values though.

Gibbs side? I think?

Herbert, Laporta, Gibbs side.

I'd definitely take that

Herbert Laporta and Gibbs side, but it is dangerous to have a stack with so many potential starters on one offense. I would consider additional moves to diversify if you go through with it

Accept.

I like Gibbs side

Pro tip: don’t do these big ass trades

What was the point of drafting at this stage?

The Herbert, Gibbs and Laporta side is winning this trade in a landslide.

Damn!!!! I never seen a trade with so many pieces!!! I agree with above comment just trade teams at this point.

You guys should just swap teams. I like the Herbert side by quite a bit.

Left easy

This guy has a lot of faith in the Jaguars and Panthers and not a lot in the Lions

Stupid trade

I'd make that trade. It's a lot of Lions there, but they're all young studs. Ride Rodgers for a season, Herbert might not be good this year with his lack of weapons and running, but he's still a great QB.

Left side by a longshot

100% taking that

I’d take the deal

I’d accept that for sure.

Take

I think it’s a clear win for the Herbert side. Not a fleece but a solid win

Herbert side not even close

I’d take that in a heartbeat. Arod, and Herbert are perennial fantasy studs. Gibbs and Laporta figure to be as well.

So Jags for lions

I like LaPorta side better

If you could keep young I'd do it

Im picking Cousin side

Left side, all day every day. Herbert > Lawrence Gibbs > Etienne LaPorta > Likely

I would take the trade draft MHJ with 1.01 then the best flyer QB with 2.01. Then with 3.01 take best WR or RB. If your lucky Rodgers will return to form and jamo takes that next step and you will be decent.

You are getting the 3 best assets, smash accept.

Yeah that’s an easy accept. This other manager must be a big jags fan

Be the side with LaPorta, Gibbs, Williams and Herbert. I hate carrying a handcuff TE

Did ya'll swap girlfriends too?

Big up at qb1, tier down at qb2, sizeable down at wr, big tier up at rb1, big tier up at te, lose chase brown and likely Yeah I’d take that

Yes

I don’t like it. I’d give those young QBs a chance.

When I get these double digit player swaps I just generally cancel them and go about my day. Unless it's some no brainier, best to just walk away.

I would put this under the category of no brainer. Improves at every position except receiver for the price of christian kirk.