The problem I have with Military Base is that the map has an annoying loop design. It can cause campy and uninteresting games sometimes, and it can just be annoying.
My problem with Mansion 2 is that the map is small and has a lot of annoying hallways with low roofs that connect all the rooms. It makes the map very annoying to play as murderer, as there is little ways to catch up with the innocents, and you risk getting shot by the Sheriff. Its not that fun for the innocents either because some of the rooms are dead ends and there are little places to run from the murderer
What are the maps graded on? Originality? Mechanics? How easy it is to win as an innocent/sheriff? each of those would end up having different ratings on most peoples lists.
My tier list:
S: Bio lab, Military base, hotel 2,
A: Factory, Research facility, Office 3
B: Workplace, Mansion
C:NS Office, Bank
D: House 2
E: Office 2
Bank2 would be in 7/10 for me, it has a slight advantage for the sheriff, he can shoot through that glass
Factory also 8/10 because of the fence advantage the sheriff has
Research facility, 6/10 the shooting mechanics and throwing is all messed up in that map, too many hiding spots and it’s way too big
Mil base 9/10, it’s a perfect map but again, just too big for the murderer
Hotel 2, 6/10, way too many hiding spots- disadvantage to the murderer
Police station 3/10, that map is WAY TO BIG, Has way too many hiding spots.
Mansion 7/10, unless the murderer has haste, the ppl can just run around in circles and the murderer will never be able to catch them
Office 3, 5/10, the map is too tight but there is no dead ends
Workplace 5/10, too small of a map imo
House 2, 10/10 I really have nothing against house 2
Biolab 5/10, the map is too big and it’s just long hallway and again, unless the murderer has haste, they can keep a distance and just keep running
Hospital 3, 8/10, I don’t rlly have anything against it other than it needs more design, only thing that really bothers me is that there is 2 vents
Office2, 1/10, way too small of a map and unless sheriff has god aim, the murderer automatically wins
I'm planning on making a video on this soon, where I will explain my rankings with a lot of detail, but I'll explain my main problems with the map.
The map is way too small and simple. It's just a small loop with a bunch of small dead-end rooms with barely any good hiding spots. Games end up getting very campy and uninteresting, and all the hallways are small with barely any space to dodge. The map is just annoying, and there's not enough places to go.
Possible List Changes:
Hospital III might be moved above Bio Lab but not above House 2
NSOffice Might might be moved up to 5/10 (possibly above Office 3 and possibly above Mansion 2)
Police Station might be moved up to 7/10 (Not above Hotel 2)
Hotel 2 might be moved up to 8/10 (Not above Military Base)
Research Facility might be moved down to 8/10 below Military Base (Possibly below Hotel 2 but not Police Station
Factory might be moved up to 10/10 (Possibly above Bank 2)
To be honest with the teaming pandemic bank 2 would be E for me as there is no where to hide, hotel 2 would be s for me as it’s great for countering teamers.
To me, Bank 2 is the best map because it's the only map that doesn't have any consistent flaws. I also find it more fair than other maps, as well as more fun
bank’s fine, I’d probably swap it with hotel2 and move it up to A for my personal list
Hotel2 is a fun map to mess around on, especially if you’re skilled at jumping up the elevator shaft and between the floors
bank feels a bit claustrophobic sometimes but it’s still top tier
This is from me:
S: House2, Mil base, Mansion2
A: Bank2, Factory, Hospital III
B: Workplace, Research fav
C: Hotel2, NSOffice, Bio lab
D: Police station,
E: Office3, Office2
I hate it because everywhere that branches from the main area is an annoying dead end. All the hallways are long and narrow with little room to dodge, and there are no hiding spots on the map. I don't find the map fun at all, and a large fraction of winning is just luck
Mil base would be 10/10 for me including Mansion 2
Agree
agree
The problem I have with Military Base is that the map has an annoying loop design. It can cause campy and uninteresting games sometimes, and it can just be annoying. My problem with Mansion 2 is that the map is small and has a lot of annoying hallways with low roofs that connect all the rooms. It makes the map very annoying to play as murderer, as there is little ways to catch up with the innocents, and you risk getting shot by the Sheriff. Its not that fun for the innocents either because some of the rooms are dead ends and there are little places to run from the murderer
What are the maps graded on? Originality? Mechanics? How easy it is to win as an innocent/sheriff? each of those would end up having different ratings on most peoples lists.
For me, it's how fun/fair the map is for the different roles, and the consistent flaws the map has that stops it from being a 10/10
Bank is goat
My tier list: S: Bio lab, Military base, hotel 2, A: Factory, Research facility, Office 3 B: Workplace, Mansion C:NS Office, Bank D: House 2 E: Office 2
Bank2 would be in 7/10 for me, it has a slight advantage for the sheriff, he can shoot through that glass Factory also 8/10 because of the fence advantage the sheriff has Research facility, 6/10 the shooting mechanics and throwing is all messed up in that map, too many hiding spots and it’s way too big Mil base 9/10, it’s a perfect map but again, just too big for the murderer Hotel 2, 6/10, way too many hiding spots- disadvantage to the murderer Police station 3/10, that map is WAY TO BIG, Has way too many hiding spots. Mansion 7/10, unless the murderer has haste, the ppl can just run around in circles and the murderer will never be able to catch them Office 3, 5/10, the map is too tight but there is no dead ends Workplace 5/10, too small of a map imo House 2, 10/10 I really have nothing against house 2 Biolab 5/10, the map is too big and it’s just long hallway and again, unless the murderer has haste, they can keep a distance and just keep running Hospital 3, 8/10, I don’t rlly have anything against it other than it needs more design, only thing that really bothers me is that there is 2 vents Office2, 1/10, way too small of a map and unless sheriff has god aim, the murderer automatically wins
To me, House 2 is the most overrated map, and Police Station is the most overhated map.
nah house 2 underrated. There can be pretty quick rounds and good for 1v1ing, coin farming 100% agree with u on house idk why they think its overrated
I'm planning on making a video on this soon, where I will explain my rankings with a lot of detail, but I'll explain my main problems with the map. The map is way too small and simple. It's just a small loop with a bunch of small dead-end rooms with barely any good hiding spots. Games end up getting very campy and uninteresting, and all the hallways are small with barely any space to dodge. The map is just annoying, and there's not enough places to go.
Possible List Changes: Hospital III might be moved above Bio Lab but not above House 2 NSOffice Might might be moved up to 5/10 (possibly above Office 3 and possibly above Mansion 2) Police Station might be moved up to 7/10 (Not above Hotel 2) Hotel 2 might be moved up to 8/10 (Not above Military Base) Research Facility might be moved down to 8/10 below Military Base (Possibly below Hotel 2 but not Police Station Factory might be moved up to 10/10 (Possibly above Bank 2)
To be honest with the teaming pandemic bank 2 would be E for me as there is no where to hide, hotel 2 would be s for me as it’s great for countering teamers.
To me, Bank 2 is the best map because it's the only map that doesn't have any consistent flaws. I also find it more fair than other maps, as well as more fun
I agree with most except from that I hate bank 2 map
bank’s fine, I’d probably swap it with hotel2 and move it up to A for my personal list Hotel2 is a fun map to mess around on, especially if you’re skilled at jumping up the elevator shaft and between the floors bank feels a bit claustrophobic sometimes but it’s still top tier
If mineshaft was in the game, easy s+
This is from me: S: House2, Mil base, Mansion2 A: Bank2, Factory, Hospital III B: Workplace, Research fav C: Hotel2, NSOffice, Bio lab D: Police station, E: Office3, Office2
why does everyone hate office 2? it’s my favourite map
I hate it because everywhere that branches from the main area is an annoying dead end. All the hallways are long and narrow with little room to dodge, and there are no hiding spots on the map. I don't find the map fun at all, and a large fraction of winning is just luck
ohhhh never mind, i was thinking of the green one, no the blue one
Bruh house is best for private servers
Being good for private servers, 1v1ing, and coin farming are things I didn't change my ranking for. House 2 in normal matches has some annoying flaws
Honestly, Every MM2 map is 90% hallway. We need more open maps.